Maximizing Community Voices to Address Health Inequities: How the Law Hinders and Helps

Abstract

This paper highlights the need to apply an equity lens when assessing the impact of preemption and related legal doctrines on community health. Community autonomy to set and pursue public health priorities is an essential part of achieving health equity. Unfortunately, the priorities of organized industry interest groups often conflict with health equity goals. These groups have a history of successfully using law to limit community autonomy to pursue public health measures, most notably through preemption and related legal doctrines. We examine this phenomenon using two examples. First, we look at dental association efforts to block the spread of dental therapists in Indian Country. Native dental therapists have been improving the oral health of native people in Alaska for over a decade; yet the national and state dental associations have sought with mixed success to leverage state and federal laws to hinder other tribal governments from utilizing these providers. We compare these efforts with a restaurant association-led movement to limit what municipal governments can do to address food-based health inequities, focusing on a “model” ALEC bill that started in Ohio. Finally, we discuss how municipalities and Tribes are fighting back and continuing to pursue health equity for their communities.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

For definitions of health equity and health disparities, see

Braveman

, “What are Health Disparities and Health Equity? We Need to Be Clear,” Public Health Report 129, S2 (2014): 5-8.

See Grassroots Change, “Preemption Watch,” available at <http://grassrootschange.net/issues/preemption/> (last visited January 4, 2017).

Public Health Law Center, “Preemption in Public Health,” available at <http://www.publichealthlawcenter.org/topics/other-public-health-law/preemption-public-health> (last visited January 4, 2017).

K. R.

Phipps and

T. L.

Ricks , “The Oral Health of American Indian and Alaska Native Children Aged 1-5 Years: Results of the 2014 IHS Oral Health Survey (2015),” available at <https://www.ihs.gov/DOH/documents/IHS_Data_Brief_March_2016_Oral_Health%20Survey_35_plus.pdf> (last visited January 4, 2017).

Id.

See, e.g., Amererican Public Health Association, “Support for the Alaska Dental Health Aide Therapist and Other Innovative Programs,” 2014, available at <https://www.apha.org/policies-and-advocacy/public-health-policy-statements/policy-database/2014/07/07/13/28/support-for-the-alaska-dental-health-aide-therapist-and-other-innovative-programs> (last visited January 4, 2017).

See 25 U.S.C. § 1601 et seq. (IHCIA) and 25 U.S.C.A. § 1616l (revision notes).

10.

Memorandum to R. Warren, DDS, Alaska Bd of Dental Examiners from P. Lyle, Sr. Asst. Attny Gen., Alaska Dep't of Law, at 2, September 8, 2005, available at <http://law.alaska.gov/pdf/opinions/opinions_2005/05-020_663050152.pdf> (last visited January 4, 2017).

11.

Alaska Dental Society et al. v. ANTHC et al., No. 3AN-06-04797CI (Alaska Super. Ct. filed January 31, 2006).

12.

DeMarben

, Dentist's Remarks Called Racist, Misinformed, Alaska Dispatch News, April 14, 2006, available at <http://www.adn.com/rural-alaska/article/dentists-remarks-called-racist-misinformed-41406/2012/04/05/> (last visited January 4, 2017).

13.

Alaska Dental Society v. Alaska et al., No. 3AN-06-04797CI (Alaska Super. Ct. June 27, 2007).

14.

Id.

15.

25 U.S.C.A. § 1616l (d)(2)(B) and (d)(3)(A).

16.

See National Congress of American Indians, An Introduction to Indian Nations in the United States, available at <http://www.ncai.org/about-tribes/indians_101.pdf> (last visited January 4, 2017).

17.

Swinomish Indian Tribal Community Code, Tit. 15, Chptr. 11 (2015).

18.

See Oregon Tribes Dental Health Aide Therapist Pilot Project, available at <https://public.health.oregon.gov/PreventionWellness/oralhealth/DentalPilotProjects/Pages/projects.aspx#100> (last visited January 4, 2017).

19.

Cleveland City Record for April 6, 2011, at 36, Res. No. 257-11, <http://www.dln.com/cr/index2011/April62011.pdf> (last visited January 4, 2017).

20.

Cleveland City Code § 241.42.

21.

Ohio Department of Health, Cuyahoga County Assessment: Access to Supermarkets, Summary of Progress-to-Date, at 5 (December 2011), available at <http://cccfoodpolicy.org/sites/default/files/resources/cuyahoga_county_assessment_access_to_supermarkets_-_2011.pdf> (last visited January 4, 2017); County Health Rankings & Roadmaps, <http://www.countyhealthrankings.org/#app/ohio/2012/measures/factors/84/data> (last visited January 4, 2017).

22.

D. Bruckman et al., Data Brief: Adult Diabetes in Cleveland (2005-2009); Data Brief: Hypertension in Cleveland (2005-2009); Data Brief: Obesity in Cleveland (2005-2009) (February 2012).

23.

Ohio R.C. 3717.53 (2011), invalidated by Cleveland v. State of Ohio, 989 N.E.2d 1072 (Oh. Ct. App. 2013).

24.

The 2012 model bill is available at <https://www.alec.org/model-policy/food-and-nutrition-act/> (last visited January 4, 2017).

25.

ALEC, Strategic Plan 2016-2018 at 8, available at <https://www.alec.org/app/uploads/2016/06/ALEC-Strat-Plan-Final-051616.pdf> (last visited January 4, 2017).

26.

Miss Code Ann. §75-29-901 (2016); S. 366 86th Gen. Assemb., Reg. Sess. (Kan. 2016).

27.

See The State of Obesity, “Adult Obesity in the United States,” available at <http://stateofobesity.org/adult-obesity/> (last visited January 4, 2017).

28.

See, e.g.,

Neff

et al ., “Food Systems and Public Health Disparities,” Journal of Hunger & Environmental Nutrition 4, nos. 3-4 (2009): 282-314, at 283. See also Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, “CDC Health Disparities and Inequalities Report — United States, 2013,” Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 62, no. 3 (November 22, 2013): 20-26, available at <http://www.cdc.gov/MMWR/pdf/other/su6203.pdf> (last visited January 4, 2017).

29.

Cleveland v. State of Ohio, 989 N.E.2d 1072 (Oh. Ct. App. 2013).