The Reliability and Validity of a First Ray Measurement Device

Abstract

The need for measuring the mobility of the first ray has been identified. The purpose of this study was to test the reliability and validity of a device built to measure the relative vertical displacement of the first ray. Twenty fresh frozen cadaver feet were sampled (mean age of donor was 70 ± 13 years). Dorsal mobility of the first ray was measured by device over three trials of repeated loading using 20 N, 35 N, 55 N and 85 N of force. Radiographs served as the criterion standard for validation of the device. Vertical displacement was measured from x-ray by a digitizing procedure that recorded movement of the first ray during loading. Reliability of the device assessed by intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) was .98 with standard errors of the measurement calculated to be 0.35 mm. A correlation of agreement value of .97 was determined for the two methods of measurement. Analysis of variance testing found a significant interaction between force and method of measurement. Tukey post-hoc analysis found no difference (F < 1.70) between the two methods of measuring first ray displacement in cadaver specimens when the force applied did not exceed 55 N. At 85 N of force (F = 10.05), unwanted movement of the second metatarsal caused the device to overestimate the amount of displacement that occurred specific to the first ray. This measure of first ray mobility should help clinicians and researchers to better investigate foot pathology resulting from faulty mechanics of the first ray.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. Baxter

D.E

: Treatment of bunion deformity in the athlete. Orthop Clin North Am., 25:33–39, 1994

2. Birke

J.A.

Franks

D.B.

Foto

J.G.

: First ray joint limitation, pressure, and ulceration of the first metatarsal head in diabetes mellitus. Foot Ankle Int., 16:277–284, 1995

3. Brand

P.W.

Coleman

W.C.

: A standard for dorsal-plantar and lateral radiographic projections of the feet. Orthopedics, 10:117–120, 1987

4. Donatelli

R.A.

: Abnormal biomechanics. In Donatelli

R.A.

(ed.), The Biomechanics of the Foot and Ankle, 2nd ed. Philadelphia, F.A. Davis Co., 1996, pp. 34–72

5. Fritz

G.R.

Prieskorn

: First metatarsocuneiform motion: a radiographic and statistical analysis. Foot Ankle Int., 16:117–123, 1995

6. Glasoe

W.M.

Allen

M.K.

Yack

H.J.

: Measurement of dorsal mobility in the first ray: elimination of fat pad compression as a variable. Foot Ankle Int., 19:542–546, 1998

7. Glasoe

W.M.

Yack

H.J.

Saltzman

C.L.

: Measuring first ray mobility with a new device. Arch Phys Med Rehabil., 80:122–124, 1999

8. Haut

R.C.

Powlison

A.C.

: The effects of test environment and cyclic stretching on the failure properties of human patellar tendons. J Orthop Res., 8:532–540, 1990

9. Hicks

J.H.

: The mechanics of the foot: I. The joints. J Anat., 87:345–357, 1953

10.

10. Jahss

: Disorders of the hallux and the first ray. In: Wickland

, (ed.), Disorders of the Foot and Ankle. 2nd ed. Philadelphia, W.B. Saunders Co., 1991; pp 943–946

11.

11. Kitaoka

Zong

Kai-Nan

: Three-dimensional analysis of normal ankle and foot mobility. Am J Sports Med, 25:238–242, 1997

12.

12. Klaue

Hansen

S.T.

Masquelet

A.C.

: Clinical, quantitative assessment of first tarsometatarsal mobility in the sagittal plane and its relation to hallux valgus deformity. Foot Ankle Int., 15:9–13, 1994

13.

13. Morton

D.J.

: Structural factors in static disorders of the foot. Am J Surg., 9:315–326, 1930

14.

14. Myerson

Allon

McGarvey

: Metatarsocuneiform arthrodesis for management of hallux valgus and metatarsus primus varus. Foot Ankle Int., 13:107–115, 1992

15.

15. Novick

: Anatomy and Biomechanics. In: Hunt

G.C.

McPoil

T.G.

, (ed.), Clinics in Physical Therapy, Physical Therapy of the Foot and Ankle. 2nd ed. New York, Churchill Livingstone, 1995; pp 34–46

16.

16. Ouzounian

T.J.

Shereff

M.J.

: In vitro determination of midfoot motion. Foot Ankle Int., 10:140–146, 1989

17.

17. Panjabi

M.M.

Krag

Summers

Videman

: Biomechanical time-tolerance of fresh cadaveric human spine specimens. J Orthop Res., 3:292–300, 1985

18.

18. Pelker

R.R.

Friedlander

G.E.

Markham

T.C.

Panjabi

M.M.

Moen

C.J.

: Effects of freezing and freeze-drying on the mechanical properties of rat bone. J Orthop Res., 1:405–411, 1984

19.

19. Perlman

P.R.

Duubois

Siskind

: Validating the process of taking lateral foot x-rays. J Am Podiatr Med Assoc., 86:317–321, 1996

20.

20. Phillips

R.D.

Law

E.A.

Ward

E.D.

: Functional motion of the medial column joints of the foot during propulsion. J Amer Podiatr Med Assoc., 86:474–486, 1996

21.

21. Prieskorn

D.W.

Mann

R.A.

Fritz

: Radiographic assessment of the second metatarsal: measure of first ray hypermobility. Foot Ankle Int., 17:331–333, 1996

22.

22. Rodgers

M.M.

Cavanagh

P.R.

: A device for the measurement of first ray mobility. Proceedings of the North American Congress on Biomechanics, Montreal, Canada, August 25–27, 1986., pp. 205–206

23.

23. Root

M.L.

Orien

W.P.

Weed

J.H.

: Normal and Abnormal Function of the Foot; Los Angeles, Clinical Biomechanics Corp., 1977; pp 48–51

24.

24. Saltzman

C.L.

Nawoczenski

D.A.

: Complexities of foot architecture as a base of support. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther., 21:354–360, 1995

25.

25. Saltzman

C.L.

Nawoczenski

D.A.

Talbot

K.D.

: Measurement of medial longitudinal arch. Arch Phys Med Rehabil., 76:45–49, 1995

26.

26. Shereff

M.J.

: Pathology, anatomy and biomechanics of hallux valgus. Orthopaedics, 13:939–945, 1990

27.

27. Shrout

Fliess

J.L.

: Intraclass correlations: uses in assessing rater reliability. Psychol Bull., 86:420–428, 1979

28.

28. Simkin

Leichter

Giladi

Stein

Milgram

: Combined effect of foot arch structure and an orthotic device on stress fracture. Foot Ankle Int., 10:25–29, 1989

29.

29. Viladot

: The metatarsals. In: Wickland

, (ed.), Disorders of the Foot and Ankle. 2nd ed. Philadelphia, W.B. Saunders Co., 1991; pp 1229–1254

30.

30. Wanivenhaus

Pretterklieber

: First ta sometatarsal joint: anatomical biomechanical study. Foot Ankle Int., 9:153–157, 1989

31.

31. Weinfeld

Haddad

Myerson

: Metatarsal stress fractures. Clin Sports Med., 16:319–338, 1997

32.

32. Woo

S.L.

Gomes

M.A.

Seguchi

Endo

C.M.

Akeson

W.H.

: Measurement of mechanical properties of ligament substance from bone-ligament-bone preparation. J Orthop Res., 1:22–29, 1983

33.

33. Wright

D.G.

Desai

S.M.

Henderson

W.H.

: Action of the subtalar and ankle-joint complex during the stance phase of walking. J Bone Joint Surg., 46A:361–382, 1964