Scholars have long sought to resolve whether and to what degree political actor diversity influences the outputs of political institutions like legislatures, administrative agencies, and courts. When it comes to the judiciary, diverse judges may greatly affect outcomes. Despite this potential, no consensus exists for whether judicial diversity affects behavior in trial courts—that is, the stage where the vast majority of litigants interact with the judicial branch. After addressing the research design limitations in previous trial court-diversity studies, the results here indicate that a trial judge’s sex and race have very large effects on his or her decision making. These results have important implications for how we view diversity throughout the judiciary and are particularly timely given the Obama Administration’s over 200 female and minority appointments to the federal trial courts.
AshenfelterOrleyEisenbergTheodoreSchwabStewart J.1995. “Politics and the Judiciary: The Influence of Judicial Background on Case Outcomes.”Journal of Legal Studies24 (2): 257–81.
2.
BaumLawrence. 1997. The Puzzle of Judicial Behavior. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
3.
BaumLawrence. 2006. Judges and Their Audiences: A Perspective on Judicial Behavior. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
4.
BlackRyan C.OwensRyan J.2012. The Solicitor General and the United States Supreme Court: Executive Branch Influence and Judicial Decisions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
5.
BlackRyan C.OwensRyan J.2013. “A Built-In Advantage: The Office of the Solicitor General and the U.S. Supreme Court.”Political Research Quarterly66:454–66.
6.
BoydChristina L.2013. “She’ll Settle It?”Journal of Law and Courts1:193–219.
7.
BoydChristina L.EpsteinLeeMartinAndrew D.2010. “Untangling the Causal Effects of Sex on Judging.”American Journal of Political Science54 (2): 389–411.
8.
BrattonKathleen A.HaynieKerry L.1999. “Agenda Setting and Legislative Success in State Legislatures: The Effects of Gender and Race.”Journal of Politics61:658–79.
9.
CameronCharlesCummingsCraig. 2003. “Diversity and Judicial Decision Making: Evidence from Affirmative Action Cases in the Federal Courts of Appeals, 1971-1999.”Paper presented at the Crafting and Operating Institutions Conference, Yale University, April 11–13.
10.
ChewPat K.KelleyRobert E.2009. “Myth of the Color-Blind Judge: An Empirical Analysis of Racial Harassment Cases.”Washington University Law Review86:1117–66.
11.
CollinsPaul M.Jr.2004. “Friends of the Court: Examining the Influence of Amicus Curiae Participation in U.S. Supreme Court Litigation.”Law & Society Review38 (4): 807–32.
12.
CollinsPaul M.Jr.2007. “Lobbyists before the U.S. Supreme Court: Investigating the Influence of Amicus Curiae Briefs.”Political Research Quarterly60 (1): 55–70.
CollinsPaul M.Jr.MartinekWendy L.2010. “Friends of the Circuits: Interest Group Influence on Decision Making in the U.S. Courts of Appeals.”Social Science Quarterly91:397–414.
15.
CollinsPaul M.Jr.MartinekWendy L.2011. “The Small Group Context: Designated District Court Judges in the U.S. Courts of Appeals.”Journal of Empirical Legal Studies8:177–205.
16.
CollinsToddMoyerLaura. 2008. “Gender, Race, and Intersectionality on the Federal Appellate Bench.”Political Research Quarterly61:219–27.
17.
CookBeverly B.1981. “Will Women Judges Make a Difference in Women’s Legal Rights?” In Women, Power, and Political Systems, edited by RendelMargherita, 216–39. London: Croom Helm.
18.
CoxAdam B.MilesThomas J.2008. “Judging the Voting Rights Act.”Columbia Law Review108 (1): 1–54.
19.
CrenshawKimberle. 1992. “Race, Gender, and Sexual Harassment.”Southern California Law Review65:1467–76.
20.
CroweNancy.1999. “The Effects of Judges’ Sex and Race on Judicial Decision Making on the U.S. Courts of Appeals, 1981–1996.” PhD diss., University of Chicago.
21.
DolanJulie. 2000. “The Senior Executive Service: Gender, Attitudes, and Representative Bureaucracy.”Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory3:513–29.
22.
DumasTao L.HaynieStacia L.2012. “Building an Integrated Model of Trial Court Decision Making: Predicting Plaintiff Success and Awards across Circuits.”State Politics & Policy Quarterly12:103–26.
23.
EdwardsHarry T.2002. “Race and the Judiciary.”Yale Law & Policy Review20:325–30.
24.
EisenbergTheodore. 2004. “Appeal Rates and Outcomes in Tried and Nontried Cases: Further Exploration of Anti-plaintiff Appellate Outcomes.”Journal of Empirical Legal Studies1:659–88.
25.
EpsteinLeeLandesWilliam M.PosnerRichard A.2013. The Behavior of Federal Judges: A Theoretical and Empirical Study of Rational Choice. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
26.
EpsteinLeeMartinAndrew D.SegalJeffrey A.WesterlandChad. 2007. “The Judicial Common Space.”Journal of Law, Economics, & Organization23 (2): 303–25.
27.
FarhangSeanWawroGregory. 2004. “Institutional Dynamics on the U.S. Court of Appeals: Minority Representation under Panel Decision Making.”Journal of Law, Economics, & Organization20:299–330.
FoxRichardSickelRobert Van. 2000. “Gender Dynamics and Judicial Behavior in Criminal Trial Courts: An Exploratory Study.”Justice System Journal21 (3): 261–80.
30.
GilesMicheal W.HettingerVirginia A.PeppersTodd. 2001. “Picking Federal Judges: A Note on Policy and Partisan Selection Agendas.”Political Research Quarterly54 (3): 623–41.
31.
GilliganCarol. 1982. In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women’s Development. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
32.
GruhlJohnSpohnCassiaWelchSusan. 1981. “Women as Policymakers: The Case of Trial Judges.”American Journal of Political Science25 (2): 308–22.
33.
GryskiGerardMainEleanor C.DixonWilliam J.1986. “Models of State High Court Decision Making in Sex Discrimination Cases.”Journal of Politics48:143–55.
34.
HaireSusan B.MoyerLaura P.2014. Does Diversity Matter? Judicial Policy making in the U.S. Courts of Appeals. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press.
35.
HaireSusan B.MoyerLaura P.TreierShawn. 2013. “Diversity, Deliberation, and Judicial Opinion Writing.”Journal of Law and Courts1:303–30.
36.
HeiderFritz. 1958. The Psychology of Interpersonal Relations. New York: Wiley.
37.
HettingerVirginia A.LindquistStefanie A.MartinekWendy L.2006. Judging on a Collegial Court. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press.
38.
HirshC. Elizabeth. 2008. “Settling for Less? Organizational Determinants of Discrimination-Charge Outcomes.”Law & Society Review42:239–74.
39.
HoDanielImaiKosukeKingGaryStuartElizabeth. 2006. “MatchIt: Nonparametric Preprocessing for Parametric Casual Inference.” R package version 2.2–11. http://gking.harvard.edu/matchit.
40.
HoffmanDavid A.IzenmanAlan J.LidickerJeffrey R.2007. “Docketology, District Courts, and Doctrine.”Washington University Law Review85:681–751.
41.
HowardRobert M.2002. “Litigation, Courts, and Bureaucratic Policy: Equity, Efficiency, and the Internal Revenue Service.”American Politics Research30:583–607.
42.
JohnsonBrian D.2014. “Judges on Trial: A Reexamination of Judicial Race and Gender Effects across Modes of Conviction.”Criminal Justice Policy Review25:159–84.
43.
KahenyErin B.SzmerJohnHansenMichaelScheurerKate. 2015. “High Court Recruitment of Female Clerks: A Comparative Analysis of the U.S. Supreme Court and the Supreme Court of Canada.”Judicature36:355–77.
KastellecJonathan P.2013. “Racial Diversity and Judicial Influence on Appellate Courts.”American Journal of Political Science57 (1): 167–83.
46.
KeeleDenise M.MalmsheimerRobert W.FloydDonald W.ZhangLianjun. 2009. “An Analysis of Ideological Effects in Published versus Unpublished Judicial Opinions.”Journal of Empirical Legal Studies6 (1): 213–39.
47.
KimPauline T.SchlangerMargoBoydChristina L.MartinAndrew D.2009. “How Should We Study District Judge Decision-Making?”Washington University Journal of Law & Policy29:83–112.
48.
KimPauline T.SchlangerMargoMartinAndrew D.2013. “EEOC Litigation Project.” Washington University in St. Louis, MO. http://eeoclitigation.wustl.edu/.
49.
KleinDavid E.2002. Making Law in the United States Courts of Appeals. New York: Cambridge University Press.
50.
KritzerHerbert M.UhlmanThomas M.1977. “Sisterhood in the Courtroom: Sex of Judge and Defendant in Criminal Case Disposition.”Social Sciences Journal14:77–88.
51.
KulikCarol T.PerryElissa L.PepperMolly B.2003. “Here Comes the Judge: The Influence of Judge Personal Characteristics on Federal Sexual Harassment Case Outcomes.”Law and Human Behavior27:69–86.
52.
MacKinnonCatharine A.1979. Sexual Harassment of Working Women: A Case of Sex Discrimination. New Haven: Yale University Press.
53.
ManningKenneth L.2004. “Como Decide? Decision-Making by Latino Judges in the Federal Courts.”Paper presented at 2004 Midwest Political Science Association Annual Meeting, Chicago, IL, March 16-21.
54.
McClainPaula D.Johnson CarewJessica D.WaltonEugeneJr.WattsCandis S.2009. “Group Membership, Group Identity, and Group Consciousness: Measures of Racial Identity in American Politics?”Annual Review of Political Science12:471–85.
55.
NielsenLaura BethNelsonRobert L.2005. “Rights Realized? An Empirical Analysis of Employment Discrimination Litigation as a Claiming System.”Wisconsin Law Review2005:663–711.
56.
PeresieJennifer L.2005. “Female Judges Matter: Gender and Collegial Decision Making in the Federal Appellate Courts.”Yale Law Journal114 (7): 1759–90.
57.
PitkinHanna. 1967. The Concept of Representation. Berkeley: University of California Press.
58.
RandazzoKirk A.2008. “Strategic Anticipation and the Hierarchy of Justice in U.S. District Courts.”American Politics Research36:669–93.
59.
RubinDonald B.2006. Matched Sampling for Causal Effects. New York: Cambridge University Press.
60.
SchanzenbachMax M.2005. “Racial and Sex Disparities in Prison Sentences: The Effect of District-Level Judicial Demographics.”Journal of Legal Studies34:57–92.
61.
SchererNancy. 2004. “Blacks on the Bench.”Political Science Quarterly119:655–72.
62.
ScottKevin M.2006. “Understanding Judicial Hierarchy: Reversals and the Behavior of Intermediate Appellate Judges.”Law & Society Review40:163–92.
63.
SegalJennifer A.2000. “Representative Decision Making on the Federal Bench: Clinton’s District Court Appointees.”Political Research Quarterly53 (1): 137–50.
64.
SherrySuzanna. 1986. “Civic Virtue and the Feminine Voice in Constitutional Adjudication.”Virginia Law Review72:543–616.
65.
SiegelmanPeterDonohueJohn J.III. 1990. “Studying the Iceberg from Its Tip: A Comparison of Published and Unpublished Employment Discrimination Cases.”Law & Society Review24:1133–70.
66.
SiskGregory C.HeiseMichaelMorrissAndrew P.1998. “Charting the Influences on the Judicial Mind: An Empirical Study of Judicial Reasoning.”New York Law Review73:1377–500.
67.
SongerDonald R.DavisSueHaireSusan. 1994. “A Reappraisal of Diversification in the Federal Courts: Gender Effects in the Courts of Appeals.”Journal of Politics56 (2): 425–39.
68.
SpohnCassia. 1990. “Decision Making in Sexual Assault Cases: Do Black and Female Judges Make a Difference?”Women & Criminal Justice2:83–105.
69.
SteffensmeierDarrellBrittChester L.2001. “Judges’ Race and Judicial Decision Making: Do Black Judges Sentence Differently?”Social Science Quarterly82:749–64.
70.
UhlmanThomas M.1978. “Black Elite Decision Making: The Case of Trial Judges.”American Journal of Political Science22:884–95.
WahlbeckPaul J.1997. “The Life of the Law: Judicial Politics and Legal Change.”Journal of Politics59:778–802.
73.
WalkerThomas G.1972. “Note Concerning Partisan Influences on Trial-Judge Decision Making.”Law & Society Review6:645–50.
74.
WalkerThomas G.BarrowDeborah J.1985. “The Diversification of the Federal Bench: Policy and Process Ramifications.”Journal of Politics47 (2): 596–617.
75.
WeinbergJill D.NielsenLaura Beth. 2012. “Examining Empathy: Discrimination, Experience, and Judicial Decisionmaking.”Southern California Law Review85:313–52.
76.
WelchSusanCombsMichaelGruhlJohn. 1988. “Do Black Judges Make a Difference?”American Journal of Political Science32 (1): 126–36.
77.
WilliamsMargaret S.GeorgeTracey E.2013. “Who Will Manage Complex Civil Litigation? The Decision to Transfer and Consolidate Multidistrict Litigation.”Journal of Empirical Legal Studies10:424–61.
78.
ZornChristopher J. W.2002. “U.S. Government Litigation Strategies in the Federal Appellate Courts.”Political Research Quarterly55:145–66.
79.
ZornChristopher J. WBowieJennifer Barnes. 2010. “Ideological Influences on Decision Making in the Federal Judicial Hierarchy: An Empirical Assessment.”Journal of Politics72 (4): 1212–21.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
