Stigma is a factor of diseases of craniofacial disfigurement, associated with negative health outcomes. Psychosocial interventions can improve the “illness” experience. The law can improve care by framing patients' rights, defining physicians' obligations to make psychological referrals, and fostering an activist orientation among patients.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
L.H.Yang, A.Kleinman, B.G.Link, J.C.Phelan. S.Lee and B.Good, “Culture and Stigma: Adding Moral Experience to Stigma Theory,”Social Science & Medicine64(2007): 1524-1535 at 1533.
2.
Stigma is also inherent in the patient role; it removes individuals from their regular activities and burdens family and friends who give care. See C.Charmaz, “Experiencing Chronic Illness,” in G.L.Albrecht, R.Fitzpatrick and S.C.Scrimshaw, eds., The Handbook of Social Studies in Health and Law (New York: Sage, 2002): at 277-292.
3.
M.Amit, M.T.Collins, E.J.Fitzgibbon, J.A.Butman, D.M.Fliss, and Z.Gil. “Surgery Versus Watchful Waiting in Patients with Craniofacial Fibrous Dysplasia—A Meta-Analysis,”PLoS One6, no. 9 (2011): e2517. J.Capelli-Junior, R.C. C.Almeida, B.Wedrychowska-Szulc, and M.Syrynska, “Orthosurgical Treatment of Patients in The Growth Period: At What Cost?”European Journal of Orthodontics, 17, no. 1 (2012): 159-177.
4.
To date, I have conducted 29 intensive interviews with women and men informants between ages 20 and 69 (6 with cherubism and 23 with CFFD). Systematic coding, development of themes, and memo writing is ongoing. This is the first study to look in depth into the stigma experiences of individuals affected by these diseases.
5.
B.G.Link and J.C.Phelan, “Conceptualizing Stigma,”Annual Review of Sociology27 (2001): 363-385; S.Green, S., C.Davis, E.Karshmer, P.Marsh, and B.Straight, “Living Stigma: The Impact of Labeling, Sterotyping, Separation, Status Loss, and Discrimination in the Lives of Individuals with Disabilities and their Families,”Sociological Inquiry75, no. 2 (2005): 197-215.
6.
A.E.R.Bos, J.B.Pryor, G.D.Reeder, and S.E.Stutter-heim, “Stigma: Advances in Theory and Research,”Basic and Applied Social Psychology35 (2013): 1-9. It is important to note that not all individuals with conditions that are typically stigmatized perceive themselves to have been stigmatized or experience self-stigma. However, for those who do report experiencing stigma, the impact is significant. R.M.Roberts, “Discrimination among Adults with Craniofacial Conditions,”The Journal of Craniofacial Surgery25, no. 1 (2014): 77-81.
7.
D.Cuhadar and M.O.Cam, “Effectiveness of Psychoeducation in Reducing Internalized Stigmatization in Patients with Bipolar Disorder,”Archives of Psychiatric Nursing28 (2014): 62-66 at 62.
8.
G.Scambler, “Health Related Stigma,”Sociology of Health & Illness31, no. 3 (2009): 441-455. R.Alansari, C.Bedos, and P.Allison, “Living with Cleft Lip and Palate: The Treatment Journey,”Cleft Palate-Craniofacial Journal51, no. 2 (2014): 222-229.
9.
See Yang et al., supra note 1.
10.
J.B.Luoma and M.G.Platt, “Shame, Self-Criticism, Self-Stigma, and Compassion in Acceptance and Commitment Therapy,”Current Opinion in Psychology2 (2015): 97-101.
11.
I.B.Holloway, Sofaer-Bennett, and J.Walker, “The Stigma-tization of People with Chronic Back Pain.”Disability and Rehabilitation29, no. 18 (2007): 1456-1464.
12.
See Yang, supra note 1 at 1532.
13.
E.A.Pascoe and L.S.Richman, “Perceived Discrimination and Health: A Meta-Analytic Review,”Psychological Bulletin135, no. 4 (2009): 531–554
14.
See Scambler, supra note 8. See Bos et al., supra note 6.
15.
S.Thomas, “A Phenomenological Study of Chronic Pain,”Western Journal of Nursing Research22, no. 6 (2000): 683-705 at 697.
16.
See Robert, supra note 5 at 80.
17.
T.C.Edwards, T.D.Topolski, K.A.Kapp-Simon, C.L.Aspinall, and D.L.Patrick, “What Difference Can a Minute Make? Social Skills and First Impressions of Youth with Craniofacial Differences,”Cleft Palate-Craniofacial Journal48, no. 1 (2011): 91-97 at 92.
18.
N.Rumsey and D.Harcourt, “Visible Difference Amongst Children and Adolescents: Issues and Interventions,”Developmental Neurorehabilitation10, no. 2 (2007): 113–123
19.
D.Reeve, “Negotiating Psycho-Emotional Dimensions of Disability and their Influence On Identity Constructions,”Disability & Society17, no. 5 (2002): 493-508.
20.
See Bos et al., supra note 6.
21.
See Reeve, supra note 19 at 494.
22.
P.T.Yanos, D.Roe, and P.H.Lysaker, “Narrative Enhancement and Cognitive Therapy: A New Group-Based Treatment for Internalized Stigma among Persons with Severe Mental Illness,”International Journal of Group Psychotherapy61, no. 4 (2011): 577-595 at 578.
23.
L.Hansson and P.T.Yanos, “Narrative Enhancement and Cognitive Therapy: A Pilot Study of Outomes of a Self-Stigma Intervention in a Swedish Clinical Context,”Stigma and Health1, no. 4 (2016): 280-286 at 281. See also E.Yilmaz and A.Okanh, “The Effect of Internalized Stigma on the Adherence to Treatment in Patients with Schizophrenia,”Archives of Psychiatric Nursing29 (2015): 297-301; D.Kamaradova, K.Latalova, J.Prasko, R.Kubinek, K.Vrbova, B.Mainerova, A.Cinculova, M.Ociskova, M.Holubova, J.Smoldasova, and A.Tichackova, ”Connection Between Self-Stigma, Adherence to Treatment, and Discontinuation of Medication,”Patient Preference and Adherence10 (2016): 1289-1298; J.D.Livingston and J.E.Boyd, “Correlates and Consequences of Internalized Stigma for People Living with Mental Illness: A Systematic Review and Meta Analysis,”Social Science & Medicine71 (2010): 2150-2161.
24.
Livingston and Boyd, supra note 23.
25.
O.C.Waugh, D.G.Byrne, and M.K.Nicholas, “Internalized Stigma in People Living with Chronic Pain,”The Journal of Pain15, no. 5 (2014): 550.e1 - 550.e10 at 550.E4-E5.
26.
See Green, supra note 5. See Scambler, supra note 8. E.Goffman, Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1986); J.Turner, B.Biesecker, J.Leib, L.Biesecker, and K.F.Peters, “Parenting Children with Proteus Syndrome: Experiences with, and Adaptation to, Courtesy Stigma,”American Journal of Medical Genetics143A, no. 18 (2007): 2089-2097. S.Green, “‘What Do You Mean ‘What’s Wrong with Her?’ Stigma and the Lives of Families of Children with Disabilities,”Social Science & Medicine57 (2003): 1361-1374.
27.
See Turner et al., supra note 26.
28.
See Goffman, supra note 26.
29.
See Pascoe and Richman, supra note 13.
30.
See Green, supra note 26 at 1372.
31.
See Bos et al., supra note 6.
32.
See Green, supra note 26.
33.
M.E.Papadaki, S.A.Lietman, M.A.Levine, B.R.Olsen, L.B.Kaban, and e. J.Reichenberger, “Cherubism: Best Clinical Practice,”Orphanet Journal of Rare Diseases7 no. Suppl 1 (2012): S6.
34.
Id.
35.
Id.
36.
S.Abela, “Orthodontic Treatment of Cherubism: An Overview and a Case Report,”Australian Orthodontic Journal30, no. 2 (2014): 214-220.
37.
S.H.Yoo, S.L.Pineles, R.Jarrahy, and F.G.Velez, “Opthalmic Manifestations of Cherubism,”Journal of American Association for Pediatric Ophthalmology and Strabismus19, No. 1 (2015): 70-72.
38.
See Abela, supra note 36. A.L.Maganzini and F.Picon, “The Multidisciplinary Management of the Cherubism Patient for Function and Aesthetics,”Journal of the World Federation of Orthodontists1, no. 1(April30, 2012): e27-33.
39.
B.Yilmaz, O.Ozan, L.Karaagaclioglu, and E.Ersoy, “A Prosthetic Treatment Approach for a Cherubism Patient,”Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry96, no. 5 (2006): 313-316.
40.
R.L.Font, G.Blanco, C.N.Soparkar, J.R.Patrinely, and M.L.Ostrowski, “Giant Cell Reparative Granuloma of the Orbit Associated with Cherubism,”Ophthalmology10, no. 9 (2003): 1846-1849.
41.
See Papadaki et al., supra note 33.
42.
Id.
43.
J.S.Lee, E.J.FitzGibbon, Y.R.Chen, H.J.Kim, L.R.Lustig, S.O.Akintoy, M.T.Collins and L.B.Kaban, “Clinical Guidelines for The Management of Craniofacial Fibrous Dysplasia,”Orphanet Journal of Rare Diseases7, no. Suppl 1 (2012): S2. 10.1186/1750-1172-7-S1-S2.
44.
Id.
45.
Id.
46.
Id.
47.
Id.
48.
This intervention was reported by informants.
49.
See Lee et al., supra note 43. There is debate about the necessity of optic nerve decompression surgery. Large scale studies suggest the desirability of “expectant management over prophylactic decompression.”A.M.Boyce, A.Burke, C.C.Peck, C.R.DuFresne, J.S.Lee, and M.T.Collins, “Surgical Management of Polyostotic Craniofacial Fibrous Dysplasia: Long Term Outcomes and Predictors for Postoperative Regrowth,”Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery137, no. 6 (2016): 1833-1839 at 1834.
50.
See Boyce et al., supra 49.
51.
Id. See also Y.Chen and M.S.Noordhoff, “Treatment of Craniomaxillofacial Fibrous Dysplasia: How Early and how Extensive?”Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery86, no. 5 (1989): 835-842. S.J.Kang, M.J.Oh, and S.P.Jeon, “A Novel and Easy Approach for Contouring Surgery in Patients With Craniofacial Fibrous Dysplasia,”Journal of Craniofacial Surgery26, no. 6 (2015): 1977-1978.
52.
See Lee et al., supra note 43. See Amit et al, supra note 3. See Capelli-Junior et al., supra note 3. See Boyce, supra 49. See also E.Béquignon, C.Cardinne, X.Lachiver, I.Wagner, F.Chabolle, and B.Baujat, “Craniofacial Fibrous Dysplasia Surgery: A Functional Approach,”European Annals of Otorhinolaryngology Head and Neck Diseases130, no. 4 (2013): 215-20.
53.
Several informants with cherubism saw genetic counselors who discussed only heritability.
54.
Affected individuals with McCune Albright Syndrome may have visible café au lait marks on their faces.
55.
See Roberts, supra note 6 at 77.
56.
See Holloway, supra at 11. C.Glenton, “Chronic Back Pain Sufferers - Striving for the Sick Role,”Social Science & Medicine57, no. 11 (2003): 2243-2252; M.C.Lennon, B.G.Link, J.J.Marbach, and B.P.Dohrenwend, “The Stigma of Chronic Facial Pain and Its Impact on Social Relationships,”Social Problems36, no. 2 (1989): 117-134.
57.
For a discussion of how regulatory opioid policy in the US fails to address pain, see D.S.Goldberg, “Job and the Stigma-tization of Chronic Pain,”Perspectives in Biology and Medicine53, no. 3 (2010): 425-438.
58.
See Bos et al., supra note 6 at 3.
59.
See Pascoe and Richman, supra note 13 at 542. D.Stavropoulos, U, Hallberg, B.Mohlin, and CHagberg, “Living with Crouzon Syndrome: How Do Young Adults with Crouzon Syndrome Handle Their Life Situation?”International Journal of Paediatric Dentistry21 (2010): 35-42.
60.
See Pascoe and Richman, supra note 13.
61.
P.A.Thoits and B.G.Link, “Stigma Resistance and Well-Being Among People in Treatment for Psychosis,”Society and Mental Health6, no. 1 (2016): 1-20 at 13.
62.
Id. at 3.
63.
P.W.Corrigan and A.C.Watson, “The Paradox of Self-Stigma and Mental Illness,”Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice9, No. 1 (2002): 35-53.
64.
See Reeve, supra note 19.
65.
See Corrigan and Watson, supra note 63 at 44.
66.
See Stavropoulos et al., supra note 59.
67.
See Alansari et al., supra note 10.
68.
Id. at 227.
69.
Id. at 228.
70.
W.E.Mouradian, “Deficits Versus Strengths: Ethics and Implications for Clinical Practice and Research,”Cleft Palate-Craniofacial Journal38, no. 3 (2001): 255-259 at 258.
71.
See Holloway et al., supra note 11 at 1462.
72.
See Mouradian, supra note 70 at 258. S.J.Cunningham, “The Psychology of Facial Appearance,”Dental Update26, no. 10 (1999): 438-443.
73.
See Roberts, supra note 6. See Rumsey and Harcourt, supra note 18.
74.
K.Tiemens, D.Nicholas and C.R.Forrest, “Living with Difference: Experiences of Adolescent Girls with Cleft Lip and Palate,”Cleft Palate-Craniofacial Journal50, no. 2 (2013): 27-34 at 32.
75.
Id. See also Turner et al., supra note 26. See Rumsey and Harcourt, supra note 18. J.A.Antle, “Factors Associated with Self-Worth in Young People with Physical Disabilities,”Health & Social Work29, No. 3 (2004): 167-175. R.W.Kelton, “Facing Up to Stigma: Workplace and Personal Strategies,”Cleft Palate-Craniofacial Journal38, no. 3 (2001): 245-247.
76.
J.Ablon, “The Nature of Stigma and Medical Conditions,”Epilepsy and Behavior3, no. 6 (2002): S2-9.
77.
See Alansari et al., supra note 10 at 228.
78.
M.Heijnders and S.van der Meij, “The Fight Against Stigma: An Overview of Stigma-Reduction Strategies and Interventions,”Psychology, Health & Medicine11, no. 3 (2006): 353-363 at 358.
79.
See Alansari et al., supra note 10.
80.
See Holloway et al., supra note 11 at 1462. See Waugh et al., supra note 25. See Goldberg, supra note 57.
81.
See Heijnders and Van der Meij, supra note 78.
82.
See Yanos et al., supra note 22 at 583.
83.
Cuhadar and Cam, supra note 7. D.Mittal, G.Sullivan, L.Chekuri, E.Allee, and P.W.Corrigan, “Empirical Studies of Self-Stigma Reduction Strategies: A Critical Review of the Literature,”Psychiatric Services63, no. 10 (2012): 974-81.
84.
See Heijnders and Van der Meij, supra note 78.
85.
R.L.Pearl, C.H.Hopkins, R.I.Berkowitz and T.A.Wadden., “Group Cognitive-Behavioral Treatment for Internalized Weight Stigma: A Pilot Study,”Eating and Weigh Disorders (Oct. 27, 2016): 1-6.
86.
See Hansson and Yanos, supra note 23.
87.
See Edwards, supra note 17 at 96.
88.
K.A.Kapp-Simon and D.E.McGuire, “Observed Social Interaction Patterns in Adolescents with and without Cranio-facial Conditions,”Cleft Palate-Craniofacial Journal34, no. 5 (1997): 380-384.
89.
Rumsey and Harcourt, supra note 18 at 119.
90.
V.Kish and R.Lansdown, “Meeting the Psychosocial Impact of Facial Disfigurement: Developing a Clinical Service for Children and Families,”Clinical Child Psychology & Psychiatry5, no. 4 (2000): 497-512.
91.
See Rumsey and Harcourt, supra note 18. L.H.Maddern, J.C.Cadogan, and M.P.Emerson, “’Outlook’: A Psychological Service for Children with a Different Appearance,”Cleft Palate-Craniofacial Journal11, no. 3 (2006): 431-443.
92.
R.P.Strauss, R.Newell, and I.Marks, “”Only Skin Deep”: Health, Resilience, and Craniofacial Care,”Cleft Palate-Craniofacial Journal38, no. 3 (2001): 226-230.
93.
C.A.Olsson, L.Bond, J.M.Burns, D.A.Vella-Brodrick, and S.M.Sawyer, “Adolescent Resilience: A Concept Analysis,”Journal of Adolescence26, no. 1 (2003): 1-11 at 7.
94.
See Ablon, supra note 76 at S6.
95.
Id.
96.
See Corrigan and Watson, supra note 63. J.Loewenstein, E.Sutton, R.Guidotti, K.Shapiro, K.Ball, D.McLean, and B.Biesecker, “The Art of Coping with a Craniofacial Difference: Helping Others Through ‘Positive Exposure’,”Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery146A, no. 12 (2008): 1547-1557.
97.
See Alansari et al., supra note 10.
98.
A.Hill-Beuf, “Children Coping with Impaired Appearance: Social and Psychological Influences,”General Hospital Psychiatry6, no. 4 (1984): 294-301.
99.
A.Clarke, A.R.Thompson, E.Jenkinson, MRumsey, and R.Newell. CBT for Appearance Anxiety: Psychosocial Interventions for Anxiety Due to Visible Difference (Chichester, UK: John Wiley and Sons, 2014).
100.
See the preamble to the Constitution, adopted 1946; entered into force 1948.
101.
T.C.de Campos, “Health as a Basic Human Need: Would This Be Enough?”Journal of Law Medicine & Ethics40, no. 2 (2012): 251-266.
102.
P.Elftheriadis, “A Right to Health Care,”Journal of Law Medicine & Ethics40, no. 2 (2012): 268-284.
103.
See de Campos, supra note 101.
104.
Id. at 256.
105.
Id.
106.
See Elftheriadis, quoting Singer, supra note 102 at 272.
107.
Id. at 280.
108.
Id. at 283.
109.
Id. at 282.
110.
See E.Parens, ed., Surgically Shaping Children: Technology, Ethics and the Pursuit of Normality (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2008) for discussion of ethical aspects of decisions about surgery.
111.
J.De Bord, “Informed Consent,”University of Washington School of Medicine, available at <http://depts.washington.edu/bioethx/topics/consent.html> (Last visited 2/12/2017). J.E.Barnett, “Informed Consent: Too Much of a Good Thing or Not Enough,”Professional Psychology: Research and Practice38, No. 2 (2007): 179-182.
112.
See Mouradian, supra note 70 at 256.
113.
Id.
114.
Id.
115.
C.L.Aspinall, “Anticipating Benefits and Decreasing Burdens: The Responsibility Inherent in Pediatric Plastic Surgery,”The Journal of Craniofacial Surgery21, no. 5 (2010): 1330-1334 at 1331.
116.
C.B.Fisher and M.Oransky, “Informed Consent to Psychotherapy: Protecting the Dignity and Respecting the Autonomy of Patients,”Journal of Clinical Psychology64, no. 5 (2008): 576-588.
117.
See Barnett, supra note 111 at 180.
118.
See Fisher and Oransky, supra note 116. S.J.Knapp and L.VandeCreek, Practical Ethics for Psychology (Washington, DC: American Psychological Association, 2006).
119.
A.Frank, “Emily’s Scars: Surgical Shapings, Technoluxe, and Bioethics,” in E.Parens, ed. Surgically Shaping Children: Technology, Ethics, and the Pursuit of Normality (Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2008): at 68-89.
120.
See Barnett, supra note 111. See Knapp and VandeCreek, supra note 118. See also S.K.Miller, “Toward Truly Informed Decisions about Appearance-Normalizing Surgeries,” in E.Parens, ed. Surgically Shaping Children: Technology, Ethics and the Pursuit of Normality (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2008): at 211-226.
121.
See Fisher and Oransky, supra note 109.
122.
W.L.Packman, M.G.Cabot, and B.Bongar, “Malpractice Arising from Negligent Psychotherapy: Ethical, Legal and Clinical Implications of Osheroff v Chestnut Lodge,”Ethics & Behavior4, no. 3 (1994): 175-197 at 178.
123.
See Fisher and Oransky, supra note 116.
124.
L.Shepard, “The Hairstylist, the Corn Merchant, and the Doctor: Ambiguously Altrusitic,”Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics42, no. 4 (2014): 509-515.
125.
National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research, The Belmont Report: Ethical Principles and Guidelines for the Protection of Human Subjects of Research Department of Health, Education, and Welfare: April 18, 1979, available at <https://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/belmont-report/> (Last visited 3/1/2017)
126.
“Americans with Disabilities Act Questions and Answers,”Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Department of Justice, available at <https://www.ada.gov/q&aeng02.htm> (Last visited 2/7/2017).
127.
Id.
128.
Id.
129.
“Protecting Students with Disabilities: Frequently Asked Questions About Section 504 and the Education of Children with Disabilities,”available at <https://www2.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ocr/504faq.html> (Last visited 2/7/2017).
130.
S.Burris, “Disease Stigma in U.S. Public Health Law,”Journal of Medicine & Ethics30, no. 2 (2002): 179-90 at 185.
