According to the widespread opinion of historians, modern mechanics is the result of a revolutionary phenomenon that occurred during the Renaissance, during the so-called scientific revolution, because of the concourse of many factors including the discovery of fundamental mathematical and scientific Archimedean, or more generally Hellenistic, texts, the spread of a Platonic vision of reality in which mathematics played a key role and more in general the affirmation of a mechanistic natural philosophy. I have a different opinion; according to it modern mechanics was primarily born as a natural development of a mechanics carried out by more or less remote mathematicians, of whom Archimedes was an illustrious exponent only. Besides mechanics, these mathematicians developed other sciences known as mixed mathematics: optics, astronomy, music, which are at the basis of modern mathematical physics. This article intends to support this latter opinion making reference to original documents.
CapecchiD. The problem of motion of bodies. New York, NY: Springer, 2014.
2.
MerzbachUCBoyerCB. A history of mathematics. 3rd edn. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley, 2011.
3.
BrownGI. The evolution of the term “mixed mathematics”. J Hist Idea1991; 52(1): 81–102.
4.
FreemanK. Ancilla to the pre-Socratic philosophers. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1948.
5.
BienerZ. Galileo’s first new science: The science of matter. Perspec Sci2004; 12: 262–287.
6.
BienerZ. The unity of science in early-modern philosophy: Subalternation, metaphysics and the geometrical manner in scholasticism, Galileo and Descartes. PhD Dissertation, University of Pittsburg, PA, 2008.
7.
LennoxJG. Aristotle, Galileo and the mixed sciences. In: WallaceW (ed.) Reinterpreting Galileo. Washington, DC: The Catholic University of America Press, 1985, 29–51.
8.
MachamerP. Galileo and the causes. In: ButtsREPittJC (eds.) New perspectives. Dordrecht: Reidel Publishing Company, 1978, 161–180.
9.
Van DyckM. An archaeology of Galileo’s science. PhD Dissertation, Ghent University, Belgium, 2006.
Archimedes. On the equilibrium of planes. In: HeathTL (ed.) The works of Archimedes. New York, NY: Dover, 2002, 189–220
19.
GallettoD. La teoria della leva nell’opera di Archimede. In: Proceedings of the conference: Archimede mito e tradizione, Siracusa-Catania, Italy, 1989, 415–475.
20.
CapecchiD (2012) History of virtual work laws. Birchäuser, Milan.
21.
Archimedes (2002) Quadrature of the parabola. In: HeathTL (ed), The works of Archimedes. New York, Dover, pp 233–252.
22.
Archimedes (1970–1972) Archimède. Texte établi et traduit par Charles Mugler. (Four volumes). Societé d’Edition “Les Belles Lettres”, Paris
23.
Hero Alexandrinus (1893) Les mécaniques ou l’élévateur de Héron d’Alexandrie. Arabic text and French translation by Carrà de Vaux. Journal Asiatique9(1):386–47
24.
HultschFO (1878) Pappi Alexandrini collections (3 vols). Weidmannas, Berlin
25.
Euclid (1945) The optics of Euclid. Translated into English by Burton HD. Journal of the optical society35(5):357–372
26.
LindbergDC (1987) Roger Bacon and the origin of perspective. In: GrantEMurdochJE (eds) (1987) Mathematics and its applications to science and natural philosophy in the Middle Ages. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 249–268
27.
LairdWR (1983) The scientiae mediae in medieval commentaries on Aristotle’s posterior analytics. PhD dissertation, University of Toronto, Canada.
28.
SyllaED (2009) John Buridan and critical realism. Early Sciences and Medicine, 14:211–247
29.
AbattouyM (2009) The Arabic science of weights: Textual tradition and significance in the history of mechanics. In: CalvoEComesMPuigRRiusM (eds) (2009) A shared legacy. Islamic science East and West. Barcelona University Press, Barcelona, pp 83–114
30.
ClagettM (1948) Some general aspects of physics in the Middle Ages. Isis39(1/2):29–44
31.
ClagettM (1959) The science of mechanics in the Middle Ages. The University of Wisconsin Press, Madison
32.
HøyrupJ (1988) Jordanus de Nemore, 13th century mathematical innovator: an essay on intellectual context, achievement, and failure. Archive for History and Exact Sciences38:307–363
33.
MoodyEAClagettM (1952) The medieval science of weights. University of Wisconsin Press, Madison
34.
De PaceA (1993) Le matematiche e il mondo. Francoangeli, Milan
35.
Aristotle (1525) Conversio mechanicarum quaestionum Aristotelis cum figuris et annotationibus quibusdam. In: Leonico TomeoN (1525) Opuscula nuper in lucem aedita quorum nomina proxima habentur pagella. Vitali B, Venice
36.
DrakeSDrabkinIE (1969) Mechanics in sixteenth-century Italy. University of Wisconsin Press, Madison
37.
LairdWR (1986) The scope of Renaissance mechanics. Osiris2(2):43–68
38.
TartagliaN (1554) Quesiti et inventioni diverse de Nicolo Tartaglia di novo restampati con una gionta al sesto libro. Bascarini, Venice
39.
FavaroA (1900) Due lettere inedite di Guidobaldo del Monte a Giacomo Contarini. Ferrari C, Venice
40.
TartagliaN (1537) Nova scientia inventa da Nicolo Tartalea. Stephano da Stabio, Venice
EkholmKJ (2010) Tartaglia’s ragioni: A maestro d’abaco’s mixed approach to the bombarder’s problem. British Journal for the History of Science43(2)181–207
43.
De NemoreJ (1533) Liber Iordani Nemorarii viri clarissimi, de ponderibus propositiones XIII & earundem demonstrationes, multarumque rerum rationes sane pulcherrimas complectens. ApianusP (ed) An edition of version P and the ‘Aliud commenum’. Iohannes Petreium, Nuremberg
44.
BrownJE. The scientia de ponderibus in the latter Middle Ages. PhD Thesis. The University of Wisconsin Press, Madison, WI, 1967.
45.
BrownJE (1976) The science of weights. In: LindbergDC (ed) (1976) Sciences in the Middle Ages. The Chicago University Press, Chicago, pp 179–205
46.
De NemoreJ (1565) Jordani opusculum de ponderositate. TartagliaN (ed). Curtio Troiano, Venice
47.
TartagliaN (1558) La Nova scientia de Nicolò Tartaglia con una gionta al terzo libro. Curtio Troiano, Venice
48.
GalileiG (1890-1909) Le opere di Galileo Galilei (National edition) (20 vols). FavaroA (ed). Barbera, Florence
49.
CrombieAC (1996) Science, art and nature in medieval and modern thought. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
50.
AlbertusMagnus (1890-1899) Physicorum libr. VIII. In: AlbertusMagnus (1890-1899) Albertui Magnui Opera omnia (38 vols). BorgnetA (ed). Ludovicum Vives, Paris, vol 3
51.
Dal MonteG (1577) Mechanicorum liber. Hieronymum Concordiam, Pesauri
52.
RennJDamerowP (2010) Guidobaldo del Monte’s Mechanicorum liber. Max Planck Research Library for the History and Development of Knowledge. Edition open access
53.
Dal MonteG (1615) Le mechaniche dell’illustriss. sig. Guido Ubaldo de’ marchesi del Monte. Tradotte in volgare da Filippo Pigafetta (1581). Deuchino E, Venezia
54.
KeplerJ (1619) Harmonices mundi. Plancus I, Linz
55.
GalileiG (1638) Discorsi e dimostrazioni matematiche sopra due nuove scienze (1638). In: GalileiG (1890-1909) Le opere di Galileo Galilei (National edition) (20 vols). FavaroA (ed). Barbera, Florence, vol 8, pp 39–362 citare
56.
Archimedes (1565) Archimedis De iis quae vehuntur in aqua libri duo. CommandinoF. (ed). Ex Officina Benacii, Bologna
