We analyze data about cigarette tax compliance from the first US-based national scale littered cigarette packs collection. We code each pack based on whether an appropriate tax had been paid at the location where it was found. Noncompliance across our 132 sample communities ranges from 0 percent to 100 percent with an appropriately weighted mean of 21 percent. We provide evidence that noncompliance is due to both cross-border shopping and cigarette trafficking. Ordinary least squares and binomial logit regressions demonstrate that the financial incentive for noncompliance is the most important explanatory variable and has a statistically and quantitatively significant impact on noncompliance. We find mixed evidence about the extent to which tax avoidance varies with distance to lower-tax borders. Our simulations show that, even after accounting for increased noncompliance, virtually all areas in our study would experience increases in tax revenue if they increased cigarette tax rates.
BachmanJerald G.JohnstonLloyd D.O’MalleyPatrick M.SchulenbergJohn E.. 2011. “The Monitoring the Future Project after Thirty-seven Years: Design and Procedures.” Monitoring the Future Occasional Paper No. 76. Institute for Social Research, Ann Arbor, MI.
3.
BaltagiBadi H.LevinDan. 1986. “Estimating Dynamic Demand for Cigarettes Using Panel Data: The Effects of Bootlegging, Taxation and Advertising Reconsidered.” The Review of Economics and Statistics68:148–55.
4.
BarkerDianneWangShuMerrimanDavidCrosbyAndrewResnickElissaChaloupkaFrank. 2016. “Estimating Cigarette Tax Avoidance and Evasion: Evidence from a National Sample of Littered Packs.” Tobacco Control25:i38–43.
5.
BeckerGary S.GrossmanMichaelMurphyKevin M.. 1991. “Rational Addiction and the Effect of Price on Consumption.” American Economic Review81:237–41.
6.
ChaloupkaFrankWarnerKenneth. E.. 2000. “The Economics of Smoking.” In The Handbook of Health Economics (vol. 1), edited by CulyerAnthonyNewhouseJoseph, 1539–627. Amsterdam, the Netherlands: North-Holland.
7.
ChernickHowardMerrimanDavid. 2013. “Using Littered Pack Data to Estimate Cigarette Tax Avoidance in NYC.” National Tax Journal66:635–68.
8.
ColmanGregory J.RemlerDahlia K.. 2008. “Vertical Equity Consequences of Very High Cigarette Tax Increases: If the Poor Are the Ones Smoking, How Could Cigarette Tax Increases Be Progressive?” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management27:376–400.
9.
CrosbyAndrewMerrimanDavidWangShuChaloupkaFrank. 2014. “How Much Cigarette Tax Avoidance Is There in the US? Different Estimates from Smoker Surveys and Physical Pack Collection Methods.” Working Paper, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL.
10.
DavisKevin C.GrimshawVictoriaMerrimanDavidFarrellyMatthew C.ChernickHowardCoadyMicaela H.CampbellKelseyKansagraSusan M.. 2013. “Cigarette Trafficking in Five Northeastern US Cities.” Tobacco Control 23:e62–68.
11.
DeCiccaPhilipKenkelDonaldLiuFeng. 2013. “Excise Tax Avoidance: The Case of State Cigarette Taxes.” Journal of Health Economics32:1130–41.
12.
FixBrian V.HylandAndrewJ. O’ConnorRichardMichael CummingsK.FongGeoffrey T.ChaloupkaFrank J.LichtAndrea S.. 2014. “A Novel Approach to Estimating the Prevalence of Untaxed Cigarettes in the USA: Findings from the 2009 and 2010 International Tobacco Control Surveys.” Tobacco Control23:i61–66.
13.
FullertonDonKinnamanThomas C.. 1996. “Household Responses to Pricing Garbage by the Bag.” The American Economic Review86:971–84.
14.
GalbraithJohn W.KaisermanMurray. 1997. “Taxation, Smuggling and Demand for Cigarettes in Canada: Evidence from Time-series Data.” Journal of Health Economics16:287–301.
15.
GoldinJacobHomonoffTatiana. 2013. “Smoke Gets in Your Eyes: Cigarette Tax Salience and Regressivity.” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy5:302–36.
16.
GoolsbeeAustanLovenheimMichaelSlemrodJoel. 2010. “Playing with Fire: Cigarettes, Taxes, and Competition from the Internet.” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy2:131–54.
17.
HansonAndrewSullivanRyan. 2009. “The Incidence of Tobacco Taxation: Evidence from Geographic Micro-level Data.” National Tax Journal62:677–98.
18.
HardingMatthewLeibtagEphraimLovenheimMichael F.. 2012. “The Heterogeneous Geographic and Socioeconomic Incidence of Cigarette Taxes: Evidence from Nielsen Homescan Data.” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy4:169–98.
19.
Institute of Medicine and National Research Council. 2015. Understanding the U.S. Illicit Tobacco Market: Characteristics, Policy Context, and Lessons from International Experience. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
20.
KurtiMarin K.LampeKlaus vonThompkinsDouglas E.. 2013. “The Illegal Cigarette Market in a Socioeconomically Deprived Inner-city Area: The Case of the South Bronx.” Tobacco Control22:138–40.
21.
LakhdarBen C.2008. “Quantitative and Qualitative Estimates of Cross-border Tobacco Shopping and Tobacco Smuggling in France.” Tobacco Control17:12–16.
22.
LovenheimMichael F.2008. “How Far to the Border? The Extent and Impact of Cross-border Casual Cigarette Smuggling.” National Tax Journal61:7–33.
23.
MacleanJohanna CatherineWebberDouglas A.MartiJoachim. 2014. “An Application of Unconditional Quantile Regression to Cigarette Taxes.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management33:188–210.
24.
MerrimanDavid. 2010. “The Micro-geography of Tax Avoidance: Evidence from Littered Cigarette Packs in Chicago.” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy2:61–84.
25.
National Cancer Institute. 2016. “The Economics of Tobacco and Tobacco Control.” NCI Tobacco Control Monograph Series 21, National Cancer Institute and World Health Organization, Washington, DC.
26.
NicholsonAndrewTurnerTracy M.AlvaradoEduardo. 2016. “Cigarette Taxes and Cross-border Revenue Effects Evidence Using Retail Data.”Public Finance Review44:311–43.
27.
OrzechowskiP.WalkerR.. 2014. The Tax Burden on Tobacco. Arlington, VA.
28.
PeskoMichael F.TaurasJohn A.HuangJidongChaloupkaFrank J.. 2016. “The Influence of Geography and Measurement in Estimating Cigarette Price Responsiveness.”National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper, Cambridge, MA.
29.
RibislKurt M.SeidenbergAndrew B.OrlanElizabeth N.. 2016. “Comprehensive E-cigarette Regulation as a Step toward Harm Reduction.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management35:492–95.
30.
SabaRichard R.Randolph BeardT.EkelundRobert B.ResslerRand W.. 1995. “The Demand for Cigarette Smuggling.” Economic Inquiry33:189–202.
31.
StehrMark. 2005. “Cigarette Tax Avoidance and Evasion.” Journal of Health Economics24:277–97.
32.
ShettyKanaka D.DeLeireThomasWhiteChapinBhattacharyaJayanta. 2011. Changes in US Hospitalization and Mortality Rates Following Smoking Bans. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management30 (1): 6–28.
33.
TaurasJohn A.2005. “Can Public Policy Deter Smoking Escalation among Young Adults?” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management24:771–84.
34.
ThursbyJerry G.ThursbyMarie C.. 2000. “Interstate Cigarette Bootlegging: Extent, Revenue Losses, and Effects of Federal Intervention.” National Tax Journal53:59–77.
35.
van WalbeekCorné. 2015. “The Economics of Tobacco Control (Part 2): Evidence from the ITC Project.” Tobacco Control24:iii1–3.
WilsonNickThomsonGeorgeEdwardsRichardPeaceJo. 2009. “Estimating Missed Government Tax Revenue from Foreign Tobacco: Survey of Discarded Cigarette Packs.” Tobacco Control18:416–18.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
