This paper examines the applicability of the Vroom-Yetton model of leadership and decision making to the battlefield behavior of ten commanding generals in six major battles of the American Civil War. The purpose of the paper was twofold. The first objective was to see if it is possible to utilize official war records, autobiographies, biographies of close associates, and scholarly works to reconstruct the thinking of decision makers in the past and frame this thinking within a contemporary theory of leadership and decision making. The second objective was to illustrate the potential value of using prior events as retrospective test cases for a contemporary leadership theory.
Although no attempt was made to suggest that the selection of the appropriate decision making and leadership style was the determining factor in the outcome of major battles of the Civil War, the study provided some interesting findings. The findings suggest that when the selected commanders on the field acted consistently with the prescriptions of the Vroom-Yetton model they were more often successful in accomplishing the goals of the campaign. In addition, the findings suggest that even though the commanders tended to favor autocratic styles, the lack of information sharing and consensus building resulted in serious disadvantages. In the cases examined, the pressure for prompt decision making was not sufficient to justify the loss of information that resulted from the determination to act alone.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alexander, E.P. (1907). Military memoirs of a Confederate. New York. Charles Scribner's & Sons.
2.
Bass B.M. (1998). Transformational leadership: Industry, military, and educational impact. New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Cist, H.M. (1881). Army of the Cumberland. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.
5.
Cox, J.D. (1882). The march to the sea - Franklin & Nashville . New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.
6.
Cozzens P. (1992). This terrible sound: The battle of Chickamauga . Chicago: University of Illinois Press.
7.
Daniel L.J. (1997). Shiloh: The battle that changed the Civil War . New York: Simon and Schuster .
8.
Davis, W.C. (1991). The Confederate general. Vols. 1-6. Washington, D.C.: National Historical Society. Doubleday, A. (1881). Chancellorsville & Gettsburg. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.
9.
Emerson, H. (1908). Efficiency as a basis for operations and wages . 4th ed. revised and enlarged. Easton, PA: Hive Publishing. Reprint 63, 1976.
10.
Ettling, J.T. & Jago A.G. (1988). Participation under conditions of conflict: More on the validity of the Vroom-Yetton model. Journal of Management Studies, 25,73-83.
11.
Festinger, L. (1957). A theory of cognitive dissonance. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
12.
Fiedler, F.E. (1996). Research on leadership selection and training: One view of the future. Administrative Science Quarterly,41, 241-250.
13.
Fiedler, F.E. (1967). A theory of leadership effectiveness. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company.
14.
Fiedler, F.E. & Chemers MM (1974). Leadership and effective management. New York: Scott, Foresman and Company.
15.
Field, R.H.G. (1982). A test of the Vroom-Yetton normative model of leadership. Journal of Applied Psychology,67, 523-532.
16.
Field, R. H. G, House RJ (1990). A test of the VroomYetton model using manager and subordinate reports. Journal of Applied Psychology,75, 362-366.
17.
Fiske, J. (1900a). The War in the West: The Mississippi Valley in the Civil War. Vol. 1. Boston . Houghton Mifflin.
18.
Fiske, J. (1900b). The War in the West: The Mississippi Valley in the Civil War. Vol. 2. Boston . Houghton Mifflin.
19.
Foote, S. (1994). Stars in their courses: The Gettysburg campaign . New York: Modern Library.
20.
Force, M.F. (1881). From Ft. Henry to Corinth. New York. Charles Scribner's Sons.
21.
Force, M.F. (1883). From Fort Henry to Corinth. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.
22.
Furgurson, E.B. (1992). Chancellorsville 1863. New York: Alfred A. Knopf1992.
23.
Gallagher, G.W. (1997). The Confederate war. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
24.
Gilderhus, M.T. (2000). History and historians: A historiographical introduction . 4th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
25.
Grant, U. S. (1885). Personal Memoirs. Vol. 1. New York: Charles L. Webster & Company.
26.
Grant, U. S. (1886). Personal Memoirs. Vol. 2. New York: Charles L. Webster & Company.
27.
Greene, F.V. (1882). The Mississippi. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.
28.
Groom, W. (1995). Shrouds of glory. New York : Atlantic Monthly Press.
29.
Gulick, L. & Urwick, L., eds. (1947). Papers on the science of administration . 2nd ed. New York: Institute for Public Administration.
30.
Hayward, M. L. A & Hambrick, D.C. (1997). Explaining the premiums paid for large acquisitions: Evidence of CEO hubris. Administrative Science Quarterly,42, 103-127.
31.
Heilman M.E., et al. (1984). Reactions to prescribed leader behavior as a function of role perspective: The case of the Vroom-Yetton model. Journal of Applied Psychology, 69,50-60.
32.
Hendrick, C., Mills, J. & Kiesler, C.A. (1968). Decision time as a function of the number and complexity of equally attractive alternatives. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.8:313-318.
33.
House, R.J. (1971). A path-goal theory of leader effectiveness. Administrative Science Quarterly,16, 321-338.
34.
Howard, O.O. (1907). Autobiography of Oliver OtisHoward. Vol. 1. New York : Baker & Taylor Company.
35.
Howell, M. & Prevenier. ( 2001). From reliable sources: An introduction to historical methods. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
36.
Hurst, J. (1963). Nathan Bedford Forrest. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
37.
Jones, A. (1992). Civil war command & strategy. New York: Free Press.
38.
Jordan, D.M. (1988). Winfield Scott Hancock: A soldier's life. Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana University Press.
39.
Kets, de Veries, M.F.R. (1990). The organizational fool: Balancing a leader's hubris. Human Relations, 43. 751-770.
40.
Knox, R.E. & Inkster, J.A. (1968). Post decision dissonance at post time. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 8:319-322.
41.
Kroll, M.J., Toombs, L.A., & Wright, P. (2000). Napoleon's tragic march home from Moscow: Lessons in hubris. Academy of Management Executive, 14( 1 ), 117-128.
42.
Kraus, D. (1996). The art of war for executives. New York: Perigee Publishing.
43.
Longstreet J. (1896). From Manassas to Appomattox. Memories of the Civil War in America. Philadelphia: J.B. Lippincott Company.
44.
Matloff M. (1969). Army Historical Series: American military history . Washington D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
45.
McClellan, G.B. (1887). McClellan's own story: The war for the union. New York: Charles L. Webster & Company .
46.
McDonough, J.L. & Connelly, T.L. (1983). Five tragic hours: The battle ofFranklin. Knoxville, TN : University of Tennessee Press.
47.
Mooney, J.D. & Reiley, A.C. (1931). Onward industry. New York: Harper & Brothers.
48.
Nolan, A.T. (1994). The iron brigade. Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana University Press.
49.
Northouse, P.G. (1997). Leadership: Theory and practice. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
50.
Palfrey, F.W. (1881). The Antietam & Fredericksburg. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.
51.
Reardon, C. (1997). Pickett's charge in history & memory. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press .
52.
Roll, R. (1986). The hubris hypothesis of corporate takeovers. Journal of Business. 59. 197-216.
53.
Ropes, J.C. (1881). The Army under Pope. New York : Charles Scribner's Sons.
54.
Schofield, J.M. (1897). Forty-six years in the army. New York: The Century Company.
55.
Sheridan, P.H. (1888). Personal memoirs of P. H. Sheridan. Vols.1 & 2. New York: Charles L. Webster & Company.
56.
Sherman, W.T. (1875). Memoirs of General William T. Sherman. Vol. 1. New York: D. Appleton & Company.
57.
Tead O. ( 1935). The art of leadership. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc.
58.
Tjosvold, D., Wedley, W.C., & Field, R.H.G. (1986). Constructive controversy, the Vroom-Yetton model, and managerial decision making. Journal of Occupational Behavior , 7, 125-138.
59.
Urwick, L. (1944). Elements of administration. London: Harper & Brothers.
60.
Van Fleet, D.D. & Yukl, G.A.Military leadership: An organizational behavior perspective. New York: Elsevier Science.
61.
Vroom, V.H. (2000). Leadership and the decision making process. Organizational Dynamics, 28 (4), 82-94.
62.
Vroom, V.H.1973. A new look at managerial decision making. Organizational Dynamics, 2 (Spring), 37-48.
63.
Vroom, V.H. (1987). Some personality determinants of the effects of participation. New York: Garland Publishing, Inc.
64.
Vroom, V.H. & Jago, A.G. (1978). On the validity of the Vroom/Yetton model. Journal of Applied Psychology, 63, 151-162.
65.
Vroom, V.H. & Jago, A.G. (1988). The new leadership. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
66.
VroomV. H. & Yetton P.W. (1973). Leadership and decision-making. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
67.
War of the rebellion: Official records of the Union and Confederate armies . (1880). Series I, Vol. 2. Washington, D.C., Government Printing Office.
68.
War of the rebellion: Official records of the Union and Confederate armies. (1884). Series I, Vol. 10. Washington, D.C., Government Printing Office.
69.
War of the rebellion: Official records of the Union and Confederate armies. (1889). Series I, Vol. 27. Washington, D.C., Government Printing Office.
70.
War of the rebellion: Official records of the Union and Confederate armies. (1894). Series I, Vol. 45. Washington, D.C., Government Printing Office.
71.
Wallace, L. (1906). Lew Wallace: An autobiography. Vol. 1. New York: Harper & Brothers.
72.
Waugh, J.C. (1994). Class of 1846. New York: Warner Books.
73.
Weber, M. (1947). The theory of social and economic organization. C. Henderson & T. Parsons (eds. & trans.), New York: Free Press.
74.
Wert J.D. (1993). General James Longstreet: The Confederacy's most controversial soldier, a biography. New York: Simon and Schuster.
75.
Wheeler, T. (1999). Leadership lessons from the Civil War. New York: Currency Book.
76.
Wood, G. (1991). Historian's handbook: A key to the study and writing of history. 2nd ed. Boston: MA : Houghton Mifflin.
77.
Yukl G.A. (1981). Leadership in organizations. New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
78.
Yukl G.A. & Van Fleet D.D. (1982). Cross-situational, multimethod research on military leader effectiveness. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance.30, 87-108.
