Prior research by Abney and Lauth concluded that governors were losing ground to legislatures in shaping the state budget. Goodman examined Abney and Lauth’s explanations for this change and found empirical support for some but not others. This article’s findings reveal that governors, as a group, have not declined in budgetary influence, although some have gained and others lost during recent decades. The longitudinal analysis arrives at two major conclusions: (1) executive—legislative influence changes that take place stem primarily from political rather than structural changes, and (2) budgetary influence is not unidimensional as governors and legislatures compete in a non-zero-sum game in pursuit of different budgetary outcomes.
Abney, Glenn, and Thomas P. Lauth .1987. Perceptions of the impact of governors and legislatures in the appropriations process. Western Political Quarterly40:335-42.
2.
---. 1993. Determinants of state agency budget success. Public Budgeting and Financial Management5 (1): 37-65.
3.
---. 1998. The end of executive dominance in state appropriations . Public Administration Review58:388-94.
4.
Adams, Greg D., and Peverill Squire .2001. A note on the dynamics and idiosyncrasies of gubernatorial popularity. State Politics and Policy Quarterly1:380-93.
5.
Atkeson, Lonna Rae, and Randall W. Partin .1995. Economic and referendum voting: A comparison of gubernatorial and senatorial elections. American Political Science Review89:99-107.
6.
Bernick, E. Lee. 1979. Gubernatorial tools: Formal vs. informal. Journal of Politics41:656-64.
7.
Beyle, Thad L.1983. Governors. In Politics in the American states, 4th ed., ed. Virginia Gray, Russell L. Hanson, and Herbert Jacobs, 180-221. Boston: Little, Brown.
8.
---. 1992. Governors and hard times. Washington, DC: CQ Press.
9.
---. 1999. The governors. In Politics in the American states, 7th ed., ed. Virginia Gray, Herbert Jacobs, and Kenneth N. Vines, 191-231. Washington, DC: CQ Press.
10.
Bowling, Cynthia J., and Deil S. Wright.1998. Change and continuity in state administration: Administrative leadership across four decades. Public Administration Review58:429-44.
11.
Bowser, Jennifer Drage.2003. The effects of legislative term limits. In The book of the states, ed. Council of State Governments , 87-91. Lexington, KY: Council of State Governments.
12.
Brudney, Jeffrey L., and Deil S. Wright .2002. Reinventing government during the 1990s. Public Administration Review62:353-61.
13.
Citizens Conference on State Legislatures.1971. The sometime governments. Kansas City, MO: Bantam.
14.
Clarke, Wes.1997. Budget requests and agency head selection methods. Political Research Quarterly50:301-16.
15.
---. 1998. Divided government and budget conflict in the U.S. states . Legislative Studies Quarterly23 (1): 5-22.
16.
Council of State Governments. Various years.Administrative Officials Classified by Function. Lexington, KY: Council of State Governments.
17.
Council of State Governments.various years. The book of the states. Lexington, KY: Council of State Governments.
18.
Crew, Robert E., Jr. , David Branham, Gregory R. Weiher, and Ethan Bernick.2002. Political events in a model of gubernatorial approval. State Politics and Policy Quarterly2: 283-97.
19.
Dilger, Robert Jay, George A. Krause, and Randolph R. Moffett .1995. State legislative professionalism and gubernatorial effectiveness, 1978-1991. Legislative Studies Quarterly20:553-71.
20.
Dometrius, Nelson C.1979. Measuring gubernatorial power. Journal of Politics41:589-610.
21.
---. 1987. Changing gubernatorial power: The measure vs. reality . Western Political Quarterly40 (2): 319-28.
22.
---. 1999. Governors: Their heritage and future. In American state and local politics: Direction for the 21st century, ed. Ronald E. Weber and Paul Brace.New York: Chatham House/Seven Bridges.
23.
Dometrius, Nelson C., Deil S. Wright, and Brendan Burke.2008. Strategies for measuring influence over state agencies. State Politics and Policy Quarterly8:88-100.
24.
Fiorina, Morris P.1994. Divided government in the American states: A byproduct of legislative professionalism?American Political Science Review88:304-16.
25.
Goodman, Doug.2007. Determinants of perceived gubernatorial budgetary influence among state executive budget analysts and legislative fiscal analysts. Political Research Quarterly60:43-54.
26.
Gosling, James J.1986. Wisconsin item-veto lessons. Public Administration Review46:292-300.
27.
Gross, Donald A.1989. Governors and policymaking: Theoretical concerns and analytic approaches. Policy Studies Journal17:764-87.
28.
Hansen, Susan B.1999. "Life is not fair": Governors’ job performance ratings and state economies. Political Research Quarterly52:167-88.
29.
Heard, Alexander, ed. 1966. State legislatures in American politics. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
30.
Holbrook, Thomas M., and Emily Van Dunk.1993. Electoral competition in the American states. American Political Science Review87:955-62.
31.
Kettl, Donald F.2003. Deficit politics: The search for balance in American politics . New York: Longman.
32.
Miles, Rufus.1978. The origin and meaning of Miles’ law. Public Administration Review38:399-403.
33.
Moncrief, Gary F., and Joel A. Thompson .1980. Partisanship and purse strings: A research note on Sharkansky. Western Political Quarterly33:336-40.
34.
Nice, David C.1988. The item veto and expenditure restraint. Journal of Politics50:487-99.
35.
Niemi, Richard G., Harold W. Stanley, and Ronald J. Vogel .1995. State economies and state taxes: Do voters hold governors accountable?American Journal of Political Science39 (November): 936-57.
36.
Partin, Randall W.1995. Economic conditions and gubernatorial elections: Is the state executive held accountable?American Politics Quarterly23:81-95.
37.
Powell, Richard J.2008. Minority party gains under state legislative term limits . State Politics and Policy Quarterly8:32-47.
38.
Ryu, JayEungha, CynthiaJ. Bowling, Chung-Lae Cho, and Deil S. Wright .2007. Effects of administrators’ aspirations, political principals’ priorities, and interest groups’ influence on state agency budget requests. Public Budgeting and Finance27 (2): 22-49.
39.
---. 2008. Exploring explanations of state agency budgets: Institutional budget actors or exogenous environment? Public Budgeting and Finance28 (2): 22-49.
40.
---. forthcoming. The partisan political context of state budgeting: Agency budget outcomes under divided governments and unified government. Public Budgeting and Finance.
41.
Sabato, Larry.1983. Good-bye to Good-time Charlie: The American governorship transformed, 2d ed. Washington, DC: CQ Press.
42.
Schraufnagel, Scot, and Karen Halperin.2006. Term limits, electoral competition, and representational diversity: The case of Florida. State Politics and Policy Quarterly6:448-62.
43.
Sharkansky, Ira.1968. Agency requests, gubernatorial support, and budget success in state legislatures. American Political Science Review26:1220-31.
44.
Sigelman, Lee, and Nelson C. Dometrius .1988. Governors as chief administrators: The linkage between formal powers and informal influence. American Politics Quarterly16:157-70.
45.
Squire, Peverill.2007. Measuring state legislative professionalism: The Squire index revisited. State Politics and Policy Quarterly7:211-27.
46.
Steen, Jennifer A.2006. The impact of state legislative term limits on the supply of congressional candidates. State Politics and Policy Quarterly4:430-41.
47.
Thompson, Joel A.1987. Agency requests, gubernatorial support, and budget success in state legislatures revisited. Journal of Politics49:756-79.
48.
Verba, Sidney, and Norman H. Nie .1972. Participation in America . New York: Harper & Row.
49.
Wildavsky, Aaron.1988. The new politics of budgetary process. Glenview, IL: Scott, Foresman/ Little, Brown College Division.
50.
Wright, Deil S., and Chung-Lae Cho .2001. American State Administrators Project (ASAP) overview: Major features of the ASAP surveys 1964-1998. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill , Odom Institute for Research in Social Science.
51.
Wright, Deil S., Chung-Lae Cho, and Delvin M. Davis .2001. A collation and identification of questions included in the ASAP mail questionnaire surveys conducted in 1964, 1968, 1974, 1978, 1984, 1988, 1994, and 1998. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill, Odom Institute for Research in Social Science.
52.
Wright, Gerald C.2007. Do term limits affect legislative roll call voting? Representation, polarization, and participation. State Politics and Policy Quarterly7:256-80.
53.
Yoo, Jae-Won, and Deil S. Wright .1994. Public administration education and formal administrative position: Do they make a difference? A note on Pope’s proposition and Miles’ law in an intergovernmental context. Public Administration Review54:357-63.
