“La Loca” y “La Victima”: An Analysis of Penalizing Gender Non-Conformity After Death

Abstract

The United States experienced a record number of homicides against transgender victims in 2020, six of which occurred in Puerto Rico. Of the victims, five were trans women, and one was a trans man. Through case-study analysis, we explore how gender nonconformity is stigmatized within the context of Puerto Rico. Using storyline analysis of the language used by offenders, news media, and police, several themes emerged: (1) framing trans people as deceitful; (2) deadnaming, misgendering, and victim-blaming, and (3) community advocacy for the murder victims. Using the framework of hetero-cis-normativity, we explore how hetero-cis-normative biases may explain why negative attitudes toward trans individuals vary.

Keywords

transgender homicide case study news coverage gender and crime

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abt

Rosenfeld

Lopez

(2020). COVID-19 and homicide: Final report to Arnold Ventures. Arnold Ventures. http://craftmediabucket.s3.amazonaws.com/uploads/COVID-19-Homicide_061520_Final.pdf

Asencio

(2011). “Locas,” respect, and masculinity: Gender conformity in migrant Puerto Rican gay masculinities. Gender & Society, 25(3), 335–354.

Ashby

M. P. J.

(2020). Initial evidence on the relationship between the coronavirus pandemic and crime in the United States. Crime Science, 9(1), 6–16.

Ashley

(2022). ‘Trans’ is my gender modality: A modest terminological proposal. Trans bodies, trans selves, 1–2.

Boman

J. H.

Gallupe

(2020). Has COVID-19 changed crime? Crime rates in the United States during the pandemic. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 45, 537–545.

Buist

C. L.

Stone

(2014). Transgender victims and offenders: Failures of the United States criminal justice system and the necessity of queer criminology. Critical Criminology, 22(1), 35–47.

Campedelli

G. M.

Aziani

Favarin

(2021). Exploring the immediate effects of COVID-19 containment policies on crime: An empirical analysis of the short-term aftermath in Los Angeles. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 46, 704–727.

Crowe

Cresswell

Robertson

Huby

Avery

Sheikh

(2018). The case study approach. BMC Medical Research Methodology, 11, 1–9.

DeJong

Holt

Helm

Morgan

S. J.

(2021). “A human being like other victims”: The media framing of trans homicide in the United States. Critical Criminology, 29, 131–149.

10.

Dinno

(2017). Homicide rates of transgender individuals in the United States: 2010-2014. American Journal of Public Health, 107(9), 1441–1447.

11.

Federal Bureau of Investigation. (2020). Expanded Homicide Data, Table 11. Crime in the United States, 2019. https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2019/crime-in-the-u.s.-2019/tables/expanded-homicide-data-table-11.xls

12.

Flonnoy

DeJong

Kaur

(2022). #BlackTransLivesMatter: An Intersectional Analysis of Transgender Homicide Victims in the United States [Paper presentation]. The American Society of Criminology Annual Meeting, Atlanta, GA.

13.

Gordián

J. A.

(2023, June 23). Jueza encuentra culpable a hombre acusado por el asesinato de Michellyn Ramos Vargas. El Nuevo Dia. https://www.elnuevodia.com/

14.

Hill

D. B.

(2003). Genderism, transphobia, and genderbashing: A framework for interpreting anti-transgender violence. In Wallace

B. C.

Carter

R. T.

(Eds.), Understanding and dealing with violence: A multicultural approach (pp. 113–136). Sage.

15.

Hughto

J. M. W.

Reisner

S. L.

Pachankis

J. E.

(2015). Transgender stigma and health: A critical review of stigma determinants, mechanisms, and interventions. Social Science & Medicine (1967), 147, 222–231.

16.

Human Rights Campaign. (2022). Resources on transgender hate crimes. https://www.hrc.org/resources/transgender?topic=hate-crimes

17.

Hurtado

Sinha

(2016). Beyond machismo: Intersectional Latino masculinities. University of Texas Press.

18.

Israel

Harkness

Delucio

Ledbetter

J. N.

Avellar

T. R.

(2014). Evaluation of police training on LGBTQ issues: Knowledge, interpersonal apprehension, and self-efficacy. Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology, 29(2), 57–67.

19.

James

S. E.

Herman

J. L.

Rankin

Keisling

Mottet

Anafi

(2016). The report of the 2015 U.S. transgender survey. National Center for Transgender Equality. https://transequality.org/sites/default/files/docs/usts/USTS-ExecutiveSummary-Dec17.pdf

20.

Jauk

(2013). Gender violence revisited: Lessons from violent victimization of transgender identified individuals. Sexualities, 16(7), 807–825.

21.

Jenness

(2021). The social ecology of sexual victimization against transgender women who are incarcerated: A call for (more) research on modalities of housing and prison violence. Criminology & Public Policy, 20(1), 3–18.

22.

Kachen

Pharr

J. R.

(2020). Health care access and utilization by transgender populations: A United States transgender survey study. Transgender Health, 5(3), 141–148.

23.

Kcomt

Evans-Polce

R. J.

Boyd

C. J.

McCabe

S. E.

(2020). Association of transphobic discrimination and alcohol misuse among transgender adults: Results from the US transgender survey. Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 215, 108223–108229.

24.

Kelley

Gruenewald

(2015). Accomplishing masculinity through anti-Lesbian, Gay, bisexual, and transgender homicide: A comparative case study approach. Men and Masculinities, 18(1), 3–29. https://doi.org/10.1177/1097184x14551204

25.

Kim

H. M.

(2020, February 28). Bad Bunny pays tribute to slain Puerto Rican trans woman on Tonight Show. them. https://www.them.us/story/bad-bunny-alexa-negron-luciano

26.

Kort-Butler

L. A.

(2023). Tweeting about crime in pandemic times: US legacy news media and crime reporting during the COVID-19 pandemic. In M. Deflem (Ed.), Crime and social control in pandemic times (Vol. 28, pp. 123–139). Emerald Publishing Limited.

27.

Landale

N. S.

Oropesa

R. S.

(2002). White, black, or Puerto Rican? Racial self-identification among mainland and island Puerto Ricans. Social Forces, 81(1), 231–254.

28.

Laufs

Waseem

(2020). Policing in pandemics: A systematic review and best practices for police response to COVID-19. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 51, 101812–101817.

29.

Lee

(2020). The trans panic defense revisited. The American Criminal Law Review, 57, 1411–1497.

30.

Lee

Kwan

(2014). The trans panic defense: Masculinity, heteronormativity, and the murder of transgender women. The Hastings Law Journal, 66(1), 77–132.

31.

Library of Congress. (n.d.). Yo Soy (I am): The historical trajectory of language in Puerto Rico. https://guides.loc.gov/language-in-puerto-rico

32.

Lloréns

García-Quijano

C. G.

Godreau

I. P.

(2017). Racismo en Puerto Rico: Surveying perception of racism. Centro Journal, 24(3), 154–183.

33.

Lynch

A. M.

(2005, June 19–21). Hate crime as a tool of the gender border patrol: The importance of gender as a protected category [Conference session]. When Women Gain, So Does the World, IWPR’s Eighth International Women’s Policy Research Conference, Washington, DC.

34.

Malkin

M. L.

DeJong

(2019). Protections for transgender inmates under PREA: A comparison of state correctional policies in the United States. Sexuality Research and Social Policy, 16, 393–407.

35.

Martínez-Rivera

Hodge

S. R.

(2022). The history and culture of the United States Commonwealth of Puerto Rico: A historical brief. International Education and Culture Studies, 2(1), 29–41.

36.

McBride

R. S.

(2021). A literature review of the secondary school experiences of trans youth. Journal of LGBT Youth, 18(2), 103–134.

37.

Messinger

A. M.

Sessarego

S. N.

Edwards

K. M.

Banyard

V. L.

(2021). Bidirectional IPV among adolescent sexual minorities. Journal of interpersonal violence, 36(11–12), NP5643–NP5662.

38.

Meyer

Hassafy

Lewis

Shrestha

Haviland

A. M.

Nagin

D. S.

(2022). Changes in crime rates during the COVID-19 pandemic. Statistics and Public Policy, 9(1), 97–109.

39.

Movement Advance Project. (2023). Snapshot: LGBTQ Equality by state. http://lgbtmap.org/equality-maps.

40.

Murray

G. R.

Davies

(2022). Assessing the effects of COVID-19-related stay-at-home orders on homicide rates in selected US cities. Homicide Studies, 26(4), 419–444.

41.

Namaste

(2000). Genderbashing: Sexuality, gender, and the regulation of public space. Environment and Planning. D, Society & Space, 14(2), 221–240.

42.

National Center for Transgender Equality. (2023). Understanding transgender people: The basics. https://transequality.org/issues/resources/understanding-transgender-people-the-basics

43.

Osborn

(2022). US news coverage of transgender victims of fatal violence: An exploratory content analysis. Violence Against Women, 28(9), 2033–2056.

44.

Pew Research Center. (2010). Global publics embrace social networking: Computer and cell phone usage up around the world. Pew Global Attitudes Project Press Release.

45.

Pew Research Center. (2015). Hispanics of Puerto Rican Origin in the United States, 2013. https://www.pewresearch.org/hispanic/2015/09/15/hispanics-of-puerto-rican-origin-in-the-united-states-2013/

46.

Padilla

M. B.

Rodriguez-Madera

Varas-Díaz

Ramos-Pibernus

(2016). Trans-migrations: border-crossing and the politics of body modification among Puerto Rican transgender women. International Journal of Sexual Health, 28(4), 261–277.

47.

Phelan

J. C.

Lucas

J. W.

Ridgeway

C. L.

Taylor

C. J.

(2014). Stigma, status, and population health. Social Science & Medicine (1967), 103, 15–23.

48.

Pyne

(2011). Unsuitable bodies: Trans people and cisnormativity in shelter services. Canadian Social Work Review, 28(1), 129–137.

49.

Rodríguez-Madera

S. L.

Padilla

Varas-Díaz

Neilands

Vasques Guzzi

A. C.

Florenciani

E. J.

Ramos-Pibernus

(2017). Experiences of violence among transgender women in Puerto Rico: An underestimated problem. Journal of Homosexuality, 64(2), 209–217.

50.

Romano

(2023, March 31). Trans people deserve better journalism. Vox. http://www.vox.com

51.

Schilt

Westbrook

(2009). Doing gender, doing heteronormativity: “gender normals,” transgender people, and the social maintenance of heterosexuality. Gender & Society, 23(4), 440–464.

52.

Seely

(2021). Reporting on transgender victims of homicide: Practices of misgendering, sourcing and transparency. Newspaper Research Journal, 42(1), 74–94.

53.

Shayegh

Malpede

(2020, April 2). Staying home saves lives, really!. SSRN. https://ssrn.com/abstract=3567394

54.

Stanley

(2011). Near life, queer death: Overkill and ontological capture. Social Text, 29(2), 1–19.

55.

Stotzer

R. L.

(2017). Data sources hinder our understanding of transgender murders. American Journal of Public Health, 107(9), 1362–1363.

56.

Truman

J. L.

Morgan

R. E.

(2022). Violent victimization by sexual orientation and gender identity, 2017-2020. Statistical Brief, Bureau of Justice Statistics (pp. 1–22).

57.

United States Census Bureau. (2021). Quick facts. https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/PR

58.

Vargas-Ramos

(2005). Black, trigueño, WHITE . . . ? Shifting racial identification among Puerto Ricans. Du Bois Review, 2(2), 267–285.

59.

Walker

Sexton

Valcore

J. L.

Sumner

Wodda

(2018). Transitioning to social justice: Transgender and nonbinary individuals. In Roberson

(Ed.), Routledge handbook of social, economic and criminal justice (pp. 220–233). Abington, Oxon, UK: Routledge.

60.

Waters

Pham

Convery

Yacka-Bible

(2018). A crisis of hate: A report on LBGTQ hate violence homicides in 2017. National Coalition of Anti-Violence Programs. http://avp.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/a-crisis-of-hate-january-release.pdf

61.

Westbrook

(2022). Violence against transgender people in the United States: Field growth, data dilemmas, and knowledge gaps. Sociology Compass, 16(6), 1–16.

62.

Westbrook

Schilt

(2014). Doing gender, determining gender: Transgender people, gender panics, and the maintenance of the sex/gender/sexuality system. Gender & society, 28(1), 32–57.

63.

West

Zimmerman

D. H.

(1987). Doing gender. Gender & Society, 1(2), 125–151.

64.

Wirtz

A. L.

Poteat

T. C.

Malik

Glass

(2020). Gender-based violence against transgender people in the United States: a call for research and programming. Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, 21(2), 227–241.

65.

Wodda

Panfil

V. R.

(2014). Don’t talk to me about deception: The necessary erosion of the trans panic defense. Albany Law Review, 78, 927.

66.

Wood

Carrillo

Monk-Turner

(2022). Visibly unknown: Media depiction of murdered transgender women of color. Race and Justice, 12(2), 368–386.

67.

Worthen

M. G. F.

(2016). Hetero-cis–normativity and the gendering of transphobia. International Journal of Transgenderism, 17(1), 31–57.

68.

Worthen

M. G. F.

(2020). Queers, bis, and straight lies: An investigation of LGBTQ stigma. Routledge.

69.

Worthen

M. G. F.

(2021). Why can’t you just pick one? The stigmatization of non-binary/genderqueer people by cis and trans men and women: An empirical test of norm-centered stigma theory. Sex Roles, 85(5-6), 343–356.