Although researchers have demonstrated conclusively that sports stadiums are not economic development catalysts, stadium projects that include preplanned ancillary developments have been proposed as a salutary strategy to overcome the widely observed dismal economic performance of standalone stadiums. Using an objective rubric for evaluating economic impact studies, we review a commissioned pro forma model that claims to demonstrate net positive fiscal impacts of two prominent publicly-financed stadium-anchored developments. Using assumptions informed by existing research and established discipline standards, the model estimates substantial negative returns for both projects (−$40 to −$60 million in Worcester, Massachusetts and −$100 to −$200 million in Cobb County, Georgia). We find that the reported fiscal surpluses derive from chosen assumptions and not the stadiums’ complementary developments. We conclude that pro forma estimates do not provide credible forecasts of fiscal impacts, and ancillary developments do not improve the fiscal returns of stadium projects.
BradburyJohn CharlesCoatesDennisHumphreysBrad R.. 2023a. “The Impact of Professional Sports Franchises and Venues on Local Economies: A Comprehensive Survey.” Journal of Economic Surveys37 (4): 1389–1431. https://doi.org/10.1111/joes.12533.
10.
BradburyJohn CharlesCoatesDennisHumphreysBrad R.. 2023b. “Public Policy toward Professional Sports Stadiums: A Review.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, forthcoming.
11.
BradburyJohn Charles. 2022b. “Does Hosting a Professional Sports Team Benefit the Local Community? Evidence from Property Assessments.” Economics of Governance23 (3–4): 219–52. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10101-022-00268-z.
12.
BradburyJohn Charles. 2022a. “The Impact of Sports Stadiums on Localized Commercial Activity: Evidence from a Business Improvement District.” Journal of Regional Science62 (1): 194–17. https://doi.org/10.1111/jors.12560.
13.
BradburyJohn Charles. 2022c. “Sports Stadiums and Local Economic Activity: Evidence from Sales Tax Collections.” Journal of Urban Affairs, forthcoming. https://doi.org/10.1080/07352166.2022.2044837.
14.
ClappChristopher M.HakesJahn K.. 2005. “How Long a Honeymoon? The Effect of New Stadiums on Attendance in Major League Baseball.” Journal of Sports Economics6 (3): 237–63. https://doi.org/10.1177/1527002504265957.
15.
CoatesDennisHumphreysBrad R.. 2005. “Novelty Effects of New Facilities on Attendance at Professional Sporting Events.” Contemporary Economic Policy23 (3): 436–55. https://doi.org/10.1093/cep/byi033.
CoatesDennisHumphreysBrad R.. 2003b. “The Effect of Professional Sports on Earnings and Employment in the Services and Retail Sectors in US Cities.” Regional Science and Urban Economics33 (2): 175–98. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0166-0462(02)00010-8.
18.
CoatesDennisHumphreysBrad R.. 2003a. “Professional Sports Facilities, Franchises and Urban Economic Development.” Public Finance and Management3 (3): 335–57.
19.
Cobb County Board of Commissioners. 2019. SunTrust Park, The Battery Atlanta: 2018 Year in Review, Meeting presentation, https://www.mdjonline.com/032619-mdj-braves2018report-pdf/pdf 17d06676-4f4c-11e9-9940-bb0fa7ce580f.html (accessed March 6, 2021).
20.
ConnollyJennifer M.TouchtonMichael. 2020. “The Lure of New Jobs: How Framing Impacts Perceptions of Local Subsidies for Sports Teams.” Public Budgeting and Finance40 (4): 86–103. https://doi.org/10.1111/pbaf.12271.
21.
CromptonJohn L.1995. “Economic Impact Analysis of Sports Facilities and Events: Eleven Sources of Misapplication.” Journal of Sport Management9 (1): 14–35. https://doi.org/10.1123/jsm.9.1.14.
22.
DelaneyKevin J.EcksteinRick. 2003. “The Devil is in the Details: Neutralizing Critical Studies of Publicly Subsidized Stadiums.” Critical Sociology29 (2): 189–210. https://doi.org/10.1163/156916303769155805.
23.
DepkenCraig, A.2006. “The Impact of New Stadiums on Professional Baseball Team Finances.” Public Finance & Management6 (3): 436–474.
HargerKaitlynHumphreysBrad R.RossAmanda. 2016. “Do New Sports Facilities Attract New Businesses?” Journal of Sports Economics17 (5): 483–500. https://doi.org/10.1177/1527002516641168.
28.
HudsonIan. 2001. “The Use and Misuse of Economic Impact Analysis: The Case of Professional Sports.” Journal of Sport and Social Issues25 (1): 20–39. https://doi.org/10.1177/0193723501251003.
29.
JohnsonBruce K.MondelloMichael J.WhiteheadJohn C.. 2007. “The Value of Public Goods Generated by a National Football League Team.” Journal of Sport Management21 (2): 123–36. https://doi.org/10.1123/jsm.21.1.123.
30.
JohnsonBruce K.WhiteheadJohn C.MasonDaniel S.WalkerGordon J.. 2012. “Willingness to Pay for Downtown Public Goods Generated by Large, Sports Anchored Development Projects: The CVM Approach.” City, Culture and Society3 (3): 201–8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ccs.2012.06.007.
LongJudith Grant. 2013. Public–Private Partnerships for Major League Sports Facilities. New York: Taylor and Francis.
36.
MathesonVictor. 2019. “Is There a Case for Subsidizing Sports Stadiums?” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management38 (1): 271–7. https://doi.org/10.1002/pam.22096.
37.
Memorandum of Understanding. 2013. Agreement between Atlanta National League Baseball Club, Cobb-Marietta Coliseum and Exhibit Hall Authority, and Cobb County, Georgia. Government document.
38.
MillerPhillip A.2002. “The Economic Impact of Sports Stadium Construction: The Case of the Construction Industry in St. Louis, MO.” Journal of Urban Affairs24 (2): 159–73. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9906.00120.
39.
NollRoger G.1974. “Attendance and Price Setting.” In Government and the Sports Business, edited by NollRoger G., 115–57. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution.
40.
NollRoger G.ZimbalistAndrew S.. 1997. Sports, Jobs, and Taxes: The Economic Impact of Sports Teams and Stadiums. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
41.
PorterPhilip K.1999. “Mega-Sports Events as Municipal Investments: A Critique of Impact Analysis.” In Sports Economics: Current Research, edited by FizelJohnGustafsonElizabethHadleyLawrence, 61–74. Westport, CT: Prager Publishers.
42.
RosenHarvey S.GayerTed. 2014. Public Finance. New York: McGraw-Hill.
43.
ScullyGerald W.1974. “Pay and Performance in Major League Baseball.” American Economic Review64 (6): 915–30. http://www.jstor.org/stable/1815242.
StearnsRobert V.2018. RE: Review of Ballpark Agreements and Financial Package. Letter. City of Worcester, Massachusetts, Auditing Department, September 12.
46.
StitzelBrandliRogersCynthia L.. 2019. “NBA Sweet Spots: Distance-Based Impacts on Establishment-Level Sales.” Growth and Change50 (1): 335–51. https://doi.org/10.1111/grow.12262.
47.
SzymanskiStefan. 2023. “Anticipating the Honeymoon: Event Study Estimation of New Stadium Effects in Major League Baseball Using the Imputation Method.” Economic Inquiry, https://doi.org/10.1111/ecin.13149.
WassmerRobert W.OngRyan S.PropheterGeoffrey. 2016. “Suggestions for the Needed Standardization of Determining the Local Economic Impact of Professional Sports.” Economic Development Quarterly30 (3): 252–66. https://doi.org/10.1177/0891242416636685.
52.
WelkerGrant. 2018. “Sports Economists: $101M WooSox Stadium Deal Unlikely to Beat the Odds.” Worcester Business Journal, August 21, https://www.wbjournal.com/article/sports-economists-101m-woosox-stadium-deal-unlikely-to-beat-the-odds (accessed September 5, 2022).
