Focusing on the Robyn Kina case, an Aboriginal Australian woman sentenced to life imprisonment for murdering her violent and abusive de facto partner, this analysis explores issues surrounding the use of battered woman syndrome as a defense to murder and the problematics of predominantly White lawyers' interface with Aboriginal clients and, in particular, with abused women. Central to this analysis is the gendering of the law on provocation and self-defense based on male standards of proportionality, immediacy, and reasonableness that deny the reality of women's experience of domestic violence and the debilitating effects of psychological and emotional power and control wielded in abusive relationships. Sociolingusitic research shows that a familiarity with Aboriginal English and the cultural norms of Aboriginal communities, in particular women's reticence to speak of private sexual matters, is necessary to have a foundation for communication between Aboriginal clients and the legal system.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Atkinson, J. (1990). Violence against Aboriginal women: Reconstitution of community law—The way forward. Aboriginal Law Bulletin, 46, 6-10.
2.
Australian Broadcasting Commission . (1993). Without consent (Four Corners program). Sydney, Australia: Author.
3.
Australian Law Reform Commission . (1994a). Equality before the law: Women's access to the legal system (Interim Report No. 67). Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service.
4.
Australian Law Reform Commission . (1994b). Equality before the law (Final Report No. 69). Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service.
5.
Bacon, W. , & Lansdowne, R. (1992). Women who kill husbands: The battered woman on trial. In C. O'Donnell & J. Craney (Eds.), Family violence in Australia (pp. 67-94). Melbourne, Australia: Longman Cheshire.
6.
Bolger, A. (1991). Aboriginal women and violence: A report for the Criminology Research Council and the Northern Territory Commission of Police. Darwin: Australian National University, North Australia Research Unit.
7.
Coughlin, A. M. (1994). Excusing women. California Law Review, 82, 1-93.
8.
Crocker, P. L. (1985). The meaning of equality for battered women who kill men in self-defense. Harvard Women's Law Journal, 8, 121-137.
9.
Eades, D. (1992). Aboriginal English and the law. Queensland, Australia: Queensland Law Society.
10.
Easteal, P. (1992). Battered woman syndrome: What is reasonable?Alternative Law Journal, 17, 220-224.
11.
Easteal, P. (1996, February 2). Life matters (national radio program hosted by Geraldine Doogue). Sydney: Australian Broadcasting Commission.
12.
Freckelton, I. (1992). Battered woman syndrome. Alternative Law Journal, 1739-41.
13.
Friere, P. (1970). Pedagogy of the oppressed. New York: Herder & Herder.
14.
Gadd, G. (1995). Unreported, Supreme Court of Queensland, March 27-30.
15.
Greer, P. (1994). Aboriginal women and domestic violence in New South Wales. In J. Stubbs (Ed.), Women, male violence and the law (pp. 64-78). Sydney, Australia: Institute of Criminology.
16.
Hatty, S. (1989). Policing and male violence in Australia. In J. Hammer, J. Radford, & E. Stanko (Eds.), Women, policing and male violence: International perspectives (pp. 70-89). London: Routledge.
17.
Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission . (1991). Report of the National Inquiry Into Racist Violence in Australia. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service.
18.
Kina, R. (1993). Unreported. Court of Criminal Appeal of Queensland, November 29.
19.
Kontinnen. (1992). Unreported. South Australia Supreme Court, March 30.
20.
Lavallee. (1990). 55 Canadian Criminal Cases, (3d) 97.
21.
Law Reform Commission of Victoria . (1991). Homicide (Report No. 40). Melbourne, Australia: Author.
22.
Leader-Elliott, I. (1993). Battered but not beaten: Women who kill in self-defense. Sydney Law Review, 15, 403-460.
23.
Mahoney, M. R. (1991). Legal images of battered women: Redefining the issue of separation. Michigan Law Review, 90, 38-43.
24.
New South Wales Law Reform Commission . (1993). Provocation, diminished responsibility and infanticide (Discussion Paper No. 31). Sydney, Australia: Author.
25.
Randall, M. (1995). Domestic violence. Alternative Law Journal/Aboriginal Law Bulletin, 3, 3-6.
26.
Rice, S. (1994). Legal aid: A domestic diagnosis. Alternative Law Journal, 19, 276-280.
27.
Robson, F. (1994, March 26). Finally justice. The Age Good Weekend, pp. 38-45.
28.
Royal Commission Into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody . (1991). National Report (Vol. 2). Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service.
29.
Runjanjic and Kontinnen. (1991). 53 Australian Criminal Reports, at 362.
30.
Scutt, J. A. (1990). Women and the law: Commentary and materials. Sydney, Australia: Law Book Company.
31.
Seddon, N. (1993). Domestic violence in Australia: The legal response. Sydney, Australia: Federation Press.
32.
Seuffert, N. (1994). Lawyering and domestic violence: A feminist integration of experiences, theories and practices. In J. Stubbs (Ed.), Women, male violence and the law (pp. 79-103). Sydney, Australia: Institute of Criminology.
33.
Sheehy, E. (1994). Developments in Canadian law after R v. Lavallee. In J. Stubbs (Ed.), Women, male violence and the law (pp. 174-191). Sydney, Australia: Institute of Criminology.
34.
Sheehy, E. , Stubbs, J., & Tolmie, J. (1992). Defending battered women on trial: The battered woman syndrome and its limitations. Criminal Law Journal, 6, 369-394.
35.
Stubbs, J. , & Tolmie, J. (1994). Battered women syndrome in Australia: A challenge to gender bias in the law? In J. Stubbs (Ed.), Women, male violence and the law (pp. 192-225). Sydney, Australia: Institute of Criminology.
36.
Tarrant, S. (1990). Provocation and self-defense: A feminist perspective. Legal Services Bulletin, 15, 47-150.
37.
Walker, L.E.A. (1992). Battered woman syndrome and self-defense. Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics and Public Policy, 6, 318-332.
38.
Zecevic. (1987). 71 Australian Law Reports 641, 162, Commonwealth Law Reports 645.
