We consider a design advisor to be performance-intelligent when its suggestions do not conflict with high-level performance-related goals of the design under study. We address the problem of representing non-domain-specific design information at a high level and show how to couple it to the inputs and outputs of design critics and their suggestion mechanisms. High-level design information represented in a function-based structure with linked allocations is shown to interact with a domain-specific design critic in three instances, viz.: allocation refinement, goal matching with a supported function, and performance-intelligent tradeoffs. Examples of manual and computer-based procedures are discussed.
H. Takeuchi & I. Nonaka, "The New New Product Development Game", Colloquium on Productivity and Technology, Havard Business School, 28-29 March 1984
2.
S. Ashley , "The Battle to Build Better Products", Mechanical Engineering, November 1990, pp 34-38.
3.
K. Ishii, R. Adler & P. Barkan, "Application of Design Compatibility Analysis to Simultaneous Engineering ", Al EDAM, Vol. 2, No. 1, 1988, pp. 53-65.
4.
S. Talukdar, M. Sapossnek, L. Hou, R. Woodbury, S. Sedas & S. Saigal, "Autonomous Critics", Carnegie Mellon University Engineering Design Research Center 18-13-90, 1990.
5.
K.O'Shaughnessy & R.H. Sturges, "A Systematic Approach to Conceptual Design", ASME Fourth International Conference on Design Theory and Methodology, September 1992, Phoenix, Arizona.
6.
C.W. Bytheway , "Basic Function Determination Techniques", Proceedings of the Fifth National Meeting—Society of American Value Engineers, Vol. 11, 21-23 April 1965.
7.
J.F. Prendergast & Westinghouse Corporate Value Analysis Staff, " Value Analysis Handbook", Westinghouse Productivity and Quality Center, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15230-0160, 1982.
8.
C.W. Bytheway , "The Creative Aspects of FAST Diagramming", Proceedings of the SAVE Conference, 1971.
9.
D. Miles, Techniques of Value Analysis, 2nd edn, McGraw-Hill, New York.
10.
J.A. Maurer, "What is Value Analysis/Value Engineering", Society of American Value Engineers, Northbrook, Illinois, 1986
11.
R.H. Sturges & M.I. Kilani, "A Function Logic and Allocation Design Environment", Proceedings of the ESD Fourth Annual Expert Systems Conference and Exposition, Detroit, Michigan , 3-5 April 1990
12.
B.H. Kantowitz & R.D. Sorkin, "Allocation of Functions", Handbook of Human Factors, Edited by G.I. Salvendy, J Wiley & Sons, New York, pp. 355-369
13.
W.F. Ruggles , "A Management Planning Tool", Proceedings of the SAVE Conference, 1971.
14.
J.J. Kaufman , "Function Analysis System Technique (FAST) for Management Application" and "Function Analysis System Technique (FAST) for Management Application, Part II", Value World, July/September 1982 and October/December 1982.
15.
R.H. Sturges , "The Function of Value Engineering", ICED '93 Proceedings, The Hague, Netherlands, July 1993.
16.
R.H. Sturges , K. O'Shaughnessy & M.I. Kilani, "Representation of Aircraft Design Data for Supportability, Operability, and Producibility Evaluations", EDRC Project Report Number: 14513, Carnegie Mellon University Engineering Design Research Center 01-30-90, 1990.
17.
R.M. Beggs, C. Ciric, J. Etzl, C. Fischer & T. McCoy, "Automated Design Development Support System (ADDSS)", Boeing Vertol Company, PO Box 33126, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19142, 1989.
18.
E. Subrahmanian , G. Podnar & A. Westerberg, "n-DIM: n-Dimensional Information Modeling—A Shared Computational Environment for Design", Carnegie Mellon University Engineering Design Research Center, September 1989.
19.
M.I. Kilani & R.H. Sturges, "Detection and Evaluation of Orientation Features for CAD Part Models", Journal of Engineering Design , Vol. 2, No. 3, January 1992.
20.
R.H. Sturges & M. Kilani, "Toward an Integrated Design for Assembly Evaluation and Reasoning System", Journal of Computer Aided Design, Vol. 24, No. 2, February 1992, pp. 67-79.
21.
R.F. Coyne, "ABLOOS: An Evolving Hierarchical Design Framework", Ph.D. Thesis, Carnegie Mellon University, Department of Architecture , Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, 1991 .
22.
M.M. Andreason , S. Kahler & T. Lund, Design for Assembly, 2nd edn, New York, 1988.
23.
J.-T. Yang & R.H. Sturges, "Design for Assembly Evaluation of Orientation Difficulty Features ", Proceedings of the ASME National Design Engineering Conference, Chicago, Illmois, 24-27 February, 92-DE-8, 1992.
