It is fashionable to point to privatization and the involvement of for-profits as the parties responsible for many, if not most, of the ills that plague the social welfare system today. This article takes a contrary point of view. Three arguments are made. First, private sector human service delivery and the use of for-profits in the United States predate privatization as a defined public policy. Second, the privatization of the human services is a world wide phenomenon that transcends politics and ideology. Third, the privatization of human services helps to promote civil society and generate social capital.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbramovitzM. (1986). “The Privatization of the Welfare State.” Social Work31:257–264.
2.
AbrainovitzM. (1984) “Social Benefits as a Right: A Reexamination of the 1980s.” Social Development Issues8:50–61.
3.
AgranoffR. (2003). Leveraging Partnerships. Arlington. VA: The IBM Center for the Business of Government.
4.
Asian Development Bank (2003). “ABD-Government-NGO Cooperation: A Framework for Action 2003 – 2005.”Manila: Author.
5.
BaileyD. and KooueyK. (2000). Strategic Alliance Between Health and Human Service Organizations. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.
BentonB., FieldT., and MillarR. (1978). Social Services v. Federal Legislation. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute.
8.
BornC. (1983). “Proprietary Firms and Child Welfare Services: Patterns and Implications.” Child Welfare62:109–118.
9.
BrodkinE., FuquaC. and ThorenK. (2002). Contracting Welfare Reforms: Uncertainties of Capacity-Building with Disjointed Federalism. Chicago: The Project on the Political Economy of Work, University of Chicago.
Government of Mongolia (2003). “TOR - Background Information and Terms of Reference, Development of Community-Based Social Welfare Services.”Ulaanbaatar: Author.
12.
Government of Mongolia (2000) “Partnership Agreement Between the Government of Mongolia and the Asian Development Band,” signed 24 March 2000.
13.
GreveC. and EjersboN. (2003). “Contracts as Reinvented Institutions in the Public Sector: A Cross Cultural Comparison. Paper presented at the 64 National Conference of the American Society for Public Administration, Washington, DC, March 15–18.
14.
HendersonK. (2002) “Alternative Service Delivery in Developing Countries: NGOs and Other Non-Profits in Urban Areas.” Public Organization Review: A Global Journal2:99–116.
KamermanS. and KahnA. (1998). Privatization. Contracting and Reform of Child and Family Services. Washington, DC: The Finance Project.
17.
KargerH. (1994). “Is Privatization a Positive Trend in Social Services? NO!,” in. KargerH. and MidgleyJ. (eds.) Controversial Issues in Social Policy. Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
18.
KettnerP. and MartinL. L. (1987). Purchase of Service Contracting. Beverly Hills: Sage Publications.
19.
KlitgaardR. and TrevertonG. (2003). Assessing Partnerships. The IBM Center for the Business of Government.
20.
LandabasoM. (2003). “The Role of Social Capital in Promoting Competitiveness in Less Favored Regions: Policy Options in Perspective.”' Instituto Superiore Universitario per la Formazione Interdisciplmare, Universita de Lecce.
21.
MartinL. L. (2003). “The Privatization of Social Services in Mongolia: A Strategic Change Opportunity for Professional Social Workers.” Mongolian Journal of Sociology and Social Work No215:128–133.
22.
MartinL. L. (1999). Contracting for Service Delivery: Local Government Choices. Washington, DC: International City/County Management Association.
23.
MartinL. L. (1986). “Purchase of Service Contracting for Human Services: An Analysis of State Decision Making.” Dissertation: Arizona State University.
24.
MartinL. L. and MillerJ. R. (2004). Contracting for Public Sector Services. Herndon, VA: National Institute of Governmental Purchasing.
25.
MattuR. (1994/95). “Civil Society in Argentina.” Lattitudes 3.
MoeR. (1987). “Exploring the Limits of Privatization.” Public Administration Review47: 453–460.
28.
MuellerC. (1978). “Purchase of Service Contracting from the View Point of the Provider,” in WedelK., KatzA. and WeickA. (eds.) Proceedings of the National Institute on Purchase of Service Contracting. Lawrence: University of Kansas, School of Social Work.
29.
NettingF. & McMurtryS. (1994). Will Privatization Destroy the Traditional Non-profit Human Services Sector? YES!” in AustinM. and LoweJ. (eds.) Controversial Issues in Communities and Organizations. Boston: Allyn and Bacon, pp. 159–164.
30.
New South Wales Department of Community Services (New South Wales DCS) (1999). Purchasing Partnership Modelhttp://www.pandora.nla.gov.au/tep/31683 (08/10/03).
NyamaamaA. (2003). Personal interview with A. Nyamaamaa — Project Manager “Social Security Sector Development Program,”Ministry of Social Welfare and Labor, Government of Mongolia.
33.
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). (1999). Contracting out Government Services: Best Practice Guidelines. Paris: Author.
34.
Pacific Consultants (1979). A Description of States' Service Delivery and Management Practices Berkeley, CA: Author.
35.
PetersB. (1994). “Managing the Hollow State.” International Journal of Public Administration17:739–757.
36.
ReedPaul and HoweValerie (1999). The Study of Voluntary Organizations in Ontario in the 1990s: A Report to Participating Agencies. One in a series of the Nonprofit Sector Knowledge Base Reports.
SalamonL. (2002). The Tools of Government: A Guide to the New Governance. New York: Oxford University Press.”.
41.
Save the Children Sweden (2002). “Social Service Provision Through Civil Society Organizations (CSOs).” Paper prepared for the UN Committee on the Rights of Children Day of Discussion, Friday 20 September 2002. Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, Palais Wilson, Geneva.
42.
ScottK. (2002). FundingMatters: The Impact of Canada's New Funding Regime on Nonprofit and Voluntary Organizations. Canadian Council on Social Development. http://www.ccsd.ca/pubs/2003/fm (08/15/03).
43.
SmithS. and LipskyM. (1999). Non-Profits for Hire: The Welfare State in the Age of Contracting. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
44.
StruykR. (2003). Contracting with NGOs for Social Services. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute.
WedelK. (1974). “Contracting for Public Assistance Social Services”. Public Welfare32:57–62.
47.
WetterhallR. (2003). “The Rhetoric and Reality of Public-Private Partnerships.” Public Organizational Review: A Global Journal3:77–107.
48.
World Vision International (2002). “Preventing the Privatization of Responsibility: The Need to Build Regulatory Linkages Between State Commitments and Providers of Services.” Paper prepared for the UN Committee on the Rights of Children Day of Discussion. Friday 20 September 2002. Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, Palais Wilson, Geneva.
