Journalism in Chains: A Field Theory Approach to Understanding the Lived Experiences of Afghan Journalists

Abstract

Following the Taliban’s takeover in Afghanistan, journalists and media organizations face unique challenges. This study uses field theory to highlight the voices of this marginalized community, missing from the dialogue on journalistic practices. Through 23 in-depth qualitative interviews, we explore how the Taliban’s rule is reshaping Afghanistan’s journalistic field. Findings reveal that journalists are adopting pragmatic strategies to bring some equilibrium to the field amid Taliban pressures. The existing practices involve renegotiating journalistic approaches where certain aspects are modified and others totally abandoned due to authoritarian constraints. This evolution underscores the profession’s resilience and adaptability, diverging from Western ideals but essential for survival in these strict conditions.

Keywords

field theory Afghanistan journalistic role conception journalist safety journalistic field threats to journalism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Afghanistan Journalists Center. (n.d.). Afghanistan’s mass media law. https://afjc.media/english/killed/afghanistan-mass-media-law

Afghanistan Journalists Center. (2023). AFJC releases 2023 annual report on media freedom in Afghanistan. https://afjc.media/english/index.php/events/press-release/afjc-releases-2023-annual-report-on-media-freedom-in-afghanistan

Almeida

Robinson

(2023). Activists and journalists as co-creators and co-revisionists of US histories: The 1619 New York Times project. International Journal of Communication, 17, 499–517.

Atton

(2003). What is “alternative” journalism? Journalism, 4(3), 267–272.

Ayalon

Raz

I. G.

Amiel

(2022). The United States withdrawal from Afghanistan after two decades of a global war on terrorism. Research Forum, Institute for National Security Studies. https://www.inss.org.il/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/Adkan25.1Eng_Ayalon.pdf

Baldor

L. C.

(2022, May). Watchdog: US troop pullout was key factor in Afghan collapse. Associate Press News. https://apnews.com/article/afghanistan-biden-government-and-politics-donald-trump-7cef514c6cc96848f61a9e8b7fcdf263

Benson

(1999). Field theory in comparative context: A new paradigm for media studies. Theory and Society, 28(3), 463–498.

Benson

(2004). Bringing the sociology of media back in. Political Communication, 21(3), 275–292.

Benson

(2006). News media as a “journalistic field”: What Bourdieu adds to new institutionalism, and vice versa. Political Communication, 23(2), 187–202.

10.

Benson

Neveu

(2005). Bourdieu and the journalistic field. Polity Press.

11.

Bobkin

(2022). The end of the war in Afghanistan: The defeat of the United States and the consequences for regional security. Herald of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 92(Suppl. 4), S331–S339.

12.

Bourdieu

(1993). The field of cultural production: Essays on art and literature. Columbia University Press.

13.

Bourdieu

(1998). The state nobility: Elite schools in the field of power. Stanford University Press.

14.

Bourdieu

(2005). The political field, the social science field, and the journalistic field. In Benson

Neveu

(Eds.), Bourdieu and the journalistic field (pp. 29–47). Polity Press.

15.

Calderone

(2017, December 6). Afghanistan media boomed during war, but faces uncertain future as U.S. withdraws. Huffington Post. https://www.huffpost.com/entry/afghanistan-media-afghan-war_n_2574818

16.

Carroll

(2021, September). The Backstory: How a Navy officer, a Ukrainian colonel and a USA TODAY reporter helped an Afghan journalist escape Kabul. USA Today. https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2021/09/30/afghanistan-journalist-escapes-taliban-help-americans-ukraine/5902629001/

17.

Cary

(2012). CIMA research report: The state of media in Afghanistan. Center for International Media Assistance National Endowment for Democracy. https://www.cima.ned.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/CIMA-Afghanistan-03-01-12.pdf

18.

Charmaz

(2014). Constructing grounded theory. Sage.

19.

Christians

C. G.

Glasser

McQuail

Nordenstreng

White

R. A.

(2010). Normative theories of the media: Journalism in democratic societies. University of Illinois Press.

20.

Comfort

S. E.

Blankenship

(2021). Curated journalism: A field theory approach to journalistic production by environmental non-governmental organizations. Journalism, 22(2), 501–518.

21.

Committee to Protect Journalists. (2023). Afghanistan: How the Taliban takeover is affecting Afghan media. https://cpj.org/cpj-coverage-on-afghanistan

22.

Creswell

J. W.

Poth

C. N.

(2016). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five approaches. Sage.

23.

Deuze

(2005). What is journalism? Professional identity and ideology of journalists reconsidered. Journalism, 6(4), 442–464.

24.

Dickinson

Memon

(2012). Press clubs, the journalistic field and the practice of journalism in Pakistan. Journalism Studies, 13(4), 616–632.

25.

Dunham

(2022). Attacks on the press: The deadliest countries in 2021. Committee to Protect Journalists. https://cpj.org/reports/2022/01/attacks-on-the-press-the-deadliest-countries-in-2021/

26.

Emerson

R. M.

Fretz

R. I.

Shaw

L. L.

(2011). Writing ethnographic fieldnotes. University of Chicago Press.

27.

English

(2016). Mapping the sports journalism field: Bourdieu and broadsheet newsrooms. Journalism, 17(8), 1001–1017.

28.

Fahmy

S. S.

Salama

Alsaba

M. R.

(2024). Shattered lives, unbroken stories: Journalists’ perspectives from the frontlines of the Israel–Gaza war. Online Media and Global Communication, 3(2), 151–180.

29.

Faizi

(2023, April 01). The Taliban wants Afghan women in media to become invisible. https://www.mediasupport.org/blogpost/the-taliban-wants-afghan-women-in-media-to-become-invisible/

30.

Farivar

(2021, October 1). How the Taliban control Afghan media. Voice of America. https://www.voanews.com/a/how-the-taliban-control-afghan-media/6267846.html

31.

Fraenkel

Shoemaker

Himelfarb

(2010). Afghanistan media assessment. U.S. Institute of Peace. https://www.usip.org/publications/2010/12/afghanistan-media-assessment

32.

Freedom House. (2024). Freedom in the world 2023: Afghanistan. https://freedomhouse.org/country/afghanistan/freedom-world/2023

33.

Gallagher

(2023). Event extra: Afghanistan’s media landscape amid Taliban rule. U.S. Institute of Peace. https://www.usip.org/publications/2023/01/event-extra-afghanistans-media-landscape-amid-taliban-rule

34.

GeoPoll. (2024). Afghanistan media audience landscape. https://325431.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hubfs/325431/GeoPoll%20Afghanistan%20Media%20Landscape%20-%20Establishment%20Survey%20Report.pdf?utm_campaign=Climate%20Change%20Adaptation%20Report&utm_medium=email&_hsmi=294896869&_hsenc=p2ANqtz-8MVT2QebHE2yUW1PbMmYYwXbUb2uD1oTlE19gSDUwUAanux_iy5H1EUiwN40qhzJx-74-04apXXKrstSKOxEmKb-TvwA&utm_content=294896869&utm_source=hs_automation

35.

Gibbs

(2002). Forgotten coverage of Afghan “freedom fighters.” Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting. https://fair.org/extra/forgotten-coverage-of-afghan-freedom-fighters/

36.

Ginosar

Reich

(2022). Obsessive–activist journalists: A new model of journalism? Journalism Practice, 16(4), 660–680.

37.

Hackett

Carroll

(2006). Remaking media: The struggle to democratize public communication. Routledge.

38.

Hanitzsch

(2011). Populist disseminators, detached watchdogs, critical change agents and opportunist facilitators: Professional milieus, the journalistic field and autonomy in 18 countries. International Communication Gazette, 73(6), 477–494.

39.

Hanitzsch

Mellado

(2011). What shapes the news around the world? How journalists in eighteen countries perceive influences on their work. The International Journal of Press/Politics, 16(3), 404–426.

40.

Hatef

Cooke

T. R.

(2020). Winning hearts and minds: A critical analysis of independent media development in Afghanistan. Journal of International and Intercultural Communication, 13(2), 114–129.

41.

Human Rights Watch. (2015). “Stop reporting, or we’ll kill your family”: Threats to media freedom in Afghanistan. https://www.hrw.org/report/2015/01/21/stop-reporting-or-well-kill-your-family/threats-media-freedom-afghanistan

42.

Human Rights Watch. (2022). Afghanistan: Taliban threatening provincial media. https://www.hrw.org/news/2022/03/07/afghanistan-taliban-threatening-provincial-media

43.

Hussain

Ahmad

A. R.

(2022). Examining perceptions towards war/peace journalism: A survey of journalists in Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan. International Communication Gazette, 84(3), 183–205.

44.

International Federation of Journalists. (2022). Afghanistan: Taliban ban and harass foreign journalist. https://www.ifj.org/media-centre/news/detail/category/press-releases/article/afghanistan-taliban-ban-and-harass-foreign-journalist.html

45.

Jahng

M. R.

Eckert

Metzger-Riftkin

(2023). Defending the profession: US journalists’ role understanding in the era of fake news. Journalism Practice, 17(2), 226–244.

46.

Jenkins

Graves

(2024). Do more with less: Minimizing competitive tensions in collaborative local journalism. Digital Journalism, 12(2), 101–120.

47.

Journalism Education in Afghanistan. (n.d.). The professionalisation of academic journalism education in Afghanistan. https://journalism-education-afghanistan.org

48.

Kabiri

Behrawan

B. A.

(2020). A study of the rate and factors affecting journalists’ job satisfaction decrease in Afghan media. Global Media Journal-Persian Edition, 14(2), 164–181.

49.

Kaplan

D. E.

(2012). Empowering independent media: U.S. efforts to foster a free press and an open internet around the world. Center for International Media Assistance National Endowment for Democracy. https://ciaotest.cc.columbia.edu/wps/ned/0025119/f_0025119_20484.pdf

50.

Karimi

(2024). Afghanistan’s media crisis: How the Taliban assaults media freedom. Stanford University. https://jskfellows.stanford.edu/afghanistans-media-crisis-f36cc12d60a3

51.

Karokhail

(2023, March). Deadly bomb attack targets journalist gathering in northern Afghanistan. Arab News. https://www.arabnews.com/node/2266571/world

52.

Krause

(2011). Reporting and the transformations of the journalistic field: US news media, 1890-2000. Media, Culture & Society, 33(1), 89–104.

53.

Leech

N. L.

Onwuegbuzie

A. J.

(2008). Qualitative data analysis: A compendium of techniques and a framework for selection for school psychology research and beyond. School Psychology Quarterly, 23(4), 587–604.

54.

Maares

Hanusch

(2022). Interpretations of the journalistic field: A systematic analysis of how journalism scholarship appropriates Bourdieusian thought. Journalism, 23(4), 736–754.

55.

Maheshwari

Sparks

(2021). Political elites and journalistic practices in India: A case of institutionalized heteronomy. Journalism, 22(1), 231–247.

56.

Mitra

Høiby

Garrido

(2021). Medium-specific threats for journalists: Examples from Philippines, Afghanistan and Venezuela. Journalism Practice, 15(1), 80–98.

57.

Moody-Ramirez

Byerly

Mishra

Waisbord

S. R.

(2023). Media representations and diversity in the 100 years of journalism & mass communication quarterly. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly, 100(4), 826–846.

58.

Moon

(2019). Beyond puppet journalism: The bridging work of transnational journalists in a local field. Journalism Studies, 20(12), 1714–1731.

59.

Neveu

(2007). Pierre Bourdieu: Sociologist of media, or sociologist for media scholars? Journalism Studies, 8(2), 335–347.

60.

News Desk. (2021, August 30). A historical timeline of Afghanistan. PBS News Hour. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/asia-jan-june11-timeline-afghanistan

61.

Noorzai

(2021, August). As Taliban advance and fighting intensifies, Afghan media outlets close. Voice of America. https://www.voanews.com/a/press-freedom_taliban-advance-and-fighting-intensifies-afghan-media-outlets-close/6209455.html

62.

Olesen

Droes

Hatton

Chico

Schatzman

(1994). Analyzing together: Recollections of a team approach. In Gibbs

G. R.

(Ed.), Analyzing qualitative data (pp. 111–128). Routledge.

63.

Osman

(2019). Between the White House and the Kremlin: A comparative analysis of Afghan and Tajik media. International Journal of Communication, 13, 23.

64.

Osman

(2020). Television and the Afghan culture wars: Brought to you by foreigners, warlords, and activists. University of Illinois Press.

65.

Padalko

(2021, September 1). Digest: World media on press in Afghanistan before and after the Taliban takeover. The Fix. https://thefix.media/2021/9/1/digest-world-media-on-press-in-afghanistan-before-and-after-the-taliban-takeover

66.

Page

Siddiqi

(2012, March). The media of Afghanistan: The challenges of transition. BBC Media Action. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/57a08a8de5274a31e0000672/bbc_media_action_afghanistan_is_in_transition.pdf

67.

Paul

(2022). A field theory approach to international journalism: The case of Indian journalists in the Middle East. Journalism, 25(3), 603–619. https://doi.org/10.1177/14648849221148017

68.

Perreault

Bell

T. R.

(2022). Towards a “digital” sports journalism: Field theory, changing boundaries and evolving technologies. Communication & Sport, 10(3), 398–416.

69.

Perreault

Hanusch

(2024). Field insurgency in lifestyle journalism: How lifestyle journalists marginalize Instagram influencers and protect their autonomy. New Media & Society, 26, 3767–3785. https://doi.org/10.1177/14614448221104233

70.

Perreault

Johnson

Klein

(2022). Covering hate: Field theory and journalistic role conception in reporting on White nationalist rallies. Journalism Practice, 16(6), 1117–1133.

71.

Perreault

Montalbano

(2023). Covering religion: Field insurgency in United States religion reporting. Journalism, 24(6), 1193–1210. https://doi.org/10.1177/14648849211073220

72.

Perreault

Stanfield

(2019). Mobile journalism as lifestyle journalism? Field theory in the integration of mobile in the newsroom and mobile journalist role conception. Journalism Practice, 13(3), 331–348.

73.

Powers

Vera Zambrano

(2016). Explaining the formation of online news startups in France and the United States: A field analysis. Journal of Communication, 66(5), 857–877.

74.

Relly

J. E.

Zanger

(2017). The enigma of news media development with multi-pronged ‘capture’: The Afghanistan case. Journalism, 18(10), 1233–1255.

75.

Reporters Without Borders. (2021). RSF asks International Criminal Court to investigate murders of journalists in Afghanistan. https://rsf.org/en/rsf-asks-international-criminal-court-investigate-murders-journalists-afghanistan

76.

Reporters Without Borders. (2022a). Afghanistan has lost almost 60% of its journalists since the fall of Kabul. https://rsf.org/en/afghanistan-has-lost-almost-60-its-journalists-fall-kabul

77.

Reporters Without Borders. (2022b). RSF helps evacuate 202 Afghan journalists, takes 152 support measures. https://rsf.org/en/rsf-helps-evacuate-202-afghan-journalists-takes-152-support-measures

78.

Reporters Without Borders. (2022c). 1,668 journalists killed in past 20 years (2003-2022), average of 80 per year. https://rsf.org/en/1668-journalists-killed-past-20-years-2003-2022-average-80-year

79.

Reporters Without Borders. (2023). Mazar-i—Sharif bombing—“Biggest attack” on Afghan journalists in months. https://rsf.org/en/mazar-i-sharif-bombing-biggest-attack-afghan-journalists-months

80.

Salih

M. A.

(2023). Post-regime-change Afghan and Iraqi media systems: Strategic ambivalence as technology of media governance. Media, War & Conflict, 16(2), 228–245.

81.

Schultz

(2007). The journalistic gut feeling: Journalistic doxa, news habitus and orthodox news values. Journalism Practice, 1(2), 190–207.

82.

Shah

S. F. A.

Ginossar

Ittefaq

(2023). “We always report under pressure”: Professionalism and journalistic identity among regional journalists in a conflict zone. Journalism, 24(4), 709–728.

83.

Shah

S. F. A.

Ginossar

Weiss

(2019). “This is a Pakhtun disease”: Pakhtun health journalists’ perceptions of the barriers and facilitators to polio vaccine acceptance among the high-risk Pakhtun community in Pakistan. Vaccine, 37(28), 3694–3703.

84.

Shah

S. F. A.

Hess

J. M.

Goodkind

J. R.

(2019). Family separation and the impact of digital technology on the mental health of refugee families in the United States: Qualitative study. Journal of Medical Internet Research, 21(9), e14171.

85.

Shah

S. F. A.

Jan

Ginossar

McGrail

J. P.

Baber

Ullah

(2022). Trauma exposure and post-traumatic stress disorder among regional journalists in Pakistan. Journalism, 23(2), 391–408.

86.

Shah

S. F. A.

Jan

Ittefaq

(2021). Health and safety risks to journalists during pandemics. In Jamil

Çoban

Ataman

Appiah-Adjei

(Eds.), Handbook of research on discrimination, gender disparity, and safety risks in journalism (pp. 90–103). IGI Global.

87.

Sharma

(2022, June). Journalist forced to sell street food to survive amid economic crises in Taliban-ruled Afghanistan. India Times. https://www.indiatimes.com/trending/social-relevance/tv-anchor-sells-street-food-taliban-regime-afghanistan-572414.html

88.

Siapera

Spyridou

L.-P.

(2012). The field of online journalism: A Bourdieusian analysis. In Siapera

Spyridou

L.-P.

(Eds.), The handbook of global online journalism (pp. 77–97). Wiley. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118313978.ch5

89.

Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction. (2022). Collapse of the Afghan National Defense and Security Forces: An Assessment of the factors that led to its demise. https://www.sigar.mil/pdf/evaluations/SIGAR-22-22-IP.pdf

90.

Sterne

(2003). Bourdieu, technique and technology. Cultural Studies, 17(3–4), 367–389.

91.

Streitmatter

(2001). Voices of revolution: The dissident press in America. Columbia University Press.

92.

Tandoc

E. C.

Jr. (2014). Journalism is twerking? How web analytics is changing the process of gatekeeping. New Media & Society, 16(4), 559–575.

93.

Tandoc

E. C.

Jr. (2017). Watching over the watchdogs: The problems that Filipino journalists face. Journalism Studies, 18(1), 102–117.

94.

Tandoc

E. C.

Jr. Jenkins

(2017). The Buzzfeedication of journalism? How traditional news organizations are talking about a new entrant to the journalistic field will surprise you!. Journalism, 18(4), 482–500.

95.

Tandoc

E. C.

Jr. Maitra

(2018). News organizations’ use of Native Videos on Facebook: Tweaking the journalistic field one algorithm change at a time. New Media & Society, 20(5), 1679–1696.

96.

TOLOnews . (2022, June). Anas Haqqani outlines ways to overcome nation’s poverty. https://tolonews.com/index.php/afghanistan-178370

97.

Torfeh

(2009). Media development in Afghanistan. Media Development, 56(1), 39–44.

98.

Tshuma

L. A.

Msimanga

M. J.

Sibanda

M. N.

(2022). “Playing” in the eyes of the Ferret Team: Examining the use of surveillance strategies by Zimbabwean journalists. African Journalism Studies, 43(1), 53–69.

99.

Tuchman

(1978). Making news: A study in the construction of reality. Free Press.

100.

United Nations Afghanistan. (2023). Revealing the truth and transparency of assistance: UN and local media partnership in Afghanistan. https://afghanistan.un.org/en/255748-revealing-truth-and-transparency-assistance-un-and-local-media-partnership-afghanistan

101.

Usher

(2017). Venture-backed news startups and the field of journalism: Challenges, changes, and consistencies. Digital Journalism, 5(9), 1116–1133.

102.

Van Dalen

. (2021). Rethinking journalist–politician relations in the age of populism: How outsider politicians delegitimize mainstream journalists. Journalism, 22(11), 2711–2728.

103.

Vejdani

Kumar

(2023, August). Analyzing the State of Afghan Journalism. The Diplomat. https://thediplomat.com/2023/08/analyzing-the-state-of-afghan-journalism/

104.

Vos

T. P.

(2016). Journalistic fields. In Witschge

Anderson

C. W.

Domingo

Hermida

(Eds.), The Sage handbook of digital journalism (pp. 383–396). Sage.

105.

Vos

T. P.

(2019). Field theory and journalistic capital. In Vos

T. P.

Hanusch

Dimitrakopoulou

Geertsema-Sligh

Sehl

(Eds.), The international encyclopedia of journalism studies (pp. 1–5). Wiley. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118841570

106.

Vos

T. P.

Craft

(2017). The discursive construction of journalistic transparency. Journalism Studies, 18(12), 1505–1522.

107.

Vos

T. P.

Craft

Ashley

(2012). New media, old criticism: Bloggers’ press criticism and the journalistic field. Journalism, 13(7), 850–868.

108.

Vos

T. P.

Eichholz

Karaliova

(2019). Audiences and journalistic capital: Roles of journalism. Journalism Studies, 20(7), 1009–1027.

109.

Wang

(2016). The transformation of investigative journalism in China: From journalists to activists. Rowman & Littlefield.

110.

Wildman

Bennis

(2010). The war in Afghanistan goes global. Critical Asian Studies, 42(3), 469–480.

111.

Willig

(2013). Newsroom ethnography in a field perspective. Journalism, 14(3), 372–387.

112.

Tandoc

E. C.

Jr. Salmon

C. T.

(2019). When journalism and automation intersect: Assessing the influence of the technological field on contemporary newsrooms. Journalism Practice, 13(10), 1238–1254.

113.

Yin

R. K.

(2015). Qualitative research from start to finish. Guilford Publications.

114.

Zeveleva

(2019). How states tighten control: A field theory perspective on journalism in contemporary Crimea. The British Journal of Sociology, 70(4), 1225–1244.