The growth of unfunded pension liabilities has raised concern over states’ fiscal sustainability and threatens their ability to access the capital market. Over the past decade, many states have implemented different types of pension reforms to reduce pension costs, improve funding levels, and mitigate the risks of default on unfunded pension obligations. However, have these reforms enabled states to enhance their credit quality? This study uses state-level data from 2004 to 2018 to examine the relationship between state pension reforms and assigned credit ratings and outlooks. The findings show that the impact of pension reforms on a state's credit quality is tangible and differs by reform type and the government's financial capacity and debt level.
AmielLindsayDellerSteven C.StallmannJudith I.. 2009. The construction of a tax and expenditure limitation index for the US. Retrieved from: https://ageconsearch.umn.edu/record/92231/
2.
AmmarSalwaDuncombeWilliamHouYilinJumpBernardWrightRonald. 2001. “Using Fuzzy Rule-Based Systems to Evaluate Overall Financial Performance of Governments: An Enhancement to the Bond Rating Process.” Public Budgeting and Finance21 (4): 91–110.
AubryJean-PierreCrawfordCaroline V.MunnellAlicia H.. 2017. “How Have Municipal Bond Markets Reacted to Pension Reform?” Boston College Center for Retirement Research57: 1–13.
5.
AutorDavid H. 2003. “Outsourcing at Will: The Contribution of Unjust Dismissal Doctrine to the Growth of Employment Outsourcing.” Journal of Labor Economics21 (1): 1–42.
6.
BensonEarl D.MarksBarry R.. 2016. “Does the Level of Funding of City Government Pension Liabilities Affect Tax-Exempt Bond Issuance Premiums and Credit Ratings.” Municipal Finance Journal37 (1): 25–49.
7.
BifulcoRobertBunchBeverlyDuncombeWilliamRobbinsMarkSimonsenWilliam. 2012. “Debt and Deception: How States Avoid Making Hard Fiscal Decisions.” Public Administration Review72 (5): 659–67.
BrownJeffrey R. 2014. “Reforming Public Pension Subject to Political and Legal Constraints: The Illinois Experience.” National Tax Journal67 (4): 941–63.
16.
BrownJeffrey R.ClarkRobertRauhJoshua. 2011. “The Economics of State and Local Pensions.” Journal of Pension Economics and Finance10 (2): 161–72.
17.
BulowJeremyMorckRandallSummersLawrence. 1987. “How Does the Market Value Unfunded Pension Liabilities.” National Bureau of Economic Research - Issues in Pension Economics, 81–104.
18.
BurnsDebra Brubaker. 2012. “Too big to fail and too big to pay: States, their public-pension bills, and the constitution.” Hastings constitutional law quarterly39 (1): 253–295.
19.
CapeciJohn. 1991. “Credit Risk, Credit Ratings, and Municipal Bond Yields: A Panel Study.” National Tax Journal44 (4): 41–56.
CarletonWillard T.LernerEugene M.. 1969. “Statistical Credit Scoring of Municipal Bonds.” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking1 (4): 750–64.
22.
CarrollThomas J.NiehausGreg. 1998. “Pension Plan Funding and Corporate Debt Ratings.” Journal of Risk and Insurance65 (3): 427–43.
23.
ChaneyBarbara A.CopleyPaul A.StoneMary S.. 2002. “The effect of fiscal stress and balanced budget requirements on the funding and measurement of state pension obligations.” Journal of Accounting and Public Policy21 (4-5): 287–313.
24.
ChenGang. 2018. “Understanding Decisions in State Pension Systems: A System Framework.” The American Review of Public Administration48 (3): 260–73.
25.
ChenCanKrizKenneth A.WangQiushi. 2016. “How Does the Health of Transportation Infrastructure Affect State Credit Ratings? An Empirical Analysis.” Public Finance Review44 (5): 660–80.
26.
ClarkeDamianTapia-SchytheKathya. 2021. “Implementing the Panel Event Study.” The Stata Journal21 (4): 853–84.
27.
ClingermayerJames C.Dan WooB.. 1995. “Disentangling Patterns of State Debt Financing.” American Political Science Review89 (1): 108–20.
28.
CoggburnJerrell D.KearneyRichard C.. 2010. “Trouble Keeping Promises? An Analysis of Underfunding in State Retiree Benefits.” Public Administration Review70 (1): 97–108.
29.
CopelandRonald M.IngramRobert W.. 1982. “The Association Between Municipal Accounting Information and Bond Rating Changes.” Journal of Accounting Research20 (2): 275.
DawsonAndrew B. 2015. “Pensioners, bondholders, and unfair discrimination in municipal bankruptcy.” U. Pa. J. Bus. L.17 (1): 1–46.
32.
DepkenCraig A.LafountainCourtney L.. 2006. “Fiscal Consequences of Public Corruption: Empirical Evidence from State Bond Ratings.” Public Choice126 (1–2): 75–85.
33.
EppleDennisSchipperKatherine. 1981. “Municipal pension funding: A theory and some evidence.” Public Choice37 (1): 141–178.
34.
FarnhamPaul G.CluffGeorge S.. 1982. “Municipal Bond Ratings: New Results, New Directions.” Public Finance and Management10 (4): 427–55.
GorinaEvgenia. 2018. “City revenue structure and unfunded pension liabilities.” State and Local Government Review50 (3): 189–202.
37.
GorinaEvgeniaHoangTrang. 2020. “Pension Reforms and Public Sector Turnover.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory30 (1): 96–112.
38.
GrangerClive WJ. 1969. “Investigating causal relations by econometric models and cross-spectral methods.” Econometrica37 (3): 424–438.
39.
GrizzleCleopatra. 2010. “The Impact of Budget Stabilization Funds on State General Obligation Bond Ratings.” Public Budgeting & Finance30 (2): 95–111.
40.
GuzmanTatyanaMoldogazievTima. 2012. “Which Bonds are More Expensive? The Cost Differentials by Debt Issue Purpose and the Method of Sale: An Empirical Analysis.” Public Budgeting and Finance32 (3): 79–101.
41.
HildrethW. BartleyMillerGerald J.. 2002. “Debt and the Local Economy: Problems in Benchmarking Local Government Debt Affordability.” Public Budgeting & Finance22 (4): 99–113.
42.
HoangTrang. 2022. “Fiscal Competition and State Pension Reforms.” Public Budgeting & Finance42 (3): 41–70.
43.
HoangTrangMaherCraig S.. 2022. “Fiscal Condition, Institutional Constraints, and Public Pension Contribution: Are Pension Contribution Shortfalls Fiscal Illusion?” Public Budgeting & Finance. (online first): 1–32.
44.
JimenezBenedict S. 2011. “Management Quality and State Bond Ratings: Exploring the Links Between Public Management and Fiscal Outcomes.” International Journal of Public Administration34 (12): 783–99.
45.
JohnsonCraig L.KrizKenneth A.. 2005. “Fiscal Institutions, Credit Ratings, and Borrowing Costs.” Public Budgeting and Finance25 (1): 84–103.
46.
JohnsonCraig L.KiokoSharon N.HildrethW. Bartley. 2012. “Government-Wide Financial Statements and Credit Risk.” Public Budgeting and Finance32 (1): 80–104.
47.
KaplanRobert S.UrwitzGabriel. 1979. “Statistical Models of Bond Ratings: A Methodological Inquiry.” The Journal of Business52 (2): 231–61.
48.
KoedelCoryPodgurskyMichaelShiShishan. 2013. “Teacher pension systems, the composition of the teaching workforce, and teacher quality.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management32 (3): 574–596.
49.
KruegerSkipWalkerRobert W.. 2008. “Divided Government, Political Turnover, and State Bond Ratings.” Public Finance Review36 (3): 259–86.
50.
LewisGregory B.StoychevaRayna L.. (2016). “Does pension plan structure affect turnover patterns?.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory26 (4): 787–799.
51.
LiuPuThakorAnjan V.. 1984. “Interest Yields, Credit Ratings, and Economic Characteristics of State Bonds: An Empirical Analysis: Note.” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking16 (3): 334–51.
52.
LiuCheolMikesellJohnMoldogazievTima T.. 2021. “Public Corruption and Pension Underfunding in the American States.” American Review of Public Administration51 (6): 449–66.
53.
LoviscekAnthony L.CrowleyFrederick D.. 1988. “Analyzing Changes in Municipal Bond Ratings: A Different Perspective.” Urban Studies25 (2): 124–32.
54.
LoviscekAnthony L.CrowleyFrederick D.. 1990. “What is in a Municipal Bond Rating?” Financial Review25 (1): 25–53.
55.
LowryRobert C.AltJames E.. 2001. “A Visible Hand? Bond Markets, Political Parties, Balanced Budget Laws, and State Government Debt.” Economics and Politics13 (1): 49–72.
56.
MarksBarry R.RamanK. K.. 1985. “The Importance of Pension Data for Municipal and State Creditor Decisions: Replication and Extensions.” Journal of Accounting Research23 (2): 878–86.
57.
MarksBarry R.RamanK. K.. 1988. “The Effect of Unfunded Accumulated and Projected Pension Obligations on Governmental Borrowing Costs.” Contemporary Accounting Research4 (2): 595–608.
58.
MarloweJustin. 2007. “Much Ado About Nothing? The Size and Credit Quality Implications of Municipal Other Postemployment Benefit Liabilities.” Public Budgeting & Finance27 (2): 104–31.
59.
MartellChristine R.KiokoSharon N.MoldogazievTima. 2013. “Impact of Unfunded Pension Obligations on Credit Quality of State Governments.” Public Budgeting and Finance33 (3): 24–54.
60.
McGuinnPatrick J. 2014. Pension Politics: Public Employee Retirement System Reform in Four States. Brown Center on Education Policy, Brookings Institution.
MillerGerald. 1996. Handbook of Debt Management. New York: M. Dekker.
64.
MoldogazievTima T.GuzmanTatyana. 2015. “Economic Crises, Economic Structure, and State Credit Quality Through-the-Cycle.” Public Budgeting and Finance35 (4): 42–67.
65.
MonahanAmy B. 2010. “Public Pension Plan Reform: The Legal Framework.” Education finance and policy5 (4): 617–646.
66.
Moody’s Investors Services. 2012. California Pension Reform Is Credit Positive.
Moody's Investors Services.2021. Public Sector Pension Investment Board.
70.
MunnellAlicia H.Golub-SassAlexHaverstickKellySotoMauricioWilesGregory. 2008. “Why Have Some States Introduced Defined Contribution Plans?” Boston College Center for Retirement Research - State and Local Pension Plans 3: 1–16.
71.
MunnellAlicia HAubryPierreBelbaseAnekHurwitzJosh. 2013. “State-Local Pension Costs: Pre-Crisis, Post-Crisis, and Post-Reform.” Center for Retirement Research at Boston College, no. February.
72.
MunnellAlicia HAubryJean-pierreCafarelliMark. 2014. “Defined Contribution Plans in the Public Sector: An Update.” Center for Retirement Research at Boston College, No. 37.
73.
NASRA. 2018. Significant Reforms to State Retirement Systems, no. December: 1–97.
74.
Novy-MarxRobertRauhJoshua. 2011. “Public Pension Promises: How Big are They and What are They Worth?” Journal of Finance66 (4): 1211–49.
75.
Novy-MarxRobertRauhJoshua D.. 2012. “Fiscal Imbalances and Borrowing Costs: Evidence From State Investment Losses.” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy4 (2): 182–213.
76.
PalumboGeorgeZaporowskiMark P.. 2012. “Determinants of Municipal Bond Ratings for General-Purpose Governments: An Empirical Analysis.” Public Budgeting and Finance32 (2): 86–102.
77.
PetersenJohn E. 2013. “Municipal Defaults: Eighty Years Make a Big Difference.” Municipal Finance Journal33/34 (4/1): 27–48.
PoterbaJames M.RuebenKim. 1999. “State Fiscal Institutions and the U.S. Municipal Bond Market.” Fiscal Institutions and Fiscal PerformanceI (January): 181–208.
81.
PoterbaJames M.RuebenKim S.. 2001. “Fiscal News, State Budget Rules, and Tax-Exempt Bond Yields.” Journal of Urban Economics50 (3): 537–62.
82.
RamanKrishnamurthy K.WilsonEarl R.. 1990. “The Debt Equivalence of Unfunded Government Pension Obligations.” Journal of Accounting and Public Policy9 (1): 37–56.
SpiottoJames E.AckerAnn E.ApplebyLaura E.. 2016. Municipalities in Distress?: How States and Investors Deal With Local Government Financial Emergencies. Chapman and Cutler LLP.
88.
St.Clair, Travis and Juan Pablo Martinez-Guzman. 2018. “Contribution volatility and public pension reform.” Journal of Pension Economics & Finance17 (4): 513–533.
89.
St. ClairTravisCookThomas D.. 2015. “Difference-in-Differences Methods in Public Finance.” National Tax Journal68 (2): 319–38.
90.
StalebrinkOdd J. 2014. “Public pension funds and assumed rates of return: An empirical examination of public sector defined benefit pension plans.” The American Review of Public Administration44 (1): 92–111.
91.
StalebrinkOdd J.DonatellaPierre. 2021. “Public pension governance and opportunistic accounting choice: A politico-economic approach.” The American Review of Public Administration51 (3): 227–245.
92.
StallmannJudith I.DellerStevenAmielLindsayMaherCraig. 2012. “Tax and Expenditure Limitations and State Credit Ratings.” Public Finance Review40 (5): 643–69.
93.
Standard & Poor's (S&P). 2017. “Local Government Pension and Other Postemployment Benefits Analysis: A Closer Look.”
94.
Standard & Poor's (S&P). 2019a. “U.S. State Pension Reforms Partly Mitigate the Effects of The Next Recession.”
95.
Standard & Poor's (S&P). 2019b. “Pension Brief: Credit Effects of Municipal Pension Plans Approaching Asset Depletion.”
96.
Standard & Poor's (S&P). 2020a. “Five U.S. State and Local Government Pension and OPEB Trends to Watch for in 2020 and Beyond.”
97.
Standard & Poor's (S&P). 2020b. “Pension Brief: The Future of U.S. Public Pensions After the Sudden-Stop Recession.”
98.
StevensonBetseyWolfersJustin. 2006. “Bargaining in the Shadow of the Law: Divorce Laws and Family Distress.” Quarterly Journal of Economics121 (1): 267–88.
ThomMichael. 2015. “The Drivers of Public Sector Pension Reform Across the U.S. States.” The American Review of Public Administration47 (4): 431–42.
101.
Triest, Robert K. and Bo Zhao. 2013. “The Role of Economic, Fiscal, and Financial Shocks in the Evolution of Public Sector Pension Funding.” Federal Reserve Bank of Boston.
102.
UyarBulentEscarrazDonald R.. 1995. “Rank Order Analysis of State General Obligation Bond Ratings.” Journal of Economics and Finance19 (2): 91–105.
103.
WagnerGary A. 2004. “The Bond Market and Fiscal Institutions: Have Budget Stabilization Funds Reduced State Borrowing Costs?” National Tax Journal57 (4): 785–804.
104.
WangQuishiPengJun. (2016). An Empirical Analysis of State and Local Public Pension Plan Funded Ratio Change, 2001-2009. The American Review of Public Administration46 (1):75–91.
105.
WarshawskyMark J.MarchandRoss A.. 2016. “The Extent and Nature of State and Local Government Pension Problems and a Solution.” Mercatus Center—George Mason University.
WeiWenchiDenisonDwight V.. 2019. “State Rainy Day Funds and Government General Fund Expenditures: Revisiting the Stabilization Effect.” Public Finance Review47 (3): 465–92.
108.
WinegardenWayne. 2016. “California’s Pension Crowd-Out: California’s Defined Benefit Public Pension Plans Are Unaffordable and over-Burden Current and Future Taxpayers.” Pacific Research Institute, no. January.
109.
WooldridgeJeffrey M. 2010. Econometric analysis of cross section and panel data. Cambridge, MA: MIT press.
110.
WooldridgeJeffrey M. 2020. Introductory Econometrics: A Modern Approach. 7th ed.Cengage.
111.
ZhaoZhirong (Jerry)GuoHai (David). 2011. “Management Capacity and State Municipal Bond Ratings: Evidence With the GPP Grades.” American Review of Public Administration41 (5): 562–76.
