Over the past several decades the social sciences have experienced an expansion of historical research. Much of this historical work is linked to the new social history that has significant materialist roots in cultural Marxism and the Annales school. In the past several years this epistemology has been challenged by members of the linguistic turn who draw on poststructuralism and deconstructionism. They seek to debunk what they see as the metanarratives of this materialist ontology, and produced an alternative historiography center on the analysis of discourse. The author argues that the linguistic turn raises important issues, but many of its practitioners hypostatize discourse and create an alternative essentialism. To explicate these problems the study uses as an exemplar the recent work of historian Patrick Joyce. The author alternatively proposes a discourse analysis drawing on Bakhtinian literary theory, which focuses on the social construction of meaning through language. This alternative recognizes the material and social foundations of meaning construction and retains a conception of agency while bringing discourse into historical explanation.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abrams, P. (1982). Historical sociologyIthaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
2.
Baker, K.M. (1992). Defining the public sphere in eighteenth-century France: Variations on a theme by Habermas In C. J. Calhoun (Ed.), Habermas and the public sphere (pp. 181-211). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
3.
Bakhtin, M.M. (1981). The dialogic imagination: Four essays (M. Holquist, Ed.; C. Emerson & M. Holquist, Trans.). Austin : University of Texas Press.
4.
Bakhtin, M.M. (1984). Problems of Dostoevsky's poetics (C. Emerson, Ed. and Trans.). Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
5.
Bakhtin, M.M. (1986). Speech genres and other late essays (C. Emerson & M. Holquist, Eds.; V W. McGee, Trans.). Austin: University of Texas Press.
6.
Bakhtin, M.M. (1993). Toward a philosophy of the act (V. Liapunov & M. Holquist, Eds.; V Liapunov, Trans.). Austin: University of Texas Press.
7.
Baron, A. (1991). Gender and labor history In A. Baron (Ed.), Work engendered: Toward a new American labor history (pp. 1-46). Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
8.
Bernard-Donals, M.F. (1994). Mikhail Bakhtin: Between phenomenology and Marxism .
9.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Brandist, C. (1996a). Gramsci, Bakhtin and the semiotics of hegemony. New Left Review 216, 94-109.
10.
Brandist, C. (1996b). The official and the popular in Gramsci and BakhtinTheory, Culture & Society, 13, 59-74.
11.
Briggs, C.L., & Baumann, R. (1992). Genre, intertextuality, and social powerJournal of Linguistic Anthropology, 2,131-172.
12.
Cadieux, R.D. (1996). Dialectics and the economy of différanceDialectical Anthropology, 20,319-340.
13.
Calhoun, C.J. (1992). Culture, history and the problem of specificity in social theory In S. Seidman & D. G. Wagner (Eds.), Postmodernism and social theory: The debate over general theory (pp. 244-288). Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
14.
Caplan, J. (1989). Postmodernism, poststructuralism, and deconstruction: Notes for historiansCentral European History , 22, 260-278.
15.
Carroll, D. (1983). The alterity of discourse: Form, history and the question of the political in M. M. Bakhtin. Diacritics, 9, 65-83.
16.
Chartier, R. (1988). Cultural history: Between practices and representationsIthaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
17.
Childers, T. (1989). Political sociology and the "linguistic turn."Central European History, 22, 381-393.
18.
Clark, K., & Holquist, M. (1984). Mikhail Bakhtin. Cambridge : Harvard University Press.
19.
Dean, M. (1994). Critical and effective histories: Foucault's methods and historical sociologyLondon: Routledge.
20.
Denzin, N.K. (1994). Postmodernism and deconstructionism. In D. R. Dickens & A. Fontana (Eds.), Postmodernism and social inquiry (pp. 182-201). New York: Guilford .
21.
Derrida, J. (1989). Like the sound of the sea deep within a shell: Paul de Man's war In W. Hamamcher, N. Hertz, & T. Keenan (Eds.), Responses on Paul de Man's wartime journalism (pp. 127-164). Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.
22.
Diaz-Diocaretz, M. (1989). Bakhtin, discourse, and feminist theoriesCritical Studies: A Journal of Critical Theory, Literature and Culture , 1, 121-139.
23.
Downs, L. (1993). If "woman" is just an empty category, then why am I afraid to walk alone at night? Identity politics and the postmodern subjectComparative Studies in Society and History , 35, 414-438.
24.
Eagleton, T. (1981). Against the grainLondon: Verso.
25.
Eagleton, T. (1983). Literary theory: An introductionMinneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
26.
Eagleton, T. (1987). The politics of subjectivity In H. Bhabha (Ed.), Identity: The real me (pp. 47-48). London : Institute for Contemporary Arts.
27.
Eagleton, T. (1990). The ideology of the aestheticOxford: Basil Blackwell.
28.
Evans, F. (1990). Language and political agency: Derrida, Marx, and BakhtinThe Southern Journal of Philosophy , 27, 505-523.
29.
Flaherty, P. (1986). Reading carnival: Towards a semiotics of historyClio, 15, 411-428.
30.
Gardiner, M. (1992)The dialogics of critique: M. M. Bakhtin and the theory of ideologyLondon: Routledge .
31.
Hall, J.R. (1979). Alfred Schutz, his critics, and applied phenomenologyCultural Hermeneutics, 4, 265-279.
32.
Hall, J.R. (1981). Max Weber's methodological strategy and comparative lifeword phenomenologyHuman Studies , 4,131-143.
33.
Hall, J.R. (1990). Epistemology and sociohistorical inquiryAnnual Review of Sociology, 16, 329-351.
34.
Hall, J.R. (1992). Where history and sociology meet: Forms of discourse and sociohistorical inquirySociological Theory , 10, 164-193.
35.
Hall, J.R. (1996). Between postmodernism and political economy: Is there a middle kingdom?Newsletter of the Comparative and Historical Section of the American Sociological Association , 8(1), 4-5.
36.
Hall, S. (1993). For Allon White: Metaphors of transformation In A. White (Ed.), Hysteria and writing: Collected essays and autobiography (pp. 1-25). Oxford: Clarendon.
37.
Halley, J.A. (1989). Bakhtin and the sociology of culture: Polyphony in the interaction of object and audienceCritical Studies, 1, 163-179.
38.
Herndl, D. (1991). The dilemmas of a feminist dialogic In D. M. Bauer & S. J. McKinstry (Eds.), Feminism, Bakhtin and dialogism (pp. 7-24). Albany, NY: SUNY Press.
39.
Hirschkop, K. (1986). Bakhtin, discourse and democracyNew Left Review, 160, 91-111.
40.
Hitchcock, P. (1994). The dialogics of the oppressedMinneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
41.
Hobson, M. (1987). History traces In D. Attridge, G. Bennington, & R. Young (Eds.), Post-structuralism and the question of history (pp. 101-115). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
42.
Hohne, K., & Wussow, H. (1994). Introduction In K. Hohne & H. Wussow (Eds.), A dialogue of voices: Feminist literary theory and Bakhtin (pp. vii-xxiii). Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
43.
Holquist, M. (1981). The politics of representation. In S. J. Greenblatt (Ed.), Allegory and representation (pp. 163-183). Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press .
44.
Holquist, M. (1986). The surd heard: Bakhtin and Derrida In G. S. Morson (Ed.), Literature and history: Theoretical problems and Russian case studies (pp. 137-156). Stanford, CA : Stanford University Press.
45.
Holquist, M. (1990). Dialogism: Bakhtin and his worldLondon: Routledge.
46.
Holquist, M. (1993). Foreword In M. M. Bakhtin Toward a philosophy of the act (pp. vii-xx). Austin: University of Texas Press.
47.
Hunt, L. (Ed.). (1989). The new cultural history.Berkeley: University of California Press .
48.
Hunt, L. (1991). History as gesture; or the scandal of history In J. Arac & B. Johnson (Eds.), Consequences of theory (pp. 91-107). Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
49.
Johnson, C.H. (1993). Lifeworld, system, and communicative action, the Habermasian alternative in social history In L. R. Berlanstein (Ed.), Rethinking labor history: Essays on discourse and class analysis (pp. 55-89). Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
50.
Joyce, P. (1991). Visions of the people: Industrial England and the question of class, 1840-1914Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
51.
Joyce, P. (1992). A people and a class: Industrial workers and the social order in nineteenth-century England In M. L. Bush (Ed.), Social orders and social classes in Europe since 1500: Studies m social stratification (pp. 199-217). London: Longman .
52.
Joyce, P. (1993). The imaginary discontents of social history: A note of response to Mayfield and Thorne, Lawrence and TaylorSocial History, 18, 81-85.
53.
Joyce, P. (1994). Democratic subjects: The self and the social in nineteenth-century EnglandCambridge: Cambridge University Press.
54.
Joyce, P. (1995). The end of social historySocial History, 20, 73-91.
55.
Kazin, M. (1988). A people not a class: Rethinking the political language of the modem U.S. labor movement In M. Davis & M. Sprinker (Eds.), Reshaping the U.S. Left: Popular struggles in the 1980s (pp. 257-286). London: Verso.
56.
Kirk, N. (1994). History, language, ideas and post-modernism: A materialist viewSocial History, 19, 221-240
57.
. Kramer, L. (1992)Habermas, history and critical theory In C. J. Calhoun (Ed.), Habermas and the public sphere (pp. 236-258). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
58.
LaCapra, D. (1983). Rethinking intellectual history: Texts, contexts, languageIthaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
59.
LaCapra, D. (1985). History and criticismIthaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
60.
LaCapra, D. (1995). History, language, and reading: Waiting for CrillonAmerican Historical Review, 100, 799-828.
61.
Laclau, E., & Mouffe, C. (1982). Recasting Marxism: Hegemony and new political movementsSocialist Review, 12, 91-113.
62.
Laclau, E., & Mouffe, C. (1985). Hegemony and socialist strategy: Toward a radical democratic politicsLondon: Verso .
63.
Liapunov, V. (1993). Translator's preface In M. M. Bakhtin, Toward a philosophy of the act (pp. xvii-xix). Austin: University of Texas Press.
64.
Lloyd, C. (1993). The structures of historyOxford: Blackwell.
65.
Mayfield, D., & Thorne, S. (1992). Social history and its discontents: Gareth Stedman Jones and the politics of languageSocial History , 17, 165-188.
66.
McDonald, T. (Ed.). (in press). The historic turn in the human sciences.Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
67.
Medvedev, P.N., & Bakhtin, M.M. (1978). The formal method m literary scholarship: A critical introduction to sociological poetics (Albert J. Wehrle, Trans.). Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
68.
Noiriel, G. (1994). Foucault and history: The lessons of a disillusionJournal of Modern History, 66, 547-568.
69.
Palmer, B.D. (1990a). Descent into discourse: The reification of language and the writing of social historyPhiladelphia: Temple University Press.
70.
Palmer, B.D. (1990b). The eclipse of materialism: Marxism and the writing of social history in the 1980s In R. Miliband, L. Panitch, & J. Saville (Eds.), The socialist register 1990 (pp. 111-146). London: Merlin.
71.
Palmer, B.D. (1993). Critical theory, historical materialism, and the ostensible end of Marxism: The poverty of theory revisitedInternational Review of Social History, 38, 133-162.
72.
Polkinghorne, D. (1988). Narrative knowing and the human sciencesAlbany, NY: SUNY Press.
73.
Reid, D. (1993). Reflections on labor history and language In L. R. Berlanstein (Ed.), Rethinking labor history: Essays on discourse and class analysis (pp. 39-54). Champaign: University of Illinois Press.
74.
Ricouer, P. (1976). Interpretation theory: Discourse and the surplus of meaningFort Worth, TX: Texas Christian University.
75.
Rose, S. (1992). Limited livelihoods: Gender and class in nineteenth-century England.
76.
Berkeley: University of California Press.
77.
Rose, S. (1993). Gender and labour history: The nineteenth-century legacyInternational Review of Social History , 38,145-162.
78.
Roseneau, P. (1994). Revitalizing sociology: Post-modem perspectives on methodology.
79.
Current Perspectives in Social Theory, 14, 89-99.
80.
Rutland, B. (1990). Bakhtinian categories and the discourse of postmodernismCritical Studies, 2,123-136.
81.
Samuel, R. (1991). Reading the signsHistory Workshop, 32, 88-109.
82.
Samuel, R. (1992). Reading the signs: II. Fact-grubbers and mind-readersHistory Workshop, 33, 220-251.
83.
Schutz, A., & Luckmann, T. (1973). The structures of the life-worldEvanston, IL: North-western University Press.
84.
Scott, J.W. (1988). Gender and the politics of historyNew York: Columbia University Press.
85.
Scott, J.W. (1991). The evidence of experienceCritical Inquiry, 17, 773-797.
86.
Seidman, S. (1991). The end of sociological theory: The postmodern hopeSociological Theory, 9, 131-146.
87.
Sewell, W. (1993). Toward a post-materialist rhetoric for labor history In L. R. Berlanstein (Ed.), Rethinking labor history: Essays on discourse and class analysis (pp. 15-38). Champaign : University of Illinois Press.
88.
Skocpol, T. (Ed.). (1984). Vision and method in historical sociology.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
89.
Smart, B. (1992). Modern conditions, postmodern controversiesLondon: Routledge.
90.
Smith, D. (1991). The rise of historical sociologyPhiladelphia: Temple University Press.
91.
Somers, M. (1992). Narrativity, narrative identity, and social action: Rethinking English working-class formationSocial Science History, 16, 591-630
92.
. Somers, M. (1994). The narrative constitution of identity: A relational and network approachTheory and Society , 23, 605-649.
93.
Somers, M., & Gibson, G. (1994). Reclaiming the epistemological "other": Narrative and the social construction of identity In C. J. Calhoun (Ed.), Social theory and the politics of identity (pp. 37-99). Oxford : Blackwell.
94.
Spiegel, G.M. (1990). History, historicism, and the social logic of the text in the middle agesSpeculum , 65,59-86.
95.
Steinberg, M.W. (1994). The dialogue of struggle: The contest over ideological boundaries in the case of London silk weavers in the early nineteenth centurySocial Science History, 18, 505-541
96.
. Steinberg, M.W. (1995). The roar of the crowd: Repertoires of discourse and collective action among Spitalfields silk weavers in nineteenth-century London In M. Traugott (Ed.), Repertoires and cycles of collective action (pp. 57-87). Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
97.
Steinberg, M.W. (1996). "The labour of the country is the wealth of the country": Class identity, consciousness, and the role of discourse in the making of the English working classInternational Labor and Working-Class History, 49,1-25.
98.
Stinchcombe, A. (1978). Theoretical methods in social historyNew York: Academic Press.
99.
Stone, L. (1991). History and post-modernismPast and Present, 131, 217-218.
100.
Stone, L. (1992). History and post-modernism IIIPast and Present, 135, 189-194.
101.
Thomson, C. (1989). Mikhail Bakhtin and contemporary Anglo-American feminist theoryCritical Studies, 1, 141-161.
102.
Tilly, C. (1981). As sociology meets history. New York: Academic Press.
103.
Tilly, C. (1984). Big structures, large processes, huge comparisonsNew York: Russell Sage.
104.
Tilly, C. (1994). Softcore solipsismLabour/Le Travail, 34, 259-268.
105.
Todorov, T. (1984). Mikhail Bakhtin: The dialogic principleMinneapolis: University of Minnesota Press .
106.
Toews, J. (1987). Intellectual history after the linguistic turnAmerican Historical Review, 92, 879-907.
107.
Turner, B. (1992). Max Weber: From modernity to historyLondon: Routledge.
108.
Vernon, J. (1994). Who's afraid of the linguistic turn? The politics of social history and its discontentsSocial History , 19, 81-87.
109.
Volosinov, V.N. (1983). Literary stylistics In A. Shukman (Ed.), Bakhtin school papers (pp. 93-152). Oxford : RPT.
110.
Volosinov, V.N. (1986). Marxism and the philosophy of languageCambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
111.
White, A. (1993). Hysteria and writing: Collected essays and autobiographyOxford: Clarendon.
112.
White, H. (1987). The content of form: Narrative discourse and historical representationBaltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
113.
Wood, E.M. (1986)The retreat from class: A new "true" socialismNew York: Verso.
114.
Wordsworth, A. (1987). Derrida and Foucault: Writing the history of historicity In D. Attridge, G. Bennington, & R. Young (Eds.), Post-structuralism and the question of history (pp. 116-125). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
115.
Zammito, J.H. (1993). Are we being theoretical yet? The new historicism, the new philosophy of history and practicing historiansJournal of Modern History, 65 , 783-814.
116.
Zavala, I. (1989). Bakhtin and the third: Communication as responseCritical Studies, 1, 43-63.
