Interorganizational Networks: Using a Theoretical Model to Predict Effectiveness of Rural Health Care Delivery Networks

Abstract

Interorganizational health care delivery networks have potential for sustaining health services delivery in rural areas faced with economic and demographic challenges. Four Nebraska rural health care delivery networks (Albion-Ord, Blue River Valley. Rural Partners. Inc., and Western Nebraska) were compared to an interorganizational model based on theories of interorganizational relations, exchange, population ecology, and synthesized collaboration. It assumes that outcomes, including effectiveness, are influenced by external and internal factors that are operationalized through external control, technology, structure, and operational process variables.

Data were collected by a non-random, two-level cluster mail survey of network, members (45/59 = 76.3% response rate). All networks received technical assistance from the Nebraska Office of Rural Health. Networks have formal organization, strategic plans, and official coordinators. Hospital administrators hold most leadership positions; few doctors or citizens are involved.

Correlation and multiple regression analysis show partial fit between the research model and study networks. Effectiveness, measure by the gap between best possible and actual practice, increased with network connectivity (r=.36, p<.05), group methods of administrative decisionmaking (r=.52, p<.001) and sequential pattern of service delivery (r=.39, p<.05). Greater dependence on vertical funding corresponds to greater external control (r=.43, p<.01). The prediction that, as scope narrows, task intensity (r=.56, p<.001). duration (r=.41, p<.01), and task volume (r=.50, p<01) increase is upheld. Centrality and network size decrease together (r=.43, p<01) where there is little reliance on vertical sources of funds (r=.36, p<.05). The integrated interorganizational model demonstrates some efficacy for testing potential effectiveness of networks.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alexander

E.R.

(1995). How Organizations Act Together: Interorganizational Coordination In Theory and Practice. Amsterdam: Gordon and Breach.

Alter

and Hage

(1993). Organizations Work Together. Newbury Parkm CA: Sage.

Ashar

and Shapiro

(1988). “Measuring Centrality: A Note on Hackman's Resource Allocation Theory.” Administrative Science Quarterly 33:275–283.

Babbie

E.R.

(1990). Survey Research Methods, 2nd ed. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing Company.

Babbie

E.R.

(1995). The Practice of Social Research, 7th ed. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing Company.

Bernard

(1938). The Function of the Executive. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Benson

J.K.

(1975). “The Organisational Network as a Political Economy.” Administrative Science Quarterly 20(2):229–249.

Blau

P.M.

(1970). “A Formal Theory of Differentiation in Organizations.” American Sociological Review 35:210–218.

Boje

and Whetten

(1981). “Effects of Organizational Strategies and Contextual Constraints on Centrality and Attributions of Influence in Interorganizational Networks.” Administrative Science Quarterly 26:378–395.

10.

Borch

O.J.

(1995). “Strategic Networks among Small Firms: Implications for Strategy Research Methodology.” Journal of Management Studies 32(4):419–441.

11.

Borys

and Jemison

(1989). “Hybrid Arrangements as Strategic Alliances: Theoretical Issues, in Organizational Combinations.” Academy of Management Review 14:234–249.

12.

Boudon

Theories of Social Change: A Critical Appraisal. Cambridge. UK: Polity Press.

13.

Boyett

J.H.

(1995). Beyond Workplace 2000: Essential Strategies for the New-American Corporations. New York: Pengum Books.

14.

Cameron

(1981). The Enigma of Organizational Effectiveness. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

15.

Corwin

R.G.

(1969). “Patterns of Organizational Conflict.” Administrative Science Quarterly 14:507–521.

16.

Coward

R.T.

. (1994). Health Services for Rural Elders. New York: Springer.

17.

Crandall

L.A.

, Dwyer

J.W.

, and Duncan

E.P.

(1990). “Recruitment and Retention of Rural Physicians: Issues for the 1990s.” Journal of Rural Health 6:1.

18.

Creswell

J.W.

(1994). Research Design: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches. Thousand Oaks. CA: Sage.

19.

Duncan

E.B.

(1972). “Characteristics of Organizational Environments and Perceived Environmental Uncertainty.” Administrative Science Quarterly 17:313–237.

20.

Fink

and Kosecoff

(1985). How to Conduct Surveys: A Step-by-Step Guide. Beverly Hills. CA: Sage.

21.

Fowler

F.J.

Survey Research Methods. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

22.

Gillespie

and Mileti

(1979). Technostructure and Interorganizational Behavior. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.

23.

Hage

(1980). Theories of Organizational; Form, Process, and Transformation. New York: John Wiley.

24.

Hall

R.H.

. (1977). “Patterns of Interorganizational Relationships.” Administrative Science Quarterly 22(3):457–474.

25.

Hechter

(1987). Principles of Group Solidarity. Berkeley: University of California Press.

26.

Horn

M.J.

(1995). The Political Economy of Public Administration Institutional Choice in the Public Sector. New York: Cambridge University Press.

27.

Killing

J.P.

(1988). “Understanding Alliance: The Role of Task and Organizational Complexity,” in Contractor

and Lorange

(eds.). Cooperative Strategies in International Business. Lexington, MA: Lexington Boots.

28.

Knoke

(1988). “Incentives in Collective Organizations.” American Sociological Review 53:311–329.

29.

Kogut

and Singh

(1988). “Entering the United States by Joint Venture: Competitive Rivalry and Industrial Structure.” in Contractor

and Lorange

(eds.). Competitive Strategies in International Business. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books,.

30.

Lawrence

P.F.

and Lorsch

J.W.

(1967). “'Differentiation and Integration in Complex Organizations.” Administrative Science Quarterly 12:1–47.

31.

Lefton

and Rosengren

(1966). “Organizations and Clients: Lateral and Longitudinal Dimensions.” American Sociological Review 31(6):802–810.

32.

Mackenzie

K.D.

(1978). “Structural Centrality in Communications Networks.” Psychornetrika 11(1):17–28.

33.

Maser

S.M.

(1986). “Transaction Costs in Public Administration,” in Calista

(ed). Bureaucratic and Governmental Reform. Greenwich/ CT: JAI.

34.

Morrissey

J.P.

, Alexander

J.A.

, and Ohsfeldt

R.L.

(1990). “Physician Integration Strategies and Hospital Input: A Comparison of Rural and Urban Institutions.” Medical Care 28(7):586–603.

35.

Moscovice

I.S.

, Christianson

J.B.

, and Wellever

(1995). “Measuring and Evaluating the Performance of Vertically Integrated Rural Health Networks.” Journal of Rural Health 11(1):9–21.

36.

Mulford

C.L.

and Rogers

D.I.

(1982). “Definitions and Models in Interorganizational Coordination.” in Rogers

D.L.

and Whetten

D.A.

(eds.). Theory, Research, and Implementation. Ames. LA: University of Iowa Press.

37.

O'Toole

L.J.

(1997). “Treating Networks Seriously: Practical and Research-Based Agendas in Public Administration.” Public Administration Review 57(1):45–52.

38.

Pfeffer

and Salancik

G.R.

(1978). “The External Control of Organizations: A Resource Dependence Perspective. New York: Harper and Row.

39.

Provan

K.G.

(1984). “Interorganizational Cooperation and Decision Making Authority in a Consortium Multihospital System: Academy of Management Review 9(3):494–504.

40.

Provan

K.G.

, Beyer

, and Kruytenbosch

(1980). “Environmental Linkages and Power in Resource-Dependence Relations between Organizations.” Administrative Science Quarterly 25(2):200–225.

41.

Selzniek

TVA and the Grass Roots. Berkeley: University of California Press.

42.

Shortell

S.M.

. (1996). Remaking Health Care in America: Building Organized Delivery Systems. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

43.

Thompson

(1967). Organizations in Action. New York: McGraw-Hill.

44.

Tosi

H.L.

and Carroll

(1980). Management: Contingencies, Structure and Process, 3rd ed. New York: John Wiley.

45.

Van de Van

A.H.

and Ferry

(1980). Measuring and Assessing Organizations. New York: John Wiley.

46.

Van de Van

A.H.

and Walker

(1984). “The Dynamics of Inrerorganizational Coordination.” Administrative Science Quarterly 29(4): 598–621.

47.

Walton

R.E.

and Dutton

J.N.

(1969). “The Management of Interorganizational Conflict: A Model and Review.” Administrative Science Quarterly 14:73–90.

48.

Weick

(1976). “Educational Organizations as Loosely Coupled Systems,” Administrative Science Quarterly 21(1):1–19.

49.

Wellever

A.L.

and Rosenberg

(1993). Alternative Models for Organizing and Delivering Health Care Services in Rural Areas. Vol. 1. State Sponsored Alternative Models: The State Government Perspective. Monograph. Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.

50.

Wildavsky

(1979). Speaking Truth to Power: The Art and Craft of Policy Analysis. Boston: Little, Brown.

51.

Zeitz

(1985). “Inteiorganizational Dialectics.” Administrative Science Quarterly 25:72–88.