Durkheim's proposition that suicide varies inversely with social inte
gration is subjected to a holocultural test, using three indicators of social
integration. Contrary to Durkheim's thesis, suicide is found to vary directly
with societal integration. An explanation of this finding is offered, em
ploying a distinction between the integration of the group as a whole and
the integration of individuals within groups.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Bohannan, Paul J.1960African homicide and suicide, Princeton, Princeton University Press.
2.
Douglas, Jack D.1967The social meanings of suicide, Princeton, Princeton University Press.
3.
Dublin, Louis I.1963Suicide: a sociological and statistical study , New York, Ronald Press.
4.
Durkheim, Emile1951Suicide, Glencoe, Free Press.
5.
1961The elementary forms of the religious life, New York, Collier Books.
6.
Fortune, Reo1932The sorcerers of Dobu, New York, Dutton.
7.
Gibbs, Jack P.1971"Suicide" in Robert K. Merton and Robert Nisbet, eds., Contemporary Social Problems, New York, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich : 271-312.
8.
Gibbs, Jack P., and Walter T. Martin1964Status integration and suicide , Eugene, University of Oregon Press.
9.
Gouldner, Alvin W., and Richard A. Peterson1962Notes on technology and the moral order, Indianapolis, Bobbs-Merrill.
10.
Henry, Andrew F., and James F. Short, Jr.1954Suicide and homicide, New York, Free Press.
11.
Johnson, Barclay D.1965 "Durkheim's one cause of suicide" American Sociological Review30: 875-86.
12.
Krauss, Herbert H., and Beatrice J. Krauss1968 "Cross-cultural study of the thwarting-disorientation theory of suicide" Journal of Abnormal Psychology73: 353-57.
13.
Krauss, Herbert H., and Abraham Tesser1971 "Social contexts of suicide," Journal of Abnormal Psychology78: 222-28.
14.
Lester, Gene, and David Lester1971Suicide: the gamble with death, Englewood Cliffs , Prentice-Hall.
15.
Masumura, Wilfred T.1974The social conditions of violence: a holocultural study, doctoral dissertationUniversity of Montana.
16.
Murdock, George P., Clellan S. Ford, Alfred E. Hudson, Raymond Kennedy, Leo W. Simmons, and John W. M. Whiting1971Outline of cultural materials, 4th revised editionNew Haven, Human Relations Area Files.
17.
Naroll, Raoul1962Data quality control, New York, Free Press.
18.
1963Thwarting disorientation and suicide: a cross-cultural surveyAnthropology Department, Northwestern University (mimeograph ) .
19.
1964 "A fifth solution to Galton's problem" American Anthropologist66: 863-67.
20.
1967 "The HRAF quality control sample universe," Behavior Science Notes2: 81-88.
21.
1969 "Cultural determinants and the concept of the sick society " in Stanley C. Plog and Robert B. Edgerton, eds., Changing Perspectives in Mental Illness, New York, Holt, Rinehart: 128-54.
22.
1973 "Holocultural theory tests" in Raoul Naroll and Frada Naroll, eds., Main Currents in Cultural Anthropology , New York, Apple-ton-Century-Crofts : 309-84.
23.
Naroll, Raoul, and Richard G. Sipes1973 "A Standard Ethnographic Sample: second edition," Current Anthropology14: 111-40.
24.
Pope, Whitney1975 "Concepts and explanatory structure in Durkheim's theory of suicide" British Journal of Sociology26: 417-34.
25.
Powell, Elwin H.1958 "Occupation, status, and suicide: toward a redefinition of anomie" American Sociological Review23: 131-39.
26.
Rootman, Irving1973 "A cross-cultural note on Durkheim's theory of suicide " Life-Threatening Behavior3: 83-94.
27.
Schaefer, James M., Michel Antoine, Harvey Carroll, James Devitt, Thomas Haberman, Bonnie Herda, Michael Moyer, Robert Rachlin, and Linda Ward1971 "Sampling methods, functional associations, and Galton's problem : a replicative assessment" Behavior Science Notes7: 229-74.
28.
Simmons, Leo W.
29.
1945The role of the aged in primitive society, New Haven, Yale University Press.
