Sustaining Unsustainability: The Legitimation Paradox of Unsustainable Companies

Abstract

Companies with inherently unsustainable business models and high public salience face a paradox, as they need to construct themselves as desirable and appropriate organizations to maintain their license to operate, while at the same time profiting from practices that are fundamentally unsustainable. This paper advances our understanding of legitimation under paradoxical conditions by examining how a highly visible and inherently unsustainable company legitimizes its unsustainability. Based on a micro-level analysis of corporate sustainability reports, press releases, and company quotes in news articles, we identify both traditional legitimation strategies and paradoxical legitimation strategies, the latter of which conflict with other legitimation strategies through tensions related to boundaries, agency, and temporality. Our findings show how paradoxical legitimation strategies enable companies to sustain their unsustainability by engaging in an ongoing oscillation between claiming sustainability and defending unsustainability.

Keywords

legitimation paradox sustainability unsustainability communication

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abnett

(2025, June 23). EU halts talks on law tackling companies’ fake “green” claims. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/sustainability/climate-energy/eu-halts-talks-law-tackling-companies-fake-green-claims-2025-06-23/

ACM. (2022, September 13). Commitment decision for H&M regarding sustainability claims. Authority for Consumers and Markets. https://www.acm.nl/en/publications/commitment-decision-handm-regarding-sustainability-claims

Arslan

Haapanen

Hurmelinna-Laukkanen

Tarba

S. Y.

Alon

(2021). Climate change, consumer lifestyles and legitimation strategies of sustainability-oriented firms. European Management Journal, 39(6), 720–730.

Banerjee

S. B.

Jermier

J. M.

Peredo

A. M.

Perey

Reichel

(2021). Theoretical perspectives on organizations and organizing in a post-growth era. Organization, 28(3), 337–357.

Berti

Cunha

M. P.

(2023). Paradox, dialectics or trade-offs? A double loop model of paradox. Journal of Management Studies, 60(4), 861–888.

Bick

Halsey

Ekenga

C. C.

(2018). The global environmental injustice of fast fashion. Environmental Health, 17(92), 1–4.

Bitektine

Haack

(2015). The “macro” and the “micro” of legitimacy: Toward a multilevel theory of the legitimacy process. Academy of Management Review, 40(1), 49–75.

Bitten

(2022, June 28). Fashion brands pause use of sustainability index tool over greenwashing claims. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/fashion/2022/jun/28/fashion-brands-pause-use-of-sustainability-index-tool-over-greenwashing-claims

Blanchard

(2023, December 28). “Textile zombie” v fossil fashion: The battle to clean up the clothing industry in 2023. The Guardian.

10.

Bocken

N. M. P.

Short

S. W.

(2021). Unsustainable business models—Recognising and resolving institutionalised social and environmental harm. Journal of Cleaner Production, 312, 127828.

11.

Boiral

Brotherton

M.-C.

Talbot

Guillaumie

(2022). Legitimizing unsustainable practices: The institutional logics of pro-pesticide organizations. Business Strategy and the Environment, 31(5), 2284–2298.

12.

Boiral

Brotherton

M.-C.

Yuriev

Talbot

(2022). Through the smokescreen of the dieselgate disclosure: Neutralizing the impacts of a major sustainability scandal. Organization & Environment, 35(2), 175–201.

13.

Breeze

(2012). Legitimation in corporate discourse: Oil corporations after deepwater horizon. Discourse & Society, 23(1), 3–18.

14.

Brydges

(2021). Closing the loop on take, make, waste: Investigating circular economy practices in the Swedish fashion industry. Journal of Cleaner Production, 293, 126249.

15.

Bundy

Shropshire

Buchholtz

A. K.

(2013). Strategic cognition and issue salience: Toward an explanation of firm responsiveness to stakeholder concerns. Academy of Management Review, 38(3), 352–376.

16.

Busch

Barnett

M. L.

Burritt

R. L.

Cashore

B. W.

Freeman

R. E.

Henriques

Husted

B. W.

Panwar

Pinkse

Schaltegger

York

(2024). Moving beyond “the” business case: How to make corporate sustainability work. Business Strategy and the Environment, 33(2), 776–787.

17.

Butler

(2022, November 30). H&M to cut 1,500 jobs as retailers face slowing sales and rising costs. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/fashion/2022/nov/30/hm-to-cut-1500-jobs-as-retailers-face-slowing-sales-and-rising-costs

18.

Celik

Ekici

(2025). “I crossed my own line, but here is what I do”: The moral transgressions of sustainable fashion consumers and their use of alternating moral practices as a cognitive-dissonance-reducing strategy. Journal of Business Ethics, 196(4), 917–936.

19.

Chassé

Boiral

(2016). Legitimizing corporate (un)sustainability: A case study of passive SMEs. Organization & Environment, 30(4), 324–345.

20.

Chiu

S.-C.

Sharfman

(2011). Legitimacy, visibility, and the antecedents of corporate social performance. Journal of Management, 37(6), 1558–1585.

21.

Chua

J. M.

(2022, September 15). Why H&M canceled “Conscious Choice.” Sourcing Journal.

22.

Cipriani

(1987). The sociology of legitimation. Current Sociology, 35(2), 1–20.

23.

Dagilienė

Varaniūtė

(2023). Transitioning to a circular economy: Paradoxical tensions of the circular business model. Organization & Environment, 36(4), 559–589.

24.

Devi

(2023). H&M enjoys Q1 profit boost thanks to Sellpy, Women’s Wear, COS, and Arket. BrandingForum. https://brandingforum.org/general/hm-enjoys-q1-profit-boost-strong-performance-in-key-segments/

25.

Dowling

Pfeffer

(1975). Organizational legitimacy: Social values and organizational behavior. Pacific Sociological Review, 18, 122–136.

26.

Durand

Hawn

Ioannou

(2019). Willing and able: A general model of organizational responses to normative pressures. Academy of Management Review, 44(2), 299–320.

27.

Edwards

M. G.

(2021). The growth paradox, sustainable development, and business strategy. Business Strategy and the Environment, 30(7), 3079–3094.

28.

Elsbach

K. D.

Sutton

R. I.

(1992). Acquiring organizational legitimacy through illegitimate actions: A marriage of institutional and impression management theories. The Academy of Management Journal, 35(4), 699–738.

29.

Erkama

Vaara

(2010). Struggles over legitimacy in global organizational restructuring: A rhetorical perspective on legitimation strategies and dynamics in a shutdown case. Organization Studies, 31(7), 813–839.

30.

European Parliament. (2020). The impact of textile production and waste on the environment.

31.

Ferns

Amaeshi

(2019). Fueling climate (in)action: How organizations engage in hegemonization to avoid transformational action on climate change. Organization Studies, 42(7), 1005–1029.

32.

Ferns

Amaeshi

Lambert

(2019). Drilling their own graves: How the European oil and gas supermajors avoid sustainability tensions through mythmaking. Journal of Business Ethics, 158, 201–231.

33.

Gioia

D. A.

Corley

K. G.

Hamilton

A. L.

(2013). Seeking qualitative rigor in inductive research: Notes on the Gioia methodology. Organizational Research Methods, 16(1), 15–31.

34.

Gómez Sánchez

Tobon

. (2025). Sustainable investing among young generations: Balancing ideals and financial realities. Discover Sustainability, 6(1), 275.

35.

Haffar

Searcy

(2020). Legitimizing potential “bad news”: How companies disclose on their tension experiences in their sustainability reports. Organization & Environment, 33(4), 534–553.

36.

Hahn

Lülfs

(2014). Legitimizing negative aspects in GRI-oriented sustainability reporting: A qualitative analysis of corporate disclosure strategies. Journal of Business Ethics, 123, 401–420.

37.

Hahn

Pinkse

Preuss

Figge

(2015). Tensions in corporate sustainability: Towards an integrative framework. Journal of Business Ethics, 127(2), 297–316.

38.

Hahn

Pinkse

Preuss

Figge

(2018). A paradox perspective on corporate sustainability: Descriptive, instrumental, and normative aspects. Journal of Business Ethics, 148, 235–248.

39.

Hahn

Preuss

Pinkse

Figge

(2014). Cognitive frames in corporate sustainability: Managerial sensemaking with paradoxical and business case frames. Academy of Management Review, 39(4), 463–487.

40.

Halliday

(2023). H&M profit gets Q1 Sellpy boost, says womenswear, COS and Arket are strong. Fashion Network. https://ww.fashionnetwork.com/news/H-m-profit-gets-q1-sellpy-boost-says-womenswear-cos-and-arket-are-strong,1501659.html

41.

Harmon

D. J.

Green

S. E.

Goodnight

G. T.

(2015). A model of rhetorical legitimation: The structure of communication and cognition underlying institutional maintenance and change. Academy of Management Review, 40(1), 76–95.

42.

Harrell

(2022, November 11). H&M hit with second greenwashing lawsuit. Sourcing Journal.

43.

Hitti

(2019, August 2). H&M called out for “greenwashing” in its Conscious fashion collection. Dezeen. https://www.dezeen.com/2019/08/02/hm-norway-greenwashing-conscious-fashion-collection-news/

44.

H&M. (2014). Sustainability report 2014. https://hmgroup.com/sustainability/sustainability-reporting/

45.

H&M. (2016a). Annual report 2016. https://hmgroup.com/about-us/corporate-governance/annual-report/

46.

H&M. (2016b). Sustainability report 2016. https://hmgroup.com/sustainability/sustainability-reporting/

47.

H&M. (2018a). Annual report 2018. https://hmgroup.com/about-us/corporate-governance/annual-report/

48.

H&M. (2018b). Sustainability report 2018. https://hmgroup.com/sustainability/sustainability-reporting/

49.

H&M. (2021). Sustainability disclosure report 2021. https://hmgroup.com/sustainability/sustainability-reporting/

50.

H&M. (2022). Sustainability disclosure 2022. https://hmgroup.com/sustainability/sustainability-reporting/

51.

H&M. (2023). Sustainability disclosure report 2023. https://hmgroup.com/sustainability/sustainability-reporting/

52.

H&M. (2024). Annual report 2024. https://hmgroup.com/about-us/corporate-governance/annual-report/

53.

H&M. (2025). Supply chain. https://hmgroup.com/sustainability/leading-the-change/transparency/supply-chain/

54.

Husband

(2022, July 5). H&M defends transparency amid claims of “bogus” environmental scores. Just-Style. https://www.just-style.com/news/hm-defends-transparency-amid-claims-of-bogus-environmental-scores/

55.

Iivonen

(2018). Defensive responses to strategic sustainability paradoxes: Have your Coke and drink it too! Journal of Business Ethics, 148(4), 309–327.

56.

Inditex. (2024). Annual report 2024. https://www.inditex.com/itxcomweb/api/media/604197b9-50de-4f4f-ab84-c1e379cb3fd0/Inditex_Group_Annual_Report_2024.pdf

57.

Jay

Soderstrom

Grant

(2017). Navigating the paradoxes of sustainability. In Smith

W. K.

Lewis

M. W.

Jarzabkowski

Langley

(Eds.), Oxford handbook of organizational paradox (pp. 353–373). OUP.

58.

Joutsenvirta

(2013). Executive pay and legitimacy: Changing discursive battles over the morality of excessive manager compensation. Journal of Business Ethics, 116(3), 459–477.

59.

Lahey

(2023, October 24). H&M issues its first $500 million green bond to fund climate, circularity goals. ESG Today. https://www.esgtoday.com/hm-issues-its-first-500-million-green-bond-to-fund-climate-circularity-goals/

60.

Little

V. J.

Lee

C. K. C.

Nair

(2019). Macro-demarketing: The key to unlocking unsustainable production and consumption systems? Journal of Macromarketing, 39(2), 166–187.

61.

Livesey

S. M.

(2002). Global warming wars: Rhetorical and discourse analytic approaches to ExxonMobil’s corporate public discourse. Journal of Business Communication, 39(1), 117–148.

62.

Livesey

S. M.

Kearins

(2002). Transparent and caring corporations? A study of sustainability reports by The Body Shop and Royal Dutch/Shell. Organization & Environment, 15(3), 233–258.

63.

Luque

Herrero-García

(2019). How corporate social (ir)responsibility in the textile sector is defined, and its impact on ethical sustainability: An analysis of 133 concepts. Corporate Social Responsibility & Environmental Management, 26, 1285–1306.

64.

Magnani

Gioia

(2023). Using the Gioia Methodology in international business and entrepreneurship research. International Business Review, 32(2), 102097.

65.

McKinsey. (2016). Style that’s sustainable: A new fast-fashion formula. https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/sustainability-and-resource-productivity/our-insights/style-thats-sustainable-a-new-fast-fashion-formula/

66.

Milne

M. J.

Kearins

Walton

(2006). Creating adventures in Wonderland: The journey metaphor and environmental sustainability. Organization, 13(6), 801–839.

67.

Morrison

(2021, October 7). Major high-street brands including H&M, Primark and Zara are accused of “greenwashing.” https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-10069187/

68.

Niinimäki

Peters

Dahlbo

Perry

Rissanen

Gwilt

(2020). The environmental price of fast fashion. Nature Reviews Earth & Environment, 1, 189–200.

69.

Odabasi

von Busch

Moon

Sansone

Rissanen

(2023). Transition design and fashion. Fashion Practice, 15(2), 349–367.

70.

Onkila

Mäkelä

Järvenpää

(2018). Employee sensemaking on the importance of sustainability reporting in sustainability identity change. Sustainable Development, 26(3), 217–228.

71.

Palm

(2023). Sustainable fashion: To define, or not to define, that is not the question. Sustainability: Science, Practice and Policy, 19(1), 2261342.

72.

Palm

Cornell

S. E.

Häyhä

(2021). Making resilient decisions for sustainable circularity of fashion. Circular Economy and Sustainability, 1(2), 651–670.

73.

Pedersen

E. R. G.

Gwozdz

Hvass

K. K.

(2018). Exploring the relationship between business model innovation, corporate sustainability, and organisational values within the fashion industry. Journal of Business Ethics, 149(2), 267–284.

74.

Peirson-Smith

Claxton

(2024). Waste not, want not: Re-routing garment and textile waste streams to create circular fashion design eco-systems in Bangladesh and beyond. In Recycling and lifetime management in the textile and fashion sector. CRC.

75.

Pinkse

Hahn

Figge

(2019). Supersized tensions and slim responses? The discursive construction of strategic tensions around social issues. Academy of Management Discoveries, 5(3), 314–340.

76.

Primark. (2025). Who we are. https://corporate.primark.com/en-gb/a/about-us/who-we-are

77.

Putnam

L. L.

Fairhurst

G. T.

Banghart

(2016). Contradictions, dialectics, and paradoxes in organizations: A constitutive approach. Academy of Management Annals, 10, 65–171.

78.

Schneider

(2020). Bound to fail? Exploring the systemic pathologies of CSR and their implications for CSR research. Business & Society, 59(7), 1303–1338.

79.

Schneider

(2024). Untaming grand challenges research: Against a de-politicization of grand challenges. Business & Society, 63(6), 1302–1306.

80.

Schoeneborn

Morsing

Crane

(2020). Formative perspectives on the relation between CSR communication and CSR practices: Pathways for walking, talking, and t(w)alking. Business & Society, 59(1), 5–33.

81.

Scott

W. R.

(2001). Institutions and organizations. Sage.

82.

Seele

Gatti

(2017). Greenwashing revisited: In search of a typology and accusation-based definition incorporating legitimacy strategies. Business Strategy and the Environment, 26(2), 239–252.

83.

Segran

(2021, January 27). H&M is one of fashion’s biggest polluters. Fast Company.

84.

Smith

W. K.

Lewis

M. W.

(2011). Toward a theory of paradox: A dynamic equilibrium model of organizing. Academy of Management Review, 36(2), 381–403.

85.

Stallard

(2022). Fast fashion: How clothes are linked to climate change. BBC. https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-60382624

86.

Stern

(2022, July 13). H&M case shows how greenwashing breaks brand promise. Forbes.

87.

Suchman

M. C.

(1995). Managing legitimacy: Strategic and institutional approaches. Academy of Management Review, 20(3), 571–610.

88.

Talbot

Boiral

(2018). GHG reporting and impression management: An assessment of sustainability reports from the energy sector. Journal of Business Ethics, 147(2), 367–383.

89.

Tonti

(2023, October 19). ‘The missing link’: Is textile recycling the answer to fashion’s waste crisis? The Guardian.

90.

Tracey

Creed

W. E. D.

(2017). Beyond managerial dilemmas: The study of institutional paradoxes in organization theory. In Smith

W. K.

Lewis

M. W.

Jarzabkowski

Langley

(Eds.), The Oxford handbook of organizational paradox (pp. 169–177). Oxford University Press.

91.

UN. (2022). UN Secretary-General’s remarks at launch of report of High-Level Expert Group on Net-Zero Commitments. https://unric.org/it/un-secretary-generals-remarks-at-launch-of-report-of-high-level-expert-group-on-net-zero-commitments/

92.

UN. (2025). Fast fashion fuelling global waste crisis, UN chief warns. https://news.un.org/en/story/2025/03/1161636

93.

UN CCD. (2024). Fashion & land. Unravelling the environmental impact of fibres. https://www.unccd.int/sites/default/files/2024-12/UNCCD-Fashion%26LAND-FINAL%20online%20publication_final_single%20pages.pdf

94.

U.S. District Court. (2022, August 17). Class action complaint. https://www.classaction.org/media/commodore-v-h-and-m-hennes-and-mauritz-lp.pdf

95.

Vaara

Monin

(2010). A recursive perspective on discursive legitimation and organizational action in mergers and acquisitions. Organization Science, 21(1), 3–22.

96.

Vaara

Tienari

(2008). A discursive perspective on legitimation strategies in multinational corporations. Academy of Management Review, 33(4), 985–993.

97.

Van der Byl

C. A.

Slawinski

. (2015). Embracing tensions in corporate sustainability: A review of research from win-wins and trade-offs to paradoxes and beyond. Organization & Environment, 28(1), 54–79.

98.

van Leeuwen

. (2007). Legitimation in discourse and communication. Discourse & Communication, 1(1), 91–112.

99.

van Leeuwen

Wodak

. (1999). Legitimizing immigration control: A discourse-historical analysis. Discourse Studies, 1(1), 83–118.

100.

Weaver

G. R.

Trevino

L. K.

Cochran

P. L.

(1999). Integrated and decoupled corporate social performance: Management commitments, external pressures, and corporate ethics practices. The Academy of Management Journal, 42(5), 539–552.