Child Deaths from Lack of Care and Injuries of Undetermined Intent in Ohio,1959 to 2015: How Many Were Probable Homicides?

Abstract

Previous scholars have shown that a considerable proportion of child deaths in mortality statistics that have been coded as deaths from Lack of Care (LC) or from Injuries of Undetermined Intent (IUI) were probable homicides. Historical research, however, shows (a) that nosologists used the LC and IUI classifications with a changing frequency over time in Ohio and in the national at large in relation to the number of child deaths that they classified as homicides, and (b) that the proportion of LC and IUI deaths in Ohio that were probable homicides changed over time. These changes should be taken into account by historical criminologists whenever they study long-term trends in child homicides, particularly the homicides of children under age 10.

Keywords

infant homicides child homicides lack of care injuries of undetermined intent International Classification of Diseases

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alharbi

M. A.

Isouard

Tolchard

(2021). Historical development of the statistical classification of causes of death and diseases. Cogent Medicine, 8(1), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1080/2331205X.2021.1893422

American Academy of Pediatrics. (1999). Committee on Child Abuse and Neglect and Committee on Community Health Services. Investigation and review of unexpected infant and child deaths. Pediatrics, 104(5), 1158–1160.

American Academy of Pediatrics. (2010). Committee on Child Abuse and Neglect, Committee on Injury, Violence, and Poison Prevention, and Council on Community Pediatrics. Policy statement—Child fatality review. Pediatrics, 126(3), 592–596.

Baltay

McCormick

M. C.

Wise

P. H.

(1999). Implementation of Fetal and Infant Mortality Review (FIMR): Experience from the national healthy start program. Maternal and Child Health Journal, 3(3), 141–150.

Baron

(1993). Gender inequality and child homicide: A state-level analysis. In Wilson

A. V.

(Ed.), Homicide: The victim/offender connection (pp. 207–225). Anderson Publishing.

Bischoff

(2024, April 18). Ohio Supreme Court says death records in a database aren’t subject to public disclosure. Columbus Dispatch, 1A.

Boos

S. C.

Wang

Karst

W. A.

Hymel

K. P.

(2022). Traumatic head injury and the diagnosis of abuse: A cluster analysis. Pediatrics, 149(1), e2021051742. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2021-051742

Breiding

M. J.

Wiersema

(2006). Variability of undetermined manner of death classification in the US. Injury Prevention, 12(Suppl II), 49–54.

Buckley

Chapin

J. L.

(1999). Fetal and Infant Mortality Review: An evolving process. Maternal and Child Health Journal, 3(3), 173–176.

10.

Bulloch

Schubert

C. J.

Brophy

P. D.

Johnson

Reed

M. H.

Shapiro

R. A.

(2000). Cause and clinical characteristics of rib fractures in infants. Pediatrics, 105(4), E48. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.105.4.e48

11.

Burnham

J. C.

(1995). Why did the infants and toddlers die? Shifts in Americans’ ideas of responsibility for accidents: From blaming mom to engineering. Journal of Social History, 29, 817–837.

12.

Burnham

J. C.

(2009). Accident prone: A history of technology, psychology, and misfits of the machine age. University of Chicago Press.

13.

Carlins

E. M.

Collins

K. S.

(2007). Cribs for kids: Risk and reduction of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome and accidental suffocation. Health and Social Work, 32(3), 225–229.

14.

Christoffel

K. K.

Anzinger

N. K.

Merrill

D. A.

(1989). Age-related patterns of violent death, Cook County, Illinois, 1977 through 1982. American Journal of Diseases of Children, 143(12), 1403–1409.

15.

Crume

T. L.

DiGuiseppi

Byers

Sirotnak

A. P.

Garrett

C. J.

(2002). Underascertainment of child maltreatment fatalities by death certificates, 1990–1998. Pediatrics, 110(2), e18. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.110.2.e18

16.

Durfee

M. J.

Gellert

G. A.

Tilton-Durfee

(1992). Origins and clinical relevance of child death review teams. JAMA, 267, 3172–3175.

17.

Ewigman

Kivlahan

Land

(1993). The Missouri child fatality study: Underreporting of maltreatment fatalities among children younger than five years of age, 1983 through 1986. Pediatrics, 91(2), 330–337.

18.

Farrell

C. A.

Fleegler

E. W.

Monuteaux

M. C.

Wilson

C. R.

Christian

C. W.

Lee

L. K.

(2017). Community poverty and child abuse fatalities in the United States. Pediatrics, 135(9), e20161616. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2016-1616

19.

Finkelhor

(2008). Childhood victimization: Violence, crime, and abuse in the lives of young people. Oxford University Press.

20.

Fox

J. A.

Swatt

M. L.

(2009). Multiple imputation of the Supplementary Homicide Reports, 1976–2005. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 25(1), 51–77.

21.

Green

(1997). Risk and misfortune: A social construction of accidents. UCL Press.

22.

Guyomarc’h

Campagna-Vaillancourt

Kremer

Sauvageau

(2010). Discrimination of falls and blows in blunt head trauma: A multi-criteria approach. Journal of Forensic Sciences, 55(2), 423–427.

23.

Hanzlick

Hunsaker

J. C.

Davis

G. J.

(2002). A guide for manner of death classification (1st ed.). National Association of Medical Examiners. https://name.memberclicks.net/assets/docs/MANNEROFDEATH.pdf

24.

Hunnicutt

(2007). Female status and infant and child homicide victimization in rural and urban counties in the U.S. Gender Issues, 24, 35–50.

25.

Kim

S. Y.

Shapiro-Mendoza

C. K.

Chu

S. Y.

Camperlengo

L. T.

Anderson

R. N.

(2012). Differentiating cause-of-death terminology for deaths coded as Sudden Infant Death Syndrome, accidental suffocation, and unknown cause: An investigation using US death certificates, 2003–2004. Journal of Forensic Sciences, 57(2), 364–369.

26.

Kremer

Sauvageau

(2009). Discrimination of falls and blows in blunt head trauma: Assessment of predictability through combined criteria. Journal of Forensic Sciences, 54(4), 923–926.

27.

Loftin

McDowall

Fetzer

M. D.

(2008). A comparison of SHR and vital statistics estimates for U.S. cities. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice, 24(1), 4–17.

28.

Mayhew

(2007). Child death investigations: Interdisciplinary techniques from cradle to court. Carolina Academic Press.

29.

National Center for Fatality Review and Prevention. (2017). Keeping kids alive: A report on the status of child death review in the United States 2016. https://www.ncfrp.org/wp-content/uploads/NCRPCD-Docs/CDRinUS_2016.pdf

30.

National Vital Statistics System. (n.d.). Training and instruction materials. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/training-and-instructional-materials.htm

31.

Overpeck

M. D.

Brenner

R. A.

Trumble

A. C.

Smith

G. S.

MacDorman

M. F.

Berendes

H. W.

(1999). Infant injury deaths with unknown intent: What else do we know? Injury Prevention, 5(4), 272–275.

32.

Pasquale-Styles

M. A.

Tackitt

P. L.

Schmidt

C. J.

(2007). Infant death scene investigation and the assessment of potential risk factors for asphyxia: A review of 209 sudden unexpected infant deaths. Journal of Forensic Sciences, 52(4), 924–929.

33.

Pierce

M. C.

Bertocci

G. E.

Janosky

J. E.

Aguel

Deemer

Moreland

Boal

D. K. B.

Garcia

Herr

Zuckerbraun

Vogeley

(2005). Femur fractures resulting from stair falls among children: An injury plausibility model. Pediatrics, 115(6), 1712–1722.

34.

Piteau

S. J.

Ward

M. G. K.

Barrowman

N. J.

Plint

A. C.

(2012). Clinical and radiographic characteristics associated with abusive and nonabusive head trauma: A systematic review. Pediatrics, 130(2), 315–323.

35.

Quinton

R. A.

(2017). Child death review: Past, present, and future. Academy of Forensic Pathology, 7(4), 527–535.

36.

Rivara

F. P.

Grossman

D. C.

(1996). Prevention of traumatic deaths to children in the United States: How far have we come and where do we need to go? Pediatrics, 97(6), 791–797.

37.

Schnitzer

P. G.

Dowd

M. D.

Kruse

R. L.

Morrongiello

B. A.

(2015). Supervision and risk of unintentional injury in young children. Injury Prevention, 21(e1), e63–e70. https://doi.org/10.1136/injuryprev-2013-041128

38.

Shapiro-Mendoza

C. K.

Tomashek

K. M.

Anderson

R. N.

Wingo

(2006). Recent national trends in sudden, unexpected infant deaths: More evidence supporting a change in classification or reporting. American Journal of Epidemiology, 163(8), 762–769.

39.

Shuman

M. J.

Hutchins

K. D.

(2017). Severe retinal hemorrhages with retinoschisis in infants are not pathognomonic for abusive head trauma. Journal of Forensic Sciences, 62(3), 807–811.

40.

U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare. (1958). Physicians’ handbook on death and birth registration (11th ed.). National Office of Vital Statistics.

41.

U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare. (1959). Vital statistics instruction manual, 1959, part II: Cause of death coding. National Office of Vital Statistics.

42.

U. S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare (1968). Vital Statistics Instruction Manual, Part 2: Cause-of-Death Coding for Deaths Occurring in 1968. National Center for Health Statistics.

43.

Vanderminden

Hamby

David-Ferdon

Kacha-Ochana

Merrick

Simon

T. R.

Finkelhor

Turner

(2019). Rates of neglect in a national sample: Child and family characteristics and psychological impact. Child Abuse and Neglect, 88, 256–265. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chiabu.2018.11.014