Continued critiques, evidence and newer reform trends have increasingly contested the use of market-centered models–the competition prescription–for urban public space maintenance as well as other local services. This article adopts a contextualized contingency perspective on the competition prescription and questions the contested status of market-centered models in a survey-based study of the current use of and satisfaction with private providers for maintenance of parks/greenspaces and road/streets in Scandinavian local governments. The study finds widespread use of and satisfaction with private providers. However, satisfaction depends on national context and multiple contingencies. The study challenges the contested status of market-centered models, highlights that different models serve different strategic objectives, and directs attention to discussions of context and key contingencies that define how well market-centered models perform.
AbbottLawrence. 1955. Quality and Competition: An Essay in Economic Theory. New York: Columbia University Press.
2.
AmirkhanyanAnna A.KimHyon J.LambrightKristina T.. 2007. “Putting the Pieces Together: A Comprehensive Framework for Understanding the Decision to Contract Out and Contractor Performance.” International Journal of Public Administration30 (6): 699–725. 10.1080/01900690601125286.
3.
AmirkhanyanAnna A.KimHyon J.LambrightKristina T.. 2010. “Do Relationships Matter? Assessing the Association Between Relationship Design and Contractor Performance.” Public Performance and Management Review34 (2): 189–220. 10.2753/PMR1530-9576340203.
4.
AmirkhanyanAnna A.KimHyon J.LambrightKristina T.. 2014. “The Performance Puzzle: Understanding the Factors Influencing Alternative Dimensions and Views of Performance.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory24 (1): 1–34. 10.1093/jopart/mut021.
5.
AndrewsRhysBoyneGeorge A.Jay MoonM.WalkerRichard M.. 2010. “Assessing Organizational Performance: Exploring Differences Between Internal and External Measures.” International Public Management Journal13 (2): 105–29. 10.1080/10967491003766533.
6.
AndrewsRhysEntwistleTom. 2015. “Public–Private Partnerships, Management Capacity and Public Service Efficiency.” Policy & Politics43 (2): 273–90. 10.1332/030557314X13917703359707.
7.
ArmstrongJ. ScottOvertonTerry S.. 1977. “Estimating Nonresponse Bias in Main Surveys.” Journal of Marketing Research14 (3): 396–402. 10.1177/002224377701400320.
8.
BaumolWilliam J. 1982. “Contestable Markets: An Uprising in the Theory of Industry Structure.” The American Economic Review72 (1): 1–15.
9.
BelGermaFagedaXavier. 2011. “Big Guys Eat Big Cakes: Firm Size and Contracting in Urban and Rural Areas.” International Public Management Journal14 (1): 4–26. 10.1080/10967494.2011.547746.
10.
BelGermaFagedaXavierWarnerMildred E.. 2010. “Is Private Production of Public Services Cheaper Than Public Production? A Meta-Regression Analysis of Solid Waste and Water Services.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management29 (3): 553–77. https://doi.org/10.1002/pam.20509.
11.
BelGermaHebdonRobertWarnerMildred E.. 2018. “Beyond Privatisation and Cost Savings: Alternatives for Local Government Reform.” Local Government Studies44 (2): 173–82. 10.1080/03003930.2018.1428190.
12.
BovairdTony. 2004. “Public-Private Partnerships: From Contested Concepts to Prevalent Practice.” International Review of Administrative Sciences70 (2): 199–215. 10.1177/0020852304044250.
13.
BoyneGeorge A. 1998. Public Choice and Local Government. A Comparative Analysis of the UK and the USA. Basingstoke: Macmillan Press LTD.
14.
BoyneGeorge A. 2002. “Concepts and Indicators of Local Authority Performance: An Evaluation of the Statutory Frameworks in England and Wales.” Public Money and Management22 (2): 17–24. 10.1111/1467-9302.00303.
15.
BrownTrevor L.PotoskiMatthewVan SlykeDavid M.. 2006. “Managing Public Service Contracts: Aligning Values, Institutions, and Markets.” Public Administration Review66 (3): 323–31. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6210.2006.00590.x.
16.
CannonJoseph P.AchrolRavi S.GundlachGregory T.. 2000. “Contracts, Norms, and Plural Form Governance.” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science28 (2): 180–94. 10.1177/0092070300282001.
17.
CarmonaMatthew. 2010. “Contemporary Public Space, Part Two: Classification.” Journal of Urban Design15 (2): 157–73. 10.1080/13574801003638111.
18.
CarmonaMatthewDe MagalhãesClaudioHammondLeo. 2008. Public Space: The Management Dimension. London: Routledge.
19.
ChristensenTomLægreidPer (editors). 2011. The Ashgate Research Companion to New Public Management. Farnham: Routledge.
20.
ChristensenTomLægreidPer (editors). 2017. Transcending New Public Management. London: Taylor & Francis.
21.
CliftonJudithWarnerMildred E.GradusRaymondBelGerma. 2019. “Re-municipalization of Public Services: Trend or Hype?” Journal of Economic Policy Reform, Online first, 1–12. 10.1080/17487870.2019.1691344.
22.
DehoogRuth. 1990. “Competition, Negotiation, or Cooperation: Three Models for Service Contracting.” Administration and Society22 (3): 317–40. 10.1177/009539979002200303.
23.
De MagalhãesClaudioCarmonaMatthew. 2006. “Innovations in the Management of Public Space: Reshaping and Refocusing Governance.” Planning Theory & Practice7 (3): 289–303. 10.1080/14649350600841461.
24.
DempseyNicolaBurtonMel. 2012. “Defining Place-Keeping: The Long-Term Management of Public Spaces.” Urban Forestry & Urban Greening11 (1): 11–20. http:/dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ufug.2011.09.005.
25.
DempseyNicolaBurtonMelDuncanRosie. 2016a. “Evaluating the Effectiveness of a Cross-Sector Partnership for Green Space Management: The Case of Southey Owlerton, Sheffield, UK.” Urban Forestry & Urban Greening15: 155–64. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ufug.2015.12.002.
26.
DempseyNicolaBurtonMelSelinJohanna. 2016b. “Contracting out Parks and Roads Maintenance in England.” International Journal of Public Sector Management29 (5): 441–56. 10.1108/IJPSM-02-2016-0029.
27.
DempseyNicolaMartínez VelardeC. L.BurtonMel. 2020. “Long-Term Partnership Contracting in Practice: Queen Elizabeth Olympic Park, London.” In Marketization in Local Government: Diffusion and Evolution in Scandinavia and England, edited by LindholstAndrej ChristianHansenMorten Balle, 225–40. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
28.
DonahueJohn D. 1989. The Privatization Decision: Public Ends, Private Means. New York: Basic Books.
29.
DonahueJohn D.ZeckhauserRichard J.. 2012. Collaborative Governance: Private Roles for Public Goals in Turbulent Times. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
30.
DunleavyPatrickMargettsHelenBastowSimonTinklerJane. 2006. “New Public Management Is Dead—Long Live Digital-Era Governance.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory16 (3): 467–94. 10.1093/jopart/mui057.
31.
ElkomyShimaaCooksonGrahamJonesSimon. 2019. “Cheap and Dirty: The Effect of Contracting Out Cleaning on Efficiency and Effectiveness.” Public Administration Review79 (2): 193–202. https://doi.org/10.1111/puar.13031.
32.
EntwistleTomMartinSteve. 2005. “From Competition to Collaboration in Public Service Delivery: A new Agenda for Research.” Public Administration83 (1): 233–42. 10.1111/j.0033-3298.2005.00446.x.
33.
FeiockRichard C. 2007. “Rational Choice and Regional Governance.” Journal of Urban Affairs29 (1): 47–63. 10.1111/j.1467-9906.2007.00322.x.
FogedSøren K. 2016. “The Relationship Between Population Size and Contracting Out Public Services: Evidence From A Quasi-Experiment in Danish Municipalities.” Urban Affairs Review52 (3): 348–90. 10.1177/1078087415591288.
36.
FongarClaudiaRandrupThomas B.WiströmBjörnSolfjeldIngjerd. 2019. “Public Urban Green Space Management in Norwegian Municipalities: A Managers’ Perspective on Place Keeping.” Urban Forestry & Urban Greening44 (2019): 1–10. 10.1016/j.ufug.2019.126438.
37.
FullerChristine M.SimmeringMarcia J.AtincGucluAtincYasminBabinBarry J.. 2016. “Common Methods Variance Detection in Business Research.” Journal of Business Research69: 3192–8. 10.1016/j.jbusres.2015.12.008.
38.
GreveCarstenLægreidPerRykkjaLise H. (editors). 2016. Nordic Administrative Reforms: Lessons for Public Management, 1–236. London: Palgrave Macmillian.
39.
HairJoseph F.BabinBarry J.AndersonRolph E.BlackWilliam C.. 2018. Multivariate Data Analysis: A Global Perspective (8th Edition). Hampshire: Cengage Learning.
40.
HansenMorten B. 2010. “Marketization and Economic Performance. Competitive Tendering in the Social Sector.” Public Management Review12 (2): 255–74. 10.1080/14719031003616644.
41.
HartOliverShleiferAndreiVishnyRobert W.. 1997. “The Proper Scope of Government: Theory and an Application to Prisons.” Quarterly Journal of Economics112 (4): 1127–61. https://doi.org/10.1162/003355300555448.
42.
HebbertMichael. 2008. “Re-enclosure of the Urban Picturesque: Green-Space Transformations in Postmodern Urbanism.” Town Planning Review79 (1): 31–59. https://doi.org/10.3828/tpr.79.1.4.
43.
HebdonRobert P.1995. “Contracting Out in New York State: The Story the Lauder Report Chose Not to Tell.” Labor Studies Journal20 (1): 3–29.
44.
HefetzAmirWarnerMildred E.. 2012. “Contracting or Public Delivery? The Importance of Service, Market, and Management Characteristics.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory22 (2): 289–317. 10.1093/jopart/mur006.
45.
HodgeGraeme A. 2000. Privatization: An International Review of Performance. Oxford: Boulder Westview Press.
46.
HoodChristopher. 1991. “A Public Management for All Seasons?” Public Administration69 (1): 3–19. 10.1111/j.1467-9299.1991.tb00779.x.
47.
IngrahamPatricia W.JoycePhilip G.DonahueAmy K.. 2003. Government Performance: Why Management Matters. Baltimore: The John Hopkins University Press.
48.
JacobsJane. 1961. The Death and Life of Great American Cities. New York: Random House.
49.
JonesRobert. 2000. “Managing the Green Spaces: Problems of Maintaining Quality in a Local Government Service Department.” Managing Service Quality: An International Journal10 (1): 19–31. 10.1108/09604520010307021.
50.
KettlDonald F. 1993. Sharing Power: Public Governance and Private Markets. Washington: The Brookings Institution.
51.
KettlDonald F. 2010. “Governance, Contract Management and Public Management.” In New Public Governance?, edited by OsborneStephan P., 239–54. Oxon: Routledge.
52.
KimYunjiWarnerMildred E.. 2016. “Pragmatic Municipalism: Local Government Service Delivery in the Great Recession.” Public Administration94 (3): 789–805. 10.1111/padm.12267.
53.
KuhlmannSabineWollmannHelmut. 2019. Introduction to Comparative Public Administration: Administrative Systems and Reforms in Europe (Second Edition). Cheltenham: Edward Edgar.
54.
LadnerAndreasKeufferNicolasBaldersheimHarald. 2016. “Measuring Local Autonomy in 39 Countries (1990–2014).” Regional & Federal Studies26 (3): 321–57. 10.1080/13597566.2016.1214911.
55.
LamotheMeeyoungLamotheScott. 2008. “Beyond the Search for Competition in Social Service Contracting.” The American Review of Public Administration39 (2): 164–88. 10.1177/0275074008316557.
56.
LamotheMeeyoungLamotheScott. 2010. “Competing for What? Linking Competition to Performance in Social Service Contracting.” The American Review of Public Administration40 (3): 326–50. 10.1177/0275074009337621.
57.
LamotheScottLamotheMeeyoungFeiockRichard C.. 2008. “Examining Local Government Service Delivery Arrangements Over Time.” Urban Affairs Review44 (1): 27–56. 10.1177/1078087408315801.
58.
Le GrandJulian. 2007. The Other Invisible Hand: Delivering Public Services Through Choice and Competition. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
59.
LijphartArend. 2012. Patterns of Democracy: Government Forms and Performance in Thirty-Six Countries. Second Edition. New Haven: Yale University Press.
60.
LindholstAndrej Christian. 2009. “Contracting-Out in Urban Green-Space Management: Instruments, Approaches and Arrangements.” Urban Forestry & Urban Greening8 (4): 257–68. 10.1016/j.ufug.2009.07.002.
61.
LindholstAndrej Christian. 2017. “A Review of the Outcomes From Contracting out Urban Green Space Maintenance: What we Know, Don’t Know and Should Know.” Urban Forestry & Urban Greening27: 50–8. 10.1016/j.ufug.2017.06.012.
62.
LindholstAndrej Christian. 2020. “Denmark: The Incremental Way Towards A Deep-Seated Marketization of Service Delivery.” In Marketization in Local Government: Diffusion and Evolution in Scandinavia and England, edited by LindholstAndrej ChristianHansenMorten Balle, 141–60. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
63.
LindholstAndrej ChristianHansenMorten BalleRandrupThomas BarfoedPerssonBengtKristofferssonAnders. 2017. “The Many Outcomes From Contracting out: The Voice of Public Managers.” Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space36 (6): 1046–67. 10.1177/2399654417733992.
64.
LindholstAndrej ChristianPetersenOle HelbyHoulbergKurt. 2020. “Economic Effects of Contracting Out in Scandinavia, and the Importance of Country Context.” In Marketization in Local Government: Diffusion and Evolution in Scandinavia and England, edited by LindholstAndrej ChristianHansenMorten Balle, 179–96. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
65.
LindholstAndrej ChristianSullivanSidKonijnendijk van den BorschCecil C.ForsHanna. 2015. “The Inherent Politics of Managing the Quality of Urban Green Spaces.” Planning Practice and Research30 (4): 376–92. 10.1080/02697459.2015.1057943.
66.
MacneilIan R. 1980. The New Social Contract: An Inquiry Into Modern Contractual Relations. New Haven: Yale University Press.
67.
MarquesRui C.BergSanford. 2011. “Risks, Contracts, and Private-Sector Participation in Infrastructure.” Journal of Construction Engineering and Management137 (11): 925–32. 10.1061/(ASCE)CO.1943-7862.0000347.
68.
MathersAliceDempseyNicolaMolinJulie F.. 2015. “Place-keeping in Action: Evaluating the Capacity of Green Space Partnerships in England.” Landscape and Urban Planning139: 126–36. 10.1016/j.landurbplan.2015.03.004.
69.
MilwardH. BrintonProvanKeith G.. 2000. “Governing the Hollow State.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory10 (2): 359–79. 10.1093/oxfordjournals.jpart.a024273.
70.
MuñozSarah-Anne. 2010. “Towards a Geographical Research Agenda for Social Enterprise.” Area42 (3): 302–12. 10.1111/j.1475-4762.2009.00926.x.
71.
OECD. 2018. Subnational Governments in OECD Countries: Key Data. Paris: Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development.
72.
O’FlynnJanineAlfordJohn. 2008. “The Separation/Specification Dilemma in Contracting: The Local Government Experience in Victoria.” Public Administration86 (1): 205–24. 10.1111/j.1467-9299.2007.00708.x.
73.
PetersenOle HelbyHjelmarUlfVrangbækKarsten. 2017. “Is Contracting out of Public Services Still the Great Panacea? A Systematic Review of Studies on Economic and Quality Effects From 2000 to 2014.” Social Policy & Administration52 (1): 130–57. 10.1111/spol.12297.
74.
PodsakoffPhilip M.MacKenzieScott B.PodsakoffNathan P.. 2012. “Sources of Method Bias in Social Science Research and Recommendations on How to Control It.” Annual Review of Psychology63 (1): 539–69. 10.1146/annurev-psych-120710-100452.
75.
PoppoLauraZhouKevin Z.ZengerTodd R.. 2008. “Examining the Conditional Limits of Relational Governance: Specialized Assets, Performance Ambiguity, and Long-Standing Ties.” Journal of Management Studies45 (7): 1195–216. 10.1111/j.1467-6486.2008.00779.x.
76.
RandrupThomas B.LindholstAndrej ChristianDempseyNicola. 2020. “Managing the Maintenance of Urban Open Spaces.” In Urban Open Space Governance and Management, edited by JanssonMäritRandrupThomas B., 150–67. London: Routledge.
77.
SamuelsonPaul A. 1954. “The Pure Theory of Public Expenditure.” Review of Economics and Statistics36 (4): 387–9.
78.
SchepkerDonald J.OhWon-YongMartynovAlekseyPoppoLaura. 2014. “The Many Futures of Contracts: Moving Beyond Structure and Safeguarding to Coordination and Adaptation.” Journal of Management40 (1): 193–225. 10.1177/0149206313491289.
79.
Van SlykeDavid M.2003. “The Mythology of Privatization in Contracting for Social Services.” Public Administration Review63 (3): 296–315. https://doi.org/10.1111/1540-6210.00291.
80.
Vincent-JonesPeter. 2000. “Contractual Governance: Institutional and Organizational Analysis.” Oxford Journal of Legal Studies20 (3): 317–51. 10.1093/ojls/20.3.317.
81.
Vincent-JonesPeter. 2007. “The New Public Contracting: Public Versus Private Ordering?” Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies14 (2): 259–78.
82.
ViningAdrian R.BoardmanAnthony E.. 1992. “Ownership Versus Competition: Efficiency in Public Enterprise.” Public Choice73 (2): 205–39. 10.1007/BF00145092.
83.
ViningAdrian R.WeimerDavid L.. 2007. “Economic Perspectives on Public Organizations.” In The Oxford Handbook of Public Management, edited by FerlieEwanLynnLaurence E.Jr.PollittChristopher, 209–33. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
84.
VrangbækKarstenPetersenOle HelbyHjelmarUlf. 2015. “Is Contracting out Good or bad for Employees? A Systematic Review of International Experience.” Review of Public Personnel Administration35 (1): 3–23. 10.1177/0734371X13511087.
85.
WalkerBruceDavisHoward. 1999. “Perspectives on Contractual Relationships and the Move to Best Value in Local Authorities.” Local Government Studies25 (2): 16–37. 10.1080/03003939908433945.
86.
WalshKieron. 1995. Public Services and Market Mechanisms, Competition, Contracting and the New Public Management. Basingstoke: Macmillan Press Ltd.
87.
WarnerMildred E. 2006. “Market-based Governance and the Challenge for Rural Governments: US Trends.” Social Policy & Administration40 (6): 612–31. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9515.2006.00523.x.
88.
WarnerMildred E.AldagAustin M.. 2019. “Re-municipalization in the US: A Pragmatic Response to Contracting.” Journal of Economic Policy Reform, Online first, 1–14. 10.1080/17487870.2019.1646133.
89.
WarnerMildred E.HefetzAmir. 2002. “Applying Market Solutions to Public Services: An Assessment of Efficiency, Equity, and Voice.” Urban Affairs Review38 (1): 70–89. 10.1177/107808702401097808.
90.
WilliamsonOliver E. 1979. “Transaction-Cost Economics: The Governance of Contractual Relations.” Journal of Law and Economics22 (2): 233–61. 10.1086/466942.
91.
WilliamsonOliver E. 2000. “The New Institutional Economics: Taking Stock, Looking Ahead.” Journal of Economic Literature38 (3): 595–613. 10.1257/jel.38.3.595.
92.
WollmannHellmutKoprićIvanMarcouGérard (editors). 2016. Public and Social Services in Europe. From Public and Municipal to Private Sector Provision, 1–342. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
93.
WollmannHellmutMarcouGérard (editors). 2010. The Provision of Public Services in Europe Between State, Local Government and Market, 1–288. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
