Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 1995-06
What the Controversies Over the Health Effects of Exposure to Environmental Tobacco Smoke Tell Us About the Debates Between Objectivists and Social Constructionists
Some social analyses of scientific knowledge are based on objectivist assumptions, whereas others assume that scientific knowledge is socially constructed. The condemna tion of environmental tobacco smoke (ETS) by the antismoking movement affects the life of virtually every American and uncounted millions of others throughout the world. Investigators who argue that ETS causes lung cancer claim the influence, objectivity, and authority of scientific mquiry, whereas critics of the results of the investigations argue that the conclusion that ETS causes lung cancer is unwarranted. The present study uses this fascinating and important sociotechnical controversy to shed light on the debate between objectivists and social constructionists and reaches the conclusion that the condemnation of ETS is a deliberate social construction of an elite social movement that mixes advocacy with alleged objective inquiry. The tobacco industry has moved the dispute into the federal courts, and so the "truth" of the matter will be decided ultimately not by technical debate but by judicial rulings and political processes.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Buffler, P.A., Pickle, L.W., Mason, T.J., & Constant, C. (1984). The causes of lung cancer In M. Mizell & P. Correa (Eds.), Lung cancer: Causes and prevention (pp. 83-99). Deerfield, FL: Chemie International.
2.
Chan, W.C., & Fung, S.C. (1982). Lung cancer in non-smokers in Hong Kong In E. Grundmann, J. Clemmesen, & C. S. Muir (Eds.), Geographical pathology in cancer epidemiology (pp.199-202). New York: Verlag.
3.
Cole, S. (1992). Making science: Between nature and societyCambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
4.
Collins, H.M. (1985). Changing order: Replication and induction in scientific orderLondon: Sage.
5.
Correa, P., Pickle, L.W., Fontham, E., Lin, Y., Haenszel, W. (1983). Passive smoking and lung cancerThe Lancet, (2), 595-597.
6.
Daynard, R.A. (1991). Tobacco policyJournal of Public Health Policy, 12, 34-36.
7.
Decline in smoking levels off and officials urge a tax rise ( 1993, April 2). New York Times.
8.
Ezrahi, Y. (1990). The descent of Icarus: Science and the transformation of contemporary democracyCambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
9.
Feinstein, A.R. (1992). Justice, science, and the "bad guys."Toxicologic Pathology, 20 , 303-305.
10.
Fielding, J.E., & Phenow, K.J. (1988). Health effects of involuntary smokingNew England Journal of Medicine, 319(22), 1452-1460.
11.
Fleiss, J.L., & Gross, A.J. (1991). Meta-analysis in epidemiology, with special reference to studies of the association between exposure to environmental tobacco smoke and lung cancer: A critiqueJournal of Clinical Epidemiology , 44(2), 127-139.
12.
Garfinkel, H. (1984). Studies in ethnomethodologyCambridge, England: Polity.
13.
Garfinkel, L. (1981). Time trends in lung cancer mortality among nonsmokers and a note on passive smokingJournal of the National Cancer Institute, 66, 1061-1066.
14.
Garfinkel, L., Auerbach, O., & Joubert, L. (1985). Involuntary smoking and lung cancer: A case-control studyJournal of the National Cancer Institute , 75, 463-469.
15.
Gergen, K.J. (1985). The social constructionist movement in modem psychologyAmerican Psychologist, 40, 266-275.
16.
Gillis, C.R., Hole, D.J., Hawthorne, V., & Boyle, P. (1984). The effect of environmental tobacco smoke in two urban communities in the West of ScotlandEuropean Journal of Respiratory Diseases, 65(133)(Suppl.), 121-126.
17.
Habermas, J. (1971). Knowledge and human interestsBoston: Beacon.
18.
Hirayama, T. (1981). Non-smoking wives of heavy smokers have a higher risk of lung cancer: A study from JapanBritish Medical Journal, 282(6259), 183-185.
19.
Hirayama, T. (1984). Cancer mortality in nonsmoking women with smoking husbands based on a large-scale cohort study in JapanPreventive Medicine, 13, 680-690.
20.
Ibarra, P., & Kitsuse, J. (1993). Vernacular constituents of moral discourse In J. Holstein & G. Miller (Eds.), Reconsidering social constructionism (pp. 25-58). New York: Aldine.
21.
Janerich, D.T., Thompson, W.D., Varela, L.R., Greenwald, P., Chorost, S., Tucci, C., Zaman, M.B., Malamed, M.R., Kiely, M., & McKneally, M.F. (1990). Lung cancer and exposure to tobacco smoke in the householdNew England Journal of Medicine, 323(10), 632-636.
22.
Jasanoff, S. (1987). Contested boundaries in policy-relevant studiesSocial Studies of Science, 17, 195-230.
23.
Kabat, G.C., & Wynder, E.L. (1984). Lung cancer in nonsmokersCancer, 53,1214-1221.
24.
Koo, L.C., Ho, J., Saw, D., & Ho, C.-Y. (1987). Measurements of passive smoking and estimates of lung cancer risk among non-smoking Chinese femalesInternational Journal of Cancer, 39,162-169.
25.
Latour, B., & Woolgar, S. (1979). Laboratory life: The construction of scientific factsPrinceton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
26.
Laudan, L. (1990). Science and relativism: Some key controversies in the philosophy of scienceChicago: University of Chicago Press.
27.
Layard, M.W. (1990). Environmental tobacco smoke and cancer: The epidemiologic evidence In D. J. Ecobichon & J. M. Wu (Eds.), Environmental tobacco smoke (pp. 99-115). Lexington, MA : Lexington Books.
28.
Lee, P.N., Chamberlin, J., & Alderson, M.R. (1986). Relationship of passive smoking to risk of lung cancer and other smoking-associated diseasesBritish Journal of Cancer, 54,97-105.
29.
Lieberman, B. (1964). i-trust: A notion of trust in three person games and international affairsJournal of Conflict Resolution , 8, 271-280.
30.
Lieberman, B. (1977). Deception and collective actionPhilosophica, 20(2), 65-84.
31.
Lieberman, B. (1988). Extrapremarital intercourse: Attitudes toward a neglected sexual behaviorJournal of Sex Research , 24, 291-299.
32.
Loehr, R., & Lippman, M. (1991). Letter to the administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency recommending that environmental tobacco smoke be classified as a group A carcinogenWashington, DC: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
33.
Mannheim, K. (1936). Ideology and utopiaNew York : Harcourt Brace.
34.
Markle, G.E., & Troyer, R.J. (1979). Smoke gets in your eyes: Cigarette smoking as deviant behaviorSocial Problems, 26, 611-625.
35.
McCarthy, J.D., & Zald, M.N. (1977). Resource mobilization and social movements: A partial theoryAmerican Journal of Sociology , 82, 1212-1214.
36.
Mervyn Susser to head Am. Journal of Public Health. (1991, December). Nation's Health, p. 12.
37.
Mitroff, I.I. (1974). The subjective side of science: A philosophical inquiry into the psychology of the Apollo moon scientistsNew York: Elsevier.
38.
Mukerji, C. (1989). A fragile power: Scientists and the statePrinceton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
39.
Mulkay, M. (1979). Science and the sociology of knowledgeLondon: Allen & Unwin.
40.
Mulkay, M. (1991). Sociology of science: A sociological pilgrimageBloomington: Indiana University Press.
41.
Nagada, N., Fortmann, R., Kootz, M., & Konheim, A. (1990). Investigation of cabin air quality aboard commercial airliners In "Indoor Air '90": Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate. Ottawa: International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate.
42.
National Cancer Institute. (1989). Media strategies for smoking control: Guidelines (Publication No. 89-3013). Bethesda, MD: National Institutes of Health.
43.
National Institute for Occupational Health and Safety. (1991). Environmental tobacco smoke in the workplace: Lung cancer and other health effectsWashington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
44.
National Resesarch Council. (1986). Environmental tobacco smoke: Measuring exposures and assessing health effectsWashington, DC: National Academy Press.
45.
Nuehring, E., & Markle, G.E. (1974). Nicotine and norms: The re-emergence of a deviant behaviorSocial Problems, 21, 513-526.
46.
OSHA accelerates ETS rulemaking, pressure on Clinton increases ( 1993, February). Indoor Air Review , p. 1.
47.
Pershagen, G., Hrubec, Z., & Svensson, C. (1987). Passive smoking and lung cancer in Swedish womenAmerican Journal of Epidemiology , 125, 17-23
48.
Pritchard, J.N., & Strong, J.C. (1990). The influence of environmental tobacco smoke on radon dosimetry In "Indoor Air '90": Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on Indoor Air Quality. Ottawa: International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate.
49.
Ravetz, J. (1971). Scientific knowledge and its social problemsLondon: Oxford University Press.
50.
Restivo, S. (1988). Modem science as a social problemSocial Problems, 35, 206-225.
51.
Schutz, A. (1982). The problem of social reality: Collected papers 1The Hague, Netherlands: Nijhoff .
52.
Scott, P., Richards, E., & Martin, B. (1990). The myth of the neutral social researcher in contemporary scientific controversiesScience Technology & Human Values, 15, 474-494.
53.
Six panelists on smoking are linked to tobacco (1990, November 10). New York Times.
54.
Smith, J.K., & Heshusius, L. (1986). Closing down the conversation: The end of the quantitative-qualitative debate among educational inquirersEducational Researcher, 15, 4-12.
55.
Standen, A. (1950). Science is a sacred cowNew York: Dutton.
56.
Transcript of the meeting of the Indoor Air Quality and Total Human Exposure Committee of the Science Advisory Board of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (1990). Prepared by Executive Court Reporters.
57.
Transcript of the meeting of the Indoor Air Quality and Total Human Exposure Committee of the Science Advisory Board of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (1992). Prepared by American Reporters.
58.
Trichopoulos, D., Kakandidi, A., Sparros, L., & McMahon, B. (1981). Lung cancer and passive smokingInternational Journal of Cancer, 27,1-4.
59.
Troyer, R.J. (1984). From prohibition to regulation: Comparing two antismoking movements In L. Kriesberg (Ed.), Research in social movements: Conflicts and change (pp. 53-69). Greenwich, CT: JAI.
60.
Troyer, R.J. (1989). The surprising resurgence of the smoking problem In J. Best (Ed.), Images of issues: Typifying contemporary social problems (pp. 159-176). New York: Aldine.
61.
Troyer, R.J., & Markle, G.E. (1983). Cigarettes: The battle over smokingNew Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
62.
U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare. (1964). Smoking and health: Report to the Surgeon General of the Public Health ServiceWashington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
63.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. ( 1986). The health consequences of involuntary smokingWashington, DC: Author.
64.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. ( 1991). Strategies to control tobacco use in the United States: A blueprint for public health action in the 1990'sRockville, MD: Author.
65.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (1987 ). The risk assessment guidelines of 1986Washington, DC: Author.
66.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (1990 ). Environmental tobacco smoke: A compendium of technical informationWashington, DC: Author.
67.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (1992 ). Respiratory health effects ofpassive smoking: Lung cancer and other disordersWashington, DC: Author.
68.
Varela, L.R. (1987). Assessment of the association between passive smoking and lung cancer. Ph.D. dissertation, Yale University, School of Medicine, Department of Epidemiology and Public Health.
69.
Wu, A.H., , B.E., Henderson, M.C., & PikeM.C., & Yu, (1985). Smoking and other risk factors for lung cancer in womenJournal of the National Cancer Institute , 74, 747-751.
70.
Wynder, E.L., & Kabat, G.C. (1990). Environmental tobacco and lung cancer: A critical assessment In Indoor Air Quality: Papers from the International Conference on Indoor Air Quality (Tokyo, November 4-6,1987). New York: Springer.
