In an earlier review of political theories of the policy process, Sabatier (1991) challenged political scientists and policy scholars to improve theoretical understanding of policy processes. This essay responds by comparing and building upon three emerging theoretical frameworks: Sabatier's advocacy coalitions framework (ACF), institutional rational choice (IRC), and Moe's political theory of bureaucracy, which he calls the politics of structural choice (SC). The frameworks are compared using six criteria: (1) the bound aries of inquiry; (2) the model of the individual; (3) the roles of informa tion and beliefs in decision making and strategy; (4) the nature and role of groups; (5) the concept of levels of action; and (6) the ability to explain action at various stages of the policy process. Comparison reveals that each framework has promising components, but each remains short of provid ing a full explanation of the processes of policy formation and change. Directions for future theory development and empirical examination are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Anderson, James E.1979. Public Policymaking, 2d ed. New York : Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
2.
Baumgartner, Frank, and Bryan Jones.1993. Agendas and Instability in American Politics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
3.
Blomquist, William.1992. Dividing the Waters: Governing Groundwater in SouthernCalifornia. San Francisco: ICS.
4.
Bromley, Daniel.1989. Economic Interests and Institutions: The Conceptual Foundations of Public Policy. New York: Basil Blackwell.
5.
Brown, Anthony, and Joseph Stewart.1993. "Competing Advocacy Coalitions, Policy Evolution, and Airline Deregulation." In Paul Sabatier and Hank Jenkins-Smith, eds., Policy Change and Learning: An Advocacy Coalition Approach. Boulder, CO: Westview.
6.
Calvert, Randall, Mathew McCubbins, and Barry Weingast.1989. "A Theory of Political Control and Agency Discretion." American Journal of Political Science33: 588-611.
7.
Dye,Thomas.1966. Politics Economics, and the Public. Chicago: Rand McNally.
8.
Eyestone, Robert.1978. From Social Issues to Public Policy. New York: Wiley.
9.
Gormley, William.1983. The Politics of Public Utility Regulation. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.
10.
Hardin, Garrett.1968. "The Tragedy of the Commons." Science162: 1243-48.
11.
Heintz, H. Theodore, and Hank Jenkins-Smith .1988. "Advocacy Coalitions and the Practice of Policy Analysis." Policy Sciences21: 263-77.
12.
Jenkins-Smith, Hank.1988. "Analytical Debates and Policy Learning: Analysis and Change in the Federal Bureaucracy." Policy Sciences21: 169-211.
13.
Jenkins-Smith, Hank, and Gilbert St. Clair .1993. "The Politics of Offshore Energy: Empirically Testing the Advocacy Coalition Framework." In Paul Sabatier and Hank Jenkins-Smith , eds., Policy Change and Learning.: An Advocacy Coalition Approach. Boulder, CO: Westview .
14.
Jenkins-Smith, Hank, and Paul Sabatier.1993a. "The Study of Public Policy Processes " In Paul Sabatier and Hank Jenkins-Smith, eds., Policy Change and Learning: An Advocacy Coalition Approach. Boulder, CO: Westview.
15.
. 1993 b. "The Dynamics of Policy-Oriented Learning" In Paul Sabatier and Hank Jenkins-Smith , eds., Policy Change and Learning: An Advocacy Coalition Approach. Boulder, CO: Westview .
16.
Jones, Charles 0. 1977. An Introduction to the Study of Public Policy, 2d edBoston: Duxbury.
17.
Kingdon, John.1984. Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies. Boston: Little Brown.
18.
Lam, Danny.1994. "Institutions, Engineering, Infrastructure, and Performance in the Governance and Management of Irrigation Systems: The Case of Nepal." Unpublished dissertation, Indiana University .
19.
Lindblom, Charles E.1968. The Policy-making Process. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
20.
Lowi, Theodore.1964. "American Business, Public Policy and Political Theory ." World Politics16: 677-715.
21.
. 1972. "Four Systems of Policy, Politics, and Choice."Public Administration Review32: 298-310.
22.
Macey, J.1992. "Organizational Design and Political Control of Administrative Agencies." Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization8: 93-110.
23.
Mayhew, David.1974. Congress: The Electoral Connection. New Haven: Yale University Press.
24.
McCubbins, Mathew, Roger Noll, and Barry Weingast.1989. "Structure and Process, Politics and Policy: Administrative Arrangements and the Political Control of Agencies." Virginia Law Review75: 431-82.
25.
Miller, Gary.1992. Managerial Dilemmas: The Political Economy of Hierarchy . New York: Cambridge University Press.
26.
Moe, Terry1984. "The New Economics of Organization." American Journal of Political Science28: 739-77.
27.
. 1990a. "The Politics of Structural Choice: Toward a Theory of Public Bureaucracy" In Oliver Williamson, ed., Organization Theory: From Chester Barnard to the Present and Beyond . New York: Oxford University Press .
28.
. 1990b. "Political Institutions: The Neglected Side of the Story ." Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization6: 213-53.
29.
Moe, Terry, and Scott Wilson.1994. "Presidents and the Politics of Structure." Law and Contemporary Problems57: 1-44.
30.
Niskanen, William1971. Bureaucracy and Representative Government. Chicago: Aldine.
31.
Olson, Macur.1965. The Logic of Collective Action. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
32.
Ostrom, Elinor.1990. Governing the Commons. New York : Cambridge University Press.
33.
_. 1991a. "A Framework for Institutional Analysis." Working paper 91-14. Bloomington, IN: Workshop inPolitical Theory and Policy Analysis.
34.
. 1991b. "Rational Choice Theory and Institutional Analysis: Toward Complementarity" American Political Science Review85: 237-43.
35.
Ostrom, Elinor, Roy Gardner, and James Walker.1994. Rules, Games, and Common-pool Resources . Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
36.
Rosenthal, Alan.1993. The Third House: Lobbyists and Lobbying in the States . Washington, DC: CQ Press .
37.
Sabatier, Paul.1988. "An Advocacy Coalition Framework of Policy Change and the Role of Policy-Oriented Learning Therein." Policy Sciences21: 129-68.
38.
_. 1991. "Toward Better Theories of the Policy Process." PS: Political Science and Politics24: 147-56.
39.
. 1993. "Policy Change Over a Decade or More." In Paul Sabatier and Hank Jenkins-Smith, eds., Policy Change and Learning: An Advocacy Coalition ApproachBoulder, CO: Westview.
40.
Sabatier, Paul, and Ann Brasher.1993. "From Vague Consensus to Clearly Differentiated Coalitions: Environmental Policy at Lake Tahoe, 1964-1985." In Paul Sabatier and Hank Jenkins-Smith , eds., Policy Change and Learning: An Advocacy Coalition Approach. Boulder, CO: Westview .
41.
Sabatier, Paul, and Hank Jenkins-Smith, eds. 1993a. Policy Change and Learning: An Advocacy Coalitions Approach. Boulder, CO : Westview.
42.
. 1993b. "The Advocacy Coalition Framework: Assessment, Revisions, and Implications for Scholars and Practitioners." In Paul Sabatier and Hank Jenkins-Smith, eds., Policy Change and Learning: An Advocacy Coalition Approach. Boulder, CO: Westview.
43.
Salisbury, Robert.1986. "Washington Lobbyists: A Collective Portrait." In Allan Cigler and Burdett Loomis, eds., Interest Group Politics, pp. 146-61. Washington, DC: CQ Press.
44.
Schlager, Edella.1990. "Model Specification and Policy Analysis: The Case of Coastal Fisheries." Unpublished dissertation, Indiana University .
45.
_. 1995. "Policy Making and Collective Action: Defining Coalitions Within the Advocacy Coalition Framework." Policy Sciences28: 243-70.
46.
Schneider, Mark, and Paul Teske, with Michael Mintrom .1995. Public Entrepreneurs: Agents for Change in American Government. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
47.
Sharkensky, Ira.1968. Spending in the American States. Chicago : Rand McNally
48.
Simon, Herbert.1985. "Human Nature in Politics: The Dialogue of Psychology with Political Science." American Political Science Review79: 293-304.
49.
Tang, S.Y.1992. Institutions and Collective Action: Self-Governance in Irrigation. San Francisco: ICS Press .
50.
Welch, W.P.1983. "The Political Feasibility of Full Ownership Property Rights: The Cases of Pollution and Fisheries." Policy Sciences16: 165-80.
51.
Wilson, James Q.1980. The Politics of Regulation. New York : Basic Books.
52.
Wood, B. Dan, and Richard Waterman .1991. "The Dynamics of Political Control of Bureaucracy." American Political Science Review85: 801-28.
