Roll Stabilization by Passive Anti-Roll Tanks Using an Improved Model of the Tank-Liquid Motion

Abstract

Roll motion is an undesirable feature of the behavior of a ship in rough seas, and so it is natural to consider ways of reducing it. The most common devices for increasing roll damping are bilge keels. However, the effectiveness of keels is limited, and anti-roll tanks and fins are used when more control is required. Moreover, unlike keels, anti-roll tanks can be used when the ship is not underway. Our objective is to develop design procedures for passive tanks for roll reduction in rough seas. To this end, we develop an improved model of the passive tank-liquid motion in this paper. This tank consists of U-shaped tubes placed side by side along the length of the ship. The equations of six-degrees-of-motion (6DOF) that govern the tank-liquid are coupled with those that govern the 6DOF motion of the ship, and all of the equations are integrated simultaneously in the time domain using the Large Amplitude Motion Program (“LAMP”). LAMP is a three-dimensional time-domain simulation of the motion of ships in waves. The unstabilized and stabilized roll motions of a S60-70 ship with forward speed and beam waves have been analyzed. For high-amplitude waves, the variation of the roll angle with the encounter-wave frequency exhibits typical nonlinear phenomena: a shift in the resonance frequency, multi-valued responses, and jumps. The performance of passive tanks on a S60-70 ship with forward speed is investigated in an irregular sea with different encounter-wave directions. It is found that passive anti-roll tanks tuned in the nonlinear range are very effective in reducing the roll motion. The effect of the tank mass and distribution of tank tubes on the performance of the tank system is studied. Also, it is found that passive anti-roll tanks are very effective in reducing the roll motion in sea state five of a ship whose pitch frequency is nearly twice its roll frequency.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abdel Gawad, A. F., Ragab, S. A., Nayfeh, A. H., and Mook, D. T., 2001, “Roll stabilization by anti-roll passive tanks,” Ocean Engineering 28, 457-469 .

Chadwick, J. H. and Klotter, K., 1954, “On the dynamics of anti-roll tanks,” Schiffstechnik 2, 23-45 .

Field, S. B. and Martin, J. P., 1976, “Comparative effects of U-tube and free surface type passive roll stabilization systems,” Royal Institute of Naval Architecture 2, 73-92 .

Fossen, T. I., 1994, Guidance and Control of Ocean Vehicles, Wiley, New York , pp. 5-30.

Frahm, H., 1911, “Results of trials of the anti-rolling tanks at sea,” INA Transactions 53, 183-197 .

Froude, W., 1874, “Considerations respecting the rolling of ships at sea,” INA Transactions 14, 96-116 .

Kim, Y., Park, Y., and Lee, H., 1994, “A numerical study on the prediction of sloshing impact pressure,” Transactions SNAME Korea 30-30.

Lee, B. S. and Vassalos, D., 1996, “Investigation into the stabilization effects of anti-roll tanks with flow obstructions,” International Shipbuilding Progress 43, 70-88 .

Minorsky, N., 1935, “Problems of anti-rolling stabilization of ships by the activated tank method,” ASNE 47, 87-119 .

10.

Nayfeh, A. H., 1988, “On the undesirable roll characteristics of ships in regular seas,” Journal of Ship Research 32, 92-100 .

11.

Nayfeh, A. H., 2000, Nonlinear Interactions, Wiley, New York .

12.

Nayfeh, A. H. and Khdeir, A. H., 1986a, “Nonlinear rolling of biased ships in regular beam waves,” International Shipbuilding Progress. 33, 84-93 .

13.

Nayfeh, A. H. and Khdeir, A. A., 1986b, “Nonlinear rolling of ships in regular beam seas,” International Shipbuilding Progress 33, 40-49 .

14.

Nayfeh, A. H. and Mook, D. T., 1979, Nonlinear Oscillations, Wiley, New York .

15.

Nayfeh, A. H., Mook, D. T., and Marshall, L. R., 1973, “Nonlinear coupling of pitch and roll modes in ship motion,” Journal of Hydronautics 7, 145-152 .

16.

Nayfeh, A. H. and Oh, I. G, 1995, “Nonlinearly coupled pitch and roll motions in the presence of internal resonance; Part 1, theory,” International Shipbuilding Progress 42, 295-324 .

17.

Oh, I. G, Nayfeh, A. H., and Mook, D. T., 2000, “A theoretical and experimental investigation of indirectly excited roll motion in ships,” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences 358(1771), 1853-1881 .

18.

Roberts, J., Dunne, J., and Debanos, A., 1994, “Stochastic estimation methods for nonlinear ship roll motion,” Probalistic Engineering Mechanics 9, 88-93 .

19.

Science Applications International Corporation, 1998, “Large amplitude motions program (LAMP) for ship motions and wave loads predictions,” Version 2.9.2 User's Guide.

20.

Shames, I. H., 1982, Mechanics of Fluids, McGraw-Hill, New York , p. 143-143.

21.

Stigter, C., 1966, “The performance of U-tanks as a passive anti-rolling device,” The Royal Institution of Naval Architects 13, 249-275 .

22.

Swamee, P. K. and Jain, A. K., 1976, “Explicit equations for pipe-flow problems,” Journal of Hydraulic Division Proceedings, ASCE, 657-664 .

23.

Van Daalen, E., Gerrits, J., Loots, G, and Veldman, A., 2000, “Free surface anti-roll tank simulations with a volume of fluid based Navier-Stokes solver,” in Proceedings of the 15th International Workshop on Water Waves and Floating Bodies, Caesara, Israel.

24.

Van den Bosch, J. J. and Vugts, J. H., 1964, “Some notes on the performance of free surface tanks as passive anti-rolling devices,” in The Report of the Shipbuilding Laboratory, Technological University of Delft , No 119, pp. 3-52 .

25.

Webster, W. C., Dalzell, J. F., and Barr, R. A., 1988, “Prediction and measurement of the performance of free-flooding ship anti rolling tanks,” SNAME Transactions 96, 333-364 .

26.

Youssef, K. S., Ragab, S. A., Nayfeh, A. H., and Mook, D. T., 2002, “Design of passive anti-roll tanks for roll stabilization in the nonlinear range,” Ocean Engineering 29, 177-192 .

27.

Zhong, Z., Falzarano, J., and Fithen, R., 1998, “Numerical study of U-tube passive anti-rolling tanks,” in Proceedings of the 8th International Offshore and Polar Engineering Conference, Montreal, Canada, Vol. 3, pp. 504-512 .