What are the appropriate criteria for evaluating candidates for the presidency? To find answers based on the collective record of the past, we analyzed the content of randomly selected biographies covering a dozen modern presidencies. From these, we distilled lists of performance criteria to which over one hundred biographers attributed the successes and failures of presidencies. Yet a comparison of eight newspapers and three news magazines revealed that these significant criteria were deemphasized in the print media during the 1992 presidential campaign. Considering the potential significance of performance-related information, we conclude that the news media should provide voters with more coverage that directly speaks to the candidates' talents for managing the presidency.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
All biographies used for this study are listed here. No references to individual biographies appear in the text.
2.
Ambrose, Stephen E. 1987. Nixon: The Education of a Politician, 1913-1962. New York: Simon and Schuster .
3.
Barber, James David . 1985. The Presidential Character. 3rd Edition. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall .
4.
Barber, James David . 1992. “Prediction as a Test for Hypothesis: Application to the Psychology of Presidents.”Political Psychology13(3): 543-552 .
5.
Barilleaux, Ryan and Mary Stuckey , eds. 1992. Leadership and the Bush Presidency. Westport, CT: Praeger .
6.
Benfari, Robert . 1991. Understanding Your Management Style. Lexington, MA: D.C. Heath .
7.
Boyarski, Bill . 1981. Ronald Reagan: His Life and Rise to the Presidency. New York: Random House .
8.
Buchanan, Bruce . 1987. The Citizen's Presidency: Standard of Choice and Judgment. Washington, D.C.: Congressional Quarterly .
9.
Burger, Chester . 1964. Survival in the Executive Jungle. New York: Macmillan .
10.
Bush, George , with Victor Gold . 1987. Looking Forward. New York: Doubleday .
11.
Cannon, Lou . 1980. Reagan. New York: Putnam .
12.
Cannon, Lou . 1991. President Reagan: The Role of a Lifetime. New York: Simon and Schuster .
13.
Carlyle, Thomas . 1872. On Heroes, Hero-Worship, and the Heroic in History. New York: Wiley .
14.
Cole, Wayne S. 1983. Roosevelt and the Isolationists. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press .
15.
Costello, William . 1960. The Facts about Nixon: An Unauthorized Biography. New York: Viking .
16.
Crigler, Ann , Marion Just , and Timothy E. Cook . 1993. “Character Issues and Performance: Discourse in the 1992 Presidential Campaign.” Presented at the annual meeting of the American Political Science Association, Washington, D.C.
17.
Doig, Jameson W. , and Erwin C. Hargrove . 1987. Leadership and Innovation: A Biographical Perspective on Entrepreneurs in Government. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press .
18.
Dugger, Ronnie . 1983. On Reagan: The Man and His Presidency. New York: McGraw-Hill .
19.
Edwards, George C., III , and Stephen J. Wayne . 1990. Presidential Leadership: Politics and Policy Making. 2nd Edition. New York: St. Martin's Press .
20.
Ferrel, Robert H. 1983, Harry S. Truman and the Modern American Presidency. Boston: Little, Brown .
21.
Ferrel, Robert . 1984. Truman. New York: Viking .
22.
Ford, Gerald . 1979. A Time to Heal. New York: Harper and Row .
23.
Freedom Forum Media Studies Center . 1993. The Finish Line: Covering the Campaign's Final Days. New York: Freedom Forum Media Studies Center, Columbia University .
24.
Friedman, Leon , and William Levantrosser , eds. 1991. Richard M. Nixon: Politician, President, Administrator. New York: Greenwood .
25.
Genovese, Michael . 1990. The Nixon Presidency: Power Politics in Turbulent Times. New York: Greenwood .
26.
Giglio, James N. 1991. The Presidency of John F. Kennedy. Lawrence: University of Kansas Press .
27.
Glad, Betty . 1980. Jimmy Carter. New York: Norton .
28.
Gosnell, Harold F. 1980. Truman's Crises: A Political Biography. Westport, CT: Greenwood .
29.
Graber, Doris A.1976. “Press and TV as Opinion Resources in Presidential Campaigns.”Public Opinion Quarterly403(3) 285-303 .
30.
Graber, Doris A. 1993. Processing the News: How People Tame the Information Tide. 2nd Edition. Lanham, MD: University Press of America .
31.
Greenstein, Fred I. 1982. The Hidden Hand Presidency: Eisenhower as Leader. New York: Basic .
32.
Gronbeck, Bruce E.1989. “Mythic Portraiture in the 1988 Iowa Presidential Caucus Bio-Ads.”American Behavioral Scientist32(3) 351-364 .
33.
Harper, Paul , and Joann P. Kreig , eds. 1988. John F. Kennedy: The Promise Revisited. New York: Greenwood .
34.
Hart, Roderick P. , Deborah Smith-Howell , and John Llewellyn . 1991. “The Mindscape of the Presidency: Time Magazine, 1945-1985.”Journal of Communication41(1) 6-25 .
35.
Hoover, Herbert . 1958. The Ordeal of Woodrow Wilson. New York: McGraw-Hill .
36.
Janz, Tom , Lowell Hellerich , and David Ardmore . 1986. Behavior Description Interviewing. Boston: Allyn and Bacon .
37.
Jennings, Eugene . 1971. Routes to the Executive Suite. New York: McGraw-Hill .
38.
Kaufman, Burton . 1993. The Presidency of James E. Carter. Lawrence: University of Kansas Press .
39.
Kendall, Joel . 1995. “The Unknown Candidate: Reporting Personal Qualifications in Midterm Senate Campaigns.” Presented at the Government and Media Seminar, School of Journalism, Indiana University, Bloomington.
40.
King, Nicholas . 1980. George Bush: A Biography. New York: Dodd, Mead .
41.
Korn, Lester . 1988. The Success Profile. New York: Simon and Schuster .
42.
Latham, Earl , ed. 1980. The Philosophy and Policies of Woodrow Wilson. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
43.
Levantrosser, William F. , ed. 1986. Harry Truman: The Man from Independence. New York: Greenwood .
44.
McCann, Kevin . 1952. Man from Abilene. Garden City, NY: Doubleday .
45.
Merritt, Davis . 1995. Public Journalism and Public Life: Why Telling the News Is Not Enough. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum .
46.
Merritt, Davis , and Jay Rosen . 1995. “Imagining Public Journalism: An Editor and Scholar Reflect on the Birth of an Idea.”Bloomington: Indiana University School of Journalism, Roy W. Howard Public Lecture #5, April 13.
47.
Meyer, Peter . 1978. James Earl Carter: The Man and the Myth. Kansas: Sheed Andrews and McMeel .
48.
Miller, Edward D. 1994. “The Charlotte Project: Helping Citizens Take Back Democracy.”St. Petersburg, FL: Poynter Institute for Media Studies , Poynter Paper #4.
49.
Miller, Richard Lawrence . 1986. Truman: The Rise to Power. New York: McGraw-Hill .
50.
Mollenhoff, Clark P. 1980. The President Who Failed: Carter Out of Control. New York: Macmillan .
51.
National Election Studies. 1984. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan .
52.
National Election Studies. 1988. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan .
53.
National Election Studies. 1992. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan .
54.
Neustadt, Richard E. 1990. Presidential Power and the Modern Presidents: The Politics of Leadership from Roosevelt to Reagan. New York: Free Press .
55.
Paper, Lewis . 1975. John F. Kennedy: The Promise and the Performance. New York: Crown .
56.
Payne, J. Gregory , John Marlier , and Robert A. Baukus . 1989. “Polispots in the 1988 Presidential Primaries: Separating the Nominees from the Rest of the Guys.”American Behavioral Scientist32(2) 365-381 .
57.
Provence, Harry . 1964. Lyndon Johnson: A Biography. New York: Fleet .
58.
Pusey, Merlo J. 1956. Eisenhower: The President. New York: Macmillan .
59.
Reedy, George . 1983. Lyndon B. Johnson: A Memoir. New York: Andrews and McMeel .
60.
Renshon, Stanley A.1992. “Some Observations on Character and Privacy Issues in Presidential Campaigns.”Political Psychology13(3) 565-585 .
61.
Rosen, Jay , and Davis Merritt . 1994. Public Journalism: Theory and Practice. Dayton, OH: Kettering Foundation .
62.
Schell, Erwin . 1950. The Technique of Executive Control. New York: McGraw-Hill .
63.
Schiffer, Bob , and Gary Paul Gates . 1989. The Acting President. New York: E.P. Dutton .
64.
Sidey, Hugh . 1968. A Very Personal Presidency: Lyndon Johnson in the White House. New York: Atheneum .
65.
Smith, Hedrick . 1980. Reagan: The Man, the President. New York: Macmillan .
66.
Sorcher, Melvin . 1985. Predicting Executive Success. New York: John Wiley .
67.
Sorenson, Theodore . 1966. Kennedy. New York: Bantam .
68.
Stoessinger, John G. 1979. Crusaders and Pragmatists: Movers of Modern American Foreign Policy. New York: Norton .
69.
Suresh, Srivastra & Associates . 1983. The Executive Mind. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass .
70.
Vestal, Bud . 1974. Jerry Ford: Up Close. New York: Coward, Mcann, and Geoghan .
71.
Washburn, Charles G. 1916. Theodore Roosevelt: The Logic of His Career. New York: Houghton Mifflin .
72.
Weaver, David H. , Doris A. Graber , Maxwell E. McCombs , and Chaim H. Eyal . 1981. Media Agenda-Setting in a Presidential Election: Issues, Images, and Interest. New York: Praeger .
73.
Whicker, Marcia Lynn and Raymond A. Moore . 1988. When Presidents Are Great. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall .
74.
White, William S. 1964. The Professional: Lyndon B. Johnson. New York: Crest .
