Personal Income Tax Decentralization,Inequality,and Social Welfare

Abstract

This article elaborates and evaluates a model for the decentralization of a personal income tax that is consistent with the optimal redistribution model. In this study’s model, the regions have individualistic, symmetrical, additively separable, and inequality-averse social welfare functions. Each region applies to its constituents a progressive personal income tax, which measures individuals’ ability to pay with sole regard to their income. The central government has a social welfare function, and its tax-raising power is limited to the establishment of a surcharge (or deduction) proportional to the income of individuals net of the respective regional taxes. This article presents the conditions that permit this model of fiscal decentralization to be recommended as a result of the reduction of inequality and the increase in welfare in each region and in the country as a whole. The theoretical results are applied to the Spanish income tax by the performance of various microsimulation exercises.

Keywords

personal income tax decentralization inequality social welfare

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Atkinson, Anthony B. 1970. On the measurement of inequality. Journal of Economic Theory 2:244-263.

Atkinson, Anthony B. , and François Bourguignon . 1987. Income distribution and differences in needs. In Arrow and the foundations of the theory of economic policy, edited by George R. Feiwel , 350-370. London: Macmillan.

Atkinson, Anthony B. , François Bourguignon , and Pierre A. Chiappori . 1988. What do we learn about tax reform from international comparisons? European Economic Review 32:343-352.

Badenes, Nuria , Julio López-Laborda , Jorge Onrubia , and Jesús Ruiz-Huerta . 2001. Simplification and decentralization of income tax. Public Finance Review 29 (1): 50-61.

Buchanan, James M. 1950. Federalism and fiscal equity. American Economic Review 40 (4): 583-599.

Cremer, Helmuth , Virginie Fourgeaud , Manuel Leite-Montero , Maurice Marchand , and Pierre Pestieau . 1996. Mobility and redistribution: A survey. Public Finance/Finances Publiques 51 (3): 325-352.

Cremer, Helmuth , and Pierre Pestieau . 2004. Factor mobility and redistribution: A survey. In Handbook of urban and regional economics, vol. 4, edited by J. Vernon Henderson and Jacques F. Thisse , 2529-2560. Amsterdam: Elsevier-North Holland.

Cubel, María , and Peter J. Lambert . 2002a. Progression-neutral income tax reforms and horizontal inequality. Journal of Economics 9 (Suppl.): 1-8.

Cubel, María , and Peter J. Lambert . 2002b. A regional approach to income tax reforms. Public Finance Review 30 (2): 124-143.

10.

Ebert, Udo . 1997. Social welfare when needs differ: An axiomatic approach. Economica 64:233-244.

11.

Ebert, Udo . 1999. Using equivalent income of equivalent adults to rank income distributions. Social Choice and Welfare 16:233-258.

12.

Ebert, Udo . 2000. Equalizing incomes: A normative approach. International Tax and Public Finance 7 (6): 619-640.

13.

Ebert, Udo , and Patrick Moyes . 2000. Adjusting income for needs: Can one avoid equivalence scales? Discussion Paper V-204-00, University of Oldenberg.

14.

Ebert, Udo , and Patrick Moyes . 2003. Equivalence scales reconsidered. Econometrica 71 (1): 319-343.

15.

Fellman, Johan . 1976. The effect of transformations on Lorenz curves. Econometrica 44:823-824.

16.

Jakobsson, Ulf . 1976. On the measurement of the degree of progression. Journal of Public Economics 5:161-168.

17.

Lambert, Peter J. 1988. Progressive income taxation is inequality-reducing or is it? IFS Working Paper 88/14, Institute for Fiscal Studies, London.

18.

Lambert, Peter J. 1992. Rich-to-poor income transfers reduce inequality: A generalization. Research on Economic Inequality 2:183-192.

19.

Lambert, Peter J. 1993a. The distribution and redistribution of income. In Current issues in public sector economics, edited by Peter M. Jackson , 200-226. London: Macmillan.

20.

Lambert, Peter J. 1993b. Inequality reduction through the income tax. Economica 239:357-365.

21.

Lambert, Peter J. 1994. Redistribution through the income tax. In Taxation, poverty and income distribution, edited by John Creedy , 1-16. Aldershot, UK: Edward Elgar.

22.

Lambert, Peter J. 2001. The distribution and redistribution of income. 3rd ed. Manchester, UK: Manchester University Press.

23.

Moyes, Patrick , and Anthony F. Shorrocks . 1998. The impossibility of a progressive tax structure. Journal of Public Economics 69:49-65.

24.

Musgrave, Richard A. 1959. The theory of public finance. New York: McGraw-Hill.

25.

Oates, Wallace E. 1972. Fiscal federalism. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.

26.

Ok, Efe A. , and Peter J. Lambert . 1999. On evaluating social welfare by sequential generalised Lorenz dominance. Economics Letters 63:45-53.

27.

Pfähler, Wilhelm . 1984. “Linear” income tax cuts: Distributional effects, social preferences and revenue elasticities. Journal of Public Economics 24:381-388.

28.

Stigler, George J. 1957. The tenable range of functions of local government. In Federal expenditure policy for economic growth and stability, 213-219. Washington, DC: Joint Economic Committee, Subcommittee on Fiscal Policy.

29.

Tresch, Richard W. 2002. Public finance: A normative theory. 2nd ed. San Diego: Academic Press.

30.

Wellisch, Dietmar . 2000. Theory of public finance in a federal state. New York: Cambridge University Press.