Searching in clutter: Visual attention strategies of expert pilots

Abstract

Clutter can slow visual search. However, experts may develop attention strategies that alleviate the effects of clutter on search performance. In the current study we examined the effects of global and local clutter on visual search performance and attention strategies. Pilots and undergraduates searched for an elevation marker in charts of high, medium, and low global clutter. The target was in a low or high local clutter region of the chart or it was absent. High global and local clutter slowed search performance for both pilots and undergraduates. Pilots were more accurate but slower. Pilots’ search strategies differed from undergraduates in the following ways: they had more conservative criteria for responding target absent and spent more time processing the information within each fixation. Pilots and undergraduates used a coarse-to-fine search strategy in which, as the trial progressed, fixation durations increased and saccade distance decreased.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Beck

M.R.

Lohrenz

M.C.

Trafton

J.G.

(2010). Measuring Search Efficiency in Complex Visual Search Tasks: Global and Local Clutter. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 16(3), 238-250.

Christensen

E. E.

Murry

R. C.

Holland

Reynolds

Landay

M. J.

Moore

J. G

(1981). The effect of search time on perception. Diagnostic Radiology, 138, 361-365.

Ferrari

Didierjean

Marmèche

(2008). Effect of expertise acquisition on strategic perception: The example of chess. The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 61 (8), 1265-1280.

Godwin

H. J.

Liversedge

S. P.

Kirkby

J. A.

Cornes

Boardman

Donnelly

(2012, May). The influence of experience upon threat assessment and visual search in complex scenes. Poster presented at the annual meeting of the Vision Sciences Society, Naples, FL.

Jarodzka

Scheiter

Gerjets

van Gog

(2010). In the eyes of the beholder: How experts and novice interpret dynamic stimuli. Learning and Instruction, 20 (2), 146-154.

Lohrenz

M.C.

Gendron

M.L.

(2008). A 3D clustering algorithm to model clutter in electronic geospatial displays. Journal of Management and Engineering Integration, 1(2), 83-88.

Lohrenz

M.C.

Trafton

J.G.

Beck

M.R.

Gendron

M.L.

(2009). A model of clutter for complex, multivariate, geospatial displays. Human Factors, 51(1), 90-101.

Lohrenz

Trenchard

Myrick

Van Zuyle

Fechtig

(1997). Optimizing cockpit moving-map displays for enhanced situational awareness. Chapter 13 in Situational awareness in the tactical air environment: Augmented proceedings of the Naval Air Warfare Center’s first annual symposium, 363-387. CSERIAC, Wright-Patterson AFB, OH. July.

Myles-Worsley

Johnston

W. A.

Simons

M. A.

(1988). The influence of expertise on x-ray image processing. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 14 (3), 553-557.

10.

Over

E.A.B.

Hooge

I.T.C.

Vlaskamp

B.N.S.

Erkelens

C.J.

(2007) Coarse-to-fine eye movement strategies in visual search. Vision Research, 47, 2272-2280.

11.

Schons

Wickens

(1993). Visual separation and information access in aircraft display layout. University of Illinois Institution of Aviation Technical Report ARL-93-7/NASA-A3I-93-1, Savoy, IL.