It is often alleged that households moving into neighborhoods with the aid of housing choice vouchers (HCVs) raise crime rates there. We use 1999–2008 quarterly data from Chicago census tracts to test this allegation with a dynamic panel model designed to overcome the challenges of omitted variable and endogeneity biases. We find no support for the proposition that growth in HCV holders leads to growth in violent crime rates, regardless of neighborhood context. We find that growth in HCV holders is positively associated with growth in property crime rates, however, in higher poverty neighborhoods or if HCVs exceed a threshold concentration.
AndersonTheodoreHsiaoCheng. 1981. “Estimation of Dynamic Models with Error Components.” Journal of the American Statistical Association76:598–606.
2.
ArellanoManuelBondStephen. 1991. “Some Tests of Specification for Panel Data: Monte Carlo Evidence and an Application to Employment Equations.” The Review of Economic Studies58:277–97.
3.
BeldenNancyShashatyAndreZippererJohn. 2004. “What We Know About Public Attitudes on Affordable Housing: A Review of Existing Public Opinion Research.” In NeighborWorks Symposium on Multifamily Excellence: The Campaign for Affordable Housing. Available at http://www.neighborworks.org/Documents
BriggsXavierPopkinSusanGoeringJohn. 2010. Moving to Opportunity: The Story of an American Experiment to Fight Ghetto Poverty. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press.
6.
BuckAndrewHakimSimon. 1989. “Does Crime Affect Property Values?” Canadian Appraiser33:23–27.
7.
BuronLarryPopkinSusanLevyDianeHarrisLauraKhadduriJill. 2002. The HOPE VI Resident Tracking Study: A Snapshot of the Current Living Situation of Original Residents from Eight Sites. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.
8.
CahillMeagan. 2011. “Using the Weighted Displacement Quotient to Explore Crime Displacement from Public Housing Redevelopment Sites.” Cityscape13:103–34.
9.
CahillMeaganLowrySamanthaDowneyP. Mitchell. 2010. Movin’ Out: Crime Displacement and HUD’s HOPE VI Initiative. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.
10.
CecattoVaniaWilhelmssonMats. 2011. “The Impact of Crime on Apartment Prices: Evidence from Stockholm, Sweden.” Geografiska Annaler: Series B, Human Geography93:81–103.
11.
DavisMorrisLehnertAndreasMartinRobert. 2008. “The Rent-Price Ratio for the Aggregate Stock of Owner-Occupied Housing.” Review of Income and Wealth54:279–84.
12.
Dawsey PrattChastityLawrenceEric. 2012. “Volunteers Needed: Help Board Up Vacant Houses to Protect Kids.” Detroit Free Press, September30, 4A.
EllenIngridLensMchaelO’ReganKathy. 2012. “American Murder Mystery Revisited: Do Housing Voucher Households Cause Crime?” Housing Policy Debate22:551–72.
15.
FreyWilliam. 1979. “Central City White Flight: Racial and Nonracial Causes.” American Sociological Review44:425–48.
16.
GalsterGeorge. 2002. “An Economic Efficiency Analysis of Deconcentrting Poverty Populations. ” Journal of Housing Economics11:303–29.
17.
GalsterGeorge. 2008. “Scholarship on U.S Housing Planning and Policy: The Evolving Topography since 1968.” Journal of the American Planning Association74:1–12.
18.
GalsterGeorge. 2013. “U.S. Assisted Housing Programs and Poverty Deconcentration: A Critical Geographic Review.” In Neighbourhood Effects or Neighbourhood Based Problems? edited by ManleyD.HamM. vanBaileyN.SimpsonL.MaclennanD., 215–49. Dordrecht: Springer-Verlag.
GalsterGeorgeCutsingerJackieMalegaRon. 2008. “The Costs of Concentrated Poverty: Neighborhood Property Markets and the Dynamics of Decline.” In Revisiting Rental Housing: Policies, Programs, and Priorities, edited by RetsinasN.BelskyE., 93–113. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
21.
GalsterGeorgeTatianPeterSantiagoAnnaPettitKathrynSmithRobin. 2003. Why NOT in My Backyard? Neighborhood Impacts of Deconcentrating Assisted Housing. New Brunswick: Center for Urban Policy Research, Transaction Press, Rutgers Univ.
22.
GalsterGeorgeTatianPeterSmithRobin. 1999. “The Impact of Neighborhoods Who Use Section 8 Certificates on Property Values.” Housing Policy Debate10:879–917.
23.
GoeringJohn. 2003. “Political Origins and Opposition.” In Choosing a Better Life? Evaluating the Moving to Opportunity Social Experiment, edited by GoeringJ.FeinsJ., 37–58. Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press.
24.
HagedornJohnRauchBrigid. 2007. “Housing, Gangs, and Homicide: What We Can Learn from Chicago.” Urban Affairs Review42:435–56.
25.
HannonLance. 2002. “Criminal Opportunity Theory and the Relationship between Poverty and Property Crime.” Sociological Spectrum22:363–81.
26.
HannonLance. 2005. “Extremely Poor Neighborhoods and Homicide.” Social Science Quarterly86:1418–34.
27.
HaynieDanaSouthScott. 2005. “Residential Mobility and Adolescent Violence.” Social Forces84:361–74.
28.
HippJohn. 2010. “A Dynamic View of Neighborhoods: The Reciprocal Relationship Between Crime and Neighborhood Structural Characteristics.” Social Problems57:205–30.
29.
HippJohnTitaGeorgeGreenbaumRobert. 2009. “Drive-Bys and Trade-Ups: Examining the Directionality of the Crime and Residential Instability Relationship.” Social Forces87:1777–814.
30.
HippJohnYatesDaniel. 2009. “Do Returning Parolees Affect Neighborhood Crime? A Case Study of Sacramento.” Criminology47:619-655.
31.
HippJohnYatesDaniel. 2011. “Ghettos, Thresholds, and Crime: Does Concentrated Poverty Really Have an Accelerating Increasing Effect on Crime?” Criminology49:955–90.
32.
Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University. 2011. The State of the Nation’s Housing 2011. Cambridge, MA: Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard Univ.
33.
JonesRoderickPaulsenDerek. 2011. “HOPE VI Resident Displacement: Using HOPE VI Program Goals to Evaluate Neighborhood Outcomes.” Cityscape13:85–102.
34.
KatzBruceTurnerMargery. 2001. “Who Should Run the Housing Voucher Program? A Reform Proposal.” Housing Policy Debate12:239–62.
35.
KatzBruceTurnerMargery. 2008. “Rethinking U.S. Rental Housing Policy: A New Blueprint for Federal, State, and Local Action.” In Revisiting Rental Housing: Policies, Programs, and Priorities, edited by RestinasN.BelskyE., 319–58. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
36.
KeelsMicereDuncanGreg J.DelucaStefanieMendenhallRubyRosenbaumJames. 2005. “Fifteen Years Later: Can Residential Mobility Programs Provide a Permanent Escape from Neighborhood Crime and Poverty?” Demography42:51–73.
37.
KleinhansReinoutVaradyDavid. 2011. “Moving Out and Going Down? A Review of Recent Evidence on Negative Spillover Effects of Housing Restructuring Programs in the USA and the Netherlands.” International Journal of Housing Policy11:155–74.
38.
KrivoLaurenPetersonRuth. 1996. “Extremely Disadvantaged Neighborhoods and Urban Crime.” Social Forces75:619–48.
39.
LimUpGalsterGeorge. 2009. “The Dynamics of Neighborhood Property Crime Rates.” Annals of Regional Science43:925–45.
40.
LivingstonMarkGalsterGeorgeKearnsAdeBannisterJon. 2014. “Criminal Neighbourhoods: Does the Density of Prior Offenders in an Area Encourage Others to Commit Crime?” Environment and Planning A46:2469–88.
41.
MastBrentWilsonRon. 2012. “Housing Vouchers and Crime in Charlotte.” Policy Development and Research Working paper, U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Washington, DC.
42.
McClureKirk. 2008. “Deconcentrating Poverty with Housing Programs.” Journal of the American Planning Association74:90–99.
NewmanSandraSchnareAnne. 1997. “‘And a Suitable Living Environment’: The Failure of Housing Programs to Deliver on Neighborhood Quality.” Housing Policy Debate8:703–41.
45.
OsgoodD. Wayne. 2000. “Poisson-Based Regression Analysis of Aggregate Crime Rates.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology16:21–43.
46.
PendallRolf. 2000. “Why Voucher Holder and Certificate Users Live in Distressed Neighborhoods.” Housing Policy Debate11:881–910.
47.
PopkinSusan. 2010. “A Glass Half Empty: Public Housing Families in Transition.” Housing Policy Debate20:42–62.
48.
PopkinSusanCunninghamMaryBurtMartha. 2005. “Public Housing Transformation and the Hard-to-House.” Housing Policy Debate16:1–24.
49.
PopkinSusanGwiasdaVictoriaOlsonLynn M.RosenbaumDennisBuronLarry. 2000. The Hidden War: Crime and the Tragedy of Public Housing in Chicago. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers Univ. Press.
50.
PopkinSusanRichMichaelHendeyLeahHayesChrisParillaJoeGalsterGeorge. 2012. “Public Housing Transformation and Crime: Making the Case for Responsible Relocation.” Cityscape14:137–60.
51.
RaleighEricaGalsterGeorge. 2014. “Neighborhood Disinvestment, Abandonment, and Crime Dynamics.” Journal of Urban Affairs. Published electronically March19. doi:10.1111/juaf.12102.
52.
RaphaelStephenStollMichael. 2011. “Neighborhoods, Social Interactions, and Crime: What Does Evidence Show?” In Neighborhood and Life Chances: How Place Matters in Modern America, edited by NewburgerH.BirchE.WachterS., 73–88. Philadelphia: Univ. of Pennsylvania Press.
SampsonRobertRaudenbushStephenEarlsFelton. 1997. “Neighborhoods and Violent Crime: A Multilevel Study of Collective Efficacy.” Science277:918–24.
55.
SardBarbaraRiceDouglas. 2014. Creating Opportunity for Children: How Housing Location Can Make a Difference. Washington, DC: Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.
56.
SchwartzAmySusinScottVoicuIoan. 2003. “Has Falling Crime Driven New York City’s Real Estate Boom?” Journal of Housing Research14:1–35.
57.
SharkeyPatrickSampsonRobert. 2010. “Destination Effects: Residential Mobility and Trajectories of Adolescent Violence in a Stratified Metropolis.” Criminology48:639–81.
58.
SkoganWesley. 2007. “Reflections on Declining Crime in Chicago.” Working paper, Department of Sociology, Northwestern Univ., Evanston, IL.
59.
SureshGeethaVitoGennaro. 2009. “Homicide Patterns and Public Housing: The Case of Louisville, KY (1980-2007).” Homicide Studies13:411–33.
60.
ThalerRichard. 1978. “A Note on the Value of Crime Control: Evidence from the Property Market.” Journal of Urban Economics5:137–45.
61.
TigheRosie. 2010. “Public Opinion and Affordable Housing: A Review of the Literature.” Journal of Planning Literature25:3–17.
62.
TitaGeorgePetrasTriciaGreenbaumRobert. 2006. “Crime and Residential Choice: A Neighborhood Level Analysis of the Impact of Crime on Housing Prices.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology22:299–317.
63.
TurbovMindyPiperValerie. 2005. HOPE VI and Fixed Finance Redevelopments: A Catalyst for Neighborhood Renewal. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution.
64.
TurnerMargery. 1998. “Moving Out of Poverty: Expanding Mobility and Choice through Tenant-Based Housing Assistance.” Housing Policy Debate9:373–94.
65.
Van ZandtShannonMhatrePratik. 2009. “The Effect of Housing Choice Voucher Households on Neighborhood Crime: Longitudinal Evidence from Dallas.” Working Paper 09-01, Sustainable Housing Research Unit (SHRU), College of Architecture, Texas A&M Univ., College Station.
66.
VenkateshSudhirCelimliIsilMillerDouglasMurphyAlexandra. 2004. Chicago Public Housing Transformation: A Research Report. New York: Center for Urban Research and Policy, Columbia Univ.
67.
WilsonWilliam J.1987. The Truly Disadvantaged: The Inner City, the Underclass, and Public Policy. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
