The US health care system has changed dramatically over the past forty years or so. This paper analyzes its potential transformation into a consumer-driven health care system (with the newly enacted HSAs and the increased popularity of employer defined contributions). The emphasis in the first part is the evolution of the role of providers (mostly physicians) into bearers of financial risk and gatekeepers. The second part discusses the new consumer-driven health care proposals and its potential impact on the future of health care as it pertains to putting consumers under financial risk and gives them a perceived sense of control over health care decisions.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ChristiansonJS, ParenteTS, TaylorR. (2002). “Defined Contributions Health Insurance Products: Development and Prospects.” Health Affairs (January): 49–64.
2.
EisenbergJM. (1985). “The Internist as Gatekeeper. Preparing the General Internist for a New Role.” Annals of Internal Medicine (April): 537–43.
3.
FetterRB, ThompsonJD. (1992). “Inventors of DRGs Look at PPS Now. Interview by Marybeth Burke.” Hospitals5 (July):136, 138.
4.
GauthierAK, ClancyCM. (2004). “Consumer-Driven Health Care – Beyond Rhetoric with Research and Experience.” HSR (August) : 1049–1055.
5.
GreeneJ. (1987). “Continued Drops in Profits, Operating Revenues Seen at Not-For-Profit Hospitals.” Modern Healthcare8 (May):78.
6.
HsiaoWC, BraunP, BeckerER, ThomasSR. (1987). “The Resource-Based Relative Value Scale. Toward the Development of an Alternative Physician Payment System.” JAMA14 (August):799–802.
HubbardCM. (1983). “Capital Budgeting and Cost Reimbursement in Investor-Owned and Not-For-Profit Hospitals.” Health Care Management Review (Summer):7–15.
9.
KoskaMT. (1992). “Physician Groups Plan on Being Major Factor in Reform Debate.” Hospitals20 (August):30, 32, 34.
10.
LevitK, CowanC, BradenB, StillerJ, SensenigA, and LazenbyH. (1998). “National Health Expenditures in 1997: More Slow Growth.” Health Affairs (November-December): 99–110.
11.
MooreS. (1979). “Cost Containment Through Risk-Sharing by Primary-Care Physicians.” New England Journal of Medicine14 (June):1359–62.
12.
ParenteST, FeldmanR, ChristiansonJB. (2004). “Employee Choice of Consumer-Driven Health Insurance in a Multiplan, Multiproduct Setting.” HSR (August): 1091–1110.
13.
PattisonRV, KatzHM. (1983). “Investor-Owned and Not-For-Profit Hospitals. A Comparison Based on California Data.” New England Journal of Medicine11 (August):347–53.
14.
PogueJF. (1993). “California Physician Groups Prosper in the “Food Chain” of Managed Care.” Hosp Strategy Rep(February):6–7.
15.
RennSC, SchrammCJ, WattJM, DerzonRA. (1985). “The Effects of Ownership and System Affiliation on the Economic Performance of Hospitals.” Inquiry (Fall):219–36.
16.
RobisonJC. (1998). “Financial Capital and Intellectual Capital in Physician Practice Management.” Health Affairs (July-August):53–74.
17.
RosenthalM, MilsteinA. (2004). “Awakening Consumer Stewardship of Health Benefits: Prevalence and Differentiation of New Health Plan Models.” HSR (August): 1055–1070.
18.
ShortellSM. (1998). “The Evolution of Hospital Systems: Unfulfilled Promises and Self-Fulfilling Prophesies.” Medical Care Review (Fall):177–214.
19.
SomersAR. (1983). “And Who Shall Be the Gatekeeper? The Role of the Primary Physician in the Health Care Delivery System.” Inquiry (Winter):301–13.
20.
StarrP.The Social Transformation of American Medicine. Basic Books; 1982.
21.
StrunkBC, GinsburgPB. (2004). “Tracking Health Care Costs: Trends Turn Downward in 2003.” Health Affairs : W4-354-W4362.
22.
ThompsonJD. (1983). “Diagnosis-Related Groups.” New England Journal of Medicine5 (May):1107.
23.
ThompsonJD. (1988). “DRG Prepayment: Its Purpose and Performance.” Bulletin of N Y Academy of Medicine (January – February):28–51.
24.
WattJM, DerzonRA, RennSC, SchrammCJ, HahnJS, PillariGD (1986). “The Comparative Economic Performance of Investor-Owned Chain and Not-For-Profit Hospitals.” New England Journal of Medicine9 (January):89–96.
25.
WeberRD. (1995). “Physician Groups Should be Allowed to Compete in Managed Care. Look to the AMA for Advocacy of Profession's Position.” Michigan Medicine (June):11–2.
26.
WigginsS, EmeryD. (2001). “Self-Directed Health Plans: Web-Enabled Alternatives to Traditional Managed Care.” Managed Care Quarterly (Winter): 33–40.
