Privatization in Health Care: Shifting the Risk

Abstract

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abel-Smith, B. "Who is the Odd Man Out? The Experience of Western Europe in Containing the Costs of Health Care." Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly 63 (Winter 1985): 1-17.

Alexander, J.A. , and B.L. Lewis. "The Financial Characteristics of Hospitals under For-Profit and Nonprofit Contract Management." Inquiry 21 (Fall 1984a): 230-42.

. " Hospital Contract Management: A Descriptive Profile" Health Services Research 19 (October 1984 b): 461-78.

Alexander, J.A. , and T.G. Rundall. "Public Hospitals under Contract Management: An Assessment of Operating Performance." Medical Care 23 (March 1985): 209-19.

Altman, D.E. , and D.H. Morgan. "The Role of State and Local Government in Health." Health Affairs 2 (Winter 1983): 7-31.

American Hospital Association. Directory of Multi-Hospital Systems, Multi-State Alliances, and Networks, 7th ed. Chicago, IL: American Hospital Publishing, Inc., 1986.

Anderson, M.D. , and P.D. Fox. "Lessons Learned from Medicaid Managed Care Approaches ." Health Affairs 6 (Spring 1987): 71-86.

Arizona. State Senate. Arizona Health Care Cost Containment System. 35th Leg., 4th Spec. Sess., Senate Bill 1001. Phoenix, AZ: State of Arizona, 9 November 1981.

Arnould, R.J. , L.W. Debrock , and J.W. Pollard. "Do HMOs Produce Specific Services More Efficiently?" Inquiry 21 (Fall 1984): 243-53.

10.

Bachman, S.S. , D.F. Beatrice , and S.H. Altman. "Implementing Change: Lessons for Medicaid Reform." Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 12 (Summer 1987): 237-51.

11.

Berliner, H.S. , and C. Regan. "Multinational Corporations of U.S. For-Profit Hospital Chains: Trends and Implications." American Journal of Public Health 77 (October 1987): 1,280-84.

12.

Biggs, E.L. , J.E. Kralewski , and G.D. Brown. "A Comparison of Contract-Managed and Traditionally Managed Nonprofit Hospitals." Medical Care 18 (June 1980): 585-96.

13.

Black, D. "Medicine and Politics." British Medical Journal 296 (2 January 1988): 53-56.

14.

Bradbury, R.C. "A Community Approach to Health Care Competition." Inquiry 24 (Fall 1987): 253-65.

15.

Brecher, C. "Medicaid Comes to Arizona: A First-Year Report on AHCCCS." Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 9 (Fall 1984): 411-25.

16.

Brown, E.R. , W.T. Price , and M.R. Cousineau. "Medi-Cal Hospital Contracting-Did It Achieve Its Legislative Objectives?" Western Journal of Medicine 143 (July 1985): 118-24.

17.

Chandra, J. , and A. Kakabadse. Privatisation and the National Health Service: The Scope for Collaboration. London: Gower Publishing Company, Ltd., England 1985, 3, 6-8, 9, 12-19, 27-29, 31-33, 41.

18.

Christianson, J.B. "Competitive Bidding: The Challenge for Health Care Managers." Health Care Management Review 10, no. 2 (1985): 39-53.

19.

. " Competitive Bidding for Home Care under the Channeling Demonstration." Health Care Financing Review 8 (Summer 1987): 73-86.

20.

Christianson, J.B. , and D.G. Hillman. Health Care for the Indigent and Competitive Contracts. The Arizona Experience. Ann Arbor, MI: Health Administration Press, 1986, 1, 79-101, 130-55.

21.

Dranove, D. "Selective Contracting: An Overview." In Selective Contracting. Proceedings of the Twenty-Seventh Annual George Bugbee Symposium on Hospital Affairs. Sponsored by the University of Chicago Graduate School of Business. Chicago, IL: Center for Health Administration Studies Publications Office, May 1985.

22.

Ensign, G.B. , and J.J. Mayerhofer . "MediCal Contracting: What Impact on California Hospitals?" Hospital Progress 64 (June 1983): 38-43.

23.

Enthoven, A.C. "Managed Competition in Health Care and the Unfinished Agenda." Health Care Financing Review annual supplement (December 1986 ): 105-19.

24.

. " Managed Competition: An Agenda for Action" Health Affairs 7 (Summer 1988): 25-47.

25.

Ermann, D. , and J. Gabel. "Multihospital Systems: Issues and Empirical Findings." Health Affairs 3 (Spring 1984): 50-64.

26.

Feldman, P.H. , and M. Gerteis. "Private Insurance for Medicaid Recipients: The Texas Experience ." Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 12 (Summer 1987): 271-98.

27.

Ferris, J.M. , and E. Graddy. "What Governs the Decision to Contract Out for Local Hospital Services?" Inquiry 24 (Fall 1987): 285-94.

28.

Franklin, J.L. , B. Solovitz , M. Mason , J.R. Clemons , and G.E. Miller. "An Evaluation of Case Management." American Journal of Public Health 6 (June 1987): 674-78.

29.

Freeman, H.E. , and B.L. Kirkman-Liff . "Health Care under AHCCCS: An Examination of Arizona's Alternative to Medicaid." Health Services Research 20 (August 1985): 245-66.

30.

Freund, D.A. , and E. Neuschler. "Overview of Medicaid Capitation and Case-Management Initiatives ." Health Care Financing Review annual supplement (December 1986): 21-30.

31.

Fuchs, V.R. "The 'Competition Revolution' in Health Care." Health Affairs 7 (Summer 1988): 5-24.

32.

Goldbeck, W.B. "Health Care Coalitions." In Health Care Cost Management: Private Sector Initiatives. Edited by P. D. Fox , W. B. Goldbeck , and J. J. Spies. Ann Arbor, MI: Health Administration Press, 1984.

33.

Gottlieb, S.R.V. "Ensuring Access to Health Care: What Communities Can Do to Make a Difference through Private Sector Coalitions." Inquiry 23 (Fall 1986): 322-29.

34.

Gray, B. H. , ed. For-Profit Enterprise in Health Care. Institute of Medicine, Committee on Implications of For-Profit Enterprise in Health Care. Washington, DC: National Academy Press, 1986.

35.

Griffith, B. , S. Iliffe , and G. Rayner. Banking on Sickness: Commercial Medicine in Britain and the USA. London: Lawrence and Wishart , 1987, 78, 81.

36.

Ham, C. Health Policy in Britain. The Politics and Organisation of the National Health Service, 2d. ed. Hampshire, London: Macmillan, 1985, 42.

37.

Henderson, M. , A. Bergman , A. Collard , B. Souder , and S. Wallack. "Private Sector Medical Case Management for High Cost Illness ." Paper presented at the conference "Private Sector Involvement in Health Care: Implications for Access, Cost, and Quality," SRI International, 9 April 1987, Menlo Park, CA.

38.

Hillman, D.G. , and J.B. Christianson . "Competitive Bidding as a Cost-Containment Strategy for Indigent Medical Care: The Implementation Experience in Arizona." Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 9 (Fall 1984): 427-51.

39.

Himmelstein, D.U. , and S. Woolhandler. "Cost without Benefit. Administrative Waste in U.S. Health Care." New England Journal of Medicine 314 (13 February 1986): 441-45.

40.

Horne, D.A. "A Survey of Patients in the Private Sector." Hospital and Health Services Review 80, no. 2 (March 1984): 70-72.

41.

Horne, D. , and A.F. Fairbairn. "Privatisation in the Care of the Elderly." Hospital and Health Services Review 81, no. 6 (November 1985): 284-86.

42.

Iglehart, J.K. "Cutting the Costs of Health Care for the Poor in California: A Two-Year Follow-Up." New England Journal of Medicine 311 (September 1984): 745.

43.

—. "Canada's Health Care System. (Second of three parts)" New England Journal of Medicine 315 (18 September 1986): 778-84.

44.

. " Second Thoughts about HMOs for Medicare Patients." New England Journal of Medicine 316 (4 June 1987): 1,487-92.

45.

Johns, L. , M.D. Anderson , and R.A. Derzon. "Selective Contracting in California: Experience in the Second Year." Inquiry 22 (Winter 1985): 335-47.

46.

Johns, L. , R.A. Derzon , and M.D. Anderson. "Selective Contracting in California: Early Effects and Policy Implications." Inquiry 22 (Spring 1985): 24-32.

47.

Kirkman-Liff, B.J. , J.B. Christianson , and T. Kirkman-Liff . "The Evolution of Arizona's Indigent Care System ." Health Affairs 6 (Winter 1987): 46-58.

48.

Kirlin, J.J. Alternative Structures for Achieving Public Purposes. Sacramento, CA: Governor's Office of Planning and Research , August 1986.

49.

Klett, S.V. "Corporate America Opens the Door to Managed Care." Medical World News 27 (13 January 1986): 52-68.

50.

Kralewski, J.E. , B. Dowd , L. Pitt , and E.L. Biggs. "Effects of Contract Management on Hospital Performance ." Health Services Research 19 (October 1984): 479-98.

51.

Lewin, L.S. , T.J. Eckels , and L.B. Miller. "Setting the Record Straight: The Provision of Uncompensated Care by Not-for-Profit Hospitals." New England Journal of Medicine 318 (5 May 1988): 1,212-15.

52.

Lister, J. "Shattuck Lecture-The Politics of Medicine in Britain and the United States." New England Journal of Medicine 315 (17 July 1986): 168-74.

53.

. " Prospects for the National Health Service." New England Journal of Medicine 318 (2 June 1988): 1,473-76.

54.

Luft, H.S. "How Do Health Maintenance Organizations Achieve Their Savings? Rhetoric and Evidence." New England Journal of Medicine 298 (15 June 1978): 1,336-43.

55.

McCall, N. , D. Henton , S. Haber , L. Paringer , M. Crane , W. Wrightson , and D. Freund. "Evaluation of the Arizona Health Care Cost Containment System, 1984-85." Health Care Financing Review 9 (Winter 1987): 79-90.

56.

Melia, E.P. , L.M. Aucoin , L.J. Duhl , and P.S. Kurokawa. "Competition in the Health-Care Marketplace: A Beginning in California." New England Journal of Medicine 308 (31 March 1983): 788-92.

57.

Merrill, J.C. , and A.B. Cohen. (Editorial) "The Emperor's New Clothes: Unraveling the Myths about Rationing." Inquiry 24 (Summer 1987): 105-09.

58.

Meyers, A.R. , A. Cupples , R.I. Lederman , L.G. Branch , M. Feltin , R.J. Master , K. Nicastro , M. Glover , and D. Kress. "A Prospective Evaluation of the Effect of Managed Care on Medical Care Utilization among Severely Disabled Independently Living Adults " Medical Care 25 (November 1987): 1,057-68.

59.

Miller, I. "Interpreneurship: A Community Coalition Approach to Health Care Reform ." Inquiry 24 (Fall 1987): 266-75.

60.

Navarro, V. "The Public/Private Mix in the Funding and Delivery of Health Services: An International Survey." American Journal of Public Health 75 (November 1985): 1,318-20.

61.

Ohsfeldt, R.L. "Uncompensated Medical Services Provided by Physicians and Hospitals ." Medical Care 23 (December 1985): 1,338-44.

62.

Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development. Financing and Delivering Health Care. A Comparative Analysis of OECD Countries. Social Policy Studies No. 4. Paris: OECD Publications Service, 1986.

63.

Pack, J.R. "Privatization of Public-Sector Services in Theory and Practice." Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 6 (Summer 1987): 523-40.

64.

Patricelli, R.E. "Employers as Managers of Risk, Cost, and Quality." Health Affairs 6 (Fall 1987): 75-81.

65.

Petersdorf, R.G. "Progress Report on Hospital Cost Control in California. More Regulation than Competition." New England Journal of Medicine 309 (28 July 1983): 254-56.

66.

Polchow, M. State Efforts at Health Care Cost Containment: 1986 Update. Denver: National Conference of State Legislatures, December 1986.

67.

Poole, D.L. "The Future of Public-Private Sector Partnerships for the Provision of Human Services: Problems and Possibilities." Journal o f Applied Behavioral Science 21, no. 4 (1985): 393-406.

68.

Prottas, J.M. , and E. Handler. "The Complexities of Managed Care: Operating a Voluntary System." Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 12 (Summer 1987): 253-69.

69.

Reagan, M. "Physicians as Gatekeepers: A Complex Challenge." New England Journal of Medicine 317 (31 December 1987): 1,731-34.

70.

Relman, A.S. "Are Voluntary Hospitals Caring for the Poor?" New England Journal of Medicine 318 (5 May 1988): 1,198-1,200.

71.

Robinson, J.C. , and C. Phibbs. "An Evaluation of Medicaid Selective Contracting in California ." Unpublished, no date.

72.

Rochaix, L. "For-Profit Hospitals for Europe: The Case of Britain and France." Health Policy 4, no. 2 (1984): 149-57.

73.

Roemer, M.I. "Foreign Privatization of National Health Systems." American Journal of Public Health 77 (October 1987): 1,271-72.

74.

Rowland, D. , and B. Lyons. "Mandatory HMO Care for Milwaukee's Poor." Health Affairs 6 (Spring 1987): 87-99.

75.

Rundall, Thomas. "Hospital Contract Management. Organizational and Public Policy Issues ." Health Services Research 19 (October 1984): 455-60.

76.

Rundall, Thomas , and W.K. Lambert. "The Private Management of Public Hospitals." Health Services Research 19 (October 1984): 519-44.

77.

Savas, E.S. "Private Enterprise is Profitable Enterprise." New York Times, sect. 3, 2, 14 February 1988.

78.

Schaller, D.F. , A.W. Bostrom , and J. Rafferty. "Quality of Care Review: Recent Experience in Arizona." Health Care Financing Review annual supplement (December 1986 ): 65-74.

79.

Schlesinger, M. , J. Bentkover , D. Blumenthal , R. Musacchio , and J. Willer. "The Privatization of Health Care and Physicians' Perceptions of Access to Hospital Services." Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly 65, no. 1 ( 1987): 25-58.

80.

Schultze, C.L. The Public Use of Private Interest. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution, 1977, 85, 87, 89-90.

81.

Schwartz, W.B. "The Inevitable Failure of Current Cost-Containment Strategies. Why They Can Provide Only Temporary Relief." Journal of the American Medical Association 257 (9 January 1987): 220-24.

82.

Seay, J.D. , Bruce Vladeck , P.S. Kramer , D.A. Gould , and J.J. McCormack. "Holding Fast to the Good: The Future of the Voluntary Hospital." Inquiry 23 (Fall 1986): 253-60.

83.

Shonick, W. , and R. Roemer. Public Hospitals under Private Management: the California Experience. Berkeley, CA: Institute of Governmental Studies, University of California, Berkeley, 1983, 50.

84.

Shortell, Stephen , E.M. Morrison , S.L. Hughes , B. Friedman , J. Coverdill , and L. Berg. "The Effects of Hospital Ownership on Nontraditional Services ." Health Affairs 5 (Winter 1986): 97-111.

85.

Spitz, B. "A National Survey of Medicaid Case-Management Programs" Health Affairs 6 (Spring 1987): 61-70.

86.

Spitz, B. , and J. Abramson. "Competition, Capitation, and Case Management: Barriers to Strategic Reform." Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly 65, no. 3 (1987): 348-70.

87.

Taylor, H. , and M. Kagay. "The HMO Report Card: A Closer Look." Health Affairs 5 (Spring 1986): 81-89.

88.

Thorpe, K.E. , and C. Brecher. "Access to Care for the Uninsured Poor in Large Cities: Do Public Hospitals Make a Difference?" Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 12 (Summer 1987): 313-24.

89.

Thurman, G. (Administrator, Glen General Hospital, Glen County, CA). Telephone interview, 21 July 1988.

90.

Wheeler, J.R.C. , and H.S. Zuckerman. "Hospital Management Contracts: Institutional and Community Perspectives." Health Services Research 19 (October 1984): 499-518.

91.

Wolfson, J. , P.J. Levin , and W.J. Brock. "Linking Health Care for the Poor to Health Care for Profit ." Health Affairs 6 (Spring 1987): 129-35.

92.

Wortzel, L.H. " 'Privatizing' Does Not Always Work." New York Times , sect. 3., 2, 14 February 1988.

93.

Zaccarelli, H.E. "Contracting with Food Management Companies." Health Care Management Review 8 (Summer 1983): 77-82.