Racial and ethnic disparities in cardiovascular disease (CVD) outcomes are widely reported, but research has largely focused on differences in quality of inpatient and urgent care to explain these disparate outcomes. The objective of this review is to synthesize recent evidence on racial and ethnic disparities in management of CVD in the ambulatory setting. Database searches yielded 550 articles of which 25 studies met the inclusion criteria. Reviewed studies were categorized into non-interventional studies examining the association between race and receipt of ambulatory CVD services with observational designs, and interventional studies evaluating specific clinical courses of action intended to ameliorate disparities. Based on the Donabedian framework, this review demonstrates that significant racial/ethnic disparities persist in process and outcome measures of quality of ambulatory CVD care. Multimodal interventions were most effective in reducing disparities in CVD outcomes.
American College of Cardiology, American Heart Association, & Physician Consortium for Performance Improvement. (2005a). Clinical performance measures: Chronic stable coronary artery disease. Chicago, IL: American Medical Association.
2.
American College of Cardiology, American Heart Association, & Physician Consortium for Performance Improvement. (2005b). Clinical performance measures: Heart failure. Chicago, IL: American Medical Association.
3.
AndersonR. E.AyanianJ. Z.ZaslavskyA. M.McWilliamsJ. M. (2014). Quality of care and racial disparities in Medicare among potential ACOs. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 29, 1296-1304.
4.
AyanianJ. Z.UdvarhelyiI. S.GatsonisC. A.PashosC. L.EpsteinA. M. (1993). Racial differences in the use of revascularization procedures after coronary angiography. Journal of American Medical Association, 269, 2642-2646.
5.
BarnatoA. E.LucasF. L.StaigerD.WennbergD. E.ChandraA. (2005). Hospital-level racial disparities in acute myocardial infarction treatment and outcomes. Medical Care, 43, 308-319.
6.
BerwickD. M. (2011). Launching accountable care organizations—The proposed rule for the Medicare Shared Savings Program. New England Journal of Medicine, 364, e32.
7.
BetancourtJ. R.GreenA. R.CarrilloJ. E.Ananeh-FirempongO.II. (2003). Defining cultural competence: A practical framework for addressing racial/ethnic disparities in health and health care. Public Health Reports, 118, 293-302.
8.
BetancourtJ. R.GreenA. R.CarrilloJ. E.ParkE. R. (2005). Cultural competence and health care disparities: Key perspectives and trends. Health Affairs, 24, 499-505.
9.
BlairI. V.SteinerJ. F.HanrattyR.PriceD. W.FaircloughD. L.DaughertyS. L.. . . HavranekE. P. (2014). An investigation of associations between clinicians’ ethnic or racial bias and hypertension treatment, medication adherence and blood pressure control. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 29, 987-995.
10.
BosworthH. B.OlsenM. K.GrubberJ. M.PowersB. J.OddoneE. Z. (2011). Racial differences in two self-management hypertension interventions. American Journal of Medicine, 124, 468.e1-468.e8.
11.
BosworthH. B.PowersB.GrubberJ. M.ThorpeC. T.OlsenM. K.OrrM.OddoneE. Z. (2008). Racial differences in blood pressure control: Potential explanatory factors. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 23, 692-698.
12.
BradleyE. H.HerrinJ.WangY.McNamaraR. L.WebsterT. R.MagidD. J.. . . KrumholzH. M. (2004). Racial and ethnic differences in time to acute reperfusion therapy for patients hospitalized with myocardial infarction. Journal of American Medical Association, 292, 1563-1572.
13.
CantoJ. G.AllisonJ. J.KiefeC. I.FincherC.FarmerR.SekarP.. . . WeissmanN. W. (2000). Relation of race and sex to the use of reperfusion therapy in Medicare beneficiaries with acute myocardial infarction. New England Journal of Medicine, 342, 1094-1100.
14.
ChanP. S.OetgenW. J.BuchananD.MitchellK.FiocchiF. F.TangF.. . . SpertusJ. A. (2010). Cardiac performance measure compliance in outpatients: The American College of Cardiology and National Cardiovascular Data Registry’s PINNACLE (Practice Innovation and Clinical Excellence) program. Journal of the American College of Cardiology, 56, 8-14.
15.
ChoM. K.BeroL. A. (1994). Instruments for assessing the quality of drug studies published in the medical literature. Journal of American Medical Association, 272, 101-104.
16.
ChobanianA. V.BakrisG. L.BlackH. R.CushmanW. C.GreenL. A.IzzoJ. L.Jr.. . . RoccellaE. J. (2003). The seventh report of the joint national committee on prevention, detection, evaluation, and treatment of high blood pressure: The JNC 7 report. Journal of American Medical Association, 289, 2560-2571.
17.
CohenM. G.FonarowG. C.PetersonE. D.MoscucciM.DaiD.HernandezA. F.. . . SmithS. C. (2010). Racial and ethnic differences in the treatment of acute myocardial infarction findings from the get with the guidelines–Coronary Artery Disease program. Circulation, 121, 2294-2301.
18.
CookN. L.AyanianJ. Z.OravE. J.HicksL. S. (2009). Differences in specialist consultations for cardiovascular disease by race, ethnicity, gender, insurance status, and site of primary care. Circulation, 119, 2463-2470.
19.
CrowderR. S.IronsB. K.MeyerroseG.SeifertC. F. (2010). Factors associated with increased hospital utilization in patients with heart failure and preserved ejection fraction. Pharmacotherapy: Journal of Human Pharmacology and Drug Therapy, 30, 646-653.
20.
DavisA. M.VinciL. M.OkwuosaT. M.ChaseA. R.HuangE. S. (2007). Cardiovascular health disparities: A systematic review of health care interventions. Medical Care Research and Review, 64, 29S-100S
21.
DonabedianA. (1988). The quality of care: How can it be assessed?Journal of American Medical Association, 260, 1743-1748.
22.
EapenZ. J.LiangL.ShubrookJ. H.BaumanM. A.BufalinoV. J.BhattD. L.. . . HernandezA. F. (2014). Current quality of cardiovascular prevention for Million Hearts: An analysis of 147,038 outpatients from The Guideline Advantage. American Heart Journal, 168, 398-404.
23.
EstesN. M.HalperinJ. L.CalkinsH.EzekowitzM. D.GitmanP.GoA. S.. . . WyseD. G. (2008). ACC/AHA/Physician Consortium 2008 clinical performance measures for adults with nonvalvular atrial fibrillation or atrial flutter: A report of the American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association Task Force on Performance Measures and the Physician Consortium for Performance Improvement (Writing Committee to Develop Clinical Performance Measures for Atrial Fibrillation) developed in collaboration with the Heart Rhythm Society. Journal of the American College of Cardiology, 51, 865-884. doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2008.01.006
24.
FlackJ. M.SicaD. A.BakrisG.BrownA. L.FerdinandK. C.GrimmR. H.Jr.. . . NasserS. (2010). Management of high blood pressure in Blacks: An update of the international society on hypertension in Blacks consensus statement. Hypertension, 56, 780-800.
25.
GoldsteinK. M.MelnykS. D.ZulligL. L.StechuchakK. M.OddoneE.BastianL. A.. . . BosworthH. B. (2014). Heart matters: Gender and racial differences in cardiovascular disease risk factor control among veterans. Women’s Health Issues, 24, 477-483.
26.
GoldsteinL. B.AdamsR.BeckerK.FurbergC. D.GorelickP. B.HademenosG.. . . del ZoppoG. J. (2001). Primary prevention of ischemic stroke: A statement for healthcare professionals from the Stroke Council of the American Heart Association. Circulation, 103, 163-182.
27.
HannanE. L.RaczM.WalfordG.ClarkL. T.HolmesD. R.KingS. B.SharmaS. (2007). Differences in utilization of drug-eluting stents by race and payer. American Journal of Cardiology, 100, 1192-1198.
28.
HannanE. L.van RynM.BurkeJ.StoneD.KumarD.AraniD.. . . DeBuonoB. A. (1999). Access to coronary artery bypass surgery by race/ethnicity and gender among patients who are appropriate for surgery. Medical Care, 37, 68-77.
29.
HutchinsonR. N.ShinS. (2014). Systematic review of health disparities for cardiovascular diseases and associated factors among American Indian and Alaska Native populations. PLoS ONE, 9, e80973.
30.
JamesP. A.OparilS.CarterB. L.CushmanW. C.Dennison-HimmelfarbC.HandlerJ.. . . OrtizE. (2014). 2014 evidence-based guideline for the management of high blood pressure in adults: Report from the panel members appointed to the eighth Joint National Committee (JNC 8). Journal of American Medical Association, 311, 507-520.
31.
Jean-JacquesM.PersellS. D.ThompsonJ. A.Hasnain-WyniaR.BakerD. W. (2012). Changes in disparities following the implementation of a health information technology-supported quality improvement initiative. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 27, 71-77.
32.
JohnsonP. A.LeeT. H.CookE. F.RouanG. W.GoldmanL. (1993). Effect of race on the presentation and management of patients with acute chest pain. Annals of Internal Medicine, 118, 593-601.
33.
KoffmanD. M. M.LanzaA.CampbellK. P. (2008). A purchaser’s guide to clinical preventive services: A tool to improve health care coverage for prevention. Preventing Chronic Disease, 5. Retrieved from https://www.cdc.gov/pcd/issues/2008/apr/07_0220.htm
34.
KurianA. K.CardarelliK. M. (2007). Racial and ethnic differences in cardiovascular disease risk factors: A systematic review. Ethnicity & Disease, 17, 143-152.
35.
LebrunL. A.ShiL.ZhuJ.SharmaR.SripipatanaA.HayashiA. S.. . . Ngo-MetzgerQ. (2013). Racial/ethnic differences in clinical quality performance among health centers. Journal of Ambulatory Care Management, 36, 24-34.
36.
LeweyJ.ChoudhryN. K. (2014). The current state of ethnic and racial disparities in cardiovascular care: Lessons from the past and opportunities for the future. Current Cardiology Reports, 16(10), 1-11.
37.
MeadowsT. A.BhattD. L.HirschA. T.CreagerM. A.CaliffR. M.OhmanE. M.. . . GabrielS. P. (2009). Ethnic differences in the prevalence and treatment of cardiovascular risk factors in US outpatients with peripheral arterial disease: Insights from the Reduction of Atherothrombosis for Continued Health (REACH) Registry. American Heart Journal, 158, 1038-1045.
38.
MirvisD. M.BurnsR.GaschenL.CloarF. T.GraneyM. (1994). Variation in utilization of cardiac procedures in the Department of Veterans Affairs health care system: Effect of race. Journal of the American College of Cardiology, 24, 1297-1304.
39.
MirvisD. M.GraneyM. J. (1998). Impact of race and age on the effects of regionalization of cardiac procedures in the Department of Veterans Affairs health care system. American Journal of Cardiology, 81, 982-987.
40.
MokweE.OhmitS. E.NasserS. A.ShafiT.SaundersE.CrookE.. . . FlackJ. M. (2004). Determinants of blood pressure response to quinapril in Black and White hypertensive patients: The Quinapril Titration Interval Management Evaluation trial. Hypertension, 43, 1202-1207.
41.
NdumeleC. D.ShaykevichS.WilliamsD.HicksL. S. (2010). Disparities in adherence to hypertensive care in urban ambulatory settings. Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved, 21(1), 132-143.
42.
NelsonA. R.SmedleyB. D.StithA. Y. (2002). Unequal treatment: Confronting racial and ethnic disparities in health care. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
43.
NiskaR.HanB. (2009). Anticoagulation for patients with atrial fibrillation in ambulatory care settings. Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine, 22, 299-306.
44.
PearsonT. A.BlairS. N.DanielsS. R.EckelR. H.FairJ. M.FortmannS. P.. . . TaubertK. A. (2002). AHA guidelines for primary prevention of cardiovascular disease and stroke: 2002 Update consensus panel guide to comprehensive risk reduction for adult patients without coronary or other atherosclerotic vascular diseases. Circulation, 106, 388-391.
45.
PetersenL. A.WrightS. M.PetersonE. D.DaleyJ. (2002). Impact of race on cardiac care and outcomes in veterans with acute myocardial infarction. Medical Care, 40, 186-196.
46.
PetersonE. D.WrightS. M.DaleyJ.ThibaultG. E. (1994). Racial variation in cardiac procedure use and survival following acute myocardial infarction in the Department of Veterans Affairs. Journal of American Medical Association, 271, 1175-1180.
47.
PoonI.LalL. S.FordM. E.BraunU. K. (2009). Racial/ethnic disparities in medication use among veterans with hypertension and dementia: A national cohort study. Annals of Pharmacotherapy, 43, 185-193.
48.
PopescuI.Vaughan-SarrazinM. S.RosenthalG. E. (2007). Differences in mortality and use of revascularization in Black and White patients with acute MI admitted to hospitals with and without revascularization services. Journal of American Medical Association, 297, 2489-2495.
49.
PrinceD. Z.SobolevM.GaoJ.TaubC. C. (2014). Racial disparities in cardiac rehabilitation initiation and the effect on survival. Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation, 6, 486-492.
50.
RathoreS. S.KetchamJ. D.AlexanderG. C.EpsteinA. J. (2009). Influence of patient race on physician prescribing decisions: A randomized on-line experiment. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 24, 1183-1191.
51.
RehmanS. U.HutchisonF. N.HendrixK.OkonofuaE. C.EganB. M. (2005). Ethnic differences in blood pressure control among men at Veterans Affairs clinics and other health care sites. Archives of Internal Medicine, 165, 1041-1047.
52.
ReynoldsD.CurtisA. B.GheorghiadeM.MehraM. R.O’ConnorC. M.WalshM. N.. . . FonarowG. C. (2012). Race and improvements in the use of guideline-recommended therapies for patients with heart failure: Findings from IMPROVE HF. Journal of the National Medical Association, 104, 287-298.
53.
SabatineM. S.BlakeG. J.DraznerM. H.MorrowD. A.SciricaB. M.MurphyS. A.. . . CannonC. P. (2005). Influence of race on death and ischemic complications in patients with non–ST-elevation acute coronary syndromes despite modern, protocol-guided treatment. Circulation, 111, 1217-1224.
54.
SahaS.FreemanM.ToureJ.TippensK. M.WeeksC.IbrahimS. (2008). Racial and ethnic disparities in the VA health care system: A systematic review. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 23, 654-671.
55.
SedlisS. P.FisherV. J.TiceD.EspositoR.MadmonL.SteinbergE. H. (1997). Racial differences in performance of invasive cardiac procedures in a Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 50, 899-901.
56.
ShelleyD.TsengT.-Y.AndrewsH.RavenellJ.WuD.FerrariP.. . . KopalH. (2011). Predictors of blood pressure control among hypertensives in community health centers. American Journal of Hypertension, 24, 1318-1323.
57.
SingerD. E.AlbersG. W.DalenJ. E.GoA. S.HalperinJ. L.ManningW. J. (2004). Antithrombotic therapy in atrial fibrillation: The Seventh ACCP Conference on Antithrombotic and Thrombolytic Therapy. CHEST Journal, 126, 429S-456S.
58.
SmithS. C.AllenJ.BlairS. N.BonowR. O.BrassL. M.FonarowG. C.. . . TaubertK. A. (2006). AHA/ACC guidelines for secondary prevention for patients with coronary and other atherosclerotic vascular disease: 2006 Update: Endorsed by the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute. Journal of the American College of Cardiology, 47, 2130-2139.
59.
SonelA. F.GoodC. B.MulgundJ.RoeM. T.GiblerW. B.SmithS. C.. . . PteresonE. D. (2005). Racial variations in treatment and outcomes of black and white patients with high-risk non–ST-elevation acute coronary syndromes. Circulation, 111, 1225-1232.
60.
TaylorA. L.ZiescheS.YancyC.CarsonP.D’AgostinoR.Jr.FerdinandK.. . . CohnJ. N. (2004). Combination of isosorbide dinitrate and hydralazine in blacks with heart failure. New England Journal of Medicine, 351, 2049-2057.
61.
TurnerB. J.HollenbeakC.WeinerM. G.Ten HaveT.RobertsC. (2009). Barriers to adherence and hypertension control in a racially diverse representative sample of elderly primary care patients. Pharmacoepidemiology & Drug Safety, 18, 672-681.
62.
UlmerC.McFaddenB.NerenzD. R. (2009). Race, ethnicity, and language data: Standardization for health care quality improvement (Chapter 3: Defining categorization needs for race and ethnicity data). Rockville, MD: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. Retrieved from http://www.ahrq.gov/research/findings/final-reports/iomracereport/reldata3b.html
63.
VaccarinoV.RathoreS. S.WengerN. K.FrederickP. D.AbramsonJ. L.BarronH. V.. . . KrumholzH. M. (2005). Sex and racial differences in the management of acute myocardial infarction, 1994 through 2002. New England Journal of Medicine, 353, 671-682.
64.
WhittleJ.ConigliaroJ.GoodC. B.LofgrenR. P. (1993). Racial differences in the use of invasive cardiovascular procedures in the Department of Veterans Affairs medical system. New England Journal of Medicine, 329, 621-627.
65.
WillsonM. N.NeumillerJ. J.SclarD. A.RobisonL. M.SkaerT. L. (2010). Ethnicity/race, use of pharmacotherapy, scope of physician-ordered cholesterol screening, and provision of diet/nutrition or exercise counseling during US office-based visits by patients with hyperlipidemia. American Journal of Cardiovascular Drugs, 10, 105-108.
66.
WolfP. A.ClagettG. P.EastonJ. D.GoldsteinL. B.GorelickP. B.Kelly-HayesM.. . . WhisnantJ. P. (1999). Preventing ischemic stroke in patients with prior stroke and transient ischemic attack: A statement for healthcare professionals from the Stroke Council of the American Heart Association. Stroke, 30, 1991-1994.
67.
WrightJ. T.DunnJ. K.CutlerJ. A.DavisB. R.CushmanW. C.FordC. E.. . . HabibG. B. (2005). Outcomes in hypertensive black and nonblack patients treated with chlorthalidone, amlodipine, and lisinopril. Journal of American Medical Association, 293, 1595-1608.
68.
YiS. S.TabaeiB. P.AngellS. Y.RapinA.BuckM. D.PaganoW. G.. . . ChamanyS. (2015). Self-blood pressure monitoring in an urban, ethnically diverse population: A randomized clinical trial utilizing the electronic health record. Circulation: Cardiovascular Quality and Outcomes, 8, 138-145.
69.
YoonP. W.TongX.SchmidtS. M.Matson-KoffmanD. (2011). Peer reviewed: Clinical preventive services for patients at risk for cardiovascular disease, National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey, 2005-2006. Preventing Chronic Disease, 8, A43. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3073436/
70.
ZhaoB.JoseP. O.PuJ.ChungS.AnchetaI. B.FortmannS. P.PalaniappanL. P. (2014). Racial/ethnic differences in hypertension prevalence, treatment, and control for outpatients in northern California 2010–2012. American Journal of Hypertension, 28, 631-639.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
