This study further examines whether not-for-profit hospitals exert pressure on for-profit hospitals to provide charity care and whether for-profit hospitals react differently than not-for-profit hospitals to managed care pressures and hospital competition in providing charity care. A two equation model is estimated using 1996 data from California hospitals. The results indicate that in mixed ownership markets, for-profit hospitals provide significantly less charity care as not-for-profit hospitals in the market provide more. Unexpectedly, study for-profit hospitals were not more influenced by price competition than other hospitals with respect to charity care. Having a unique role in providing charity care may justify continuing tax exemption for not-for-profit hospitals and enhance interest in payment and other policies with regard to conversions to ensure that not-for-profit hospitals continue to be represented in market areas.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Banks, D. A. , M. Paterson, and J. Wendel. 1997. Uncompensated hospital care: Charitable mission or profitable business decision?Health Economics6:133-143.
2.
Barro, J. R.1998. Hospital conversions to for-profit status: Causes and consequences. Unpublished manuscript, Harvard University.
3.
Bennefield, R. L.1996. Health insurance coverage: 1995. Current population reports. U.S. Census Bureau (Publication 60-195). Retrieved 3 April 2000 from http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/hlthins.html
4.
Bennefield, R. L. . 1999. Health insurance coverage: 1998. Current population reports. U.S. Census Bureau (Publication 60-208). Retrieved 3 April 2000 from http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/hlthins.html
5.
Bernstein, A. B. , and A. K. Gauthier. 1998. Defining competition in markets: Why and how?Health Services Research33:1421-1438.
6.
Ermann, D. , and J. Gabel. 1986. Investor-owned multihospital systems: A synthesis of research findings. In For-profit enterprise in health care, edited by B. H. Gray. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
7.
Frank, R. G. , and D. S. Salkever. 1991. The supply of charity services by nonprofit hospitals: Motives and market structure. RAND Journal of Economics22:430-445.
8.
Gaynor, M. , and W. Vogt. 1999. Antitrust and competition in health care markets. NBER Working Paper No. 7112.
9.
Gray, B. H.1991. The profit motive and patient care. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
10.
Gruber, J.1994. The effect of competitive pressure on charity: Hospital responses to price shopping in california. Journal of Health Economics38:183-212.
11.
Herzlinger, R. E. , and W. S. Krasker. 1987. Who profits from non-profits?Harvard Business Review65:93-106.
12.
Hirth, R. A.1997. Competition between for-profit and nonprofit health care providers: Can it help achieve social goals?Medical Care Research and Review54:414-438.
13.
Hughes, R. G. , and H. S. Luft. 1990. Keeping up with the Joneses: The influence of public and proprietary neighbours on voluntary hospitals. Health Services Management Research3 (3): 173-181.
14.
James, E. , and S. Rose-Ackermann. 1996. The nonprofit enterprise in market economics. In Fundamentals of pure and applied economics, edited by J. Lesourne and H. Sonneschien (vol. 9). Chur, Switzerland: Harwood Academic Publishers.
15.
Keeler, E. B. , G. Melnick, and J. Zwanziger. 1999. The changing effects of competition on non-profit and for-profit hospital pricing behavior. Journal of Health Economics18:69-86.
16.
Kleinbaum, D. G. , and L. L. Kupper. 1978. Applied regression analysis and other multivariate methods. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
17.
Kuttner, R.1999. The American health care system—Wall Street and health care. New England Journal of Medicine34:664-668.
18.
LeBlanc, A. J. 1991. Undercompensated, unpopular services in hospitals: The case of HIV/AIDS. Ph.D. diss., Pennsylvania State University.
19.
Lewin, L. S. , T. J. Eckels, and L. B. Miller. 1988. Setting the record straight: The provision of uncompensated care by not-for-profit hospitals. New England Journal of Medicine318:1212-1215.
20.
Maddala, G. G.1983. Limited dependent and quantitative variables in econometrics. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
21.
Mann, J. , G. Melnick, A. Bamezai, and J. Zwanziger. 1995. Uncompensated care: Hospitals’ responses to fiscal pressures. Health Affairs14:263-270.
22.
Marsteller, J. A. , R. R. Bovbjerg, and L. M. Nichols. 1998. Nonprofit conversion: Theory, evidence, and state policy options. Health Services Research33:1495-1535.
23.
Melnick, G. A. , J. Mann, and I. Golan. 1989. Uncompensated emergency care in hospital markets in Los Angeles County. American Journal of Public Health79:514-516.
24.
Melnick, G. A. , J. Zwanziger, A. Bamezai, and R. Pattison. 1992. The effect of market structure and bargaining position on hospital prices. Journal of Health Economics11:217-233.
25.
Mills, R. J.2000. Health insurance coverage: 1999. Current population reports. U.S. Census Bureau (Publication 60-211). Retrieved 16 November 2000 from http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/hlthin99.html
26.
Newhouse, J. P. , and M. McClellan. 1998. Econometrics in outcomes research: The use of instrumental variables. Annual Review of Public Health19:17-34.
27.
Norton, E. C. , and D. O. Staiger. 1994. How hospital ownership affects access to care for the uninsured. RAND Journal of Economics25:171-185.
28.
Schlesinger, M. , R. Dorwart, C. Hoover, and S. Epstein. 1997. Competition, ownership, and access to hospital services: Evidence from psychiatric hospitals. Medical Care35:974-992.
29.
Seay, J. D. , B. C. Vladek, P. S. Kramer, D. A. Gould, and J. J. McCormack. 1986. Holding fast to the good: The future of the voluntary hospital. Inquiry23:253-260.
30.
Shortell, S. M. , E. M. Morrison, S. L. Hughes, B. Friedman, J. Coverdill, and L. Berg. 1986. The effects of hospital ownership on nontraditional services. Health Affairs5 (winter): 97-111.
31.
Thorpe, K. E. , and C. E. Phelps. 1991. The social role of not-for-profit organizations: Hospital provision of charity care. Economic Inquiry29:472-484.
32.
Weisbrod, B. A.1988. The nonprofit economy. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
33.
Weissman, J.1996. Uncompensated hospital care: Will it be there if we need it?JAMA276:823-828.
34.
Zeckhauser, R. , J. Patel, and J. Needleman. 1995. The economic behavior of for-profit and nonprofit hospitals: The impact of ownership on responses to changing reimbursement and market environments. Princeton, NJ: The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.
