Expenditures on police departments account for significant portions of local government budgets in the United States. Yet activism on police reform and changing views on the causes of violence have called into question law enforcement's role in public safety. While intergovernmental transfers have historically supported traditional policing, the American Rescue Plan Act's Coronavirus State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds (CSLFRF) affords cities the opportunity to disrupt the status quo by providing them with the federal funds and flexibility to reshape their public safety policies around Community Violence Interventions (CVIs). This article examines how 13 cities that participated in a White House convened collaborative used CSLFRF aid to support CVIs. Our analysis reveals significant variation in how these cities in allocated CSLFRF dollars to CVI programs, suggesting that the combination of federal aid and White House encouragement has thus far led to incremental policy changes, whose durability remains an open question.
AbtThomas. 2019. Bleeding Out. New York: Hachette.
2.
AldagAustin MKimYunjiWarnerMildred E. 2019. “Austerity Urbanism or Pragmatic Municipalism? Local Government Responses to Fiscal Stress in New York State.” Environment and Planning A7 (1): 1287–305. https://doi.org/10.1177/0308518×19844794.
3.
AspholmRoberto. 2020. Views from the Streets: The Transformation of Gangs and Violence on Chicago's South Side. New York: Columbia University Press.
BaumgartnerFrank R.JonesBryan. 1993. Agendas and Instability in American Politics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
6.
BeckBrendenGoldsteinAdam. 2017. “Governing Through Police? Housing Market Reliance, Welfare Retrenchment, and Police Budgeting in an Era of Declining Crime.” Social Forces96 (3): 1183–210. https://doi.org/10.1093/sf/sox076.
7.
Bipartisan Safer Communities Act. 2022. “Public Law 117–159.” U.S. Statutes at Large136 (2022): 1313–44.
BoyleDouglas J.LantermanJennifer L.PascarellaJoseph E.ChengChia. 2010. Impact of Newark’s Operation CeaseFire. Newark: Violence Institute of New Jersey, University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey.
10.
BranasCharlesBuggsShaniButtsJeffreyHarveyAnnaKerrisonErinMearesTraceyPapachristosAndrew, et al.2020. “Reducing Violence Without Police: A Review of Research Evidence.” Publications and ResearchNovember, https://academicworks.cuny.edu/jj_pubs/349.
BuggsShani AWebsterDaniel WCrifasiCassandra K. 2022. “Using Synthetic Control Methodology to Estimate Effects of a Cure Violence Intervention in Baltimore, Maryland.” Injury Prevention28 (1): 61–7. https://doi.org/10.1136/injuryprev-2020-044056.
13.
ButtsJeffrey A.RomanCaterina GouvisBostwickLindsayPorterJeremy R.. 2015. “Cure Violence: A Public Health Model to Reduce Gun Violence.” Annual Review of Public Health36 (1): 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-publhealth-031914-122509.
Executive Order No. 13,985. 2021. “Advancing Racial Equity and Support for Underserved Communities Through the Federal Government.” Federal Register86 (14): 7009–13.
25.
FisherRonald C. 1982. “Income and Grant Effects on Local Expenditure: The Flypaper Effect and Other Difficulties.” Journal of Urban Economics12 (3): 324–45.
26.
FisherRonald C. 2023. State and Local Public Finance. 5th ed. New York: Routledge.
27.
FoxAndrew M.KatzCharles M.ChoateDavid E.HedbergE. C.. 2015. “Evaluation of the Phoenix TRUCE Project: A Replication of Chicago CeaseFire.” Justice Quarterly32 (1): 85–115. https://doi.org/10.1080/07418825.2014.902092.
GlaserDaniel. 1958. “The Sociological Approach to Crime and Correction.” Law and Contemporary Problems23 (4): 683–702.
30.
GoldsteinRebeccaSancesMichael W.YouHye Young. 2020. “Exploitative Revenues, law Enforcement, and the Quality of Government Services.” Urban Affairs Review56 (1): 5–31.
31.
GorinaEvgeniaMaherCraigJoffeMarc. 2018. “Local Fiscal Distress: Measurement and Prediction.” Public Budgeting & Finance38 (1): 72–94. https://doi.org/10.1111/pbaf.12165.
32.
GottschalkMarie. 2016. Caught. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
33.
HerringTiana. 2021. “Jail Incarceration Rates Vary Widely, but Inexplicably, across US Cities.” Prison Policy Initiative, May 4.
34.
HinkleySaraWeberRachel. 2020. “Incentives and Austerity: How Did the Great Recession Affect Municipal Economic Development Policy?” Urban Affairs Review28 (2): 107808742096425–36. https://doi.org/10.1177/1078087420964254.
35.
HoangBai LinhBenjaminAndrea. 2023. “‘Defund’ or ‘Refund’ the Police?: City Council Responsiveness to the Black Lives Matter Protests.” Urban Affairs Review60: 387–419. https://doi.org/10.1177/10780874231187131.
KeglerScott R.SimonThomas R.ZwaldMarissa L.ChenMay S.MercyJames A.JonesChristopher M.Mercado-CrespoMelissa C., et al.2022. “Vital Signs: Changes in Firearm Homicide and Suicide Rates—United States, 2019–2020.” Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report71 (19): 656–63.
40.
KimYunjiWarnerMildred E. 2020. “Pragmatic Municipalism or Austerity Urbanism? Understanding Local Government Responses to Fiscal Stress.” Local Government Studies47 (00): 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1080/03003930.2020.1729751.
KrugEtienne G.MercyJames A.DahlbergLinda L.ZwiAnthony B.. 2002. “The World Report on Violence and Health.” The Lancet360 (9339): 1083–8.
43.
LaceyNicolaSoskiceDavid. 2015. “Crime, Punishment and Segregation in the United States: The Paradox of Local Democracy.” Punishment & Society17 (4 ): 454–81.
44.
LeeRobert D.JohnsonRonald W.JoycePhilip G.. 2021. Public Budgeting Systems, 10th ed. Burlington, MA: Jones & Bartlett Learning.
45.
LewisGregory B. 1984. “Municipal Expenditures Through Thick and Thin.” Publius: The Journal of Federalism2 (14): 31–9.
46.
McCartyWilliam P.RenLingZhaoJihong “Solomon”. 2012. “Determinants of Police Strength in Large U.S. Cities During the 1990s.” Crime & Delinquency58 (3): 397–424. https://doi.org/10.1177/0011128709336942.
47.
MillerLisa L. 2008. The Perils of Federalism: Race, Poverty, and the Politics of Crime Control. New York: Oxford University Press.
48.
MillerLisa L. 2015. “What’s Violence got to do with it? Inequality, Punishment, and State Failure in US Politics.” Punishment & Society17 (2): 184–210. https://doi.org/10.1177/1462474515577153.
49.
MortensenPeter B. 2005. “Policy Punctuations in Danish Local Budgeting.” Public Administration83 (4): 931–50.
50.
MughanSiân. 2021. “Municipal Reliance on Fine and fee Revenues: How Local Courts Contribute to Extractive Revenue Practices in US Cities.” Public Budgeting & Finance41 (2): 22–44.
PaganoMichaelHoeneChristopher W.. 2018. City Budgets in an Era of Increased Uncertainty. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.
54.
PapachristosAndrew V. 2011. “Too Big to Fail: The Science and Politics of Violence Prevention.” Criminology & Public Policy10 (4): 1053–61.
55.
ParkAngela YSSapotichneJoshua. 2020. “Punctuated Equilibrium and Bureaucratic Autonomy in American City Governments.” Policy Studies Journal48 (4): 896–925.
RoccoPhilipKassAmanda. 2022. “Flexible Aid in an Uncertain World: The Coronavirus State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds Program.” State and Local Government Review, 54 (4): 346–361.
58.
ShermanLawrence W. 2004. “Research and Policing: The Infrastructure and Political Economy of Federal Funding.” The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science593 (1): 156–78.
59.
SinclairJ. AndrewLoveMayaGutiérrez-VeraMaría. 2021. “Federalism, Defunding the Police, and Democratic Values: A Functional Accountability Framework for Analyzing Police Reform Proposals.” The Journal of Federalism51 (3): 484–511.
60.
SinglaAkheilKirschnerCharlotteStoneSamuel B.. 2020. “Race, Representation, and Revenue: Reliance on Fines and Forfeitures in City Governments.” Urban Affairs Review56 (4): 1132–67.
61.
SkoganWesley G.HartnettSusan M.BumpNatalieDuboisJill. 2009. Evaluation of CeaseFire-Chicago. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs.
62.
SkowronekStephen. 1982. Building a New American State. New York: Cambridge University Press.
63.
SossJoeWeaverVesla. 2017. “Police are our Government: Politics, Political Science, and the Policing of Race–Class Subjugated Communities.” Annual Review of Political Science20 (1): 565–91.
64.
SunShengzhiCaoWangnanGeYangSiegelMichaelWelleniusGregory A.. 2022. “Analysis of Firearm Violence During the COVID-19 Pandemic in the US.” JAMA Network Open5 (4): e229393–e229393.
65.
WarnerMildred EKellyPaige MZhangXue. 2022. ““Challenging Austerity Under the COVID-19 State.” Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society16: 197–209. https://doi.org/10.1093/cjres/rsac032.
66.
WeaverTimothy P. R. 2022. “Charting Change in the City: Urban Political Orders and Urban Political Development.” Urban Affairs Review58 (2): 319–55. https://doi.org/10.1177/1078087420988608.
67.
WebsterDaniel W.WhitehillJennifer MendelVernickJon S.CurrieroFrank C.. 2013. “Effects of Baltimore’s Safe Streets Program on Gun Violence: A Replication of Chicago’s CeaseFire Program.” Journal of Urban Health: Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine90 (1): 27–40.
68.
WebsterDaniel W.VernickJon S.MendelJennifer. 2009. “Interim Evaluation of Baltimore's Safe Streets Program.” Center for the Prevention of Youth Violence, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health. Baltimore, MD: Harvard.
WilsonJeremy W.ChermakSteven. 2011. “Community-driven Violence Reduction Programs: Examining Pittsburgh’s One Vision One Life.” Criminology & Public Policy10 (4): 993–1027.
73.
ZhaoJihongRenLingLovrichNicholas P.. 2010. “Budgetary Support for Police Services in U.S. Municipalities: Comparing Political Culture, Socioeconomic Characteristics and Incrementalism as Rival Explanations for Budget Share Allocation to Police.” Journal of Criminal Justice38 (3): 266–75.
