Small Area Variations: A Critical Review of Propositions,Methods,and Evidence

Acton, J.P. "Nonmonetary Factors in the Demand for Medical Services: Some Empirical Evidence." Journal of Political Economy 83, no. 3 (June 1975): 595-613.

Andersen, R. , and L. Benham. "Factors Affecting the Relationship between Family Income and Medical Care Consumption." In Empirical Studies in Health Economics. Edited by H. Klarman. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1970.

Auster, R.D. , and R.L. Oaxaca. "Identification of Supplier Induced Demand in the Health Care Sector." Journal of Human Resources 16, no. 3 (Summer 1978): 35-56.

Barnes, B.A. "Population-Based Small-Unit Analysis of Health Care." In Regional Variations in Hospital Use. Edited by D. L. Rothberg. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books, 1982.

Barnes, B.A. , E. O'Brien , C. Comstock , D.G. d'Arpa , and C.L. Donahue. "Report on Variations in Rates of Utilization of Surgical Services in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts." Journal of the American Medical Association 254, no. 3 (19 July 1985): 371-75.

Barry, M.J. , A.G. Mulley , Jr., F.J. Fowler , and J.W. Wennberg. "Watchful Waiting vs Immediate Transurethral Resection for Symptomatic Prostatism." Journal of the American Medical Association 259, no. 20 (27 May 1988): 3010-17.

Berman, D.E. , and P.M. Gertman. "Variations in Hospital Use, Inappropriate Use and Public Policy Consequences" In Regional Variations in Hospital Use . Edited by D. L. Rothberg. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books, 1982.

Blumberg, M.S. "Inter-Area Variations in Age-Adjusted Health Status" Medical Care 25, no. 4 (April 1987): 340-53.

Bombardier, C. , V.R. Fuchs , L.A. Lillard , and K.E. Warner. "Socioeconomic Factors Affecting the Utilization of Surgical Operations." New England Journal of Medicine 297, no. 13 (29 September 1977): 699-705.

Boyle, F. "Regional Variations in the Use of Medical Services and the Accountability of the Profession." Journal of the American Medical Association 254, no. 3 (19 July 1985): 407.

Brewer, W.R. , and M.A. Freedman. "Causes and Implications of Variation in Hospital Utilization ." Journal of Public Health Policy 3, no. 4 (December 1982): 445-54.

Brook, R.H. , K.N. Lohr , M. Chassin , J. Kosecoff , A. Fink , and D. Solomon. "Geogrpahic Variations in the Use of Services: Do They Have Clinical Significance ?" Health Affairs 3, no. 2 (Summer 1984 ): 63-73.

Bunker, J.P. , and B.W. Brown. "The Physician-Patient as Informed Consumer of Surgical Services." New England Journal of Medicine 290, no. 19 (1974): 1051-55.

Caper, P. "Variations in Medical Practice: Implications for Health Policy." Health Affairs 3, no. 2 (Summer 1984): 110-19.

Chassin, M. , and S.M. McCue. "A Randomized Trial of Medical Quality Assurance: Improving Physicians' Use of Pelvimetry." Journal of the American Medical Association 256, no. 8 (22/29 August 1986): 1012-16.

Chassin, M.R. , R.H. Brook , R.E. Park , J. Keesey , A. Fink , J. Kosecoff , K. Kahn , N. Merrick , and D.H. Solomon. "Variations in the Use of Medical and Surgical Services by the Medicare Population." New England Journal of Medicine 314, no. 5 (30 January 1986): 285-90.

Chassin, M. , J. Kosecoff , R.E. Park , C.M. Winslow , K.L. Kahn , N.J. Merrick , J. Keesey , A. Fink , D.H. Solomon , and R.H. Brook. . "Does Inappropriate Use Explain Geographic Variations in the Use of Health Care Services?" Journal of the American Medical Association 258, no. 18 (13 November 1987): 2533-37.

Chiswick, R. "Hospital Utilization: An Analysis of SMSA Differences in Occupancy Rates, Admission Rates, and Bed Rates." Explorations in Economic Research 3, no. 3 (Summer 1976): 326-78.

Connell, F.A. , L.A. Blide , and M.A. Hanken. "Clinical Correlates of Small Area Variations in Populuation-Based Admission Rates for Diabetes." Medical Care 22, no. 10 (October 1984): 939-49.

Davis, K. , and L.B. Russell. "The Substitution of Hospital Outpatient Care for Inpatient Care." Review of Economics and Statistics 54, no. 2 (May 1972): 109-20.

Deacon, R. , J. Lubitz , M. Gornick , and M. Newton. 'Analysis of Variations in Hospital Use by Medicare Patients in PSRO Areas, 1974-77." Health Care Financing Review 1, no. 1 (Summer 1979 ): 79-106.

Diehr, P. , K. Cain , F.C. Connell , and E. Volinn. "What is Too Much Variation: The Null Hypothesis in Small Area Analysis?" Health Services Research 24, no. 6 (February 1990): 741-71.

Dranove, D. "Demand Inducement and the Physician/Patient Relationship." Economic Inquiry 26, no. 2 (April 1988): 281-98.

Dyck, F.J. , F.A. Murphy , J.K. Murphy , D.A. Road , M.S. Boyd , E. Osborne , D. de Vlieger , B. Korchinski , C. Ripley , A.T. Bromley , and P. Innes. "Effect of Surveillance on the Number of Hysterectomies in the Province of Saskatchewan." New England Journal of Medicine 296, no. 23 (9 June 1977): 1326-28.

Eddy, D.M. "Clinical Decision Making: From Theory to Practice." Journal of the American Medical Association 263, no. 3 (19 January 1990): 441-43.

Eisenberg, J.M. Doctors' Decisions and the Cost of Medical Care. Ann Arbor, MI: Health Administration Press, 1986.

. " Physician Utilization: The State of Research about Physician Practice Patterns ." Medical Care 23, no. 5 (May 1985): 461-83.

Evans, R.G. "Supplier-Induced Demand: Some Empirical Evidence and Implications ." In The Economics of Health and Medical Care. Edited by M. Perlman. London: MacMillan & Co., 1974.

Feldstein, M. "Hospital Cost Inflation: A Study of Nonprofit Price Dynamics." American Economic Review 61, no. 5 (December 1971): 853-72.

Folland, S. , and M. Stano. "Sources of Small Area Variations in the Use of Medical Care." Journal of Health Economics 8, no. 1 (March 1989): 85-107.

Fowler, F.J., Jr. , J.E. Wennberg , R.P. Timothy , M.J. Barry , A.G. Mulley , and D. Hanley. "Symptom Status and Quality of Life Following Prostatectomy ." Journal of the American Medical Assocation 259, no. 20 (27 May 1988): 3018-22.

Fuchs, V.R. "The Supply of Surgeons and the Demand for Operations." Journal of Human Resources 13, Supplement (1978): 35-56.

Fuchs, V.R. , and M.J. Kramer. Determinants of Expenditures for Physicians' Services in the United States 1948-68. New York: National Bureau of Economic Research/ HEW, 1972.

Gillespie, K.N. , J.C. Romeis , K.S. Virgo , J.W. Fletcher , and A. Elixhauser. "Practice Pattern Variation between Two Medical Schools ." Medical Care 27, no. 5 (May 1989): 537-42.

Ginsburg, P.B. , and D.M. Koretz. "Bed Availability and Hospital Utilization: Estimates of the 'Roemer Effect'." Health Care Financing Review 5, no. 1 (Fall 1983): 87-92.

Glover, J.A. "The Incidence of Tonsillectomy in School Children." Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine 31 (1938): 1219-36.

Gornick, M. "Trends and Regional Variations in Hospital Use under Medicare." Health Care Financing Review 3, no. 3 (March 1982): 41-73.

Goyert, G.L. , S.F. Bottoms , M.C. Treadwell , and P.C. Nehra. "The Physician Factor in Cesarian Birth Rates." New England Journal of Medicine 320, no. 11 (16 March 1989): 706-709.

Green, J. "Physician-Induced Demand for Medical Care." Journal of Human Resources 13 (1978, Supplement): 21-34.

Griffith, J. R., J. D. Restuccia, P. J. Tedeschi. P. A. Wilson, and H. S. Zuckerman. "Measuring Community Hospital Services in Michigan." In Regional Variations in Hospital Use. Edited by D. L. Rothberg. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books, 1982.

Hay, J. , and G. Anderson. "The Hospital Services Market: A Disequilibrium Analysis ." Southern Economic Journal 54, no. 3 (January 1988): 656-65.

Health Affairs. Vol. 3, no. 2 (Summer 1984).

Howell, D. , and C.G. McLaughlin . "Regional Variation in 1917 Health Care Expenditures ." Medical Care 27, no. 8 (August 1989): 772-88.

Hulka, B. , and J.R. Wheat. "Patterns of Utilization: The Patient Perspective." Medical Care 23, no. 5 (May 1985): 438-60.

Judge, G.G. , W.E. Griffiths , R.C. Hill , H. Lutkepohl , and T.-S. Lee. The Theory and Practice of Econometrics. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 1985.

Kazandjian, V.A. , P.W. Durance , and M.A. Schork. "The Extremal Coefficient in Small-Area Analysis." Health Services Research 24, no. 5 (December 1989): 665-84.

Keeler, E.B. , and J.E. Rolph. "The Demand for Episodes of Treatment in the Health Insurance Experiment." Journal of Health Economics 7, no. 4 (December 1988): 336-67.

Knickman, J.R. "Variations in Hospital Use across Cities: A Comparison of Utilization Rates in New York and Los Angeles." In Regional Variations in Hospital Use. Edited by D. L. Rothberg. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books , 1982.

Knickman, J.R. , and A.M. Foltz. "A Statistical Analysis of Reasons for East-West Differences in Hospital Use." Inquiry 23, no. 1 (Spring 1985): 45-58.

Langbein, L.I. , and A.J. Lichtman. Ecological Inference. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications, 1978.

Leape, L.L. "Unnecessary Surgery." Health Services Research 24, no. 3 (August 1989 ): 351-407.

Leape, L.L. , R.E. Park , D.H. Solomon , M.R. Chassin , J. Kosecoff , and R.H. Brook. "Relation between Surgeons' Practice Volumes and Geographic Variation in the Rate of Carotid Endarterectomy." New England Journal of Medicine 321, no. 10 (7 September 1989): 653-57.

Lohr, K.N. , W.R. Lohr , and R.H. Brook. "Geographic Variations in the Use of Medical Services and Surgical Procedures: A Chartbook." Washington, DC: National Health Policy Forum, August 1985.

Manning, W. , J.P. Newhouse , N. Duan , E.B. Keeler , A. Leibowitz , and M.S. Marquis. "Health Insurance and the Demand for Medical Care: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment." American Economic Review 77, no. 3 (June 1987 ): 251-77.

McAfee, R.E. "The Hospital 'Surgical Signature'." Journal of the American Medical Association 257, no. 7 (20 February 1987): 972.

McLaughlin, C.G. , "Measuring Small Area Variation in Hospital Site-of-Care Versus Patient Origin Data." Socio-Economic Planning Science 22, no. 4 (1988): 177-84.

McLaughlin, C.G. , D.P. Normalle , R.A. Wolfe , L.F. McMahon, Jr. , and J.R. Griffith. "Small-Area Variation in Hospital Dishcarge Rates: Do Socioeconomic Variables Matter?" Medical Care 27, no. 5 (May 1989): 507-21.

McMahon, L.F. , R.A. Wolfe , and P.J. Tedeschi. "Variation in Hospital Admissions among Small Areas: A Comparison of Maine and Michigan." Medical Care 27, no. 6 (June 1989 ): 623-31.

McPherson, K. , P.M. Strong , A. Epstein , and L. Jones. "Regional Variations in the Use of Common Surgical Procedures: Within and between England and Wales, Canada and the United States of America ." Social Science and Medicine 15A (1981): 273-88.

McPherson, K. , J.E. Wennberg , O.B. Hovind , and P. Clifford. "Small-Area Variations in the Use of Common Surgical Procedures: An International Comparison of New England, England, and Norway." New England Journal of Medicine 307, no. 21 (18 November 1982): 1310-13.

Mitchell, J.B. , and J. Cromwell. "Variations in Surgery Rates and the Supply of Surgeons ." In Regional Variations in Hospital Use. Edited by D. L. Rothberg. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books, 1982.

Moore, F.D. "Small Area Variation Studies: Illuminating or Misleading?" Health Affairs 4, no. 1 (Spring 1985): 96-101.

Morrisey, M.A. , and G.A. Jensen. "Regional Variation in Health Insurance Coverage." Health Affairs 8, no. 3 (Fall 1989): 91-103.

Newhouse, J.P. , C.E. Phelps. "Price and Income Elasticities for Medical Care Services." In The Economics of Health and Medical Care. Edited by M. Perlman. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1974.

Newhouse, J.P. , W.G. Manning , C.N. Norris , L.L. Orr , N. Duan , E.B. Keeler , A. Leibowitz , K.H. Marquis , M.S. Marquis , C.E. Phelps , and R.H. Brook. "Some Interim Results from a Controlled Trial of Cost Sharing in Health Insurance." New England Journal of Medicine 305, no. 25 (17 December 1981): 1501-07.

Pasley, B. , P. Vernon , G. Gibson , M. McCauley , and J. Andoh. "Geographic Variations in Elderly Hospital and Surgical Discharge Rates, New York State." American Journal of Public Health 77, no. 6 (June 1987): 679-84.

Paul-Shaheen, P. , J.D. Clark , and D. Williams. "Small Area Analysis: A Review and Analysis of the North American Literature." Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 12, no. 4 (Winter 1987): 741-809.

Pauly, M.V. "Is Medical Care Different? Old Questions, New Answers." Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 13, no. 2 (Summer 1988): 227-37.

. " What is Unnecessary Surgery?" Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly 57, no. 1 ( 1979): 95-117.

Phelps, C. "Effects of Insurance on Demand for Medical Care." In Equity in Health Services: Empirical Analysis in Social Policy. Edited by R. Andersen , J. Kravitz , and O. Anderson. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger, 1975.

Piantadosi, S. , D.P. Byar , and S.B. Green. "The Ecological Fallacy." American Journal of Epidemiology 127, no. 5 (May 1988): 893-904.

Reinhardt, U.E. "Comment on 'Competition among Physicians'." In Competition in the Health Care Sector: Past, Present, and Future. Edited by W. Greenberg. Washington, DC: Federal Trade Commission, 1978.

. " Economists in Health Care: Saviors or Elephants in a Porcelain Shop?" American Economic Review 79, no. 2 (May 1989): 337-42.

. " The Theory of Physician-Induced Demand after a Decade." Journal of Human Resources 4 (Summer 1985 ): 187-93.

Robinson, W.S. "Ecological Correlations and the Behavior of Individuals." American Sociological Review 15, no. 3 (June 1950): 351-57.

Roos, N.P. "Hysterectomy: Variations in Rates across Small Areas and across Physicians' Practices." American Journal of Public Health 74, no. 4 (April 1984 ): 327-35.

. " Predicting Hospitalization by the Elderly: The Importance of Patient, Physician, and Hospital Characteristics" Medical Care 27, no. 10 (October 1989): 905-19.

Roos, N.P. , and L.L. Roos, Jr. "High and Low Surgical Rates: Risk Factors for Area Residents" American Journal of Public Health 71, no. 6 (June 1981 ): 591-600.

—. "Surgical Rate Variations: Do They Reflect the Health or Socioeconomic Characteristics of the Population?" Medical Care 20, no. 9 (September 1982): 945-58.

Roos, N.P. , L.L. Roos , and P.D. Henteleff. "Elective Surgical Rates—Do High Rates Mean Lower Standards?" New England Journal of Medicine 299, no. 7 (18 August 1977): 360-65.

Roos, N.P. , J.E. Wennberg , and K. McPherson. "Using Diagnosis-Related Groups for Studying Variations in Hospital Admissions." Health Care Financing Review 8, no. 4, (Summer 1988 ): 53-62.

Rossiter, L.F. , and G.R. Wilensky. "Identification of Physician-Induced Demand." Journal of Human Resources 19, no. 2 (Spring 1984): 231-244.

. " A Reexamination of the Use of Physician Services: The Role of Physician-Initiated Demand." Inquiry 20, no. 2 (Summer 1983): 162-72.

Rothberg, D.L. "Regional Variation in Hospital Use: Introduction and Overview." In Regional Variations in Hospital Use. Edited by D. L. Rothberg. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books, 1982.

Sloan, F.A. , and R. Feldman. "Competition among Physicians." In Competition in the Health Care Sector: Past, Present, Future. Edited by W. Greenberg. Washington, DC: Federal Trade Commission, 1978.

Stano, M. "An Analysis of the Evidence on Competition in the Physician Services Markets." Journal of Health Economics 4, no. 3 (September 1985): 197-212.

. " A Further Analysis of the Physician Inducement Controversy" Journal of Health Economics 6, no. 3 (September 1987): 227-38.

. 'A Further Analysis of the 'Variations in Practice Style' Phenomenon" Inquiry 23 (Summer 1986): 176-82.

Stano, M. , and S. Folland. "Variations in the Use of Physician Services by Medicare Beneficiaries." Health Care Financing Review 9, no. 4 (Spring 1988 ): 51-58.

Stano, M. , J. Cromwell , J. Velky , and A. Saad. "The Effects of Physician Availability on Fees and the Demand for Doctor's Services." Atlantic Economic Journal 13 (July 1985): 51-60.

Stockwell, H. , and E. Vayda. "Variations in Surgery in Ontario." Medical Care 17, no. 4 (April 1979): 390-96.

Vayda, E. , and G.D. Anderson. "Comparison of Provincial Surgical Rates in 1968." Canadian Journal of Surgery 18 (January 1975): 18-26.

Vayda, E. , J.M. Barnsley , W.R. Mindell , and B. Cardillo. "Five-Year Studies of Surgical Rates in Ontario's Counties " Canadian Medical Association Journal 131 (15 July 1984): 111-15.

Wall Street journal. "Patient Data May Reshape Health Care ." 213, no. 74 (17 April 1989): B1.

Wennberg, J.E. "Dealing with Medical Practice Variations: A Proposal for Action." Health Affairs 3, no. 2 (Summer 1984): 6-32.

. " On Patient Need, Equity, Supplier-Induced Demand, and the Need to Assess the Outcome of Common Medical Practices" Medical Care 23, no. 5 (May 1985): 512-20.

. " Population Illness Rates Do Not Explain Population Hospitalization Rates." Medical Care 25, no. 4 (April 1987): 354-59.

. " Should the Cost of Insurance Reflect the Cost of Use in Local Hospital Markets ?" New England Journal of Medicine 307, no. 22 (25 November 1982): 1374-81.

. " Which Rate is Right?" New England Journal of Medicine 314, no. 5 (30 January 1986): 310-11.

Wennberg, J.E. , B.A. Barnes , and M. Zubkoff. "Professional Uncertainty and the Problem of Supplier-Induced Demand." Social Science and Medicine 16, no. 7 (1982): 811-24.

Wennberg, J.E. , and F.J. Fowler. 'A Test of Consumer Contribution to Small Area Variations in Health Care Delivery" Journal of the Maine Medical Association 68 (August 1977): 275-79.

Wennberg, J.E. , J.L. Freeman , and W. Culp. "Are Hospital Services Rationed in New Haven or Over-Utilised in Boston?" The Lancet 1, no. 8543 (23 May 1987): 1185-88.

Wennberg, J.E. , and A. Gittelsohn. A Small Area Approach to the Analysis of Health System Performance. DHHS Publication no. (HRA) 80-14012. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office, August 1980.

. " Small Area Variations in Health Care Delivery" Science 182 (14 December 1973 ): 1102-08.

. " Variations in Medical Care among Small Areas." Scientific American 246, no. 4 (April 1982): 120-34.

Wennberg, J.E. , K. McPherson , and P. Caper. "Will Payment Based on Diagnosis-Related Groups Control Hospital Costs?" New England Journal of Medicine 311, no. 5 (2 August 1984): 295-300.

Wennberg, J.E. , L. Blowers , R. Parker , and A.M. Gittelsohn . "Changes in Tonsillectomy Rates Associated with Feedback and Review." Pediatrics 59, no. 6 (June 1977): 821-26.

Wennberg, J.E. , N. Roos , L. Sola , A. Schori , and R. Jaffe. "Use of Claims Data Systems to Evaluate Health Care Outcomes: Mortality and Reoperation following Prostatectomy." Journal of the American Medical Association 257, no. 7 (20 February 1987): 933-36.

Wennberg, J.E. , A.G. Mulley , Jr., D. Hanley , R.P. Timothy , F.J. Fowler , Jr., N.P. Roos , M.J. Barry , K. McPherson , R. Greenberg , D. Soule , T. Bubolz , E. Fisher , and D. Malenka. 'An Assessment of Prostatectomy for Benign Urinary Tract Obstruction: Geographic Variations and the Valuation of Medical Care Outcomes ." Journal of the American Medical Association 259, no. 20 (27 May 1988): 3027-30.

Willemain, T.R. "On the Comparison of Highest and Lowest Surgery Rates in Small-Area Studies." In Regional Variations in Hospital Use. Edited by D. L. Rothberg. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books, 1982.

Wilson, P. , and P. Tedeschi. "Community Correlates of Hospital Use." Health Services Research 19, no. 3 (August 1984): 333-55.

Wilson, P.A. , J.R. Griffith , and P.J. Tedeschi. "Does Race Affect Hospital Use?" American Journal of Public Health 75, no. 3 (March 1985): 263-69.

Wolfe, R.A. , J.R. Griffith , L.F. McMahon , Jr., P.J. Tedeschi , G.R. Petroni , and C.G. McLaughlin . "Patterns of Surgical and Nonsurgical Use in Michigan Communities from 1980 through 1984." Health Services Research 24, no. 1 (April 1989): 66-82.