Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2020-5
Are Collectivistic Cultures More Prone to Rapid Transformation? Computational Models of Cross-Cultural Differences,Social Network Structure,Dynamic Social Influence,and Cultural Change
Societies differ in susceptibility to social influence and in the social network structure through which individuals influence each other. What implications might these cultural differences have for changes in cultural norms over time? Using parameters informed by empirical evidence, we computationally modeled these cross-cultural differences to predict two forms of cultural change: consolidation of opinion majorities into stronger majorities, and the spread of initially unpopular beliefs. Results obtained from more than 300,000 computer simulations showed that in populations characterized by greater susceptibility to social influence, there was more rapid consolidation of majority opinion and also more successful spread of initially unpopular beliefs. Initially unpopular beliefs also spread more readily in populations characterized by less densely connected social networks. These computational outputs highlight the value of computational modeling methods as a means to specify hypotheses about specific ways in which cross-cultural differences may have long-term consequences for cultural stability and cultural change.
AlbarracínD.VargasP. (2010). Attitudes and persuasion: From biology to social responses to persuasive intent. In FiskeS. T.GilbertD. T.LindzeyG. (Eds.), The handbook of social psychology (pp. 394-427). Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.
2.
AlujaA.Garcı́aÓ.Garcı́aL. F. (2003). Relationships among extraversion, openness to experience, and sensation seeking. Personality and Individual Differences, 35, 671-680.
3.
ApicellaC. L.MarloweF. W.FowlerJ. H.ChristakisN. A. (2012). Social networks and cooperation in hunter-gatherers. Nature, 481, 497-501.
4.
ArentzeT. A.KowaldM.AxhausenK. W. (2013). An agent-based random-utility-maximization model to generate social networks with transitivity in geographic space. Social Networks, 35, 451-459.
5.
ArpaciI.BaloğluM.KesiciŞ. (2018). The relationship among individual differences in individualism-collectivism, extraversion, and self-presentation. Personality and Individual Differences, 121, 89-92.
6.
AsendorpfJ. B.WilpersS. (1998). Personality effects on social relationships. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 74(6), 1531.
7.
AxelrodR. M. (1997). The complexity of cooperation: Agent-based models of competition and collaboration. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
8.
BackstromL.BoldiP.RosaM.UganderJ.VignaS. (2012, June22-24). Four degrees of separation. Paper presented at the Proceedings of the 4th Annual ACM Web Science Conference, Evanston, IL.
9.
BaldingD. J.NicholsR. A. (1995). A method for quantifying differentiation between populations at multi-allelic loci and its implications for investigating identity and paternity. In WeirB. S. (Ed.), Human identification: The use of DNA markers (Vol. 4, pp. 3-12). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer.
10.
BarabásiA.-L. (2016). Network science. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
11.
BatchelderW. H. (1975). Individual differences and the all-or-none vs incremental learning controversy. Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 12, 53-74.
12.
BergerJ.HeathC. (2007). Where consumers diverge from others: Identity signaling and product domains. Journal of Consumer Research, 34, 121-134.
13.
BergerJ.HeathC. (2008). Who drives divergence? Identity signaling, outgroup dissimilarity, and the abandonment of cultural tastes. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 95, 593-607.
14.
BergerJ.SchwartzE. M. (2011). What drives immediate and ongoing word of mouth?Journal of Marketing Research, 48, 869-880.
15.
BoldiP.VignaS. (2012, August26-29). Four degrees of separation, really. Paper presented at the 2012 IEEE/ACM International Conference on Advances in Social Networks Analysis and Mining, Istanbul, Turkey.
16.
BondR.SmithP. B. (1996). Culture and conformity: A meta-analysis of studies using Asch’s (1952b, 1956) line judgment task. Psychological Bulletin, 119, 111-137.
17.
BoydR.RichersonP. J. (1985). Culture and the evolutionary process. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
18.
BrownJ. J.ReingenP. H. (1987). Social ties and word-of-mouth referral behavior. Journal of Consumer Research, 14, 350-362.
19.
ButtsC. T.ActonR. M.HippJ. R.NagleN. N. (2012). Geographical variability and network structure. Social Networks, 34, 82-100.
20.
ByrneD. (1971). The attraction paradigm. San Diego, CA: Academic Press.
21.
CacioppoJ. T.PettyR. E.FeinsteinJ. A.JarvisW. B. G. (1996). Dispositional differences in cognitive motivation: The life and times of individuals varying in need for cognition. Psychological Bulletin, 119, 197-253.
22.
CentolaD.BeckerJ.BrackbillD.BaronchelliA. (2018). Experimental evidence for tipping points in social convention. Science, 360, 1116-1119.
23.
ChiuC. Y.MorrisM. W.HongY. Y.MenonT. (2000). Motivated cultural cognition: The impact of implicit cultural theories on dispositional attribution varies as a function of need for closure. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 78, 247-259.
24.
ChoiS. M.KimY.SungY.SohnD. (2011). Bridging or bonding? A cross-cultural study of social relationships in social networking sites. Information, Communication & Society, 14, 107-129.
25.
ChuaY.-J.MorrisM. W. (2006). Dynamics of trust in guanxi networks. In ChenR.-Y. (Ed.), National culture and groups (Vol. 9, pp. 95-113). Oxford, UK: JAI Press.
26.
ChudekM.MuthukrishnaM.HenrichJ. (2015). Cultural evolution. In BussD. M. (Ed.), The handbook of evolutionary psycho-logy (2nd ed., Vol. 2, pp. 749-769). Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley.
27.
CollarA. (2007). Network theory and religious innovation. Mediterranean Historical Review, 22, 149-162.
28.
ConwayL. G.IIISchallerM. (2007). How communication shapes culture. In FiedlerK. (Ed.), Social communication (pp. 107-127). New York, NY: Psychology Press.
29.
CullumJ.HartonH. C. (2007). Cultural evolution: Interpersonal influence, issue importance, and the development of shared attitudes in college residence halls. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 33, 1327-1339.
30.
DeS.NauD. S.GelfandM. J. (2017May). Understanding norm change: An evolutionary game-theoretic approach. Paper presented at the Proceedings of the 16th Conference on Autonomous Agents and MultiAgent Systems, Sao Paulo, Brazil.
31.
DeS.NauD. S.PanX.GelfandM. J. (2018). Tipping points for norm change in human cultures. arXiv preprint arXiv:1804.07406.
32.
DerexM.BoydR. (2016). Partial connectivity increases cultural accumulation within groups. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA, 113, 2982-2987.
33.
DwyerS.MesakH.HsuM. (2005). An exploratory examination of the influence of national culture on cross-national product diffusion. Journal of International Marketing, 13(2), 1-27.
34.
ErikssonK.EnquistM.GhirlandaS. (2007). Critical points in current theory of conformist social learning. Journal of Evolutionary Psychology, 5, 67-87.
35.
FestingerL.SchachterS.BackK. (1950). The spatial ecology of group formation. In FestingerL.BackK. W.SchachterS. (Eds.), Social pressures in informal groups (pp. 33-60). Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
36.
FlacheA.MäsM.FelicianiT.Chattoe-BrownE.DeffuantG.HuetS.LorenzJ. (2017). Models of social influence: Towards the next frontiers. Journal of Artificial Societies & Social Simulation, 20(4). Retrieved from http://jasss.soc.surrey.ac.uk/20/4/2.html
37.
GrossmannI.VarnumM. E. (2015). Social structure, infectious diseases, disasters, secularism, and cultural change in America. Psychological Science, 26, 311-324.
38.
GuptaA. K.NadarajahS. (2004). Handbook of beta distribution and its applications. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
39.
HaiderM.KrepsG. L. (2004). Forty years of diffusion of innovations: Utility and value in public health. Journal of Health Communication, 9(Suppl. 1), 3-11.
40.
HartonH. C.BourgeoisM. J. (2003). Cultural elements emerge from dynamic social impact. In SchallerM.CrandallC. S. (Eds.), The psychological foundations of culture (pp. 41-75). New York, NY: Psychology Press.
41.
HartonH. C.BullockM. (2007). Dynamic social impact: A theory of the origins and evolution of culture. Social & Personality Psychology Compass, 1, 521-540.
42.
HastieR.KamedaT. (2005). The robust beauty of majority rules in group decisions. Psychological Review, 112, 494-508.
43.
HeineS. J.FosterJ. A. B.SpinaR. (2009). Do birds of a feather universally flock together? Cultural variation in the similarity-attraction effect. Asian Journal of Social Psychology, 12, 247-258.
44.
HenrichJ. (2001). Cultural transmission and the diffusion of innovations: Adoption dynamics indicate that biased cultural transmission is the predominate force in behavioral change. American Anthropologist, 103, 992-1013.
45.
HenrichJ. (2004). Cultural group selection, coevolutionary processes and large-scale cooperation. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 53(1), 3-35.
46.
HenrichJ.BroeschJ. (2011). On the nature of cultural transmission networks: Evidence from Fijian villages for adaptive learning biases. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 366, 1139-1148.
47.
HofstedeG.McCraeR. R. (2004). Personality and culture revisited: Linking traits and dimensions of culture. Cross-Cultural Research, 38, 52-88.
48.
Hoshino-BrowneE. (2012). Cultural variations in motivation for cognitive consistency: Influences of self-systems on cognitive dissonance. Social & Personality Psychology Compass, 6, 126-141.
49.
JacksonJ. C.RandD.LewisK.NortonM. I.GrayK. (2017). Agent-based modeling: A guide for social psychologists. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 8, 387-395.
50.
JacksonM. O. (2010). Social and economic networks. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
51.
KamedaT.TakezawaM.HastieR. (2003). The logic of social sharing: An evolutionary game analysis of adaptive norm development. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 7(1), 2-19.
52.
KaoA. B.CouzinI. D. (2014). Decision accuracy in complex environments is often maximized by small group sizes. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 281(1784), 20133305.
53.
KashimaY.WilsonS.LusherD.PearsonL. J.PearsonC. (2013). The acquisition of perceived descriptive norms as social category learning in social networks. Social Networks, 35, 711-719.
54.
KempeM.MesoudiA. (2014). An experimental demonstration of the effect of group size on cultural accumulation. Evolution & Human Behavior, 35, 285-290.
55.
KenneyP. J.RiceT. W. (1994). The psychology of political momentum. Political Research Quarterly, 47, 923-938.
56.
KerrN. L.TindaleR. S. (2004). Group performance and decision making. Annual Review of Psychology, 55, 623-655.
57.
KimH.MarkusH. R. (1999). Deviance or uniqueness, harmony or conformity? A cultural analysis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 77, 785-800.
58.
KojadinovicI.YanJ. (2010). Modeling multivariate distributions with continuous margins using the copula R package. Journal of Statistical Software, 34(9), 1-20.
59.
KruglanskiA. W.WebsterD. M.KlemA. (1993). Motivated resistance and openness to persuasion in the presence or absence of prior information. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 65, 861-876.
60.
LaarC. V.LevinS.SinclairS.SidaniusJ. (2005). The effect of university roommate contact on ethnic attitudes and behavior. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 41, 329-345.
61.
LatanéB. (1996). Dynamic social impact: The creation of culture by communication. Journal of Communication, 46(4), 13-25.
62.
LatanéB.LiuJ. H.NowakA.BoneventoM.ZhengL. (1995). Distance matters: Physical space and social impact. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 21, 795-805.
63.
LiuP.ChanD.QiuL.TovW.TongV. J. C. (2018). Effects of cultural tightness–looseness and social network density on expression of positive and negative emotions: A large-scale study of impression management by Facebook users. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin44, 1567–1581.
64.
MacCounR. J. (2012). The burden of social proof: Shared thresholds and social influence. Psychological Review, 119, 345-372.
65.
MasonW. A.ConreyF. R.SmithE. R. (2007). Situating social influence processes: Dynamic, multidirectional flows of influence within social networks. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 11, 279-300.
66.
McCraeR. R.TerraccianoA., & 79 Members of the Personality Profiles of Cultures Project. (2005). Personality profiles of cultures: Aggregate personality traits. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 89, 407.
67.
MoscoviciS. (1980). Toward a theory of conversion behavior. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 13, 209-239.
68.
MuthukrishnaM.HenrichJ. (2016). Innovation in the collective brain. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 371(1690), 20150192.
69.
MuthukrishnaM.MorganT. J. H.HenrichJ. (2016). The when and who of social learning and conformist transmission. Evolution & Human Behavior, 37(1), 10-20.
70.
MuthukrishnaM.ShulmanB. W.VasilescuV.HenrichJ. (2013). Sociality influences cultural complexity. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 281(1774), 20132511.
71.
NadeauR.CloutierE.GuayJ.-H. (1993). New evidence about the existence of a bandwagon effect in the opinion formation process. International Political Science Review, 14, 203-213.
72.
NemethC. J. (1986). Differential contributions of majority and minority influence. Psychological Review, 93(1), 23-32.
73.
NgK. Y.Van DyneL. (2001). Individualism-collectivism as a boundary condition for effectiveness of minority influence in decision making. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 84, 198-225.
74.
NowakA. (2004). Dynamical minimalism: Why less is more in psychology. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 8, 183-192.
75.
NowakA.SzamrejJ.LatanéB. (1990). From private attitude to public opinion: A dynamic theory of social impact. Psychological Review, 97, 362-376.
76.
OrjiR. (2016, April). Persuasion and culture: Individualism-collectivism and susceptibility to influence strategies. Paper presented at the Proceedings of the Personalization in Persuasive Technology Workshop, Persuasive Technology 2016, Salzburg, Austria.
77.
PaulhusD. L.TrapnellP. D. (1998). Typological measures of shyness: Additive, interactive, and categorical. Journal of Research in Personality, 32, 183-201.
78.
PfauJ.KirleyM.KashimaY. (2013). The co-evolution of cultures, social network communities, and agent locations in an extension of Axelrod’s model of cultural dissemination. Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and Its Applications, 392, 381-391.
79.
PolletT. V.RobertsS. G. B.DunbarR. I. M. (2011). Extraverts have larger social network layers: But do not feel emotionally closer to individuals at any layer. Journal of Individual Differences, 32, 161-169.
80.
RogersE. M. (2003). Diffusion of innovations (5th ed.). New York, NY: Free Press.
81.
SchallerM.ConwayL. G.IIITanchukT. L. (2002). Selective pressures on the once and future contents of ethnic stereotypes: Effects of the communicability of traits. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 82, 861-877.
82.
SchnettlerS. (2009). A structured overview of 50 years of smallworld research. Social Networks, 31, 165-178. doi:10/dg6sjr
83.
SchugJ.YukiM.HorikawaH.TakemuraK. (2009). Similarity attraction and actually selecting similar others: How cross-societal differences in relational mobility affect interpersonal similarity in Japan and the USA. Asian Journal of Social Psychology, 12, 95-103.
84.
SelfhoutM.BurkW.BranjeS.DenissenJ.Van AkenM.MeeusW. (2010). Emerging late adolescent friendship networks and Big Five personality traits: A social network approach. Journal of personality, 78, 509-538.
85.
SingelisT. M.TriandisH. C.BhawukD. P.GelfandM. J. (1995). Horizontal and vertical dimensions of individualism and collectivism: A theoretical and measurement refinement. Cross-Cultural Research, 29, 240-275.
86.
SmaldinoP. E. (2017). Models are stupid, and we need more of them. In VallacherR. R.ReadS. J.NowakA. (Eds.), Computational social psychology (pp. 311-331). New York, NY: Routledge.
87.
Spencer-RodgersJ.WilliamsM. J.PengK. (2010). Cultural differences in expectations of change and tolerance for contradiction: A decade of empirical research. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 14, 296-312.
88.
TesserA. (1993). The importance of heritability in psychological research: The case of attitudes. Psychological Review, 100, 129-142.
89.
UganderJ.KarrerB.BackstromL.MarlowC. (2011). The anatomy of the Facebook social graph. arXiv preprint arXiv:1111.4503.
90.
ValenteT. W. (1995). Network models of the diffusion of innovations (Vol. 2). Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press.
91.
VallacherR. R.ReadS. J.NowakA. (2002). The dynamical perspective in personality and social psychology. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 6, 264-273.
92.
VarnumM. E.GrossmannI. (2017). Cultural change: The how and the why. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 12, 956-972.
93.
von RosenstielD. P.HeuermannD. F.HüsigS. (2015). Why has the introduction of natural gas vehicles failed in Germany?—Lessons on the role of market failure in markets for alternative fuel vehicles. Energy Policy, 78, 91-101. doi:10/f64kxx
94.
WeisbuchG.DeffuantG.AmblardF. (2005). Persuasion dynamics. Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and Its Applications, 353, 555-575.
95.
WejnertB. (2002). Integrating models of diffusion of innovations: A conceptual framework. Annual Review of Sociology, 28, 297-326.
96.
WilkenB.MiyamotoY.UchidaY. (2011). Cultural influences on preference consistency: Consistency at the individual and collective levels. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 21, 346-353.
97.
WoodW.LundgrenS.OuelletteJ. A.BuscemeS.BlackstoneT. (1994). Minority influence: A meta-analytic review of social influence processes. Psychological Bulletin, 115, 323-345.
98.
ZouX.TamK. P.MorrisM. W.LeeS. L.LauI. Y.ChiuC.-Y. (2009). Culture as common sense: Perceived consensus versus personal beliefs as mechanisms of cultural influence. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 97, 579-597.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
