Monte Carlo Analysis of Payer and Provider Risks in Shared Savings Arrangements

Abstract

This article provides a thorough empirical analysis of random variation in shared savings arrangements. It uses claims data from seven provider coalitions that applied for certification to become Medicaid accountable care organizations (ACOs) in New Jersey to conduct Monte Carlo simulations under varying assumptions about true ACO savings. Among all the ACOs examined, the observed savings rate can be several percentage points higher or lower than the assumed true savings rate, leading to large probabilities of Type I and Type II error in determining the existence of savings. Although the effects of random variation are smaller for larger ACOs, the ACO-level coefficient of variation in health care spending also stands out as a highly relevant parameter. The risks of overpayment and underpayment can be minimized through modified specification of the savings measurement methodology. These findings have implications for the terms of shared savings arrangements negotiated between payers and providers.

Keywords

shared savings accountable care organizations performance measurement payment reform delivery reform

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ash

A. S.

Fienberg

S. E.

Louis

T. A.

Normand

S. T.

Stukel

T. A.

Utts

(2012). Statistical issues in assessing hospital performance (Rev. ed.). Baltimore, MD: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.

Bailit

Hughes

(2011, August). Key design elements of shared-savings payment arrangements (Pub. No. 1539). New York, NY: Commonwealth Fund.

Bailit

Hughes

Burns

Freedman

D. H.

(2012, August). Shared-savings payment arrangements in health care: Six case studies (Pub. No. 1624). New York, NY: Commonwealth Fund.

Cameron

A. C.

Trivedi

P. K.

(2010). Microeconometrics using Stata (Rev. ed.). College Station, TX: Stata.

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. (2011). Medicare program; Medicare Shared Savings Program: Accountable care organizations. Final rule. Federal Register, 76, 67802-67990.

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. (2014). Medicare program; Medicare Shared Savings Program: Accountable care organizations. Proposed rule. Federal Register, 79, 72760-72872.

Crawford

McGinnis

Auerbach

Golden

(2015, March). Population health in Medicaid delivery system reforms. New York, NY: Milbank Memorial Fund.

DeLia

(2013). Leaving it to chance: The effects of random variation in shared savings arrangements. Health Services and Outcomes Research Methodology, 13, 219-240.

DeLia

Hoover

Cantor

J. C.

(2012). Statistical uncertainty in the Medicare Shared Savings Program. Medicare & Medicaid Research Review, 2(4), E1-E15.

10.

Efron

Tibshirani

R. J.

(1994). An introduction to the bootstrap. Boca Raton, FL: Chapman & Hall/CRC.

11.

Fisher

E. S.

McClellan

M. B.

Bertko

Lieberman

S. M.

Lee

J. J.

Lewis

J. L.

. . . Skinner

J. S.

(2009). Fostering accountable health care: Moving forward in Medicare. Health Affairs, 28, w219-w231.

12.

Friedberg

M. W.

Buendia

A. M.

Lauderdale

K. E.

Hussey

P. S.

(2013). Option pricing: A flexible tool to disseminate shared savings contracts. American Journal of Managed Care, 19, e295-e292.

13.

Ghandi

(2015). ACO update: A slower pace of growth. Philadelphia, PA: Oliver Wyman.

14.

Iezzoni

L. I.

(Ed.). (2012). Risk adjustment for measuring health care outcomes (4th ed.). Chicago, IL: Health Administration Press.

15.

Kronick

Gilmer

Dreyfus

Lee

(2000). Improving health-based payment for Medicaid beneficiaries: CDPS. Health Care Financing Review, 21(3), 29-64.

16.

Lewis

V. A.

McClurg

A. B.

Smith

Fisher

E. S.

Bynum

J. P.

(2013). Attributing patients to accountable care organizations: Performance year approach aligns stakeholders’ interests. Health Affairs, 32, 587-595.

17.

Luft

H. S.

(2012). From small area variations to accountable care organizations: How health services research can inform policy. Annual Review of Public Health, 33, 377-392.

18.

Pope

G. C.

Kautter

Ellis

R. P.

Ash

A. S.

Ayanian

J. Z.

Lezzoni

L. I.

. . . Robst

(2004). Risk adjustment of Medicare capitation payments using the CMS-HCC model. Health Care Financing Review, 25(4), 119-141.

19.

Varian

H. R.

(1992). Microeconomic analysis (3rd ed.). New York, NY: W. W. Norton.

20.

Weissman

J. S.

Bailit

D’Andrea

Rosenthal

M. B.

(2012). The design and application of shared savings programs: Lessons from early adopters. Health Affairs, 31, 1959-1968.