What Should We Expect? A Comparison of the Community Benefit and Projected Government Support of Maryland Hospitals

Abstract

Designation as a tax-exempt, not-for-profit entity carries with it specific tax benefits. In exchange for tax exemptions, not-for-profit entities are expected to provide benefits to their communities. To evaluate whether hospitals provide community benefits (CBs) equivalent to the financial subsidies and advantages extended to them, tax liabilities and financial support were projected for all Maryland acute care hospitals between 2010 and 2012 and in the aggregate over the 3 years of this study. A comparison was then made between the provision of CBs and the financial support that governments provide to the hospitals. The results indicate that hospitals provide significantly and substantially more CBs than the material financial support they receive. Even after modeling changes in CB activities and the associated tax liabilities that may result from transitioning to taxable status, the benefits that hospitals provide to the communities they serve continue to exceed the potential government tax revenues.

Keywords

community benefit tax liability not-for-profit hospitals hospital tax exemption government support

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Hospital Association. (2013). Fast facts on U.S. hospitals. Retrieved from http://www.aha.org/research/rc/stat-studies/fast-facts.shtml

Bakken

Kindig

D. A.

(2012). Is hospital “community benefit” charity care? WMJ, 111, 215-219.

Bartlett

(2013). Effective corporate tax rates. Retrieved from http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/11/26/effective-corporate-tax-rates/?_php=true&_type=blogs&_r=0

Bob Jones Univ. v. United States, 461 U.S. 574, 588 (1983).

Brealey

R. A.

Myers

S. C.

Allen

(2014). Principles of corporate finance. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.

Brueckner

J. K.

Saavedra

L. A.

(2001). Do local governments engage in strategic property tax competition? National Tax Journal, 54, 203-229.

Byrd

Landry

(2012). Distinguishing community benefits: Tax exemption versus organizational legitimacy. Journal of Healthcare Management, 45, 119-136.

Chirinko

R. S.

Wilson

D. J.

(2011, July). Tax competition among US states: Racing to the bottom or riding on a seesaw? (CESifo Working Paper No. 3535). Retrieved from http://www.cesifo-group.de/portal/page/portal/DocBase_Content/WP/WP-CESifo_Working_Papers/wp-cesifo-2011/wp-cesifo-2011-07/cesifo1_wp3535.pdf

Clark

R. C.

(1980). Does the nonprofit form fit the hospital industry? Harvard Law Review, 93, 1416-1489.

10.

Cohen

H. A.

(2010). Maryland’s all-payor hospital payment system. Retrieved from http://www.hscrc.state.md.us/documents/HSCRC_PolicyDocumentsReports/GeneralInformation/MarylandAll-PayorHospitalSystem.pdf

11.

Colombo

J. D.

(2005). Failure of community benefit. Health Matrix, 15, 29-65.

12.

Colombo

J. D.

(2006). The role of tax exemption in a competitive health care market. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 31, 623-642.

13.

Comptroller of Maryland. (2014a). Medicine and medical equipment. Retrieved from http://taxes.marylandtaxes.com/Business_Taxes/Business_Tax_Types/Sales_and_Use_Tax/Tax_Information/Special_Situations/Medicine_and_Medical_Equipment.shtml

14.

Comptroller of Maryland. (2014b). Tax information for individual income tax. Retrieved from http://taxes.marylandtaxes.com/Individual_Taxes/Individual_Tax_Types/Income_Tax/Tax_Information/

15.

Congressional Budget Office. (1994). Health care trends and the tax treatment of health care institutions. Retrieved from http://www.cbo.gov/doc.cfm?index=4836&type=1

16.

Congressional Budget Office. (2006). Nonprofit hospitals and the provision of community benefits. Retrieved from http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/ftpdocs/76xx/doc7695/12-06-nonprofit.pdf

17.

Congressional Budget Office. (2013). The distribution of household income and federal taxes, 2010. Retrieved from http://www.cbo.gov/publication/44604

18.

David

(2005). The convergence between for-profit and nonprofit hospitals in the United States. Philadelphia: Wharton School of Business, University of Pennsylvania.

19.

DeLeire

Joynt

McDonald

(2014). Impact of insurance expansion on hospital uncompensated care costs in 2014. Retrieved from http://aspe.hhs.gov/health/reports/2014/UncompensatedCare/ib_UncompensatedCare.pdf

20.

Desai

K. R.

Van Deusen Lukas

Young

G. J.

(2000). Public hospitals: Privatization and uncompensated care. Health Affairs, 19, 167-172.

21.

Ellison

(2015). Tax breaks for nonprofit hospitals soar to $24.6B: 5 things to know. Retrieved from http://www.beckershospitalreview.com/finance/tax-breaks-for-nonprofit-hospitals-soar-to-24-6b-5-things-to-know.html

22.

Gentry

W. M.

Penrod

(2000). The tax benefits of not-for-profit hospitals: The changing hospital industry: Comparing for-profit and not-for-profit institutions (pp. 285-324). Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

23.

Ginsberg

R. E.

(1996). Ginsberg and Martin on bankruptcy. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Aspen Law & Business.

24.

Government Accountability Office. (1990). Nonprofit hospitals: Better standards needed for tax exemption (GAO/HRD-90-84). Retrieved from http://www.gao.gov/assets/150/149206.pdf

25.

Government. Accountability Office. (2005). Nonprofit, for-profit, and government hospitals: Uncompensated care and other community benefits (GAO-05-GA743T). Retrieved from http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d05743t.pdf

26.

Gray

B. H.

Schlesinger

(2009a). The accountability of nonprofit hospitals: Lessons from Maryland’s community benefit reporting requirements. Inquiry: Excellus Health Plan, 46, 122-139.

27.

Gray

B. H.

Schlesinger

(2009b). Charitable expectations of nonprofit hospitals: Lessons from Maryland. Health Affairs, 28, w809-w821.

28.

Gustafsson

(1996). The definition of “charitable” for federal income tax purposes: Defrocking the old and suggesting some new fundamental assumptions. Houston Law Review, 33, 587-649.

29.

Hadley

Holahan

(2003). How much medical care do the uninsured use, and who pays for it? Health Affairs, (Suppl Web Exclusives), W3-W66.

30.

Hall

M. A.

Colombo

J. D.

(1991). The charitable status of nonprofit hospitals: Toward a donative theory of tax exemption. Washington Law Review, 66, 307.

31.

Health Services Cost Review Commission. (2009). Report on the results of the uncompensated care policy for FY 2010. Retrieved from http://www.hscrc.state.md.us/documents/Hospitals/UCC/ResultsUCC_PolicyFY2010.pdf

32.

Health Services Cost Review Commission. (2013). Maryland hospital community benefits report FY 2012. Retrieved from http://www.hscrc.maryland.gov/documents/HSCRC_Initiatives/CommunityBenefits/cb-fy12/hscrc-fy-12-cbr-final.pdf

33.

Health Services Cost Review Commission. (2014). Report on uncompensated care policy recommendations. Retrieved from http://www.hscrc.state.md.us/documents/md-maphs/wg-meet/pay/2014-05-05/3-DRAFT-Report-on-Uncompensated-Care-Policy-Recommendations-05-05-14.pdf

34.

The Hilltop Institute. (2013). Community benefit state law profiles. Retrieved from http://www.hilltopinstitute.org/hcbp_cbl.cfm

35.

Horwitz

J. R.

National Bureau of Economic Research. (2005). Does corporate ownership matter? Service provision in the hospital industry (NBER Working Paper No. 11376). Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.

36.

Hyman

D. A.

(1990). Conundrum of charitability: Reassessing tax exemption for hospitals. American Journal of Law & Medicine, 16, 327-380.

37.

Internal Revenue Service. (1969). Revenue Ruling 69-545. Washington, DC: Internal Revenue Service.

38.

Internal Revenue Service. (2010). Instructions for Schedule H (Form 990). Washington, DC: Internal Revenue Service.

39.

Internal Revenue Service. (2012a). Instructions for Form 1120. Retrieved from http://www.irs.gov/instructions/i1120/index.html

40.

Internal Revenue Service. (2012b). Section 501(c)(3) organizations. Retrieved from http://www.irs.gov/publications/p557/ch03.html

41.

Japsen

(2011, September 10). State challenging hospitals’ tax exemption. New York Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/11/us/11cnchospitals.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0

42.

Joint Committee on Taxation. (2005). Historical development and present law of the federal tax exemption for charities and other tax-exempt organizations. Retrieved from http://www.jct.gov/x-29-05.pdf

43.

Joint Committee on Taxation. (2006). Present law and background relating to the tax-exempt status of charitable hospitals. Retrieved from http://www.jct.gov/x-49-06.pdf

44.

Kane

N. M.

Wubbenhorst

W. H.

(2000). Alternative funding policies for the uninsured: Exploring the value of hospital tax exemption. Milbank Quarterly, 78, 185-212.

45.

Maryland Department of Assessments and Taxation. (2012). 2012-2013 County tax rates. Retrieved from http://charmeck.org/mecklenburg/county/TaxCollections/Pages/2012-2013-Tax-Rates.aspx

46.

Maryland Health Services Cost Review Commission. (2013). Welcome to the Health Services Cost Review Commission. Retrieved from http://www.hscrc.state.md.us/

47.

Miller

M. H.

(1977). Debts and taxes. Journal of Finance, 32, 261-275.

48.

Morrisey

M. A.

Wedig

G. J.

Hassan

(1996). Do nonprofit hospitals pay their way? Health Affairs, 15, 132-144.

49.

Murray

(2009). Setting hospital rates to control costs and boost quality: The Maryland experience. Health Affairs, 28, 1395-1405.

50.

Nation

G. A.

III ., (2010). Non-profit charitable tax exempt hospitals: Wolves in sheep’s clothing: To increase fairness and enhance competition all hospitals should be for profit and taxable. Rutgers Law Journal, 42, 141-211.

51.

Provena Covenant Medical Center v. Department of Revenue, N.E. 2d1131 (Ill, 2010).

52.

Public Health Accreditation Board. (2011). Standards & Measures Version 1.0. Retrieved from http://dl.dropbox.com/u/12758866/PHAB%20Standards%20and%20Measures%20Version%201.0.pdf

53.

Rosenbaum

Kindig

D. A.

Bao

Byrnes

M. K.

O’Laughlin

(2015). The value of the nonprofit hospital tax exemption was $24.6 billion in 2011. Health Affairs, 34, 1225-1233.

54.

Rueben

Rosenberg

(2014). State and local tax policy: How does the deduction for state and local taxes work? Retrieved from http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/state-local/fiscal/deduction.cfm

55.

Schneider

(2007). Paying their way? Do nonprofit hospitals justify their favorable tax treatment? Inquiry: Excellus Health Plan, 44, 187-199.

56.

Schneider

Yilmaz

(2013). Hospital community benefits and the effect of Schedule H: A difference-in-difference approach. Health, 5, 1681-1688.

57.

Singh

S. R.

(2013). Not-for-profit hospitals’ provision of community benefit: Is there a trade-off between charity care and other benefits provided to the community? Journal of Health Care Finance, 39, 42-52.

58.

Singh

S. R.

Song

P. H.

(2013). Non-operating revenues and hospital financial performance: Can hospitals rely on income from non-patient-care activities to offset losses on patient care? Health Care Management Review, 38, 201-210.

59.

Sloan

F. A.

Hoerger

T. J.

Morrisey

M. A.

Hassan

(1990). The demise of hospital philanthropy. Economic Inquiry, 28, 725-743.

60.

Song

Lee

S. Y.

Alexander

J. A.

Seiber

E. E.

(2013). Hospital ownership and community benefit. Journal of Healthcare Management, 58, 126-141.

61.

Sound Health Association v. Commissioner, 71 T.C. 158, 180-181 (1978).

62.

Tax Foundation. (2014). Annual state-local tax burden ranking FY 2011. Retrieved from http://taxfoundation.org/article/annual-state-local-tax-burden-ranking-fy-2011

63.

Malm

Kant

(2013). The sources of state and local tax revenues. Retrieved from http://taxfoundation.org/article/sources-state-and-local-tax-revenues

64.

Turner

Goldner

(2012). Do hospital community benefit requirements help public health activities. New Orleans, LA: Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Public Health Law.

65.

Vansant

B. A.

(2011). The effect of regulatory pressures on earnings management behavior of nonprofit hospitals. Retrieved from http://scholarworks.gsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1008&context=accountancy_diss.

66.

Young

G. J.

Chou

C. H.

Alexander

Lee

S. Y. D.

Raver

(2013). Provision of community benefits by tax-exempt U.S. hospitals. New England Journal of Medicine, 368, 1519-1527