An In vitro Study Comparing the Use of Suture Anchors and Drill Hole Fixation for Flexor Digitorum Longus Transfer to the Navicular

Abstract

Background: The surgical management of posterior tibial tendon dysfunction often includes transfer of the flexor digitorum longus (FDL) tendon through a tunnel in the navicular. Fixation often is obtained by sewing the tendon back onto itself. The purpose of this study was to compare this standard method of fixation with suture anchor fixation, a technique that may be associated with less surgical morbidity, because it requires the harvesting of less tendon length. Methods: FDL tendon transfer to the navicular was done in 13 fresh-frozen cadaver specimens. In six feet comprising the standard group, the FDL tendon was transected distal to the master knot of Henry, placed through a drill hole into the navicular, and sutured back onto itself. In seven feet the FDL tendon was transected proximal to the master knot of Henry, placed into a drill hole into the navicular, and fixed with a suture anchor. Load was applied to the proximal FDL muscle and tendon using a materials testing system (MTS) machine and peak load to failure was measured. Results: The mean load to failure was 142.48 N ± 38.06 N for the standard group and 142.12 N ± 59.26 N for the suture anchor group (p = 0.305 for the Student-t test and p = 0.945 for the Mann-Whitney test). Conclusion: Transfer of the FDL tendon to the navicular using suture anchor fixation requires less tendon length yet provides similar fixation strength as compared to sewing the tendon back onto itself. However, suture anchors are considerably more expensive than sutures. Clinical Implications: Suture anchors allow comparable fixation of FDL tendon transfer into a navicular without the need to disrupt the master knot of Henry. This technique may be associated with less morbidity including a shorter incision, decreased risk of medial plantar nerve injury, and decreased loss of lesser toe plantarflexion strength secondary to maintenance of the normal interconnections between the flexor hallucis longus (FHL) and FDL tendons.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. Fennell

Ballard

Pflaster

Adkins

: Comparative evaluation of bone suture anchor to bone tunnel fixation of tibialis anterior tendon in cadaveric cuboid bone: A biomechanical investigation. Foot Ankle Int. 16: 641–645, 1995

2. Goldner

Keats

Bassett

3rd Clippinger

: Progressive talipes equinovalgus due to trauma or degeneration of the posterior tibial tendon and medial plantar ligaments. Orthop. Clin. North Am. 5: 39–51, 1974

3. Guyton

Jeng

Krieger

Mann

: Flexor digitorum longus transfer and medial displacement osteotomy for posterior tibial tendon dysfunction: A middle-term clinical follow-up. Foot Ankle Int. 22: 627–632, 2001

4. Hui

Goh

JC.H

Lee

: Biomechanical study of tibialis anterior tendon transfer. Clin. Orthop. 349: 249–255, 1998

5. Jahss

: Spontaneous rupture of the tibialis posterior tendon: Clinical findings, tenographic studies, and a new technique of repair. Foot Ankle, 3: 158–166, 1982

6. Johnson

Cohen

DiGiovanni

Lamdan

: Subtalar arthrodesis with flexor digitorum longus transfer and spring ligament repair for treatment of posterior tibial tendon insufficiency. Foot Ankle Int. 21: 722–729, 2000

7. Johnson

Strom

: Tibialis posterior tendon dysfunction. Clin. Orthop. 239: 196–198, 1989

8. Krackow

Thomas

Jones

: A New stitch for ligament-tendon fixation. J. Bone Joint. Surg. 68-A: 764–766, 1986

9. Liu

Panossian

Al-Shaikh

: Morphology and matrix composition during early tendon to bone healing. Clin. Orthop. 339: 253–260, 1997

10.

10. Mosier-LaClair

Pomeroy

Manoli

: Intermediate follow-up on the double osteotomy and tendon transfer procedure for stage II posterior tibial tendon insufficiency. Foot Ankle Int. 22: 283–291, 2001

11.

11. Louden

Ambrose

Beaty

McGarvey

Clanton

: Tendon transfer fixation in the foot and ankle: A biomechanical study evaluating two sizes of pilot holes for bioabsorbable screws. Foot Ankle Int. 24: 67–72, 2003

12.

12. Mann

Thompson

: Rupture of the posterior tibial tendon causing flatfoot. Surgical treatment. J. Bone Joint Surg. 67-A: 556–561, 1985

13.

13. Myerson

Corrigan

: Treatment of posterior tibial tendon dysfunction with flexor digitorum longus tendon transfer and calcaneal osteotomy. Orthopedics 19: 383–388, 1996

14.

14. Myerson

Cohen

Uribe

: An easy way of tensioning and securing a tendon to bone. Foot Ankle Int. 23: 753–755, 2002

15.

15. Sabonghy

Wood

Ambrose

McGarvey

Clanton

: Tendon transfer fixation: Comparing a tendon to tendon technique vs. bioabsorbable interference-fit screw fixation. Foot Ankle Int. 24: 260–262, 2003

16.

16. Sammarco

Hockenbury

: Treatment of stage II posterior tibial tendon dysfunction with flexor hallucis longus transfer and medial displacement calcaneal osteotomy. Foot Ankle Int. 22: 305–312, 2001

17.

17. Song

Deland

: Outcome following addition of peroneus brevis tendon transfer treatment of acquired posterior tibial tendon insufficiency. Foot Ankle Int. 22: 301–304, 2001

18.

18. Toolan

Sangeorzan

Hansen

Jr. : Complex reconstruction for the treatment of dorsolateral peritalar subluxation of the foot. Early results after distraction arthrodesis of the calcaneocuboid joint in conjunction with stabilization of, and transfer of the flexor digitorum longus tendon to, the midfoot to treat acquired pes planovalgus in adults. J. Bone Joint Surg. 81-A: 1545–1560, 1999

19.

19. Wapner

Hecht

Shea

Allardyce

: Anatomy of second muscular layer of the foot: considerations for tendon selection in transfer for Achilles and posterior tibial tendon reconstruction. Foot Ankle Int. 15: 420–423, 1994