Surgical Versus Non-Surgical Treatment of Calcaneal Fractures in Children: A Long-term Results Comparative Study

Abstract

This study compared surgical and non-surgical treatment of 46 calcaneal fractures in children aged 3-17 years. Patients were divided into: Group A ranging 3-14 years and Group B 15-17 years, and classified according to surgical or non-surgical treatment. Mean follow-up was 22.8 years. Extra-articular fractures were treated non-surgically and all results were satisfactory. Results of articular fractures in Group A were satisfactory regardless of the type of treatment. Articular fractures surgically treated in group B were satisfactory, and those non-surgically treated were mainly poor. Extra-articular fractures can be treated non-surgically. Articular fractures in skeletally immature children can be treated non-surgically; conversely, those in children with skeletal maturity must be treated surgically.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. Boöhler

: Diagnosis, pathology and treatment of fractures of the os calcis. J. Bone Joint Surg., 13A:75–89, 1931.

2. Chapman

H.G.

Galway

H.R.

: Os calcis fractures in childhood. J Bone Joint Surg., 59B: 510, 1977.

3. Duparc

De La Caffiniere

J.Y.

: Mechanism, anatomo-patholo- gy and classification of articular fractures of the calcaneus. Ann Chir., 24:289–301, 1970.

4. Essex-Lo Presti

: The mechanism, reduction technique and results in fractures of the os calcis. Brit J Surg., 39:395–419, 1952.

5. Frediani

P.V.

, et al.: Lurgenza traumatologica nel piede del bambino. Riv Ital Ortop Traumatol Pediatr., 6(2): 337–345, 1990.

6. Generoso

, et al.: Puericultura, neonatologia, pediatria con assistenza. SEE Firenze, 1994.

7. Giannini

Ceccarelli

: La nostra esperienza nel trattamento chirurgico delle fratture di calcagno. Progressi in medicina e chirurgia del piede-Societa italiana di medicina e chirurgia del piede. Bologna, Aulo Gaggi Editore, 1994, pp.145–152.

8. Green

N.E.

Swiontkowski

M.F.

: Skeletal trauma in children. Philadelphia, W.B. Saunders Company, 1998, pp.505–575.

9. Linhart

W.E.

Hollwart

M.E.

: Fracturen des Kindlichen tubes. Orthopade, 15:242–250, 1985.

10.

10. Mattery

R.E.

Frymoyer

J.W.

. Fracture of the calcaneus in young children: report of 3 cases. J. Bone Joint Surg., 55A:1091–1094, 1973.

11.

11. Palmer

: The mechanism and treatment of fractures of calcaneus. Open reduction with the use of cancellous grafts. J. Bone Joint Surg., 30A:2–8, 1948.

12.

12. Putnam Blount

: Injuries of the foot in fractures in children, Baltimore, The Williams & Wilkins Company, 1955, pp.195–201.

13.

13. Rowe

C.R.

: Fracture of the os calcis. JAMA, 184:920–923, 1963.

14.

14. Sanders

: Intra-articular fractures of calcaneus: present state of the art. J Orthop Trauma, 6(2): 252–265, 1996.

15.

15. anders

Fortin

Dipasquale

Walling

: Operative treatment in 120 displaced intraarticular calcaneal fractures. Clin Orthop Rel Res., 290:87–95, 1993.

16.

16. Schantz

Rasmussen

: Good prognosis after calcaneal fracture in childhood. Acta Orthop Scand., 59(5), 560–563, 1988.

17.

17. Schmidt

T.L.

Weiner

D.S.

: Calcaneal fractures in children: an evaluation of the nature of the injury in 56 children. Clin Orthop., 171: 150–155, 1982.

18.

18. Schofield

R.O.

: Fracture of os calcis. J. Bone Joint Surg., 18B:566–580, 1936.

19.

19. Thomas

H.M.

: Calcaneal fracture in childhood. Brit J Surg., 56:664–666, 1969.

20.

20. Thomez

J.G.

: Ankle Fractures and foot fractures in operative foot surgery. Philadelphia, W. B. Sanders Company, 1994, pp. 878–898.

21.

21. Trott

A.W.

: Fractures of the foot in children. Orthop Clin North Am., 7(3): 677–686, 1976.

22.

22. Warrick

C.K.

Bremmer

A.E.

: Fractures of the calcaneum, with an atlas illustrating the various types of fractures. J. Bone Joint Surg., 35B: 33–45, 1953.

23.

23. Wiley

J.J.

Profitt

: Fractures of the os calcis in children clinical orthopaedics and reated research, 188:131–138, 1984.

24.

24. Wilkins

K.E.

: The incidence of fracture in children. Rockwood

C.A.

Jr , Fourth edition vol. 3 Philadelphia, Lippincott-Raven, 1996, pp. 3–17.

25.

25. Zwipp

Ranft

T.H.

: Fehlverheilte Kindliche frakturen in fub- bereich. Orthopade, 20:374–380, 1991.