Warning signs to fasten seat belts result in higher rates of rear seat belt use in rideshare vehicles

Abstract

Using seat belts reduces traffic injuries and fatalities. Passengers in the rear seat typically use their seat belts less often than drivers or front-seat passengers. Seat belt use in the back is even less frequent in vehicles for hire such as taxi cabs and rideshare vehicles than in private passenger vehicles. This observational study of adult passengers video-recorded in rideshare vehicles in San Francisco found that a sign mounted at rear passenger seated eye level, and that warned of the risks of failing to wear a seat belt, resulted in significantly higher rates of seat belt use than for rear seat passengers not exposed to the warning sign. Results also showed that age, gender, and trip duration did not have a significant effect on rear seat belt use. Implications for future research and other countermeasures are discussed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams

A.S.

Edworthy

(1995). Quantifying and predicting the effects of basic text display variables on the perceived urgency of warning labels: Tradeoffs involving font size, border weight and colour. Ergonomics, 38, 2221-2237.

ANSI Z535.4 (2011), American National Standard for Product Safety Signs and Labels. New York: American National Standards Institute.

Bao

Xiong

Buonarosa

M.L.

Sayer

J.R.

(2015). Using naturalistic driving data to examine drivers' seatbelt use behavior: Comparison between teens and adults. J. Safety Research 54, 69–73.

Braun

C. C.

Sansing

Kennedy

R. S.

Silver

N. C.

(1994). Signal word and color specifications for product warnings: An isoperformance application. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 38, 1104–1108.

Braun

C.C.

Silver

N.C.

(1995). Interaction of signal word and colour on warning labels: Differences in perceived hazard and behavioural compliance. Ergonomics, 38(11), 2207-2220.

Chapanis

(1994). Hazards associated with three signal words and four colours on warning signs. Ergonomics, 37, 265–275.

Chy-Dejoras

E.A.

(1992). Effects of an aversive vicarious experience and modeling on perceived risk and self-protective behavior. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 36, 603-607.

Densu

S.N.

(2013). Occupant protection: Observed seatbelt use in the Sekondi-Takoradi Metropolis (STM), Ghana. International Journal of Structural and Civil Engineering Research, 2(4), 201-212.

Desaulniers

D.R.

(1987). Layout, organization, and the effectiveness of consumer product warnings. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 31, 56-60.

10.

deTurck

M.A.

Chih

I.H.

Hsu

Y.P.

(1999). Three studies testing the effects of role models on product users' safety behaviors. Human Factors, 41, 397-412.

11.

Farmer

C.M.

Wells

J.K.

2010. Effect of enhanced seat belt reminders on driver fatality risk. Journal of Safety Research 41(1):53-57.

12.

Ferguson

S.A.

Wells

J.K.

Williams

A.F.

Feldman

A.F.

(1999). Belt use rates among taxicab drivers in a jurisdiction with license points for nonuse. Journal of Safety Research, 30(2), 87–91.

13.

Foss

R.D.

Beirness

D.J.

Sprattler

(1994). Seat belt use among drinking drivers in Minnesota. American Journal of Public Health, 84(11), 1732-1737.

14.

Frantz

J.P.

(1993). Effect of location and presentation format on attention to and compliance with product warnings and instructions. Journal of Safety Research, 24, 131–154.

15.

Freedman

Levi

Zador

Lopdell

Bergeron

(2007). The Effectiveness of Enhanced Seat Belt Reminder Systems (Report No. DOT HS 810 844). Washington, DC: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.

16.

Godfrey

S.S.

Laughery

K.R.

Young

S.L.

Vaubel

K.P.

Brelsford

J.W.

Laughery

K.A.

Horn

(1991). The new alcohol warning labels: How noticeable are they? Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 35, 446-450.

17.

Goodwin

Kirley

Sandt

Hall

Thomas

O’Brien

Summerlin

(2013). Countermeasures that Work: A Highway Safety Countermeasures Guide for State Highway Safety Offices. 7th edition. (Report No. DOT HS 811 727). Washington, DC: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.

18.

Hathaway

J. A.

Dingus

T. A.

(1992). The effects of compliance cost and specific consequence information on the use of safety equipment. Accidental Analysis & Prevention, 24, 577–584.

19.

Hedlund

(2016). Unbuckled in back: An overlooked issue in occupant protection. Washington, D.C.: Governors Highway Safety Assoc.

20.

Hong

Kim

Kritkausky

Rashid

(1998). Effects of imitative behavior on seat belt usage: Three field observational studies. Proceedings of the Human Factors Society, 42, 1093–1097.

21.

Howell

R.H.

Owen

P.D.

Necks

E.C.

(1990). Increasing safety belt use: Effects of modeling and trip length. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 20(3), 254-263.

22.

Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (2018, May). Safety Belts. Retrieved from http://www.iihs.org/iihs/topics/t/safety-belts/qanda.

23.

Jaynes

L. S.

Boles

D. B.

(1990). The effect of symbols on warning compliance. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 34, 984–987.

24.

Kahane

C. J.

(2015, January). Lives saved by vehicle safety technologies and associated Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards, 1960 to 2012 – Passenger cars and LTVs (Report No. DOT HS 812 069). Washington, DC: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.

25.

Kalsher

M.J.

Obenauer

W.G.

Weiss

C.F.

(2016). Evaluating ANSI Z535-formatted warning labels as an integrative system. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 60th Annual Meeting (pp. 1640-1644).

26.

Kids and Cars and Center for Auto Safety v. Elaine Chao and National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (2017). Complaint. United States District Court For The District Of Columbia. Retrieved from https://www.autosafety.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/FiledComplaint.pdf.

27.

Knowles

Walter

L.K.

Buckle

(2008). Mobile phone and seat belt usage rates in London 2008. TRL Project Report PPR 364. Wokingham: TRL Ltd.

28.

Laughery

K. R.

Sr. Stanush

J. A.

(1989). Effects of warning explicitness on product perceptions. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 33, 431–435.

29.

Laughery

K. R.

Sr. Vaubel

K. P.

Young

S. L.

Brelsford

J. W.

Jr. Rowe

A. L.

(1993). Explicitness of consequence information in warnings. Safety Science, 16, 597–613.

30.

Kim

Nitz

(1999). Predictors of safety belt use among crash-involved drivers and front seat passengers: Adjusting for over-reporting. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 31(6), 631-638.

31.

Pickrell

T. M.

(2018, May, Revised). Occupant restraint use in 2016: Results from the NOPUS controlled intersection study (Report No. DOT HS 812 463). Washington, DC: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.

32.

McIlvenny

Al Mahrouqi

Al Busaidi

Al Nabhani

Al Hikmani

Al Kharousi

Al Mammari

Al Hoti

Al Shihi

Al Lawati

Al Kharousi

(2004). Rear seat belt use as an indicator of safe road behaviour in a rapidly developing country. J. Royal Society for the Promotion of Health, 124(6), 280-283.

33.

Morrow

D.G.

Leirer

V.O.

Andrassy

J.M.

Hier

C.M.

Menard

W.E.

(1998). The influence of list format and category headers on age differences in understanding medication instructions. Experimental Aging Research, 24, 231-256.

34.

National Center for Statistics and Analysis. (2018, June (revised)). Seat Belt Use in 2017—Use Rates in the States and Territories (Traffic Safety Facts Crash•Stats. Report No. DOT HS 812 546). Washington, DC: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.

35.

Nemire

(2017). Seat belt use by adult rear seat passengers in private passenger, taxi, and rideshare vehicles. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 61st Annual Meeting (pp. 1644-1648).

36.

Nichols

J.L.

Tippetts

A.S.

Fell

J.C.

Auld-Owens

Wiliszowski

C.H.

Haseltine

P.W.

Eichelberger

(2010). Strategies to Increase Seat Belt Use: An Analysis of Levels of Fines and the Type of Law (Report No. DOT HS 811 413). Washington, DC: US Department of Transportation.

37.

Otsubo

S. M.

(1988). A behavioral study of warning labels for consumer products: Perceived danger and use of pictographs. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 32, 536–540.

38.

Raneses

Pressley

J. C.

(2015). Factors associated with mortality in rear-seated adult passengers involved in fatal motor vehicle crashes on US roadways. Injury Epidemiology, 2(1), 5-17.

39.

Reagan

I.J.

McClafferty

J.A.

Berlin

S.P.

Hankey

J.M.

(2013). Using naturalistic driving data to identify variables associated with infrequent, occasional, and consistent seat belt use. Accident Analysis and Prevention 50, 600–607.

40.

Rogers

W. A.

Lamson

Rousseau

G. K.

(2000). Warning research: An integrative perspective. Human Factors, 42, 102-139.

41.

Russo

B.J.

Kay

J.J.

Savolainen

P.T.

Gates

T.J.

(2014). Assessing characteristics related to the use of seatbelts and cell phones by drivers: Application of a bivariate probit model. Journal of Safety Research 49, 137–142.

42.

Stempel

(2017, Aug 16). “U.S. Too Slow to Require Rear Seat Belt Warnings, Lawsuit Says.” Automotive News, 16 Aug. 2017. Retrieved from www.autonews.com/article/20170816/OEM11/170819842/u.s.-too-slow-to-require-rear-seat-belt-warnings-lawsuit-says.

43.

Thyer

B.A.

Geller

E.S.

(1987). The buckle up dashboard sticker: An effective environmental intervention for safety belt promotion. Environment and Behavior, 19, 484-494.

44.

Walter

L.K.

Narine

Buttress

(2009). Thames Valley seat belt survey 2009. TRL Published Project Report PPR416. Crowthorne: Transport Research Laboratory.

45.

Welkon

Reisinger

K.S.

(1977). The phantom taxi seat belt. American Journal of Public Health, 67(11), 1091-1092.

46.

Williams

A.F.

Wells

J.K.

Farmer

C.M.

(2002). Effectiveness of Ford’s enhanced belt reminder system in increasing seat belt use. Injury Prevention, 8, 293-296.

47.

Wogalter

M.S.

Alison

S.T.

McKenna

N.A.

(1989). Effects of cost and social influence on warning compliance. Human Factors, 31, 133-140.

48.

Wogalter

M.S.

Begley

P.B.

Scancorelli

L.F.

Brelsford

J.W.

(1997). Effectiveness of elevator service signs: Measurement of perceived understandability, willingness to comply, and behaviour. Applied Ergonomics, 28, 181-187.

49.

Wogalter

M.S.

Conzola

V.C.

Smith-Jackson

T.L.

(2002). Research-based guidelines for warning design and evaluation. Applied Ergonomics 33, 219–230.

50.

Wogalter

M.S.

Godfrey

S.S.

Fontenelle

G.A.

Desaulniers

D.R.

Rothstein

P.R.

Laughery

K.R.

Sr . (1987). Effectiveness of warnings. Human Factors, 29, 599–612.

51.

Wogalter

M.S.

Kalsher

M.J.

Racicot

B.M.

(1992). The influence of location and pictorials on behavior compliance to warnings. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 36, 1029–1033.

52.

Wogalter

M.S.

Rashid

(1998). A border surrounding warning sign text affects looking behavior: A field observational study. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 42, 1628.

53.

Young

(1991). Increasing the noticeability of warnings: Effects of pictorial, color, signal icon and border. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 35, 580-584.