Review Article : Physicians' Background Characteristics and their Career Choices: a Review of the Literature

Aaron, P.R. , Somes, G.W. , Marx, M.B. and Cooper, J.K. (1980). "Relationship between Traits of Kentucky Physicians and Their Practice Areas," Inquiry 17 (Summer 1980): 128-36.

American Medical Association (1973). "Medical Education in the United States, 1972-1973," J. of the American Medical Association 226 (November 19, 1973): 893-1023.

_ ( 1976). "Medical Education in the United States, 1975-1976," J. of the American Medical Association 236 (December 27, 1976): 2935-3082.

( 1977). Physician Distribution and Medical Licensure in the U.S., 1976. Chicago: American Medical Association, 1977.

( 1980). "Medical Education in the United States, 1978-1979," J. of the American Medical Association 243 (March 7, 1980): 835-989.

Association of American Medical Colleges ( 1959). "Datagram: Type of Practice Planned," J. of Medical Education 34 (November 1959): 1108-9.

Balinsky, W.L. (1974). "Distribution of Young Medical Students from Western New York," Medical Care 12 (May 1974): 437-44.

Barish, A.M. (1979). "The Influence of Primary Care Preceptorships and Other Factors on Physicians' Career Choices," Public Health Reports 94 (January-February 1979 ): 36-47.

Becker, G. (1975). Human Capital. 2d ed. New York: Columbia University Press , 1975.

Becker, P. , Hartz, A. and Cuttler, J. (1979). "Time Trends in the Association of a Rural or Urban Background with Physician Location," J. of Medical Education 54 (July 1979): 544-50.

Bible, B.L. (1970). "Physicians' Views of Medical Practice in Nonmetropolitan Communities," Public Health Reports 85 (January 1970): 11-17.

Bidese, C.M. and Danais, D.G. (1982). Physician Characteristics and Distribution in the U.S., 1981 Edition. Chicago: American Medical Association, 1982.

Bodel, P.T. and Short, E.M. (1972). "Women in Medicine: Views from a Medical School ," Clinical Research 20 (February 1972): 125-29.

Bowers, J.Z. (1968). "Special Problems of Women Medical Students," J. of Medical Education 43 (May 1968): 532-37.

Brandt, E.N. , Holmstrom, F. and Fitzsimmons, E.L. (1979). "A Study of UTMB Graduates: 1967-1976," Texas Medicine 75 (June 1979): 54-58.

Brown, L.A. and Belcher, J.C. (1966). "Residential Mobility of Physicians in Georgia ," Rural Sociology 31 (September 1966): 439-48.

Burket, G.E. (1977). "Rural Manpower: A Different Perspective as Viewed by the Kansas Physician and Senior Medical Student," J. of the Kansas Medical Society 78 (November 1977): 475-77.

Buzek, J. and McNamara, M. (1968). "A Partial Solution to the Manpower Problem," J. of Medical Education 43 (November 1968): 1197-99.

Carline, J.D. , Cullen, T.J. , Dohner, C.W. , Schwartz, M.R. and Zinser, E.A. (1980). "Career Preferences of First- and Second-Year Medical Students: The WAMI Experience," J. of Medical Education 55 (August 1980): 682-91.

Champion, D.J. and Olsen, D.B. (1971). "Physician Behavior in Southern Appalachia: Some Recruitment Factors," J. of Health and Social Behavior 12 (September 1971): 245-52.

Charles, E.D. (1971). "Analysis of Policies Designed to Aid Rural Communities Recruit Physicians: A Case Study of Alabama." Ph.D. diss., University of Alabama, 1971.

Chipman, M.L. , Clarke, G.G. and Steiner, J.W. (1969). "Career Choice within Medicine: A Study of One Graduating Class at the University of Toronto," Canadian Medical Association J. 101 (November 29, 1969): 34-39.

Cohen, E.D. and Korper, S.P. (1976a). "Women in Medicine: A Survey of Professional Activities, Career Interruptions, and Conflict Resolutions, Part I," Connecticut Medicine 40 (February 1976): 103-10.

_ ( 1976b). "Women in Medicine: A Survey of Professional Activities, Carcer Interruptions, and Conflict Resolutions, Part II," Connecticut Medicine 40 (March 1976): 195-200.

Coker, R.E. , Back, K.W. , Donnelly, T.G. and Miller, N. (1960). "Patterns of Influence: Medical School Faculty Members and the Values and Specialty Interests of Medical Students," J. of Medical Education 35 (June 1960): 518-27.

Colcman, S. (1976). Physician Distribution and Rural Access to Medical Services. Publication No. R-1887-HEW. Santa Monica. Calif. : Rand Corporation, April 1976.

Collins, F. and Roessler, R. (1975). "Intellectual and Attitudinal Characteristics of Medical Students Selecting Family Practice," J. of Family Practice 2 (December 1975): 431-32.

Crowley, A. E. , ed. (1975a). Medical Education in the United States, 1973-1974. Chicago : American Medical Association, 1975.

_ ( 1975b). "Medical Education in the United States, 1974-1975," J. of the American Medical Association 234 (December 29, 1975): 1325-1432.

Cuca, J.M. (1977). "Career Choices of the 1976 Graduates of U.S. Medical Schools." Washington, D.C.: Association of American Medical Colleges, March 1977. Processed.

Cullison, S. , Reid, C. and Colwill, J.M. (1976a). "Medical School Admissions, Specialty Selection, and Distribution of Physicians," J. of the American Medical Association 235 (February 2, 1976 ): 502-5.

_ ( 1976b). "The Rural-Urban Distribution of Medical School Applicants ," J. of Medical Education 51 (January 1976): 47-49.

Davidson, L.R. (1979). "Choice by Constraint: The Selection and Function of Specialties among Women Physicians-in-Training," J. of Health Politics, Policy and Law 4 (Summer 1979): 200-20.

D'Elia, G. and Johnson, I. (1980). "Women Physicians in a Nonmetropolitan Area," J. of Medical Education 55 (July 1980): 580-88.

Dinkel, R.M. (1946). "Factors Underlying the Location of Physicians within Indiana," American Sociological Review 11 (February 1946): 16-25.

Dykman, R.A. and Stalnaker, J.M. (1957). "Survey of Women Physicians Graduating from Medical School 1925-1940," J. of Medical Education 32 (March 1957, Part 2): 3-38.

Ernst, R.L. and Yett, D.E. Physician Location and Specially Choice. Ann Arbor, Mich. : Health Administration Press, forthcoming.

Ernst, R.L. , Greenlees, J.S. and Yett, D.E. (1978). "U.S. and Foreign Medical Graduates: Comparison of Initial Career Choices." Paper presented at a Joint Session of the American Economic Association and the Health Economics Research Association, Chicago, August 30, 1978.

Fein, R. (1956). "Factors Influencing the Location of North Carolina General Practitioners: A Study in Physician Distribution." Ph.D. diss., Johns Hopkins University, 1956.

Fredericks, M.A. and Mundy, P. (1967). "The Relationship between Social Class, Average Grade in College, Medical School Admission Test Scores, and Academic Achievement of Students in a Medical School," J. of Medical Education 42 (February 1967): 126-33.

Geertsma, R.H. and Grinols, D.R. (1972). "Specialty Choice in Medicine," J. of Medical Education 47 (July 1972): 509-17.

Goodman, L.J. and Mason, H.R. (1976). Physician Distribution and Medical Licensure in the U.S., 1975, Part 1. Chicago: American Medical Association, 1976.

Gordon, T.L. (1978). "1975 Medical School Graduates Entering Family Practice Residencies," J. of Medical Education 53 (November 1978): 939-42.

Gough, H.G. (1978). "Some Predictive Implications of Premedical Scientific Competence and Preferences," J. of Medical Education 53 (April 1978): 291-99.

Gough, H.G. and Ducker, D.G. (1977). "Social Class in Relation to Medical School Performance and Choice of Specialty," J. of Psychology 96 (May 1977): 31-43.

Gough, H.G. and Hall, W.B. (1975). "The Prediction of Academic and Clinical Performance in Medical School," Research in Higher Education 3 (1975): 301-12.

Gray, L.C. (1977). "The Geographic and Functional Distribution of Black Physicians: Some Research and Policy Implications," American J. of Public Health 67 (June 1977): 519-26.

Guzick, D.S. and Jahiel, R.I. (1976). "Distribution of Private Practice Offices of Physicians with Specified Characteristics among Urban Neighborhoods," Medical Care 14 (June 1976): 469-88.

Hadley, J. (1975). "Models of Physicians' Specialty and Location Choices." Ph.D. diss., Yale University, December 1975.

_ ( 1977). "An Empirical Model of Medical Specialty Choice," Inquiry 14 (December 1977): 384-401.

( 1979). "A Disaggregated Model of Medical Specialty Choice," in Research in Health Economics, ed. R. M. Scheffler. Greenwich, Conn.: JAI Press, 1979.

Haley, H.B. , Juan, I.R. and Paiva, R.E.A. (1971). "MCAT Scores in Relation to Personality Measures and Biographical Variables," J. of Medical Education 45 (November 1971): 947-58.

Hassinger, E.W. (1963). "Background and Community Orientation of Rural Physicians Compared with Metropolitan Physicians in Missouri." Research Bulletin No. 822. Columbia, Mo.: College of Agriculture, University of Missouri, 1963. Processed.

Haug, J.N. (1975). "A Review of Women in Surgery," Bull. of the American College of Surgeons 60 (September 1975): 21-23.

Haug, J.N. and Roback, G.A. (1968). Distribution of Physicians, Hospitals, and Hospital Beds in the U.S., 1967. Chicago: American Medical Association, 1968.

_ ( 1970). Distribution of Physicians, Hospitals, and Hospital Beds in the U.S., 1969. Vol. 1. Chicago: American Medical Association, 1970.

Haug, M.R. , Lavin, B. and Breslau, N. (1980). "Practice Location Preferences at Entry to Medical School," J. of Medical Education 55 (April 1980): 333-38.

Haynes, M.A. (1969). "Distribution of Black Physicians in the United States, 1967," J. of the American Medical Association 210 (October 6, 1969): 93-95.

Heald, K.A. , Cooper, J.K. and Coleman, S. (1974). An Analysis of Two Surveys of Recent Medical School Graduates. Publication No. R-1477-HEW. Santa Monica, Calif. : Rand Corporation, 1974.

Held, P.J. (1972). "The Migration of the 1955-65 Graduates of American Medical Schools." Ph.D. diss., University of California , Berkeley, 1972.

Hunter, R.C.A. (1965). "Some Factors Affecting Undergraduate Academic Achievement," Canadian Medical Association J. 92 (April 3, 1965): 732-36.

Johnson, D.G. , Smith, V.C. and Tarnoff, S.L. (1975). "Recruitment and Progress of Minority Medical School Entrants, 1970-72," J. of Medical Education 50 (July 1975): 713-55.

Johnson, S.E. , Baeumler, W.L. and Carter, R.E. (1973). "The Family Physician: A Comparative Study of Minnesota and Wisconsin Family Physicians Practicing in Rural and Urban Communities ," Minnesota Medicine 36 (August 1973): 713-18.

Juan, I.R. and Haley, H.B. (1970). "High and Low Levels of Dogmatism in Relation to Personality, Intellectual, and Environmental Characteristics of Medical Students," Psychological Reports 26 (April 1970): 535-44.

Jussim, J. and Muller, C. (1975). "Medical Education for Women: How Good an Investment ?" J. of Medical Education 50 (June 1975): 571-80.

Kaplan, H.I. (1971). "Women Physicians," New Physician 20 (January 1971):11-19.

Kehrer, B.H. (1974). "Factors Affecting the Incomes of Men and Women Physicians: An Exploratory Analysis." Paper presented at the Annual Meetings of the Southern Economic Association, Atlanta, November 15, 1974.

( 1976). "Factors Affecting the Incomes of Men and Women Physicians: An Exploratory Analysis," J. of Human Resources 11 (Fall 1976): 526-45.

Kosa, J.D. (1969). "The Medical Student: His Career and Religion ," Hospital Progress 50 (April 1969): 51-53.

Kosa, J.D. and Coker, R.E. (1965). "The Female Physician in Public Health: Conflict and Reconciliation of the Sex and Professional Roles," Sociology and Social Research 49 (April 1965 ): 294-305.

Kritzer, H. and Zimet, C.N. (1967). "A Retrospective View of Medical Specialty Choice ," J. of Medical Education 42 (January 1967): 47-58.

Last, J.M. , Martin, F.M. and Stanley, G.R. (1967). "Academic Record and Subsequent Career," Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine 60 (August 1967): 21-24.

Lee, R.H. (1980). "Regional Physician Supply and Graduate Medical Education," Health Policy and Education I (December 1980): 351-66.

Levit, E.J. , Schumacher, C.F. and Hubbard, J.P. (1963). "The Effect of Characteristics of Hospitals in Relation to the Caliber of Interns Obtained and the Competence of Interns After One Year of Training," J. of Medical Education 38 (November 1963): 909-19.

Lieberson, S. (1958). "Ethnic Groups and the Practice of Medicine," American Sociological Review 23 (October 1958): 542-49.

Lief, V.F. , Lief, H.I. and Young, K.M. (1965). "Academic Success: Intelligence and Personality ," J. of Medical Education 40 (Febrttary 1965): 114-24.

Livingston, P.B. and Zimet, C.N. (1965). "Death Anxiety, Authoritarianism, and the Choice of Specialty in Medical Students," J. of Nervous and Mental Disease 140 (March 1965): 222-30.

Lloyd, S.M. , Johnson, D.G. and Mann, M.M. (1978). "Survey of Graduates of a Traditionally Black College of Medicine," J. of Medical Education 53 (August 1978): 640-50.

Long, M.D. (1980). "Specialty Choice of Black Medical School Graduates ," J. of Medical Education 55 (May 1980): 409-14.

Longnecker, D.P. (1975). "Practice Objectives and Goals: A Survey of Family Practice Residents," J. of Family Practice 2 (October 1975): 347-51.

Lopate, C. (1968). Women in Medicine. Baltimore : Johns Hopkins Press, 1968.

Lyden, F.J. , Geiger, H.J. and Peterson, O.L. (1968). The Training of Good Physicians. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1968.

Mantovani, R.E. , Gordon, T.L. and Johnson, D.G. (1976). Medical Student Indebtedness and Career Plans, 1974-75. DHEW Publication No. (HRA) 77-21. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, September 1976.

Martin, B.C. , (1975). Medical School Alumni. Rockville, Md.: Aspen Systems Corporation, 1975.

Martin, E.D. , Moffat, R.E. , Falter, R.T. and Walker, J.D. (1968). "Where Graduates Go. The University of Kansas School of Medicine: A Study of the Profile of 959 Graduates and Factors Which Influenced the Geographic Distribution," J. of the Kansas Medical Society 49 (March 1968): 84-89.

Mason, H.R. (1975). "Medical School, Residency, and Eventual Practice Location: Toward a Rationale for State Support of Medical Education," J. of the American Medical Association 233 (July 7, 1975): 49-52.

Matthews, M.R. (1970). "The Training and Practice of Women Physicians: A Case Study," J. of Medical Education 45 (December 1970): 1016-24.

Monk, M.A. and Terris, M. (1956). "Factors in Student Choice of General or Specialty Practice," New England J. of Medicine 255 (December 13, 1956): 1135-40.

Monk, M.A. and Thomas, C.B. (1970). "Characteristics of Male Medical Students Related to Their Subsequent Careers," Johns Hophins Medical J. 127 (November 1970): 254-72.

_ ( 1973). "Personal and Social Factors Related to Medical Specialty Practice," Johns Hopkins Medical J. 133 (July 1973): 19-29.

Oates, R.P. and Feldman, H.A. (1971). "Medical Career Patterns: Choices among Several Classes of Medical Students." New York State J. of Medicine 71 (October 15, 1971): 2437-40.

_ ( 1974). "Patterns of Change in Medical Student Career Choices ," J. of Medical Education 49 (June 1974): 563-69.

Otis, G.D. and Weiss, J. (1972). "Explorations in Medical Career Choice." Report on Contract No. (NIH) 71-4066, U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, May 1972. Processed.

Paiva, R.E.A. and Haley, H.B. (1971). "Intellectual, Personality, and Environmental Factors in Career Specialty Preferences," J. of Medical Education 46 (April 1971): 281-89.

Paul, D.W. (1978). "Regional Physician Maldistribution," Texas Medicine 74 (May 1978): 116-22.

Perlstadt, H. (1972). "Internship Placements and Faculty Influence," J. of Medical Education 47 (November 1972): 862-68.

Peterson, O.L. , Lyden, F.J. , Geiger, H.J. and Colton, T. (1963). "Appraisal of Medica! Students' Abilities as Related to Training and Careers After Graduation," New England J. of Medicine 269 (November 23, 1963 ): 1174-82.

Powers, L. , Parmelle, R.D. and Wiesenfelder, H. (1969). "Practice Patterns of Women and Men Physicians," J. of Medical Education 44 (June 1969): 481-91.

Renshaw, J.E. and Pennell, M.S. (1971). "Distribution of Women Physicians, 1969," Woman Physician 25 (April 1971): 187-98.

Roleston, K.I. (1973). Michigan Medical Manpower Study: An Investigation of the Decision-Making Factors among Medical Students, Interns, and Residents, and an Evaluation of Proposed Loan Programs for Retaining Medical Manpower . Detroit: Blue Shield of Michigan , 1973.

Rosenlund, M.L. and Oski, F.A. (1967). "Women in Medicine," Annals of Internal Medicine 46 (May 1967): 1008-12.

Rothman, A.I. (1973). "A Comparison of Persistent High and Low Achievers Through Four Years of Undergraduate Medical Training," J. of Medical Education 48 (February 1973): 180-82.

Rushing, W.A. (1975). Community, Physicians, and Inequality. Lexington, Mass.: D. C. Heath and Company, 1975.

Sanazaro, P.J. (1965). "Research in Medical Education: Exploratory Analysis of a Black-box," Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 128 (September 1965): 519-31.

Schaupp, F.W. (1969). "A Study of Factors Influencing Outmigration of M.D. Graduates of West Virginia University, 1926-66." Morgantown, W.Va.: Bureau of Business Research, West Virginia University, January 1969. Processed.

Scher, M. (1973). "Women Psychiatrists in the United States," American J. of Psychiatry 10 (October 1973): 1118-22.

Schumacher, C.F. (1964). "Personal Characteristics of Students Choosing Different Types of Medical Careers," J. of Medical Education 39 (March 1964): 278-88.

Schwartz, L.E. and Cantwell, J.R. (1976). "Weiskotten Survey, Class of 1960: A Profile of Physician Location and Specialty Choice," J. of Medical Education 51 (July 1976): 533-40.

Shapiro, C.S. , Stibler, B. , Zelkovic, A.A. and Mausner, J.S. (1968). "Careers of Women Physicians: A Survey of Women Graduates from Seven Medical Schools, 1945-51," J. of Medical Education 43 (October 1968): 1033-40.

Stefanu, C. and Pate, M.L. (1978). "Location of Residency: Analysis of a Critical Determinant in Keeping Physicians in Texas," Texas Medicine 74 (June 1978): 61-65.

Stefanu, C. , Pate, M.L. and Chapman, J.S. (1979). "Hospitals and Medical Schools as Factors in the Selection of Location of Practice," J. of Medical Education 54 (May 1979): 379-83.

Taylor, M. , Dickman, W. and Kane, R. (1973). "Medical Students' Attitudes Toward Rural Practice ," J. of Medical Education 48 (October 1973): 885-95.

Thompson, T. (1974a). "Curbing the Black Physician Manpower Shortage ," J. of Medical Education 49 (October 1974): 944-49.

( 1974b). "Selected Characteristics of Black Physicians in the United States, 1972," J. of the American Medical Association 229 (September 23, 1974): 1758-61.

Thurow, L. (1970). Investment in Human Capital. Belmont, Calif.: Wadsworth, 1970.

Turner, E.V. , Helper, M.M. and Kriska, S.D. (1974). "Predictors of Clinical Performance," J. of Medical Education 49 (April 1974): 338-42.

U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare (1974). How Medical Students Finance Their Education. DHEW Publication No. 75-13. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, June 1974.

Walsh, R.J. , Aherne, P. and Ryan, G.A. (1972). 1972 Reference Data on the Profile of Medical Practice. Chicago: American Medical Association, 1972.

Watson, C.J. (1980a). "An Empirical Model of Physician Practice Location Decisions." Computers and Biomedical Research 13 (August 1980): 363-81.

( 1980b). "The Relationship between Physician Practice Location and Medical School Area: An Empirical Model," Social Science & Medicine 14 (March 1980): 63-69.

Weil, P.A. and Schleiter, M.K. (1981). "National Study of Internal Medicine Manpower: VI. Factors Predicting Preferences of Residents for Careers in Primary Care and in Clinical Practice or Academic Medicine," Annals of Internal Medicine 94 (May 1981): 691-703.

Weil, P.A. , Schleiter, M.K. and Tarlov, A.R. (1981). "National Study of Internal Medicine Manpower: V. Comparison of Residents in Internal Medicine—Future Generalists and Subspecialists," Annals of Internal Medicine 94 (May 1981): 678-90.

Weiskotten, H.G. , Wiggins, W.S. , Altenderfer, M.E. , Gooch, M. and Tipner, A. (1960). "Trends in Medical Practice: An Analysis of the Distribution and Characteristics of Medical College Graduates, 1915-50," J. of Medical Education 35 (December 1960): 1071-1121.

Weisman, C.S. , Levine, D.M. , Steinwachs, D.M. and Chase, G.A. (1980). "Male and Female Physician Career Patterns: Specialty Choices and Graduate Training," J. of Medical Education 55 (October 1980): 813-25.

Westling-Wilkstrand, H. , Monk, M.A. and Thomas, C.B. (1970). "Some Characteristics Related to the Career Status of Women Physicians," Johns Hopkins Medical J. 127 (November 1970): 273-86.

Wiggins, W.S. , Green, F. and Altenderfer, M.E. (1970). Trends in Medical Practice — An Analysis of the Distribution and Characteristics of Medical College Graduates, 1915-1955. Chicago: American Medical Association, 1970.

Williams, P.A. (1971). "Women in Medicine: Some Themes and Variations ," J. of Medical Education 46 (July 1971): 584-91.

Wooldridge, J. (1976). "Differences in Pricing Policy, Modes of Practice and Location between White Male and Minority Physicians." Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Western Economic Association , San Francisco, June 1976.

Wunderman, L.E. (1979). Physician Distribution and Medical Licensure in the U.S., 1978. Chicago: American Medical Association, 1979.

_ ( 1980). "Female Physicians in the 1970s: Their Changing Roles in Medicine," in Profile of Medical Practice, 1980, eds. G. L. Glandon and R. J. Shapiro. Chicago: American Medical Association, 1980.

Yett, D.E. and Sloan, F.A. (1974). "Migration Patterns of Recent Medical School Graduates ," Inquiry 11 (June 1974): 125-42.