A growing literature documents racial disparities throughout the American criminal justice system. Yet, even as this evidence accumulates and garners increasing media attention, we know relatively little about the consequences of this type of information for public opinion. We incorporate insights from attribution theory to suggest that people differ in the cause they attribute to racial disparities in the justice system, and these different causal attributions profoundly affect attitudes and responses to information. Using two survey experiments, we find that attributions for the cause of racial disparities in pulled-over rates have a substantial impact on trust in police, and perhaps more importantly, alter susceptibility to persuasion and attitude change. Learning about racial disparities in pulled-over rates reduces trust in police, but only for predictable subsets of the citizenry.
AppleNancyO’BrienDavid. 1983. “Neighborhood Racial Composition and Residents’ Evaluation of Police Performance.” Journal of Police Science and Administration11:76–84.
2.
BaumgartnerFrank R.EppDerek A.ShoubKelsey. 2018. Suspect Citizens: What 20 Million Traffic Stops Tell Us about Policing and Race. New York: Cambridge University Press.
3.
BoboLawrence D.JohnsonDevon. 2004. “A Taste for Punishment: Black and White Americans’ Views on the Death Penalty and the War on Drugs.” Du Bois Review1:151–80.
4.
BragaAnthony A.2016. “Better Policing Can Improve Legitimacy and Reduce Mass Incarceration.” Harvard Law Review Forum129:233–41.
5.
BrandlSteven G.FrankJamesWordenRobert E.BynumTimothy S.1994. “Global and Specific Attitudes toward the Police: Disentangling the Relationship.” Justice Quarterly11:119–34.
6.
BrownBenBenedictWm Reed. 2002. “Perceptions of the Police: Past Findings, Methodological issues, Conceptual Issues and Policy Implications.” Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management25:543–80.
7.
CaoLiquinFrankJamesCullenFrancis T.1996. “Race, Community Context and Confidence in the Police.” American Journal of Police15:3–22.
8.
CarrollJohn S.PayneJohn W.1977. “Crime Seriousness, Recidivism Risk, and Causal Attributions in Judgments of Prison Term by Students and Experts.” Journal of Applied Psychology62:595–602.
9.
CorreiaMark E.ReisigMichael D.LovrichNicholas P.1996. “Public Perceptions of State Police: An Analysis of Individual-Level and Contextual Variables.” Journal of Criminal Justice24:17–28.
10.
DruckmanJames N.LeeperThomas J.2012. “Learning More from Political Communication Experiments: Pretreatment and its Effects.” American Journal of Political Science56:875–96.
11.
EntmanRobert M.1992. “Blacks in the News: Television, Modern Racism and Cultural Change.” Journalism Quarterly69:341–61.
12.
EppCharles R.Maynard-MoodyStevenHaider-MarkelDonald. 2014. Pulled over: How Police Stops Define Race and Citizenship. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
13.
FloresAndrew R.Haider-MarkelDonald P.LewisDaniel C.MillerPatrick R.TadlockBarry L.TaylorJami K.2018. “Challenged Expectations: Mere Exposure Effects on Attitudes about Transgender People and Rights.” Political Psychology39:197–216.
14.
GauJacinta M.BrunsonRod K.2010. “Procedural Justice and Order Maintenance Policing: A Study of Inner-City Young Men’s Perceptions of Police Legitimacy.” Justice Quarterly27:255–79.
15.
GelmanAndrewFaganJeffreyKissAlex. 2007. “An Analysis of the New York City Police Department’s ‘Stop and Frisk’ Policy in the Context of Claims of Racial Bias.” Journal of the American Statistical Association102:813–23.
GottliebAaron. 2017. “The Effect of Message Frames on Public Attitudes toward Criminal Justice Reform for Nonviolent Offenses.” Crime & Delinquency63:636–56.
18.
GrossKimberly. 2008. “Framing Persuasive Appeals: Episodic and Thematic Framing, Emotional Response, and Policy Opinion.” Political Psychology29:169–92.
19.
Haider-MarkelDonald P.JoslynMark R.2008. “Beliefs about the Origins of Homosexuality and Support for Gay Rights.” Public Opinion Quarterly72:291–310.
20.
HeiderFritz. 1944. “Social Perception and Phenomenal Causality.” Psychological Review51:358–74.
21.
HeiderFritz. 1958. The Psychology of Interpersonal Relations. New York: John Wiley.
22.
HeteyRebecca C.EberhardtJennifer L.2014. “Racial Disparities in Incarceration Increase Acceptance of Punitive Policies.” Psychological Science25:1949–54.
23.
HuangW. S. WilsonVaughnMichael. 1996. “Support and Confidence: Public Attitudes toward the Police.” In Americans View Crime and Justice: A National Public Opinion Survey, edited by FlanaganTimothy J.LongmireDennis R.Thousand Oaks: SAGE, pp. 31-45.
24.
IyengarShanto. 1991. Is Anyone Responsible? How Television Frames Political Issues. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
25.
JohnsonDevonWarrenPatricia Y.FarrellAmy. 2015. Deadly Injustice: Trayvon Martin, Race, and the Criminal Justice System. New York: New York University Press.
KrosnickJon A.1999. “Survey Research.” Annual Review of Psychology50:537–67.
28.
KundaZiva. 1990. “The Case for Motivated Reasoning.” Psychological Bulletin108:480–98.
29.
LangtonLynnDuroseMatthew. 2013. Police Behavior during Traffic and Street Stops, 2011. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.
30.
LaqueurHannahRushinStephenSimonJonathan. 2014. “Wrongful Conviction, Policing, and the ‘Wars on Crime and Drugs.’” In Examining Wrongful Convictions: Stepping Back, Moving Forward, edited by RedlichAllison D.AckerJames R.NorrisRobert J.BonventreCatherine L.Durham: Carolina Academic Press, pp. 93-108.
31.
La VigneNancyFontaineJocelynDwivediAnamika. 2017. How Do People in High-Crime, Low-Income Communities View the Police. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.
32.
LavineHowardJohnstonChristopherSteenbergernMarco. 2012. The Ambivalent Partisan: How Critical Loyalty Promotes Democracy. New York: Oxford University Press.
LundmanRichard J.KaufmanRobert L.2003. “Driving While Black: Effects of Race, Ethnicity, and Gender on Citizen Self-Reports of Traffic Stops and Police Actions.” Criminology41:195–220.
35.
MaguireEdward R.JohnsonDevon. 2010. “Measuring Public Perceptions of the Police.” International Journal of Police Strategies & Management33:703–30.
36.
MauerMarc. 2006. Race to Incarcerate. New York: The New Press.
37.
MazerolleLorraineAntrobusEmmaBennettSarahTylerTom R.2013. “Shaping Citizen Perceptions of Police Legitimacy: A Randomized Field Trial of Procedural Justice.” Criminology51:33–63.
MooreNina M.2015. The Political Roots of Racial Tracking in American Criminal Justice. New York: Cambridge University Press.
40.
MorinRichSteplerRenee. 2016. The Racial Confidence Gap in Police Performance. Pew Research Center.
41.
MullinixKevin J.2018. “Civic Duty and Political Preference Formation.” Political Research Quarterly71:199–214.
42.
MullinixKevin J.LeeperThomas J.DruckmanJames N.FreeseJeremy. 2015. “The Generalizability of Survey Experiments.” Journal of Experimental Political Science2:109–38.
NelsonMatthew S.GabbidonShaun L.BoisvertDanielle. 2015. “Philadelphia Area Residents’ Views on the Disproportionate Representation of Blacks and Hispanics in the Criminal Justice System.” Journal of Crime and Justice38:270–90.
46.
NelsonThomas E.1999. “Group Affect and Attribution in Social Policy Opinion.” The Journal of Politics61:331–62.
47.
PeffleyMarkHurwitzJon. 2007. “Persuasion and Resistance: Race and the Death Penalty in America.” American Journal of Political Science51:996–1012.
48.
PeffleyMarkHurwitzJonMondakJeffery. 2017. “Racial Attributions in the Justice System and Support for Punitive Crime Policies.” American Politics Research45:1032–58.
49.
ReisigMichael D.ParksRoger B.2000. “Experience, Quality of Life, and Neighborhood Context: A Hierarchical Analysis of Satisfaction with Police.” Justice Quarterly17:607–30.
50.
RosenbaumDennis P.SchuckAmie M.CostelloSandra K.HawkinsDarnell F.RingMarianne K.2005. “Attitudes toward the Police: The Effects of Direct and Vicarious Experience.” Police Quarterly8:343–65.
51.
SchaferJoseph A.HuebnerBeth M.BynumTimohty S.2003. “Citizen Perceptions of Police Services: Race, Neighborhood Context, and Community Policing.” Police Quarterly6:440–68.
52.
SchumanHowardSteehCharlotteBoboLawrence D.KrysanMaria. 1998. Racial Attitudes in America: Trends and Interpretations, Revised Edition. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
SimonJonathan. 2007. Governing through Crime: How the War on Crime Transformed American Democracy and Created a Culture of Fear. New York: Oxford University Press.
55.
SunshineJasonTylerTom R.2003. “The Role of Procedural Justice and Legitimacy in Shaping Public Support for Policing.” Law & Society Review37:513–48.
56.
TaberCharles S.LodgeMilton. 2006. “Motivated Skepticism in the Evaluation of Political Beliefs.” American Journal of Political Science50:755–69.
57.
TankebeJustice. 2013. “Viewing Things Differently: The Dimensions of Public Perceptions of Police Legitimacy.” Criminology51:103–35.
58.
TheoboldNick A.Haider-MarkelDonald P.2009. “Race, Bureaucracy, and Symbolic Representation: Interactions between Citizens and Police.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory19:409–26.
59.
ThomasCharles W.HymanJeffrey M.1977. “Perceptions of Crime, Fear of Victimization, and Public Perceptions of Police Performance.” Journal of Police Science and Administration5:305–17.
60.
TonryMichael. 2011. Punishing Race: A Continuing American Dilemma. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
61.
TylerTom R.2004. “Enhancing Police Legitimacy.” The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science583:84–99.
62.
TylerTom R.2005. “Policing in Black and White: Ethnic Group Differences in Trust and Confidence in the Police.” Police Quarterly8:322–42.
63.
TylerTom R.HuoYuen. 2002. Trust in the Law: Encouraging Public Cooperation with the Police and the Courts. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
64.
TylerTom R.WakslakChery J.2004. “Profiling and Police Legitimacy: Procedural Justice, Attributions of Motive, and Acceptance of Police Authority.” Criminology42:253–82.
65.
UnneverJames D.2008. “Two Worlds Far Apart: Black-White Differences in Beliefs about Why African-American Men Are Disproportionately Imprisoned.” Criminology46:511–38.
66.
WeinerBernard. 1985. “An Attributional Theory of Achievement Motivation and Emotion.” Psychological Review92:548–73.
67.
WeitzerRonald. 2000. “Racialized Policing: Residents’ Perceptions in Three Neighborhoods.” Law & Society Review34:129–55.
68.
WeitzerRonald. 2002. “Incidents of Police Misconduct and Public Opinion.” Journal of Criminal Justice30:397–408.
69.
WeitzerRonaldTuchSteven A.1999. “Race, Class, and Perceptions of Discrimination by the Police.” Crime & Delinquency45:494–507.
70.
WeitzerRonaldTuchSteven A.2002. “Perceptions of Racial Profiling: Race, Class, and Personal Experience.” Criminology40:435–56.
71.
WeitzerRonaldTuchSteven A.2005. “Determinants of Public Satisfaction with the Police.” Police Quarterly8:279–97.
72.
WeitzerRonaldTuchSteven A.SkoganWesley G.2008. “Police–Community Relations in a Majority-Black City.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency45:398–428.
73.
WhiteMichael D.FradellaHenry F.2016. Stop and Frisk: The Use and Abuse of a Controversial Policing Tactic. New York: New York University Press.
74.
WortleyRichard. 1997. “Attributions as a Function of Expertise: The Case of the Police Decision to Arrest.” Journal of Applied Social Psychology27:525–38.
75.
WuYuningSunIvan Y.TriplettRuth A.2009. “Race, Class or Neighborhood Context: Which Matters More In Measuring Satisfaction with Police?” Justice Quarterly26:125–56.
76.
YoungRobert L.1991. “Race, Conceptions of Crime and Justice, and Support for the Death Penalty.” Social Psychology Quarterly54:67–75.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
