Correlation of Travel Time on Roads versus Straight Line Distance

Abstract

Studies of hospital demand and choice of hospital have used straight line distance from a patient's home to hospitals as a measure of geographic access, but there is the potential for bias if straight line distance does not accurately reflect travel time. Travel times for unimpeded travel between major intersections in upstate New York were compared with distances between these points. The correlation between distance and travel time was 0.987for all observations and 0.826 for distances less than 15 miles. These very high correlations indicate that straight line distance is a reasonable proxy for travel time in most hospital demand or choice models, especially those with arge numbers of hospitals. The authors' outlier analyses show some exceptions, however, so this relationship may not hold for studies focusing on specific hospitals, very small numbers of hospitals, or studies in dense urban areas with high congestion and reliance on surface streets.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams, E. K. , R. Houchens , G. E. Wright , and J. Robbins . "Predicting Hospital Choice for Rural Medicare Beneficiaries: The Role of Severity of Illness." Health Seruices Research 26 (December 1991): 583-612.

Burns, L. R. , and D. R. Wholey . "The Impact of Physician Characteristics in Conditional Choice Models for Hospital Care." Journal of Health Economics 11 (1992): 43-62.

Cohen, M. A. , and H. L. Lee . "The Determinants of Spatial Distribution of Hospital Utilization in a Region." Medical Care 23 (1985): 27-38.

Folland, S. T.

"Predicting Hospital Market Shares."

Inquiry 20 (Spring 1983): 34-44.

Garnick, D. W. , E. Lichtenberg , C. S. Phibbs , H. S. Luft , D. J. Peltzman , and S. J. McPhee . "The Sensitivity of Conditional Choice Models for Hospital Care to Estimation Technique." Journal of Health Economics 8 (1989): 377-397.

Garnick, D. W. , H. S. Luft , J. C. Robinson , and J. Tetreault . "Appropriate Measures of Hospital Market Areas." Health Services Research 22 (April 1987): 69-90.

Gesler, W. M. , and M. S. Meade . "Locational and Population Factors in Health Care-Seeking Behavior in Savannah, Georgia." Health Services Research 23 (August 1988): 443-462.

Lee, H. L. , and M. A. Cohen . "A Multinomial Logit Model for the Spatial Distribution of Hospital Utilization." Journal of Business & Economic Statistics 3 1985): 159-168.

Luft, H. S. , D. W. Garnick , D. H. Mark , D. J. Peltzman , C. S. Phibbs , E. Lichtenberg , and S. J. McPhee . "Does Quality Influence Choice of Hospital?" Journal of the American Medical Association 263 (June 1990): 2899-2906.

10.

McGuirk, M. , and F. W. Porell . "Spatial Patterns of Hospital Utilization: The Impact of Distance and Tume." Inquiry 21 (Spring 1984): 84-95.

11.

Morrill, R. L. , R. J. Earickson , and P. Ries . "Factors Influencing Distances Traveled to Hospitals." Economic Geography 46 (1970): 161-172.

12.

Phibbs, C. S. , D. H. Mark , H. S. Luft , D. J. Peltzman-Rennie , D. W. Garnick , E. Lichtenberg , and S. J. McPhee . "Choice of Hospital for Delivery: A Comparison of High-Risk and Low-Risk Women." Health Services Research 28 (une 1993): 201-222.

13.

Whitten, C. A. Airline Distances between Cities in the U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey, Special Publication no. 238, 238-241. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1947.

14.

Williams, A. P. , W. B. Schwartz , J. P. Newhouse , and B. W. Bennett . "How Many Miles to the Doctor?" New England Journal of Medicine 311 (1983): 958-963.