Self-Limited and Unlimited Word Usage during Problem Solving in Two Telecommunication Modes

Abstract

Subjects using oral modes of communication generate far more verbiage than do subjects using written (handwritten or typewritten) modes to solve the same problems. This study was designed to provide support for one of two alternative hypotheses that have been proposed to account for this disparity: (1) written modes produce a hard copy of interchanges that can be referred to at any time, thereby compensating for the limitations of short-term memory and reducing the need to repeat information, and (2) talking is so much easier than handwriting or typewriting that there is no incentive to be concise in oral modes. Two-person teams of subjects solved problems cooperatively using either a voice or a teletypewriter mode of communication. Half the teams were given a monetary incentive to use as few words as possible. No such request was made of the control teams. The main finding was that subjects in the brevity condition, regardless of the communication mode, greatly reduced verbiage with no increase in time or decrease in accuracy. Moreover, subjects in the brevity-voice condition used even fewer words than did subjects in the control-teletypewriter condition. These results, then, lend weight to the second hypothesis.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Chapanis

Ochsman

R. B.

Parrish

R. N.

Weeks

G. D.

, Studies in interactive communication: I. The effects of four communication modes on the behavior of teams during cooperative problem solving. Human Factors, 1972, 14, 487–509.

Chapanis

Overbey

C. M.

Studies in interactive communication: III. Effects of similar and dissimilar communication channels and two interchange options on team problem solving. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 1974, 38, 343–374 (Monograph Supplement 2-V38).

Chapanis

Parris

R. N.

Ochsman

R. B.

Weeks

G. D.

Studies in interactive communication: II. The effects of four communication modes on linguistic performance of teams during cooperative problem solving. Human Factors, 1977, 19.

Duncan

Some signals and rules for taking speaking turns in conversations. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1972, 23, 283–292.

Horowitz

M. W.

Newman

J. B.

Spoken and written expression: An experimental analysis. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1974, 68, 640–647.

Kelly

M. J.

Chapanis

Studies in interactive communication: Limited vocabulary natural language dialogue. Submitted to the International Journal of Man-Machine Studies.

Ochsman

R. B.

Chapanis

The effects of 10 communication modes on the behavior of teams during cooperative problem solving. International Journal of Man-Machine Studies, 1974, 6, 579–619.

Parrish

R. N.

Interactive communication in team problem solving as a function of two educational levels and two communication modes. (Doctoral dissertation, The Johns Hopkins University, 1973). Dissertation Abstracts International, 1974, 34, 5721B. (University Microfilms No. 74–10, 440).

Weeks

G. D.

Chapanis

Cooperative versus conflictive problem solving in three telecommunication modes. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 1976, 42, 879–917.

10.

Weeks

G. D.

Kelly

M. J.

Chapanis

Studies in interactive communication: V. Cooperative problem solving by skilled and unskilled typists in a teletypewriter mode. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1974, 59, 665–674.