This article offers a review and critique of the large literature on the pollution havens hypothesis. This hypothesis refers to the notion that certain jurisdictions can become pollution havens as dirty industries relocate or expand in response to differences in regulatory stringency. The early literature, based on cross-sectional analyses, typically concludes that environmental regulations have an insignificant effect on firm location decisions. However, recent studies that use panel data to control for unobserved heterogeneity, or instruments to control for endogeneity, find statistically significant pollution haven effects of reasonable magnitude. Furthermore, this distinction appears regardless of whether the studies look across countries, states, counties, or industries, or whether they examine plant locations, investment, or international trade patterns.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abel, A., & Phillips, T. (2000, October). The relocation of El Paso’s stonewashing industry and its implication for trade and the environment. Paper presented at the North American Symposium on Assessing the Linkages Between Trade and the Environment, Washington, DC. Available from www.cec.org/files/PDF/ECONOMY/symposium-e.pdf
2.
Antweiler, W., Copeland, B. R., & Taylor, M. S. (2001). Is free trade good for the environment? American Economic Review, 91(4), 877-908.
3.
Bartik, T. J. (1988, summer). The effects of environmental regulations on business location in the United States. Growth & Change, 22-44.
4.
Bartik, T. J. (1989). Small business start-ups in the United States: Estimates of the effects of characteristics of states. Southern Economic Journal, 55(4), 1004-1018.
5.
Becker, R., & Henderson, V. (2000). Effects of air quality regulations on polluting industries. Journal of Political Economy, 108(2), 379-421.
6.
Berman, E., & Bui, L. (2001, February). Environmental regulation and labor demand: Evidence from the South Coast Air Basin. Journal of Public Economics, 79, 265-295.
7.
Bhagwati, J. (1987). The generalized theory of distortions and welfare. In J. Bhagwati (Ed.), International trade: selected readings (2nd ed., pp. 265-286). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
8.
Bhagwati, J. (1993, November). The case for free trade. Scientific American, 269(5), 42-49.
9.
Birdsall, N., & Wheeler, D. (1993). Trade policy and industrial pollution in Latin America: Where are the pollution havens? Journal of Environment & Development, 2(1), 137-149.
10.
Bommer, R. (1998). Economic integration and the environment. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing.
11.
Brunnermeier, S., & Cohen, M. (2003). Determinants of environmental innovation in U.S. manufacturing industries. Journal of Environmental Economics & Management, 45(2), 278-293.
12.
Clark, D., Marchese, S., & Zarrilli, S. (2000). Do dirty industries conduct offshore assembly in developing countries? International Economic Journal, 14(3), 75-86.
13.
Copeland, B., & Taylor, S. (in press). Trade, growth and the environment. Journal of Economic Literature.
14.
Coughlin, C. C. (2002, January/February). The controversy over free trade: The gap between economists and the general public. Review, 1-21. St Louis, MO: Federal Reserve Bank.
15.
Dean, J. (1992). Trade and the environment: A survey of the literature. In P. Low (Ed.), International trade and the environment (World Bank Discussion Paper #159) (pp. 819-842). Washington, DC: World Bank.
16.
Dean, J. (2002, November). Does trade liberalization harm the environment? A new test. Canadian Journal of Economics, 35(4), 819-842.
17.
Ederington, J., Levinson, A., & Minier, J. (2003). Footloose and pollution-free (NBER Working Paper #W9718). Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
18.
Ederington, J., & Minier, J. (2003). Is environmental policy a secondary trade barrier? An empirical analysis. Canadian Journal of Economics, 36(1), 137-154.
19.
Eskeland, G. S., & Harrison, A. (1997). Moving to greener pastures? Multinationals and the pollution haven hypothesis (World Bank Working Paper). Washington, DC: World Bank.
20.
Fortune. (1977). Facility location decisions. New York: Fortune.
21.
Fredriksson, P. G., & Millimet, D. L. (2002). Strategic interaction and the determination of environmental policy across U.S. states. Journal of Urban Economics, 51, 101-122.
22.
Friedman, J., Gerlowski, D. A., & Silberman, J. (1992). What attracts foreign multinational corporations? Evidence from branch plant location in the United States. Journal of Regional Science, 32(4), 403-418.
23.
Greenstone, M. (2002). The impacts of environmental regulations on industrial activity: Evidence from the 1970 and 1977 Clean Air Act amendments and Census of Manufactures. Journal of Political Economy, 110(6), 1175-1219.
24.
Grossman, G., & Krueger, A. (1993). Environmental impacts of a North American Free Trade Agreement. In P. Garber (Ed.), The U.S.-Mexico free trade agreement (pp. 13-56). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
25.
Henderson, J. V. (1996). Effects of air quality regulation. American Economic Review, 86(4), 789-813.
26.
Jaffe, A., Peterson, S., Portney, P., & Stavins, R. (1995). Environmental regulations and the competitiveness of U.S. manufacturing: What does the evidence tell us? Journal of Economic Literature, 33, 132-163.
27.
Kalt, J. P. (1988). The impact of domestic environmental regulatory policies on U.S. international competitiveness. In M. Spence & H. Hazard (Eds.), International competitiveness (pp. 221-262). Cambridge, MA: Harper and Row, Ballinger.
28.
Keller, W., & Levinson, A. (2002). Environmental regulations and FDI to U.S. States. Review of Economics & Statistics, 84(4), 691-703.
29.
Levinson, A. (1996a). Environmental regulations and industry location: International and domestic evidence. In J. Bhagwati & R. Hudec (Eds.), Fair trade and harmonization: Prerequisite for free trade? (pp. 429-457). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
30.
Levinson, A. (1996b). Environmental regulations and manufacturer’s location choices: Evidence from the Census of Manufactures. Journal of Public Economics, 62(1-2), 5-29.
31.
Levinson, A. (1997). A note on environmental federalism: Interpreting some contradictory results. Journal of Environmental Economics & Management, 33(3), 359-366.
32.
Levinson, A. (2003, March). Environmental regulatory competition: A status report and some new evidence. National Tax Journal, 56(1), 91-106.
33.
Levinson, A., & Taylor, S. (2003). Trade and the environment: Unmasking the pollution haven hypothesis (Georgetown University Working Paper). Washington, DC: Georgetown University.
34.
List, J. A., & Co, C. Y. (2000). The effects of environmental regulations on foreign direct investment. Journal of Environmental Economics & Management, 40, 1-20.
35.
List, J. A., & Kunce, M. (2000). Environmental protection and economic growth: What do the residuals tell us? Land Economics, 76(2), 267-282.
36.
Low, P., & Yeats, A. (1992). Do dirty industries migrate? In P. Low (Ed.), International trade and the environment (World Bank Discussion Paper #159) (pp. 89-104). Washington, DC: World Bank.
37.
Lucas, R., Wheeler, D., & Hettige, H. (1992). Economic development, environmental regulation, and international migration of toxic industrial pollution: 1960-1988. In P. Low (Ed.), International trade and the environment (World Bank Discussion Paper #159) (pp. 67-88). Washington, DC: World Bank.
38.
Lyne, J. (1990, October). Service taxes, international site selection and the Green Movement dominates executives political focus. Site Selection, n.p.
39.
Mani, M., Pargal, S., & Huq, M. (1997). Does environmental regulation matter? Determinants of the location of new manufacturing plants in India in 1994 (World Bank Working Paper #1718). Washington, DC: World Bank.
40.
Mani, M., & Wheeler, D. (1998). In search of pollution havens? Dirty industries in the world economy, 1960 to 1995. Journal of Environment & Development, 7(3), 215-247.
41.
Markusen, J., Morey, E., & Olewiler, N. (1995). Noncooperative equilibria in regional environmental policies when plant locations are endogenous. Journal of Public Economics, 56(1), 55-77.
42.
McConnell, V. D., & Schwab, R. (1990). The impact of environmental regulation on industry location decisions: The motor vehicle industry. Land Economics, 66(1), 67-81.
43.
McFadden, D. (1973). Conditional logit analysis of qualitative choice behavior. In P. Zarembka (Ed.), Frontiers of econometrics (pp. 105-142). New York: Academic.
44.
Neumayer, E. (2001). Pollution havens: An analysis of policy options for dealing with an elusive phenomenon. Journal of Environment & Development, 10(2), 147-177.
45.
Oates, W. E., & Schwab, R. M. (1988). Economic competition among jurisdictions: Efficiency enhancing or distortion inducing? Journal of Public Economics, 35, 333-354.
46.
Osang, T., & Nandy, A. (2000). Impact of U.S. environmental regulation on the competitiveness of manufacturing industries (Southern Methodist University, Department of Economics Working Paper). Dallas, TX: Southern Methodist University.
47.
Pethig, R. (1976). Pollution, welfare and environmental policy in the theory of comparative advantage. Journal of Environmental Economics & Management, 2, 160-169.
48.
Porter, M. E., & van der Linde, C. (1995). Toward a new conception of the environment-competitiveness relationship. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 9(4), 97-118.
49.
PROFEPA (Federal Attorney for Environmental Protection). (2001). Tri-annual report of activities of the federal attorney for Environment Protection 1995-1997. Mexico City, MEX: Author.
50.
Rauscher, M. (1997). Environmental regulation and international capital allocation. In C. Carraro & D. Siniscalco (Eds.), New directions in the economic theory of the environment (pp. 193-237). Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
51.
Siebert, H. (1977). Environmental quality and the gains from trade. Kyklos, 30, 657-673.
52.
Smarzynska, B. K., & Wei, S.-J. (2001). Pollution havens and foreign direct investment: Dirty secret or popular myth? (World Bank Working Paper). Washington, DC: World Bank
53.
Stafford, H. A. (1985). Environmental protection and industrial location. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 75(2), 227-240.
54.
Tobey, J. A. (1990). The effects of domestic environmental policies on patterns of world trade: An empirical test. Kyklos, 43(2), 191-209.
55.
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), Program on Transnational Corporations. (1993). Environmental management in transnational corporations: Report on the Benchmark Environmental Survey. New York: United Nations.
56.
U.S. General Accounting Office. (1991, April). U.S.-Mexico trade: Some U.S. wood furniture firms relocated from Los Angeles to Mexico. (GAO/NSIAD-91-191). Washington, DC: Author.
57.
van Beers, C., & van den Bergh, J. C. J. M. (1997). An empirical multi-country analysis of the impact of environmental regulations on foreign trade flows. Kyklos, 50, 29-46.
58.
Wheeler, D. (2001). Racing to the bottom? Foreign investment and air pollution in developing countries. Journal of Environment & Development, 10(3), 225-245.
59.
Xing, Y., & Kolstad, C. D. (2002). Do lax environmental regulations attract foreign investment? Environmental & Resource Economics, 21(1), 1-22.
