Healthcare Provider Limitation of Life-Sustaining Treatment without Patient or Surrogate Consent

Abstract

In June 2015, the major North American and European critical care societies released new joint guidelines that delineate a process-based approach to resolving intractable conflicts over the appropriateness of providing or continuing LST.2 This article frames the new guidelines within the history, ethical arguments, legal landscape, and empirical evidence regarding limitation of LST without surrogate consent in cases of intractable conflict.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

A. M.

Courtwright ,

Brackett ,

Cadge ,

E. L.

Krakauer , and

E. M.

Robinson , “Experience with a Hospital Policy on Not Offering Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation When Believed More Harmful Than Beneficial,” Journal of Critical Care 30, no. 1 (2015): 173-177;

Casarett and

Siegler , “Unilateral Do-Not-Attempt-Resuscitation Orders and Ethics Consultation: A Case Series,” Critical Care Medicine 27, no. 6 (1999): 1116-1120.

G. T.

Bosslet ,

T. M.

Pope ,

G. D.

Rubenfeld , et al., “An Official ATS/AACN/ACCP/ESICM/SCCM Policy Statement: Responding to Requests for Potentially Inappropriate Treatments in Intensive Care Units,” American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine 191, no. 11 (2015): 1318-1330.

In re Quinlan, 70 N.J. 10, 355 A.2d 647 (NJ 1976).

Cruzan v. Director, Missouri Department of Health, 497 U.S.

G. D.

Lundberg

, “American Health Care System Management Objectives: The Aura of Inevitability Becomes Incarnate,” JAMA 269, no. 19 (1993): 2554-2555.

L. J.

Schneiderman ,

N. S.

Jecker , and

A. R.

Jonsen , “Medical Futility: Its Meaning and Ethical Implications,” Annals of Internal Medicine 112, no. 12 (1990): 949-954.

Veatch and

C. M.

Spicer , “Medically Futile Care: The Role of the Physician in Setting Limits,” American Journal of Law & Medicine 18, nos. 1-2 (1992): 15-36;

R. D.

Truog ,

A. S.

Brett , and

Frader , “Sounding Board: The Problem with Futility,” New England Journal of Medicine 356, no. 4 (1992): 1560-1554;

R. M.

Veatch

, “Why Physicians Cannot Determine If Care Is Futile,” Journal of the American Geriatric Society 42, no. 8(1994): 871-874;

S. J.

Youngner

, “Who Defines Futility?” JAMA 260, no. 14 (1988): 2094-1095.

G. J.

Annas

, “Asking the Courts to Set the Standard of Emergency Care: The Case of Baby K,” New England Journal of Medicine 330, no. 21 (1994): 1542-1545;

Brody

, “The Physician's Role in Determining Futility,” Journal of the American Geriatric Society 42, no. 8 (1994): 875-878;

Gampel

, “Does Professional Autonomy Protect Medical Futility Judgments?” Bioethics 20, no. 2 (2006): 92-104;

Tomlinson and

Brody , “Futility and the Ethics of Resuscitation,” JAMA 264, no. 10 (1990): 1276-1280.

L. J.

Blackhall

, “Must We Always Use CPR?” New England Journal of Medicine 317, no. 20 (1987): 1281-1285;

Hilberman ,

Kutner ,

Parsons , and

D. J.

Murphy , “Marginally Effective Medical Care: Ethical Analysis of Issues in Cardio-pulmonary Resuscitation (CPR),” Journal of Medical Ethics 23, no. 6 (1997): 361-367.

10.

P. R.

Helft ,

Siegler , and

Lantos , “The Rise and Fall of the Futility Movement,” New England Journal of Medicine 343, no. 4 (2000): 293-296;

M. P.

Cotler ,

Piven , and

D. R.

Gregory , “Futility: Is Definition the Problem? Part I,” Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 2, no. 2 (1993): 219-224;

R. A.

Gatter and

J. C.

Moskop , “From Futility to Triage,” Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 20, no. 2 (1995): 191-205.

11.

Halevy and

B. A.

Brody , “A Multi-institution Collaborative Policy on Medical Futility,” JAMA 276, no. 7 (1996): 571-574.

12.

American Medical Association, Opinion 2.035 (1994).

13.

C. W.

Plows ,

R. M.

Tenery ,

Hartford , et al., “Medical Futility in End-of-Life Care: Report of the Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs,” JAMA 281, no. 10 (1999): 937-941.

14.

Tex HS Code Ann. § 166.046 (1999).

15.

See Bosslet et al., supra note 2.

16.

Id., at 1326.

17.

Id., at 1324.

18.

V. A.

Palda ,

K. W.

Bowman ,

R. F.

Mclean , and

M. G.

Chapman , ‘“Futile’ Care: Do We Provide It? Why? A Semistructured, Canada-Wide Survey of Intensive Care Unit Doctors and Nurses,” Journal of Critical Care 20, no. 3 (2005): 207-213.

19.

Uniform Health Care Decisions Act (1993).

20.

Va. Code Ann. 5 54.1-2990(A) (2005); Conn. Gen. Stat. Ann. 5 19a-571(a) (2002).

21.

Cal Prob. Code § 4734 (1999).

22.

Mass. Gen. Laws Ann. Ch. 201D, § 14 (2005); Neb. Rev. Stat. § 30-3428 (2007).

23.

755 Ill. Comp. Stat. § 40/20 (2009).

24.

Oh. Rev. Code Ann. § 1337.16(B)(2)(a) (2012).

25.

Idaho Code Ann. § 39-4513 (2015); Del Code Tit. 16 §25-10 (1989).

26.

Ark. Code § 20-6-109 (2014).

27.

T. M.

Pope

, “Medical Futility Statutes: No Safe Harbor to Uni-laterally Refuse Life-Sustaining Treatment,” Tennessee Law Review 75, no. 1 (2007): 1-81.

28.

In re Conservatorship of Helga Wanglie, No. PX-91-283 (D. Minn. P. Div. 1991).

29.

Rideout v. Hershey Medical Center, 30 Pa. D. & C.4th 57 (Ct. Com. Pl. 1995).

30.

Matter of Baby K, 832 F. Supp. 1022 (E.D. Va. 1993).

31.

Matter of Baby K, 16 F.3d 590 (4th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 115 S. Ct. 91 (1994).

32.

Bryan v. Rectors and Visitors of Univ. of Virginia, 95 F.3d 349 (4th Cir. 1996).

33.

Hudson v. Texas Children's Hosp., No. 352.526 (Tx. Prob. Ct. 2004)

34.

Lightfoot

, “The Ethical Health Lawyer,” Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics 33, no. 4 (2005): 851-856.

35.

Nikolouzos v. St. Luke's Episcopal Hosp., 162 S.W.3d 678 (Tx. App. 2005).

36.

Dunn v. Methodist Hospital (Harris County, Tex., Nov. 2015).

37.

Gilgunn v. Massachusetts General Hospital, SUCV92-4820 (Ma. Super. Ct. 1995).

38.

See Pope, supra note 27, at 75-76.

39.

Estate of Goldberg v. Nimoityn, Civil Action No. 14-980 (E.D. Pa. Jun 17, 2016).

40.

Marsala v. Yale New Haven Hospital (Milford Sup. Ct., Conn. Mar. 2015, ruling on partial summary judgment).

41.

Marsala v. Yale-New Haven Hospital, Inc., 142 A.3d 316, 166 Conn. App. 432 (App. Ct. 2016).

42.

Siner v. Kindred Hospital Limited Partnership, 51 N.E.3d 1184 (Ind. 2016).

43.

2015 WL 9608853 (Tex. Dist.) (Trial Pleading).

44.

O'Callaghan

, “Dying for Due Process: The Unconstitutional Medical Futility Provision of the Texas Advance Directives Act,” Baylor Law Review 60, no. 2 (2008): 527-611.

45.

W. E.

Wojtasiewicz

, “Damage Compounded: Disparities, Distrust, and Disparate Impact in End-of-Life Conflict Resolution Policies,” American Journal of Bioethics 6, no. 5 (2006): 8-12;

T. M.

Pope

, “The Growing Power of Healthcare Ethics Committees Heightens Due Process Concerns,” Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution 15, no. 1 (2015): 425-569;

J. L.

Werth

, “Concerns about Decisions Related to Withholding/Withdrawing Life-Sustaining Treatment and Futility for Persons with Disabilities,” Journal of Disability and Policy Studies 16, no. 1 (2005): 31-37;

P. M.

Rosoff

, “Institutional Futility Policies Are Inherently Unfair,” Hospital Ethics Committee Forum 25, no. 3 (2013): 191-209.

46.

T. N.

Huynh ,

E. C.

Kleerup ,

J. F.

Wiley , et al., “The Frequency and Cost of Treatment Perceived to Be Futile in Critical Care,” JAMA: Internal Medicine 173, no. 20 (2013): 1887-1894;

Meadow ,

Pohlman ,

Frain et al., “Power and Limitations of Daily Prognostications of Death in the Medical ICU for Outcomes in the Following 6 Months,” Critical Care Medicine 42, no. 11 (2014): 2387-2392.

47.

M. L.

Smith ,

Gremillion ,

Slomka , and

Warneke , “Texas Hospitals' Experience with the Texas Advance Directives Act,” Critical Care Medicine 35, no. 5 (2007): 1271-1276.

48.

See Courtwright et al., supra note 1.

49.

R. D.

Truog

, “Tackling Medical Futility in Texas,” New England Journal of Medicine 357, no. 1 (2007): 1-3.

50.

L. C.

Hoffman

, “Hospital Medical Futility Policy & the Severely Disabled Child: Is Disability a Death Sentence?” Hamline Law Review 36, no. 2 (2014): 275-298.

51.

See Pope, supra note 27, at 46.

52.

See Boslett et al., supra note 2, at 1332-1333.

53.

C. J.

Misak ,

D. B.

White , and

R. D.

Truog , “Medical Futility: A New Look at an Old Problem,” CHEST 146, no. 6 (2014): 1667-1672.

54.

Wilkinson ,

Truog , and

Savulescu , “In Favour of Medical Dissensus: Why We Should Agree to Disagree about Endof-Life Decisions,” Bioethics (2015), available at <http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/bioe.12162/full> (last visited August 9, 2017).

55.

A. J.

Tarzian and ASBH Core Competencies Update Task Force, “Health Care Ethics Consultation: An Update on Core Competencies and Emerging Standards from the American Society for Bioethics and Humanities' Core Competencies Update Task Force,” American Journal of Bioethics 13, no. 2 (2013): 3-13.

56.

See Smith et al., supra note 47.