Scholars have been quick to try to assess the consequences of the U.S. Supreme Court’s monumental ruling abrogating abortion rights in the U.S. (Dobbs), with several studies showing that the decision seems to have ushered in a new era of significantly diminished support for the Court. But important issues remain unresolved. Perhaps most important, how have racial minorities, especially African Americans, been affected by the Court’s ruling? Based on an unusually large and representative subsample of African Americans, I discover that a substantial proportion of Black people extend remarkably little legitimacy to the U.S. Supreme Court after Dobbs. Some of the difference between Black and White people seems to be associated with the abortion ruling (as I carefully document), but another portion has to do with much lower levels of support of the Court before Dobbs, and with weaker attachments to legitimacy-enhancing democratic values. I conclude that studies of the attitudes and values of minorities, while important in and of themselves, can also help researchers understand more general processes by which citizens update their institutional attitudes.
ArmalyMiles T.KrewsonChristopher N.LaneElizabeth A.. 2025. “The Influence of Descriptive Representation on Support for Judicial Nominees and the US Supreme Court.” Political Behavior47: 661–87.
2.
BadasAlex. 2019. “Policy Disagreement and Judicial Legitimacy: Evidence from the 1937 Court-Packing Plan.” Journal of Legal Studies48 (2): 377–408.
3.
BostonJoshuaKrewsonChristopher N.. 2024. “Public Approval of the Supreme Court and Its Implications for Legitimacy.” Political Research Quarterly77 (3): 835–50.
4.
BruchSara K.SossJoe. 2018. “Schooling as a Formative Political Experience: Authority Relations and the Education of Citizens.” Perspectives on Politics16 (1): 36–57.
5.
CaldeiraGregory A.GibsonJames L.. 1992. “The Etiology of Public Support for the Supreme Court.” American Journal of Political Science36 (3): 635–64.
6.
ClarkChelsey S.ElizabethLevy PaluckWestwoodSean J.SenMayaMalhotraNeilJesseStephen. 2024. “Effects of a US Supreme Court Ruling to Restrict Abortion Rights.” Nature Human Behaviour8 (January): 63–71.
7.
ClawsonRosalee A.WaltenburgEric N.. 2009. Legacy and Legitimacy: Black Americans and the Supreme Court. Temple University Press.
8.
DupreeErnestIIIHibbingJohn R.. 2023. “Black Trust in U.S. Legislatures.” Legislative Studies Quarterly48 (2): 399–424.
9.
EastonDavid. 1965. A Systems Analysis of Political Life. John Wiley & Son, Inc.
10.
GibsonJames L.2015. “Legitimacy Is for Losers: the Interconnections of Institutional Legitimacy, Performance Evaluations, and the Symbols of Judicial Authority.” In Motivating Cooperation and Compliance with Authority: The Role of Institutional Trust. [Nebraska Symposium on Motivation, Volume 62], edited by BornsteinBrian H.TomkinsAlan J., 81–116. Springer.
11.
GibsonJames L.2017. “Performance Evaluations Are Not Legitimacy Judgments: a Caution About Interpreting Public Opinions Toward the U.S. Supreme Court.” Washington University Journal of Law & Policy54: 71–88.
12.
GibsonJames L.2024a. “Losing Legitimacy: the Challenges of the Dobbs Ruling to Conventional Legitimacy Theory.” American Journal of Political Science68 (3): 1041–56.
13.
GibsonJames L.2024b. Democracy's Destruction? Changing Perceptions of the Supreme Court, the Presidency, and the Senate After the 2020 Election. Russell Sage Foundation.
14.
GibsonJames L.2024c. “The U.S. Supreme Court’s Legitimacy: How Public Opinion Updates.” The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science713 (May): 260–77.
15.
GibsonJames L.2025. “Do the Effects of Unpopular Supreme Court Rulings Linger? the Dobbs Decision Rescinding Abortion Rights.” American Political Science Review119 (1): 500–07.
16.
GibsonJames L.2026. “’The Talk’ as an Element of Black Political Socialization: an Exploratory Analysis.” In New Directions in Black Political Psychology, edited by SullivanJas M.BurgeCamilleSlaughterChristine M.. University of Michigan Press. Forthcoming.
17.
GibsonJames L.CaldeiraGregory A.. 1992. “Blacks and the United States Supreme Court: Models of Diffuse Support.” The Journal of Politics54 (4): 1120–45.
18.
GibsonJames L.CaldeiraGregory A.. 2009. Citizens, Courts, and Confirmations: Positivity Theory and the Judgments of the American People. Princeton University Press.
19.
GibsonJames L.NelsonMichael J.. 2018. Black and Blue: How and Why African Americans Judge the American Legal System. Oxford University Press.
20.
GibsonJames L.LodgeMiltonWoodsonBenjamin. 2014. “Losing, but Accepting: Legitimacy, Positivity Theory, and the Symbols of Judicial Authority.” Law & Society Review48 (4): 837–66.
21.
GoodwinAlexander I.CareyTony E.Jr.2025. “With all due Respect: Respectability Politics and Black Support for Policing Defunding and Absolution.” Political Behavior. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11109-025-10051-5
22.
HaglinKathrynJordanSorenMerrillAlison HigginsUraJoseph Daniel. 2021. “Ideology and Specific Support for the Supreme Court.” Political Research Quarterly74 (4): 955–69.
JesseeStephenMalhotraNeilSenMaya. 2022. “A Decade-Long Longitudinal Survey Shows that the Supreme Court is now Much More Conservative than the Public.” PNAS119 (24): 1–7.
25.
JozkowskiKristen N.AmeliaHawbakerTurnerRonna C.CrawfordBrandon L.ParkerErikArroyoLilian Golzarri. 2024. “Attitudes Toward Abortion Legality and Abortion Regulation: Insights from a Nationally Representative Study.” Social Science Quarterly105: 1649–67.
26.
KingzetteJonNebloMichael A.. 2021. “The Civil Culture(S): Groups, Norms, and the Health of Democracy.” The Journal of Race, Ethnicity, and Politics6 (1): 144–56.
27.
KrehbielJay N.2025. “Native Americans’ Support for Supreme Court Legitimacy.” Politics, Groups, and Identities13 (4): 1000–11.
28.
KrehbielJay N.2026. “Does Descriptive Representation Increase Acceptance of Judicial Decisions?” Political Research Quarterly79 (1): 155–68.
29.
KrewsonChristopher N.SchroedelJean R.. 2023. “Modern Judicial Confirmation Hearings and Institutional Support for the Supreme Court.” Social Science Quarterly104 (3): 364–9.
30.
LevenduskyMatthewPattersonShawnJr.MargolisMichelePasekJoshWinnegKennethJamiesonKathleen H.. 2024. “Has the Supreme Court Become Just Another Political Branch? Public Perceptions of Court Approval and Legitimacy in a Post-Dobbs World.” Science Advances10: eadk95950.
31.
LoboDanielBurtgerRyan. 2025. “Fairness According to Whom? Divergent Perceptions of Fairness Among White and Black Americans and Its Effect on Trade Attitudes.” American Political Science Review119 (4): 1822–35.
32.
Martinez-EbersValerieBrantonReginaCalfanoBrian. 2021. “The Impact of Subjective Social Position on Public Evaluations of Police.” Social Science Quarterly102 (4): 1719–42.
33.
MondakJeffery J.SmitheyShannon Ishiyama. 1997. “The Dynamics of Public Support for the Supreme Court.” The Journal of Politics59 (4): 1114–42.
34.
MorganJanaKellyNathan J.. 2025. “Ethnoracial Hierarchies and Democratic Commitments.” Perspectives on Politics23 (3): 822–46.
35.
MorganJanaChristianiLeahKellyNathan J.. 2025. “Racial Inequality and Support for Democracy.” Political Studies73 (4): 1347–69.
36.
NelsonMichael J.GibsonJames L.. 2018. “U.S. Supreme Court Legitimacy: Unanswered Questions and an Agenda for Future Research.” In Routledge Handbook of Judicial Behavior, edited by HowardRobert M.RandazzoKirk A., 132–50. Routledge.
37.
NelsonMichael J.GibsonJames L.. 2020. “Measuring Subjective Ideological Disagreement with the U.S. Supreme Court.” Journal of Law and Courts8 (1): 75–94.
38.
NelsonMichael J.TuckerPatrick D.. 2021. “The Stability and Durability of the US Supreme Court’s Legitimacy.” The Journal of Politics83 (2): 767–71.
39.
PeffleyMarkHurwitzJon. 2010. Justice in America: The Separate Realities of Black People and White People. Cambridge University Press.
40.
PerrySylvia P.AbaiedJamie L.WuDeborah J.DoriscarJonathan E.. 2025. “Racial Socialization in the United States.” Annual Review of Psychology76: 443–74.
PhilpotTasha S.2017. Conservative but Not Republican: The Paradox of Party Identification and Ideology Among African Americans. Cambridge University Press.
43.
SmythRussell. 2024. “Public Opinion and Legitimacy.” In The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Judicial Behavior, edited by EpsteinLeeGrendstadGunnarSadlUrksaWeinshallKeren. Oxford University Press.
44.
TylerTom R.JeffreyFaganAmandaGeller. 2014. “Street Stops and Police Legitimacy: Teachable Moments in Young Urban Men’s Legal Socialization.” Journal of Empirical Legal Studies11 (4): 751–85.
45.
WhiteIsmail K.LairdChryl N.. 2020. Steadfast Democrats: How Social Forces Shape Black Political Behavior. Princeton University Press.
46.
WilleckClaireMendelbergTali. 2022. “Education and Political Participation.” Annual Review of Political Science25: 89–210.
47.
ZilisMichael A. 2021. The Rights Paradox: How Group Attitudes Shapes US Supreme Court Legitimacy. Cambridge University Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
