The Impact of Instrumented Gait Analysis on Surgical Planning: Treatment of Spastic Equinovarus Deformity of the Foot and Ankle

Abstract

Background: Despite the logic behind instrumented gait analysis, its specific contribution to clinical and surgical decision making is not well known. Our purpose in this study was to determine the influence of gait analysis with dynamic electromyography upon surgical planning in patients with upper motor neuron syndrome and gait dysfunction.

Methods: Two surgeons prospectively evaluated 36 consecutive adult patients with a spastic equinovarus deformity of the foot and ankle. After an initial history and physical exam, each surgeon independently formulated a surgical plan. Surgical treatment options for each individual muscle/tendon unit crossing the ankle included lengthening, transfer, release or no surgery. After the initial clinical evaluation and surgical planning, all patients then underwent instrumented gait analysis collecting kinetic, kinematic and poly-EMG data using a standard protocol by a single experienced physiatrist. Each surgeon reviewed the gait studies and patients independently and again formulated a surgical plan. The surgical plans were compared for each surgeon before and after gait study. The agreement between the two surgeon's surgical plans was also compared before and after gait study. Each patient was evaluated for the clinical outcome of surgery.

Results: Overall a change was made in 64% of the surgical plans after the gait study. The frequency of changing the surgical plan was not significantly different between the more and less experienced surgeons. The agreement between surgeons increased from 0.34 to 0.76 (p = 0.009) after the gait study. The number of surgical procedures planned by each surgeon converged after the gait studies. Correction of the varus deformity was seen in all patients that underwent surgical treatment.

Conclusion: Instrumented gait analysis alters surgical planning for patients with equinovarus deformity of the foot and ankle and can produce higher agreement between surgeons in surgical planning.

Clinical Relevance: The equinovarus deformity is due to a variety of deforming forces and a single, best operation does not exist to correct all equinovarus deformities. Rather, a muscle specific approach that identifies the deforming forces will produce the best outcomes when treating the spastic equinovarus deformity.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. Fulford

: Surgical Management of Ankle and Foot Deformities in Cerebral Palsy. Clin Orthop. 253:55–61, 1990.

2. Lawrence

Botte

: Management of the Adult, Spastic, Equinovarus Foot Deformity. Foot Ankle Int. 15:340–6. 1994.

3. Mooney

Goodman

: Surgical Approaches to Lower-extremity Disability Secondary to Stroke. Clin Orthop. 63:142–52, 1969.

4. Kregs

Edelstein

Fishman

: Reliability of Observational Kinematic Gait Analysis. Phys Ther. 65:1027–33, 1985.

5. Saleh

Murdoch

: In Defence of Gait Analysis. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 67:237–41, 1985.

6. Jordan

: Current Status of Functional Lower Extremity Surgery in Adult Spastic Patients. Clin Orthop. 233:102–9, 1988.

7. Keenan

MAE

: Surgical Decision Making for Residual Limb Deformities Following Traumatic Brain Injury. Orthop Rev. 17:1185–92, 1988.

8. Keenan

Creighton

Garland

Moore

: Surgical Correction of Spastic Equinovarus Deformity in the Adult Head Trauma Patient. Foot Ankle. 5:35–41, 1984.

9. Perry

: The Use of Gait Analysis for Surgical Recommendations in Traumatic Brain Injury. J Head Trauma Rehabil. 116–35, 1999.

10.

10. Perry

Waters

Perrin

: Electromyographic Analysis of Equinovarus Following Stroke. Clin Orthop. 131:47–53, 1978.

11.

11. Barnes

Herring

: Combined Split Anterior Tibial-Tendon Transfer and Intramuscular Lengthening of the Posterior Tibial Tendon: Results in Patients who have a Varus Deformity of the Foot Due to Spastic Cerebral Palsy. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 73:734–8, 1991.

12.

12. Vogt

: Split Anterior Tibial Transfer for Spastic Equinovarus Foot Deformity: Retrospective Study of 73 Operated Feet. J Foot Ankle Surg. 37:2–7, 1998.

13.

13. Watts

: Gait Laboratory Analysis for Preoperative Decision Making in Spastic Cerebral Palsy: Is It All It's Cracked Up To Be? J Pediatr Orthop. 14:703–4, 1994.

14.

14. DeLuca

Davis

Ounpuu

Rose

Sirkin

: Alterations in Surgical Decision Making in Patients with Cerebral Palsy Based on Three-Dimensional Gait Analysis. J Pediatr Orthop. 17:608–14, 1997.

15.

15. Kay

Dennis

Rethlefsen

Reynolds

RAK

Skaggs

Tolo

: The Effect of Preoperative Gait Analysis on Orthopaedic Decision Making. Clin Orthop. 372:217–22, 2000.

16.

16. Lee

Goh

Bose

: Value of Gait Analysis in the Assessment of Surgery in Cerebral Palsy. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 73:642–6, 1992.

17.

17. Hinterman

Nigg

Sommer

: Foot Movement and Tendon Excursion: An In Vitro Study. Foot Ankle Int. 15:386–95, 1994.

18.

18. Esquenazi

: Computerized Gait Analysis for Rehabilitation and Surgical Planning in Upper Motor Neuron Syndrome. Eur Medicophys. 35:111–8, 1999.

19.

19. Esquenazi

Rolle

Hirai

Vachranukunkiet

: EMG Activity of the Medial and Lateral Gastrocnemius During Pathologic Gait. Arch Phys Med Rehab. 69:778, 1988.

20.

20. Fulford

Veldman

HJG

Stewart

: Dynamic Inversion of the Forefoot and Dorsiflexion of the Big Toe Treated by Transfer of Extensor Hallucis Longus. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 71:21–3, 1989.

21.

21. Kling

Kaufer

Hensinger

: Split Posterior Tibial-Tendon Transfers in Children with Cerebral Spastic Paralysis and Equinovarus Deformity. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 67:186–94, 1985.

22.

22. Morita

Yamamoto

Furuya

: Anterior Transfer of the Toe Flexors for Equinovarus Deformity Due to Hemiplegia. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 76:447–9, 1994.

23.

23. Root

Miller

Kirz

: Posterior Tibial-Tendon Transfer in Patients with Cerebral Palsy. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 69:1133–9, 1987.

24.

24. Saji

Upadhyay

Hsu

LCS

Leong

JCY

: Split Tibialis Posterior Transfer for Equinovarus Deformity in Cerebral Palsy: Long-term Results of a New Surgical Procedure. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 75:498–501, 1993.

25.

25. Schneider

Balon

: Deformity of the Foot Following Anterior Transfer of the Posterior Tibial Tendon and Lengthening of the Achilles Tendon for Spastic Equinovarus. Clin Orthop. 125:113–8, 1977.