This article constructs a transitional protection rule-an “old-wealth deduction” -for conversion of the income tax to a personal consumption tax and tests it in four stylized life cycle economies (identical, pension, bequest, and spender) by performing numerical simulations. It is assumed that the compensated elasticity of saving with respect to the interest rate is zero (the uncompensated elasticity is negative). In all four economies, the protection rule substantially reduces the harm to older cohorts from tax conversion; at the same time, young and future cohorts continue to benefit (in almost all cases) from tax conversion despite this protection rule. The results may be sensitive to the particular functions used in the model: a Cobb-Douglas production function and a Leontief utility function (implying a zero compensated saving elasticity).
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aaron, Henry J., and Harvey Galper. 1985. Assessing tax reform. Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution.
2.
Andrews, William D.1974. A consumption-type or cash flow personal income tax. Harvard Law Review87: 1113-1188.
3.
Auerbach, Alan J., and Laurence J. Kotlikoff. 1987. Dynamic fiscal policy. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
4.
Bradford, David F.1986. Untangling the income tax. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
5.
Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS).1992. Strengthening of America Commission: First report. Washington, D.C.: CSIS.
6.
Domenici, Pete V.1994. The unamerican spirit of the federal income tax. Harvard Journal on Legislation31 (2): 273-320.
7.
Feldstein, Martin S.1976. Taxing consumption. New Republic, 28 February, 14-17.
8.
Fisher, Irving, and Herbert Fisher. 1942. Constructive income taxation: A proposal for reform. New York: Harper & Brothers.
9.
Ginsburg, Martin D.1995. Life under a personal consumption tax: Some thoughts on working, saving, and consuming in Nunn-Domenici’s tax world. National Tax Journal48 (4): 585-602.
10.
Graetz, Michael J.1979. Implementing a progressive consumption tax. Harvard Law Review92:1575-1661.
11.
Harriss, C. Lowell. 1978. Taxing consumption, not production: Expenditure instead of income taxation. Tax Review39 (1): 1-4.
12.
Institute for Fiscal Studies. 1978. The structure and reform of direct taxation. London: Allen & Unwin.
13.
Jorgenson, Dale, Frank Gollop, and Barbara Fraumeni. 1987. Productivity and U.S. economic growth. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
14.
Kaldor, Nicholas. 1955. An expenditure tax. London: Allen & Unwin.
15.
Kaplow, Louis. 1995. Recovery of pre-enactment basis under a consumption tax: The USA tax system. Tax Notes68:1109-1118.
16.
Kay, John A., and Mervyn A. King. 1990. The British tax system. 5th ed.Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
17.
Lewis, Kenneth A., and Laurence S. Seidman. 1994. A phased increase in the U.S. investment rate: Sacrifice times, T-year gains, and investment rate returns. Journal of Policy Modeling16 (6): 653-676.
18.
Lord, William. 1989. The transition from payroll to consumption receipts with endogenous human capital. Journal of Public Economics38:53-73.
19.
McLure, Charles E., Jr.1988. The 1986 act: Tax reform’s finest hour or death throes of the income tax?National Tax Journal41 (3): 303-315.
20.
McLure, Charles E., Jr.1993. Economic, administrative, and political factors in choosing a general consumption tax. National Tax Journal46 (3): 345-358.
21.
McLure, Charles E., Jr., and George R. Zodrow. 1990. Administrative advantages of the individual tax prepayment approach to the direct taxation of consumption. In Heidelberg Congress on taxing consumption, edited by Manfred Rose, 335-382. New York: Springer-Verlag.
22.
Menchik, Paul, and Martin David. 1982. The incidence of a lifetime consumption tax. National Tax Journal35 (2): 189-203.
23.
Metcalf, Gilbert E.1994. Life cycle versus annual perspectives on the incidence of the value added tax. In Tax policy and the economy, vol. 8, edited by James M. Poterba, 45-64. Cambridge: MIT Press.
24.
Mieszkowski, Peter. 1980. The advisability and feasibility of an expenditure tax system. In The economics of taxation, edited by Henry J. Aaron and Michael J. Boskin, 179-201. Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution.
25.
Pechman, Joseph A., ed. 1980. What should be taxed: Income or expenditure?Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution.
26.
Poterba, James M.1994. Government saving incentives in the United States. In Public policies and household saving, edited by James M. Poterba. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
27.
Rose, Manfred, ed. 1990. Heidelberg Congress on taxing consumption. Berlin: Springer-Verlag.
28.
Sarkar, Shounak S., and George R. Zodrow. 1993. Transitional issues in moving to a direct consumption tax. National Tax Journal46 (3): 359-376.
29.
Seidman, Laurence S.1980. The personal consumption tax and social welfare. Challenge23 (4): 10-16.
30.
Seidman, Laurence S.1984. Conversion to a consumption tax: The transition in a life-cycle growth model. Journal of Political Economy92 (2): 247-267.
31.
Seidman, Laurence S.1990. Saving for America’s economic future: Parables and policies. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe.
32.
Seidman, Laurence S.1994. A better way to tax. Public Interest, Winter, 65-72.
33.
Seidman, Laurence S.1997. The USA tax: A progressive consumption tax. Cambridge: MIT Press.
34.
Seidman, Laurence S., and Kenneth A. Lewis. 1997. The design of a tax rule for housing under a personal consumption tax. Public Finance Quarterly25 (1): 5-24.
35.
Slemrod, Joel. 1996. Which is the simplest tax system of them all? In Economic effects of fundamental tax reform, edited by Henry J. Aaron and William G. Gale, 355-391. Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution.
36.
Summers, Lawrence. 1981. Capital taxation and accumulation in a life cycle growth model. American Economic Review71 (4): 533-544.
37.
(Revised version issued as David F. Bradford and the U.S. Treasury Tax Policy Staff, Blueprints for basic tax reform. Arlington, VA: Tax Analysts, 1984)
38.
Warren, Alvin. 1995. The proposal for an “unlimited savings allowance.”Tax Notes68:1103-1108.
