Effects of Mission Preparation on Crew Combat Mission Training Performance

Abstract

Although military doctrine assumes that thorough mission preparation is a prerequisite for mission success, empirical data are lacking. The present study investigated the relationship between mission preparation and mission performance during combat mission training of 11 MC-130P (Combat Shadow) aircrews from USAF Special Operations Forces squadrons. Two observers independently rated crew coordination processes and mission performance based on extensive observations taken both during a planning period and while the crews executed a simulated mission. Statistically, a reliable, strong relationship between preparation and performance was noted, with correlations ranging from .60 to .78. Exceptional preparation behaviors include utilizing personnel effectively, establishing a firm timeline, aggressively questioning a plan's assumptions, and testing a plan's logic against possible contingencies. The paper concludes with a discussion of the characteristics of effective mission preparation and implications of the research for combat mission training.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bowers

C. A.

Baker

D. P.

Salas

(1995). Measuring the importance of teamwork: The reliability and validity of job/task analysis indices for team-training design. Military Psychology, 6, 205–214.

Fowlkes

J. E.

Lane

N. E.

Salas

Franz

Oser

(1994). Improving the measurement of team performance: The TARGETS methodology. Military Psychology, 6, 47–61.

Hunt

G. H.

(1993, October). Introduction and Overview. 1–1–1–5. Presented at an AGARD Lecture Series on ‘New Advances in Mission Planning and Rehearsal Systems.’.

Nullmeyer

R. T.

Spiker

V. A.

(in press). Utilization strategies for simulation-based mission rehearsal systems. (AL/HR-TR–1996-xxxx). Mesa, AZ: Aircrew Training Research Division, Armstrong Laboratory.

Nullmeyer

R. T.

Bruce

P. D.

Spiker

V. A.

(1994, April). Simulation-based mission rehearsal: Some behavioral issues. Paper presented at the 14th Applied Behavioral Sciences Conference, Colorado Springs, Colorado.

Oser

R. L.

Dwyer

D. J.

Fowlkes

J. E.

(1995, November). Team performance in multi-service distributed interactive simulation exercises: Initial results. Proceedings of the 17th Interservice/Industry Training Systems and Education Conference. Orlando, FL.

Povenmire

H. K.

Rockway

M. R.

Bunecke

J. L.

Patton

M. W.

(1989). Evaluation of measurement techniques for aircrew coordination and resource management skills (UDR-TR-89–108). Williams AFB, AZ: Air Force Human Resources Laboratory, Operations Training Division.

Spiker

V. A.

Nullmeyer

R. T.

(1995a, April). Benefits and limitations of simulation-based mission planning and rehearsal. Eighth International Symposium on Aviation Psychology, Columbus, Ohio.

Spiker

V. A.

Nullmeyer

R. T.

(1995b, September). Measuring the effectiveness of mission preparation in the special operations forces. (AL/HR-TR–1995–007). Mesa, AZ: Aircrew Training Research Division, Armstrong Laboratory.

10.

Spiker

V. A.

Tourville

S. J.

Silverman

D. R.

Nullmeyer

R. T.

(1996, November). Team performance during combat mission training: A conceptual model and measurement framework. (AL/HR-TR–1996–0092). Mesa, AZ: Aircrew Training Research Division, Armstrong Laboratory.

11.

Taylor

R. M.

(1993, October). Human factors of mission planning systems: Theory and Concepts. 2–1 through 2–28. Presented at an AGARD Lecture Series on ‘New Advances in Mission Planning and Rehearsal Systems.’.

12.

Thornton

R. C.

Kaempf

G. L.

Zeller

J. L.

McAnulty

D. M.

(1992). An evaluation of crew coordination and performance during a simulated UH-60 helicopter mission (ARI-RN-92–63). Fort Rucker, AL: U. S. Army Research Institute for the Behavioral and Social Sciences.

13.

Tourville

S. J.

Spiker

V. A.

Silverman

D. R.

Nullmeyer

R. T.

(1996, November). An assessment methodology for team combat mission training and rehearsal. Proceedings of the 18th Interservice/Industry Training Systems and Education Conference. Orlando, FL.